10 Wrestlers Who Didn't Care About Kayfabe
Gall Levesque.
Some 24 years after the events of WCW SuperBrawl VI, at which Brian Pillman gleefully removed the first brick in the dam of onscreen kayfabe, we're not swimming in an ocean of atomised form; the mainstream product in the US is mostly a faithful interpretation of what always constituted professional wrestling, albeit self-referential in a way that infrequently conflates real-life failure with character weakness.
Worked shoot angles are aberrations mostly engulfed in and thus ruined by a certain irony; as soon as they tell you it's real, it becomes harder to believe. The old guard in meltdown over Pillman's transgression - and the Curtain Call - had little to fear. No fan felt betrayed at the revelation of an open secret, nor was this new storytelling form sustainable. There is a further irony, of course, in that those most protective of wrestling's sanctity are also those quickest to erode it, as if a different medium excuses them of their own, extremely pointless code.
The people largely still seek babyfaces and heels at war with stakes, hence why that is still sold as wrestling's flagship product. The talent mostly operates within kayfabe onscreen as a result - and it is very much YMMV as to whether or not transgressing upon it is good.
*Cartman voice*
Mostly...
10. Kenny Omega
Some wrestling fans are peculiar.
It is as if they never quite shook the hero worship mentality conditioned in them to become fans in the first place, and those who stan J*m Cor**tte cannot think for themselves - nor even speak for themselves, looking at their pitiful attempts to lick his a*se.
I hate these cosplay wrasslers, too, Jim!
The existence of parody does not ruin that which is parodied. It is an asinine fallacy - imagine applying this take to film, and you might see how mental you are - regurgitated by morons because Corny takes wrestling a bit too seriously. Kenny Omega wrestled a nine year-old girl because it sparked the boundless creativity within him, and the match is a genuine triumph, a piss funny blend of unconscionable cruelty and, if you allow yourself to get on its wavelength, halfway convincing comeuppance. He didn't harm anybody's career, nor undermine his peers in a promotion with stricter rules and a more trad audience.
A man put on a comedy show, and somebody of influence campaigned for him to lose his job because he didn't agree with the content.
Apply that to stand-up, and some of you knackers would whinge "Snowflake!" at the critic quicker than it would melt.
9. Ronda Rousey
Ronda Rousey doesn't give a sh*t about kayfabe.
In character.
Her character is informed by her very real existence as a legendary mixed martial artist, and when she eventually did transition to the world of professional wrestling, she did so as a fan thrilled to be a part of it - so much so that she, as if this should matter, turned up "every week" to WWE RAW, the show, incidentally, that people rip to shreds with an identical frequency, thus ensuring that its stars are absolutely f*cked either way.
It is perhaps with that shrugging nihilism Ronda Rousey took the nuclear option by informing her heel turn with what appeared to be a real falling out with wrestling itself, or at least its fandom, at Survivor Series 2018. After one of the most brutal, heart-pounding and convincing WWE women's matches ever, the fans jeered her mercilessly, after which she took to calling wrestling fake...
...in a bid to convince you that she might "shoot" on "Rebecca Quin", or, more realistically, get Becky Lynch over as the wrestler who finally took down the invincible UFC killer who looked down her nose at you.
Ronda Rousey the character thinks you're dumb for liking fake wrestling, but given how awesome she was and how quickly some were to turn on her, if the person actually does, then fair f*cks.
8. Triple H
The thing some people tend not to like about Triple H - beyond of course working the same pattern and length of match for 25 years - is that he likes to have his cake and Pedigree it too, and then wait 23 seconds to make the cover to teach it a damn lesson about this business.
He's a staunch Harley Race acolyte, shaped in ring style and psychology by sacred traditions, but put a microphone in his hand and a promising midcard act across the ring from him and he will ruthlessly expose the fiction of it all to get himself "f*cking" over. Kofi Kingston used to have a Jamaican accent - and as awful as it was it was better then Triple H's French - but he wouldn't have dared point that out because, "you see," only Triple H may break kayfabe. In 2006, John Cena happened to "not be a very good pro wrestler," but he must have been, fans thought, since he was the WWE Champion.
But, "you see," Triple H was referring to Cena's perception within in-the-know circles to babyface himself as...the heel...
By the damn good standards of the 2000s, WrestleMania 22 drew a 4/10 buy rate.
7. Shawn Michaels
Triple H's D-Generation X cohort Shawn Michaels was also, as we say in this part of the world, a little bastard.
The walls came tumbling down when Brian Pillman used a meta narrative to drive his price up and bring an end to the reign of the '80s muscle men, but Shawn blurred the lines for the less noble pursuit of "being a total c*nt to Bret Hart". Michaels throughout 1997 was a prize prick, but he was bloody funny with it, showing open disdain for his peer and the principles he held so dearly. He was a little bastard in the ring, too, f*cking the European Title in an intentionally fake match with Triple H that acutely exposed the extent to which the pro wrestler cooperates with his dance partner, not combat opponent.
Everybody knew, this didn't kill the business or any boring old sh*te like that, but it was an insult to the colleagues who had to follow. 1997 WWF wasn't PWG. They had to feel like total a**holes, performing their craft after that, but Michaels wouldn't have. He was too damn incredible at it.
Echoes of this wildly exaggerated "This thing you like is fake, you dumb marks" genre were seen in his infamous SummerSlam 2005 performance, in which he gleefully exposed the warts of Hulk Hogan's Superman act by flailing about the place as if trying to convince a toddler they were stronger than daddy.
6. Joey Janela
Joey Janela came up in era in which there was no ground left to break; just a lot of pieces to reassemble however he wished.
With no restrictions to limit his creativity - not, you suspect, that he'd give a f*ck - he used a world of possibility to create even more of them, approaching the industry with the flair of a maverick. After almost losing the use of his hand in one of the most demented death match bumps ever - think of the ground that covers - Janela pivoted towards the avant garde to prolong his career, getting his first taste of the intoxicating heat/acclaim cocktail that would get him over as an iconoclast.
To viral buzz, he wrestled an invisible man, showing a strong grasp of craft behind the initial visual gag. And, as a vastly underrated storyteller, his opponent eventually developed a mythology that resulted in murder and meta masterpieces. His transgressive approach - not that there is anything to transgress upon anymore - predictably drew the ire of the old guard and its most vocal gatekeeper.
Janela responded by ridiculing the idea of using a tennis racket in a hardcore match - an insult all the funnier and cleverer for how contrived it was.
5. Kevin Nash
Kevin Nash stopped giving a toss when WCW business declined, which it did in no small part through his booking, but he was so incorrigible and funny with it that his antics have a developed a certain charm in retrospect.
Or a posthumous charm, since this sort of thing killed the company.
The second that man erupts into his sh*t-eating grin at the start of That Thunder, Jesus Christ. You feel like ruffling his hair and forgiving him for the last 20 years of U.S. mainstream rot.
He openly admits to being a horrible booker the very minute fans are introduced to the broadcast, helpfully revealing it to be both fake and terrible. He buries Jim Duggan's knee drop with the most cutting of comedic tools: incredulity of its very existence. He documents Goldberg's initial struggle to locate the hard camera before patronising him with a hugely enthusiastic "Yeah!" when he finally manages. Goldberg also makes an appearance later in the night, which Nash calls like a wildlife documentary narrator. It's the one time Goldberg's spear doesn't look great, because Nash, in a fabulous quasi-Attenborough accent, calls it a tackle.
This was probably more damaging than a guy who...
4. Orange Cassidy
...wrestles with his hands in his pockets (better, and this isn't hyperbole, than most do with full use of them).
Orange Cassidy operates almost staunchly within kayfabe - or a fairly strict version of wrestling that opts for realism, as oxymoronic as that reads - in AEW. He lazily throws apathetic calf grazes at his opponents, but that's because he can't be bothered. Nobody sells. That's his character. It makes little sense that such a character would want to be a professional athlete, but that's the gag. The humour - that which makes life tolerable and has been a part of wrestling in various forms for a century - is derived from how absurd that is situationally, Mr. Thompson.
It's also funny because the dude has like 1.7% body fat. He's shredded. He is, wonderful with every reveal, an exceptionally capable pro wrestler. This enigmatic quality of Cassidy's doubles as a psychological ploy in AEW, but outside of it, Cassidy, a product of post-post-kayfabe, will roll around the canvas with his hands in his pockets to satirise the drop down and - not unlike a certain urn - be magically energised by his sunglasses.
The gift of Orange Cassidy is that he's less silly than pro wrestling itself, but the parody is affectionate - and, given how superb he is, hard-earned.
3. Mick Foley
Mick Foley wasn't married to the concept of kayfabe, and the irony, re: all of the dreaded discourse wrapped around it, is that a performer with no regard for the code better advanced the industry than so many who do; a superb performer in a field most were too selfish to excel in, Foley was a genius at getting his peers over.
Foley openly presented the idea that professional wrestling was a larger-than-life spectacle populated by characters, not people, and used its scripted platform to express the different recesses of his personality. He explored his run in the WWF not as sport but as drama therapy for a damaged and dangerous man, and it doubled as a tremendous means of refusing to allow himself to grow stale under the punishing grind of episodic television.
He wasn't beyond abusing kayfabe explicitly - his bizarre TNA run was none more meta - and even in the WWF, he famously claimed that he wouldn't "sell" the "abortion" that was the People's Elbow.
It was consistent with Foley's drive and experience, and the perspective he consequently developed; he thrived on enduring real pain to set his matches apart as spectacles, and when this awful toil was not recognised by a shrugging mainstream, he shrugged at their traditions.
2. John Cena
John Cena ritually broke (the veneer of) kayfabe to - and this was always so bizarre, especially how accepted it became - bury his opponents as a means of building his upcoming pay-per-view match with them (!).
It was an altogether more charmless continuation of the Rock's patter, in which under Vince Russo's non-traditional creative direction he favoured slick and witty trash talk over the traditional three-point wrestling promo. Cena also wasn't fond of the put your opponent over, explain your hatred of them, tell the people the date on which you're going to kick their ass deal, and instead treated promos like a battle rap even when he had stopped rhyming.
This worked to a not insignificant extent, obviously - John Cena was a major star, the last draw - but that there were so few competing with him for that spot tells its own story, one over which Cena on the mic held creative control.
Cena exposed Alberto Del Rio's gimmick as a sham in 2011, which it was, because it's wrestling, but you don't say that, because it's wrestling. With Bray Wyatt, he hurled fat jokes at the guy we were meant to be afraid of, and this ruined the man's aura. His presence was reduced to sh*t; you saw not the menace in his eyes, but the folds bulging through the t-shirt. He told Roman Reigns that he'd have to learn how to cut a promo.
Perhaps best to do so from another teacher.
1. Minoru Suzuki
The best thing about the Minoru Suzuki Vs. Mecha Mummy match is that it exists, and its existence is the perfect counter argument to the knackers who claim that comedy wrestling is the preserve of those without the talent - nor the toughness - to have made it in pro wrestling when it was a real man's world.
Minoru Suzuki would tear every '80s territorial babyface who very theatrically played blind with the crimson mask limb from limb. He is also an incredible wrestler and performer, an elite talent at 51, who is so legitimate and expressive that he can make a 10 minute heel hook entertaining. And yet, he worked a comedy match with a robot mummy because it was never going to do a damn thing to his aura. He will absolutely kill you, bastard. The other best thing about Minoru Suzuki Vs. Mecha Mummy is that Suzuki doesn't betray his character nor patronise the form.
It's a very elegant joke; he ambles from end of the ring to the other, playing along, before ensnaring Mecha Mummy into a submission hold. Mummy is helpless - he is a chancer in a stupid outfit - but the outfit while stupid is very well thought-out, and he is able to temporarily blind Suzuki with the dust he coated it with. Suzuki then short-circuits the Mummy with a bottle of water, because he is also a machine, again, in what is a marvellous, inexplicable twist.
Only fractionally less inexplicable character development than the EC3 Vs. Dean Ambrose feud.