10 Wrestlers Who Failed In NXT (But Were Successful Elsewhere)

While NXT is clearly fantastic, these stars prove it's not the be-all and end-all.

By Andrew Pollard /

NXT is the place where so many of WWE’s current top stars cut their teeth on the way to becoming true megastars of the business.

Advertisement

From Becky Lynch, to Seth Rollins, to Charlotte Flair, to Finn Bálor, to Bayley, to Kevin Owens, to… you get the point. Regardless of just how good they may have been before signing with WWE, so many of the current crop of top stars gained some extra seasoning in the yellow and black brand.

Of course, not everybody who signs with NXT is guaranteed to become a major star. In fact, some of those to have passed through NXT have barely been heard of since (seriously, what ever happened to Marcus Louis?) as they’ve dropped off the face of the wrestling landscape.

On the flipside of that, leaving WWE and NXT can sometimes prove to be a masterstroke that ultimately sees a talent flourish elsewhere away from underneath the WWE umbrella. It's those who fledglings who flew the roost to become soaring superstars elsewhere who we're going to focus on today.

10. Luchasaurus

Remember the time that NXT had a guy in a dinosaur mask running wild? No? Well, that’s because that never actually happened. That’s not to say that the man behind Luchasaurus didn’t have a spell in WWE’s developmental arm, though.

Advertisement

Recently signed to All Elite Wrestling, Luchasaurus has become a major favourite of many a wrestling fan for his sheer uniqueness. After all, can you really remember any sort of even remotely similar gimmick in a mainstream wrestling promotion?

Way before Luchasaurus was roaring through the competition, the wrestler underneath the gimmick used to go by the name of Judas Devlin back in FCW and then in NXT. Working under the WWE umbrella for just over a year, Devlin was released by WWE as they seemingly saw nothing special about the performer.

Not only did Devlin get reinvented as Luchasaurus, but he also had a spell as Vibora in Lucha Underground that saw him team with Drago and Pindar to win the promotion’s Trios Championships. As mentioned, Luchasaurus is now a signed-up member of the AEW roster as Tony Khan’s upstart company looks to offer wrestling fans a genuine alternative to WWE.

9. Tanga Loa

If it's with Bullet Club or simply The Guerrillas of Destiny, Tanga Loa has been tearing it up in New Japan Pro Wrestling since 2016. Whether The Guerrillas of Destiny are the greatest team in the world, that’s up for debate. But still, even the tandem’s biggest detractors have to admit that Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa are at least in the conversation of the current best teams out there.

Advertisement

Back in 2009, though, Tanga Loa began his wrestling career by signing a contract with WWE’s development system – at that time Florida Championship Wrestling – and he’d make his main roster debut within just two years of that FCW deal. Initially debuting on an episode of WWE Superstars as the muscle of Hunico, Camacho was the name given to the Hawaii native. By 2013, however, Camacho was competing as a solo act in NXT. And well, the less said about that the better.

Camacho’s time in NXT fizzled out with a whimper in 2014 but, following a brief spell in Impact Wrestling, this talented performer has really began to shine since landing in New Japan in 2016.

8. Catrina

As Maxine, Karlee Perez was a standout part of the early days of NXT. Whether as an in-ring talent, a manager, or even as a commentator, Perez felt like a star in the making who fit so much of what WWE looks for in its female superstars. Unfortunately, those NXT days didn’t end well as Karlee quit WWE in 2012 due to being frustrated at how she was being used.

Advertisement

Fast forward to two years later, and viewers were treated to Karlee Perez turning up in Lucha Underground as the nefarious Catrina. The unique and magical corner of the wrestling business known as Lucha Underground positioned Catrina as a big-time player who was the manipulative and evil manager of LU’s dominant heel, Mil Muertes.

With the future of Lucha Underground still uncertain as the TV show looks increasingly unlikely to be given another season, one of the biggest shames is that Catrina isn’t on TV right now. Either way, Karlee Perez has taken her stardom to a whole other level since departing NXT seven years ago.

7. Ivelisse

Much like the aforementioned Karlee Perez, Ivelisse Velez is somebody who found great success in Lucha Underground after departing WWE and NXT. In addition to being one third of Lucha Underground’s first ever Trios Champions, Ivelisse similarly impressed in SHIMMER and in multiple stints in Impact Wrestling.

Advertisement

Before being recognised as one of the best female wrestlers in the business, Ivelisse first came onto WWE’s radar back in 2011. It was back then that Ivelisse took part in WWE’s Tough Enough before signing a development deal later that year. From Florida Championship Wrestling through to the infancy of NXT, Ivelisse continued to hone her craft before WWE decided to release her from her contract.

Ivelisse seems to be one of those wrestlers whose career is in limbo right now due to the ongoing contract dispute between Lucha Underground and several performers. Still, her future looks like it might see her return to WWE, with the talented grappler attending a WWE tryout just this past April. Whether anything comes of that, again it seems to rely on how things play out with Lucha Underground.

6. Bram

The story of Tom Latimer is one that could have been so different. If you remember, Latimer looked like becoming a huge WWE star as Kenneth Cameron of The Ascension. Before they became the sham tag team that they are now, The Ascension was a fascinating pairing of Kenneth Cameron and Conor O’Brian that had an almost vampiric edge to them.

Advertisement

With The Ascension one of the hottest acts in NXT, the wheels well and truly come off when Latimer was charged with drunkenly assaulting a police officer. The Ascension were repackaged and eventually became a laughing stock, while Latimer would end up landing in Impact Wrestling as Bram.

From 2014 to 2017, Bram was one of Impact’s most intriguing acts. Whether as a heel or babyface, the Briton’s look and rough in-ring style made him constantly come across like a true badass. Currently working on the independent scene, Bram is still only 32 years of age and so has a lot of wrestling left in him.

Even though he was great at what he did during his run in NXT, the manner in which Tom Latimer exited WWE has class his time there as a failure. Luckily, Latimer would go on to find success elsewhere as he embraced the King of Hardcore nickname given to him in Impact.

5. Austin Aries

He may have at times referred to himself as The Greatest Man That Ever Lived, but that was sadly not a moniker you could realistically place on Austin Aries during his time in NXT.

Advertisement

Throughout various spells in both Ring of Honour and TNA/Impact Wrestling, A Double was absolutely fantastic, with his cocky attitude and intense in-ring style making him a bona fide star who was viewed as one of the best in the business. And then came an ill-fated jump to WWE.

Signing up to be a part of the NXT brand in 2016, Aries’ run was a major disappointment – and not all of that was down to the former TNA World Heavyweight Champion. It was only mere months into his NXT career that Aries was put on the shelf thanks to a broken eye socket suffered in a match against Shinsuke Nakamura.

Aries would take up a spot on the 205 Live commentary table – a role he was fantastic in – and his return to action would culminate with a WrestleMania 33 match against Neville. But just like that, A Double requested (and received) his WWE release only three months after ‘Mania.

During his NXT days, many fans had pegged Austin Aries as a prime candidate to become NXT Champion. Sadly, that was not meant to be, and The Greatest Man That Ever Lived would return to Impact Wrestling before more recently competing for MLW.

4. Eli Drake

So often, those in the wrestling business talk about that magical “it factor” that a truly special talent has to have if they're to connect to a mass audience. And one person who has that special something is Eli Drake.

Advertisement

A fantastic talker and a good in-ring hand, Drake became one of the very few bright lights of some absolutely dire years of TNA/Impact Wrestling upon arriving in the company in 2015. Where his time in NXT is concerned, Drake actually had a couple of stints with WWE. The most notable of these spells came in 2013, with the real-life Shaun Ricker heading to Florida to begin training under the NXT brand. The charismatic Ricker would only have a total of 13 matches in NXT before being released from his WWE contract just eight months later in August 2014.

In a move that could see things come full circle, WWE has reportedly expressed strong interest in signing Eli Drake over the past couple of years – even more-so now that Drake is a free agent after leaving Impact Wrestling earlier this year.

3. Sami Callihan

In recent years, Sami Callihan has proudly referred to himself as The Draw as he’s continued to cause quite the buzz throughout the wrestling industry. But even before his time under the WWE umbrella, Callihan had amassed an impressive reputation for himself with stints in promotions such as CZW, Ring of Honor, Dragon Gate, and Pro Wrestling Guerrilla.

Advertisement

Upon Callihan signing with WWE and NXT back in 2013, he was rejigged as a computer hacker called Solomon Crowe. Whether the gimmick could’ve ever really worked, nobody really knows for sure because Crowe ended up being used sporadically and without any real intent or purpose bar a super-brief rivalry with Kalisto.

Since asking and receiving his WWE release in 2015, Sami Callihan has made himself one of the most sought-after talents on the independent scene. More recently, 2019 saw Sami as a main player in both Major League Wrestling and Impact Wrestling, although that MLW relationship seems to have soured after Callihan went off script and caused excessive damage during a Falls Count Anywhere bout against Mance Warner.

2. Juice Robinson

CJ Parker was a fun and entertaining character in NXT, yet there was always the feeling that the character had a certain shelf live - as highlighted by CJP soon becoming a jobber to the stars.

Advertisement

Having been signed to WWE since 2011, Joe Robinson would leave the company and his CJ Parker name behind in 2015. Juice Robinson would soon be born, and he has not looked back since. After wrestling for CZW, CMLL, and Ring of Honor, Robinson made the ballsy move to take a chance in Japan and became one of New Japan’s famed young boys.

Working his way up the ranks, Juice Robinson is now one of the most must-watch characters in New Japan Pro Wrestling and is delivering some of the best promos in the business. As NJPW continues to look at expanding its appeal to a wider audience, Juice has been a key figure on New Japan programming and has held the prestigious IWGP United States Championship on two occasions.

Juice has regularly stated how he’s loving live in Japan and has no plans to make a permanent return to a North American wrestling promotion any time soon. He is a shining example of what can be achieved when you take a chance on yourself away from WWE.

1. Tessa Blanchard

Right now, Tessa Blanchard is one of the hottest names in the wrestling business. So much so, The Queen of the Carolinas recently headlined Impact’s Slammiversary PPV in an intergender match against Sami Callihan.

Advertisement

Blanchard has a swagger and legitimacy to her wrestling persona and in-ring work, and at only 23 years of age she has an extremely bright future ahead of her. Tessa may have landed on the radar of long-time wrestling fans due to being the daughter of legendary Four Horsemen stalwart Tully Blanchard, but she’s already crafted a reputation completely of her own as being a standout performer.

When it comes to NXT, Tessa had a run with the WWE’s developmental brand back in 2016 ahead of competing in the 2017 Mae Young Classic. Unfortunately for Blanchard, her first-round Mae Young Classic bout saw her going up against eventual winner Kairi Sane. And like that, Tessa Blanchard was eliminated from the tournament in her very first match.

WWE must be absolutely kicking themselves at not being able to tie Tessa down for a prolonged run in NXT; Blanchard is thriving in Impact Wrestling.

Advertisement