10 Wrestlers Who Debuted As "Fans"

Whose first appearance was on the other side of the guardrail?

By Jacob Simmons /

It's bittersweet that we're celebrating the idea of fans in wrestling during a time when they're not permitted.

Advertisement

Fans make wrestling what it is; it's that raw rush of emotion when a stadium full of people cheer in unison or have their hearts broken all at once that transforms two sweaty people pretending to punch each other into the glorious post-modern theatre that we know and love.

However, when it comes to the theatre, you don't often see members of the audience leap onstage and hit a dropkick on Hamlet.

Planting wrestlers in the crowd as "fans" is a tried and tested method of debuting a new star. Promoters have been using this trope for decades, with varying degrees of success.

For some wrestlers, debuting as a fan goes on to become an integral part of their character. Others lose that association and forge very successful careers for themselves, their offbeat debut a mere footnote in their story.

And then there's a few for whom running out from the crowd would be as good as it gets.

From the wonderful to the weird to the wacky, the following ten performers all began their (kayfabe) wrestling careers as mere fans of the sport.

It's important to remember, though, not to jump the barrier at a real life wrestling show. Not because of any virus, but just to save yourself from looking like a fool.

10. Zach Gowen

Zach Gowen's wrestling story is nothing short of incredible.

Advertisement

A childhood cancer survivor, Gowen's illness cost him his left leg, which was amputated when he was just eight. Through sheer tenacity, he pursued his dream of becoming a pro wrestler and, in 2003, made his debut for WWE.

And what a debut it was.

Gowen was inserted in the "Mr. America" storyline, which saw Hulk Hogan sport the worst disguise since Mark Zuckerberg tried to pass himself off as a human being.

Mr. America was being assaulted by Roddy Piper and Sean O'Haire on an episode of SmackDown when Gowen decided that he'd seen enough. Portrayed as a planted fan, Zach leapt the barricade and came to Hogan's aid. During the scuffle, Piper yanked Gowen's prosthetic leg off to a very confused reaction from the fans.

Gowen was in Mr. America's corner for his match with Piper at Judgment Day 2003 and even got a match against Vince McMahon at Vengeance, which he lost (because of course Vince booked himself to beat the wrestler with one leg).

The Mr. America storyline might divide some fans, but there's no denying that Zach Gowen's first appearance for WWE TV was extremely memorable.

9. Rosa Mendes

Here's something that will blow your mind: Rosa Mendes debuted for WWE in 2008.

Advertisement

That was twelve years ago.

The future dance partner of Fandango first came to the company's attention after participating in the Diva Search. She was signed to a developmental contract and turned up in the crowd on an episode of Raw in November 2008.

She was holding a sign that proclaimed her to be "Beth Phoenix's Number One Fan". Over the next few weeks, Rosa kept appearing with signs until she jumped the guardrail to save The Glamazon from an attack by Melina.

Mendes was then hired by Phoenix and her partner, Santino Marella, to be their "intern", which essentially meant she would be on the outside for all of Beth's matches.

Sadly, this partnership never actually went anywhere, as Mendes' association with Phoenix was quietly dropped and she morphed into a managerial role.

Mendes never won a championship in her time with the WWE, but she managed champions like Carlito, The Colons, and even The Miz at one point.

Rosa made a very good career for herself in WWE and all she had to do was hold up a sign.

8. Mel

Melanie Cruise made her professional wrestling debut for POWW Entertainment in 2008.

Advertisement

She went on to cut her teeth in SHIMMER, where she mixed it up with the likes of Allie, Madison Rayne, and Billie Kay.

She even turned up in the short-lived Global Force Wrestling, challenging the NWA Women's World Champion, Santana Garrett, in an unsuccessful effort.

However, it was the 4 December 2019 episode of AEW Dynamite where Mel got her first taste of national exposure.

Although, in hindsight, she might wish she hadn't.

Mel made her AEW debut when she pledged allegiance to the ill-fated Nightmare Collective. Planted in the crowd, Mel begged Brandi Rhodes to let her join the group for... some reason... and even had her head shaved as part of her initiation.

Sadly, AEW's audience couldn't remove the memory of this storyline from their brains as easily as Brandi removed Mel's hair.

The Nightmare Collective was widely panned by wrestling fans; they thought it was too close to the already-established Dark Order stable and there was confusion surrounding Brandi's role in AEW, as she was a heel with the Collective but a babyface when managing her husband.

Thankfully Mel managed to shake this group off, but it was touch and go for a while.

7. Serena

Speaking of female "fans" emerging from the crowd to have their heads shaved...

Advertisement

Almost a full decade before AEW audiences met Mel, WWE audiences met Serena Deeb.

The current NWA Women's World Champion was sat at ringside during the 22 January 2010 edition of SmackDown, where she was particularly taken by a Mr. CM Punk and his Straight Edge Society.

Serena liked the cut of their boozeless jib and hopped the barricade to join the group. In order to prove her loyalty to the Society, Serena's head was shaved, giving her a distinctive look that is still memorable to many WWE fans.

Sadly, this iconic debut was about as good as it got for Serena. The Straight Edge Society was never given the main event run it deserved and Serena only got to take part in one actual match on TV - a mixed tag bout pitting her and Luke Gallows against The Big Show and Kelly Kelly.

It's hard to feel too sorry for Deeb, though. She later took part in the first Mae Young Classic, joined AEW, and is holding one of the most prestigious Women's Championships in the world.

Also, her hair grew back.

Hooray!

6. Hillbilly Jim

From a woman with no hair to a man with, arguably, far too much.

Advertisement

Before breaking the record for Longest Hall of Fame Speech of All Time, James Morris entertained millions of wrestling fans around the world as the gentle giant, Hillbilly Jim.

But before that, the fans thought Jim was one of their own.

Originally known as "Big Jim", the future Hall of Famer would sit in the front row of WWF shows in the mid-'80s. He became a fixture of live events and even took part in an edition of Piper's Pit.

"Rowdy" Roddy even made the offer to train Jim in the ways of wrestling, but the big man turned down the villainous Piper in favour of tutelage from WWF World Champion, Hulk Hogan.

What followed was a long, if somewhat unremarkable career for Hillbilly.

Despite a marquee match at WrestleMania III and the main event of Survivor Series 1988, he was mostly used to fill out the lower card with his entertaining antics.

Oh, and he got a song on The Wrestling Album. Make of that what you will.

5. Beth Phoenix

Beth Phoenix holds a number of pretty substantial records in WWE.

Advertisement

She's the youngest Hall of Famer ever and was the first person to enter both the Men's and Women's Royal Rumble matches. Strange to think that this legendary career began as a plant.

The hottest women's feud of 2006 was between Trish Stratus and Mickie James. James had beaten Stratus for the Women's Championship at WrestleMania that year and the two had been at each other's throats ever since.

On the 8 May episode of Raw, James was laying waste to Stratus when a "fan" jumped the barricade and took her out.

That fan was Beth and it was implied that her and James had previously had some sort of relationship, as Beth would go on to call her a "psycho" and promised to "not let her get away with it" during a promo the following week.

Thankfully, Beth broke away from this storyline and was able to come into her own as the dominant Glamazon. She would capture four championships during her time with the company and now has a place on the commentary table in NXT.

4. Earthquake

On an episode of WWF Superstars in November 1989, Dino Bravo made a challenge to The Ultimate Warrior.

Advertisement

Bravo chose a heavy-looking man from the audience to sit on The Warrior's back whilst he did press-ups. Warrior accepted the challenge, but to his dismay the fan jumped on Warrior leaving him prone.

The fan then joined Bravo and his manager, Jimmy Hart, in a beatdown of Warrior and revealed himself to be in cahoots with the two heels.

This was the WWF faithful's first introduction to John "Earthquake" Tenta, who went on to be pushed as an absolute monster during his run with the company.

The gargantuan man was primed as a successor to the departing Andre The Giant. He went on to feud with Hulk Hogan and was the final man eliminated during the 1991 Royal Rumble.

Earthquake never had the full-on main event heel run that the WWF might have had in mind, but, for a while, he was one of the hottest things in the company. He was pushed very strongly and got to share ring time with a legend like The Warrior in his very first appearance.

Not bad for a man who would go on to become The Shark in WCW.

3. Savio Vega

In May 1995, the WWF ran its first ever In Your House Pay-Per-View.

Advertisement

Matches on this card included a main event of Diesel vs. Sid for the world title, Bret Hart taking on Hakushi, and a 2-on-1 Handicap match pitting Razor Ramon against Jeff Jarrett and The Roadie.

The Bad Guy was able to best his two foes, but received a post-match beatdown for his troubles.

Thankfully, Ramon had friends in the crowd that night.

An unknown man leapt the barricade and chased Jarrett and The Roadie off. Later in the night, Ramon introduced his mystery saviour as Savio Vega, one of his childhood friends.

Vega had previously competed in the WWF as the masked Kwang, but this was the first time we'd ever seen his face.

Savio was thrust into a high-profile storyline following his debut, when he made it to the finals of the King of the Ring tournament in 1995. Vega was a last-minute replacement for Ramon, but wasn't able to stop the villainous Mabel from capturing the crown.

He then went on to form the Puerto Rican stable, Los Boricuas, and was Steve Austin's first ever WrestleMania opponent.

His childhood friend must have been so proud.

2. Steve Blackman

Tensions were high as the WWF rolled into Montreal for the 1997 Survivor Series, especially between American wrestlers and their Canadian counterparts.

Advertisement

This led to a 4-on-4 Elimination Match pitting Team Canada against Team USA. Canada was represented by Phil Lafon, who was Canadian, The British Bulldog, who was from the UK, Jim Neidhart and Doug Furnas, who were American.

Right.

As for Team USA, that was comprised of Vader, Goldust, and Marc Mero. The Patriot was scheduled to be on the team, but, when he got injured, the WWF decided to introduce a brand new character to take his place.

On an episode of Raw, The Hart Foundation laid waste to Vader in the ring. However, before they could do any serious damage, a mystery man jumped the guard rail and fended them off.

That man was Steve Blackman.

Blackman was presented as a martial arts expert who decided to take things into his own hands when The Hart Foundation stepped out of line. To repay him, Vader bailed Blackman out of jail and got him a spot on Team USA.

And that's the only notable thing that happened at Survivor Series 1997...

1. Santino Marella

On 16 April 2007, Raw emanated from Milan, Italy.

Advertisement

Vince McMahon and Intercontinental Champion Umaga addressed the crowd with Vince offering a member of the audience the chance to challenge The Samoan Bulldozer for his belt.

This led to Vince choosing someone "at random" to step into the ring. That man introduced himself to audiences around the world as Santino Marella.

A nervous-looking Marella then got even more nervous when Vince announced the match would be No Holds Barred. What followed was an absolute mugging with Umaga ragdolling Santino around the ring.

However, because this is wrestling, Bobby Lashley ran down to save the day.

Lashley had been feuding with Umaga and Vince and saw his chance to get one over on the villainous pair. Lashley took Umaga down with a brutal spear and pulled Marella's prone body on top for the referee to count to three and crown the newcomer the brand new Intercontinental Champion.

This segment is fantastic from top to bottom; Santino's performance as the plucky fan, Lashley's run-in, the shock of a "fan" winning one of the company's top titles. It all came together beautifully and it remains the most famous "fan" debut in WWE history.

Advertisement