10 Wrestlers Who Have Suddenly Disappeared
Here one minute, then gone the next. When will we see these wrestlers again?
Disclaimer: This entire article was inspired by Lance Archer.
There's no doubting that when the 'Murderhawk' made his way to AEW in 2020, alongside Jake 'The Snake' Roberts, it was treated as a big deal. He oozed menace but over the years, terrible booking has rendered him redundant and he fell off of AEW TV for so long, it was a genuine surprise when he showed up on Rampage last month for a needless squash.
Just dropping from TV isn't helpful booking. Sure, there are some wrestlers who outstay their welcome and need a refresh (think Dolph Ziggler), but when a wrestler just disappears and is then reintroduced with little to no explanation or update to their character, it's hard to get invested. Sorry Mr. Archer, but it's true.
But he isn't the only one, and All Elite Wrestling isn't the only company guilty of such sloppy talent management.
Now, whether the following list of wrestlers are stars that would significantly impact the card is up for interpretation. The fact is, they were heavily featured on the weekly programming, some in some pretty serious spots, and then were dropped cold. Nobody truly knows what goes on behind the scenes in these wrestling companies, but you have to think that either they were perceived to drop the ball they were thrown, or perhaps someone just didn't fancy them?
Either way, these wrestlers seemed to vanish without so much as a trace.
10. Dana Brooke
Everyone loves a trier.
Having made her main roster debut seven years ago, it's safe to say that Dana Brooke has never really kicked on. Not everyone is destined to be a main event talent, and there is nothing wrong with just being a regular face within the division. That's always been Brooke's ceiling, and you have to give the woman some credit: she has thrown herself fully into most of the tripe that WWE have served up to her.
No, she's not a Becky Lynch or Bianca Belair, but Brooke has been a staple on the show for the past few years, whether that's being thrilled to be crowned 24/7 Champion, having a terrible marriage storyline with Reggie, or thrown into a number of make shift tag teams in the genuinely terrible women's tag division. She was always just sort of there.
Things have certainly changed under Triple H's booking, but for the women's division that hasn't necessarily been for the best. With the 24/7 Championship binned off (literally), there seems to be no place for Brooke in the current malaise of the RAW women's division.
Is she missed?
Seems harsh to say she's not, but beyond a forgettable appearance in the Royal Rumble, the last time the Ohio native was seen on Monday Night RAW was back in November.
Since then, she's been an exclusive of Main Event, and that's hardly must watch TV at the best of times.
9. The Good Brothers
It was no real surprise when the smartest men in professional wrestling made their returns to the WWE back in October 2022, especially as Triple H was on a mission to rehire everyone that had been let go in the preceding two years.
It makes sense. Gallows and Anderson are recognisable names, come with an inbuilt fanbase and already have a connection to the main roster in AJ Styles. In the few years since they were sent packing by the WWE during their hideous pandemic-inspired cull of wrestlers, the duo have been on a roll.
They were a key part of AEW for a while, won the IMPACT Tag Team Titles three times, as well as Anderson picking up the NJPW NEVER Openweight Championship, which he still held when he re-signed with the fed.
With AJ Styles feuding with the Judgment Day, it was a sensible return, and the welcoming pop from the crowd was proof in itself. But the bloom quickly fell off the rose, as Styles went down with an injury and the Good Brothers were just sort of there. They had two matches with Alpha Academy in December, and their only onscreen appearance in 2023 was part of the 2023 RAW Tag Title gauntlet in January. Which was won by their previous rivals, the Judgment Day.
For all the praise that Triple H has quite rightly received since taking over the reigns, the comebacks have kind of sucked, haven't they?
8. Shanky
Oh boy.
Nothing says that a wrestler is dead in the water in WWE than being given the dreaded 'giant who just loves to dance' gimmick. Just look back at the success of Brodus Clay or Lord Tensai to see that this only ever goes one way. And it isn't to the top.
Brought in alongside Jinder Mahal and Veer Mahaan, Shanky did the square root of nothing before he and Mahal were sent packing to SmackDown. Whilst Monday Night RAW would spend literally months awaiting the arrival of Veer, Shanky and Mahal quickly became midcard fodder, and Shanky, despite his size, lost any intimidation he may have had. How do you exist as a dominant big man when the likes of GUNTHER and Braun Strowman are on your show?
Well, someone had the smart idea of introducing Shanky to some awful dance moves, and so began a pointless exercise in Shanky costing himself and Mahal matches due to his inability to control his hips. Fans popped, a little, but when those died down, so did any modicum of potential for the big lad's career.
The arrival of The Game as Head of Creative saw Shanky disappear from WWE TV completely, and whilst Mahal and Mahaan have found a new home in NXT, it seems like the man with the gyrating hips has a new permanent home in catering.
7. PAC
PAC's tenure in AEW has been a strange one.
Travelling issues, especially during the pandemic, really impacted his ability to perform in the US, and therefore stifled his push. There is no denying that the Geordie native has all the tools in his locker to become a major star for the promotion, but it has just never really happened.
Whilst his stop-start career in All Elite Wrestling has seen him put on classics with the likes of Kenny Omega, Hangman Page and Orange Cassidy, the sudden influx of readymade main eventers really didn't help his cause. Also, it never really feels like Tony Khan has a solid plan for the 'Bastard', and he has flip flopped between face and heel a worrying amount.
After the 'Brawl Out' fiasco in the summer of 2022, PAC and his Death Triangle team mates were admirable stopgaps in the stumbling trios division, before they handed the Trios Tag Team Titles back to the Elite at the culmination of their best of seven series in January. Since that match, we haven't seen the former WWE Cruiserweight Champion, and we have no idea when we will.
The worrying thing is, for a man who has all the tools to be an AEW World Champion, it sort of feels like that will never happen.
6. Miro
Speaking of men who have all the tools to be AEW Champion but will never be...
There have been numerous paragraphs written about the disastrous booking of Miro after he needlessly lost the AEW TNT Championship in late 2021. It was a noble failure, which turned disastrous, to try and book Sammy Guevara as a valiant babyface, but sacrificing one of the best things of the entire year to do so looks like a bad decision in hindsight. To be honest, Miro should still be TNT Champion right now.
After a lukewarm debut as 'The Best Man' alongside Kip Sabian, the Bulgarian morphed into the terrifying 'Redeemer', and over the course of the year he became one of the most believable stars in the company. Already carrying a loyal fanbase, Miro stacked on fans and was riding a wave of popularity that looked destined to take him to the top of the card.
The matches were brutal. The theme music was fantastic. His one liners were impeccable.
But it does feel like Miro has fallen foul of Tony Khan. He had time off in 2022 to film a TV show and reports have stated that he turned down an angle to return to TV in the autumn of 2022. So, it's not all on Khan.
Still, it's outrageous that a star of such magnitude has only wrestled four times since he lost to Bryan Danielson at Full Gear 2021! Return to us, Miro. We miss you!
5. Alexa Bliss
'Spooky' Alexa Bliss is rubbish.
Sorry, it is. In fact, no, not sorry. It's absolute trash and it has been for over two years!
It's been an absolute stain on the poor woman's career, and although she has stated a few times that she has really enjoyed delving into her 'darker' side on camera, it has failed. The tenuous links to Bray Wyatt have always felt forced, and the biggest factor of all, she just isn't intimidating. She's so ill-suited to being scary, that the most terrifying part of the entire gimmick was Bliss being infantilised for the weirdos to enjoy her acting like a child.
It was creepy. But not in the way it was intended.
Thankfully, in the summer of 2022 it seemed like we would be done with it, and although we had to persevere with those awful therapy vignettes, it looked like we would soon see the return of 'The Goddess'. The five-time WWE Women's Champion is an exceptional heel and a good worker, and there was hope we would soon get another major player back in the women's division.
But then Wyatt returned, along with the laughable Uncle Howdy, and sure enough, the spooky nonsense began. Alexa snapped and turned heel, embraced the darkness and then subsequently lost to Bianca Belair at the Royal Rumble. Remember that? Remember when Uncle Howdy got involved?
Nothing has been followed up, Bliss is nowhere to be seen, and in the run up to a stacked-looking WrestleMania, that's a bad place for the former 'Little Miss Bliss' to be.
4. Powerhouse Hobbs
Alongside his tag partner, Ricky Starks, Powerhouse Hobbs looked like the next breakout, homegrown star of All Elite Wrestling.
Yes, both of them had wrestled elsewhere, but AEW gave them prime-time television exposure, and the duo became easily the coolest act in the company. From their street swagger to their explosive matches, their implosion was well handled, but fizzled swiftly. However, Hobbs did squash his former friend at All Out in 2022 and bigger things lay ahead.
Instantly, effort was made to present the former Team Taz member as a superstar. A banging new theme song accompanied by a new entrance routine, which saw him gifted the middle entrance that was vacated by Cody Rhodes' defection to WWE. Hobbs, for all intents and purposes, was presented as a major deal.
Heading into Full Gear, Hobbs clashed with Samoa Joe and TNT Champion Wardlow in a big, meaty man collision, where he was choked out by Samoa Joe and then disappeared. Sure, we've had the 'Book of Hobbs' vignettes, but this wasn't so much as pouring cold water over the act but more like plunging him into an ice bath.
Since Full Gear in November, Hobbs had a one minute squash on the rapidly declining Rampage, before he was inexplicably brought back to win the 'Face of the Revolution' ladder match last week.
3. Anthony Ogogo
One of the strangest signings All Elite Wrestling made looked, for a while, to be one of it's shrewdest.
After winning a bronze medal for boxing in the 2012 Olympic Games held in his native Britain, the Lowestoft-born fighter looked set for a big boxing career. A professional run saw him win 11 of his 12 bouts, but a series of eye injuries soon brought Ogogo career between those ropes to an end.
AEW offered him a different set of ropes and many people raised their eyebrows. For those few short months in 2021, it looked like a slam dunk.
For a brief time, as Cody Rhodes feuded with The Factory, Anthony Ogogo felt like a star in the making. 'The Guvnor' soon became the most dangerous man on the roster, and his gut punch was a believable finisher that could end a match out of nowhere. He also possesses such unteachable charisma, that it seemed like the world was at his feet.
Out of nowhere, Cody was going to Cody, and he turned their decent feud into a MURICA feud, presenting the Olympian as a foreign heel invading the USA, followed by Rhodes defeating Ogogo in an underwhelming match at Double or Nothing 2021. There was no follow up, and although his eye injuries haven't helped, the Brit's so far from Tony Khan's orbit right now, he may as well be in another universe.
The last time he was given anything by AEW, was a 43 second match on YouTube last summer.
2. Shinsuke Nakamura
There will not be a point in time, during Shinsuke Nakamura's run with WWE, that fans will not be wishing that creative will wake up and make the most of him.
It's been nearly six years since he arrived on the main roster, as a readymade, bona fide superstar, and the fact that WWE haven't got anywhere close to getting the best out of Nakamura is an abject failure on their part. It does feel like 'The Artist' has been going through the motions these past few years, and every title reign or victory has felt insignificant.
That looked set to change in 2022. After a standout showing in a gauntlet match at the beginning of the year, WWE seemed to line the 'King of Strong Style' up as Roman Reigns' post-WrestleMania 38 rival. It tied in with the injury Rick Boogs suffered in his bout with Nakamura against the Usos at 'Mania, and just seeing Nakamura and Reigns go nose to nose felt credible.
But it was dropped cold. No explanation. No write off. Out of nowhere, Nakamura was kicked from his main event spot and he tumbled back to the midcard. Apart from a decent rivalry with GUNTHER for the WWE Intercontinental Championship, Shinsuke has completely dropped off the WWE radar. His last televised WWE match was a losing effort to Santos Escobar in the opening round of the WWE World Cup in November, and since then, he's feasted on the scraps of house shows.
You could write a book on how badly WWE have booked Shinsuke Nakamura, but considering the market leader haven't used him in over three months, would anyone even read it?
1. Shawn Spears
MJF vs. Wardlow was one of the hottest and most entertaining storylines in AEW's four-year history. It was personal, it was action packed, and it had literal years of build up. It also was woven into, and dovetailed into, the immaculate MJF and CM Punk rivalry which stands today as one of the best in modern wrestling history.
What doesn't get mentioned enough, is that Shawn Spears played a key part in it. Excelling as the current AEW Champion's nasty, pitbull of a henchman, Spears was a laugh riot as Wardlow's appointed 'Accountabilibuddy'. Sneaking in vicious chair shots and clowning around behind the big man, the former 'Perfect Ten' played the role to perfection, and when he met his comeuppance inside a steel cage, it was one of the highlights of an exceptional story.
Then MJF decided to take a steaming hot piss all over the pay-off with his behaviour surrounding Double of Nothing, Wardlow's star fizzled, and Spears went on to do... nothing. It was astonishing, as there was a lot of fan investment in the Canadian and he could have easily been a decent rival for Wardlow once 'Mr. Mayhem' had picked up his first belt in AEW when he won the TNT Title.
But we didn't see the 'Chairman' again for five months, until he appeared in his native Canada to a monstrous pop to save his former Pinnacle buddies, FTR, from the Embassy. He even brought back the 'Ten' gimmick that made him so popular in WWE.
Considering Spears' former ally MJF is the AEW Champion, it feels strange that someone so closely associated with the champ has completely disappeared.