10 Wrestlers Who Overdelivered In 2023

Doing the job - and then some.

By Josh Mills /

As 2023 draws to a close, and fans reflect on a particularly wild year in wrestling, the standout performers have mostly been as expected. Roman Reigns remains a draw whether you like him or not, MJF’s evolution has been a joy to behold, Seth Rollins remains the workhorse’s workhorse.

Advertisement

Beyond the usual suspects, though, are the wrestlers who have found themselves unexpectedly holding the ball and running with it. From superstars in the spotlight who have used it in exciting and unexpected ways, to those who have marched their way to the front of the queue through sheer force of personality, these workers have done far more than could reasonably be expected from what they’ve been given.

In the strange world of sports entertainment you live or die by the booker’s pencil, to some extent, but some of these performers have proved that it’s not always so simple - find that spark, or simply bust a gut, and you can turn yourself from also-ran to next in line.

An incredible 12 months, then, but for these wrestlers, now’s the time to look forward to what will be an incredible 2024.

10. Bryan Danielson

Danielson features low on this list because overdelivery is relative. Fans know what to expect from him to some extent. That he’s one of the best wrestlers on the planet goes without saying; that he’s a true locker room leader is obvious.

Advertisement

Even by his own lofty standards, though, 2023 has been pretty fantastic for the American Dragon. From the off he’s put on a bevy of spectacular TV matches: a bloodbath against Rush, show stealing bouts against Swerve, Andrade, and Kingston.

On PPV, he levels up further. The MJF Iron Man match. The technical spectacular with Zack Sabre Jr, a match with impossible hype that it somehow lived up to. Perhaps most impressively of all, the strap match against Ricky Starks, a masterclass on how to shine a spotlight on a younger star while still looking like a killer.

All that, and he’s expertly hyped fans for 2024, his final full time year. Tony Khan is clearly enamoured of Danielson, and will likely let him do whatever he wants for his swansong. For a lot of superstars, that would be cause for concern - not for this guy, wrestling’s purest man.

9. Ricky Starks

The former FTW champion got his 2023 off to a roaring start following a feud against MJF in which he performed admirably. While the scumbag’s world title reign was obviously only just beginning, things looked bright for homegrown Starks, who was earmarked as a potential next champ.

Advertisement

Then, things kind of stalled. Attention was diverted elsewhere, Ricky was on and off TV, never really getting his teeth into anything too serious.

Cream, though, rises to the top. No one seized the opportunity like Starks when Collision rolled around, quickly establishing himself as the top heel. The CM Punk firing was a blessing in disguise for Ricky, who instead embarked on a career-defining angle against Bryan Danielson.

He’s gone toe to toe with two of the best talkers in Punk and MJF (and seemed to genuinely get under Adam Copeland’s skin), has come on leaps and bounds in the ring, and is now trusted enough to effectively elevate colleagues like Big Bill, who has soared under Starks’ auspices. A 2024 face turn could send him to the moon.

8. Willow Nightingale

A lot of what’s worked best for AEW’s women’s division in 2023 has been pretty high concept stuff. Toni Storm’s off the wall descent into monochromatic madness; the ever-debatable complexities of blue and black mist.

Advertisement

The exception to this is Willow Nightingale, about as pure and unadulterated a gimmick as you can get in wrestling. She’s an uncommonly effective, straight down the line heroic babyface who genuinely connects with the crowd. That’s no easy feat to pull off - just ask Rocky Maivia - but Willow’s high octane persona hits all the right notes, and never feels forced.

It helps that she’s terrific in the ring, and getting better by the month. From what she’s displayed so far, Nightingale hasn’t come close to finding her ceiling. The match with Athena was probably her best to date, but bouts with Kris Statlander and Julia Hart went a long way to showcasing her versatility. She even chalked up a win over Mercedes Mone, even if this was an audible called due to injury.

She’s utilised well and often, and the Owen Hart tournament win suggests the office is behind her. There’s a slight doubt as to how she’d fare with a significant character tweak, but when the formula works, why mess with it?

7. Tiffany Stratton

While there’s plenty of reason to wish NXT would go back to the good old days, the tweaked, youth-centric format is starting to pay dividends. 2023’s best example: Tiffany Stratton, whose exceptional year proves that they know what they’re doing down in developmental.

Advertisement

Stratton is just 24 years old and made her debut barely over two years ago, but can lay claim to one of the brand’s finest matches in the past 12 months, the extreme rules clash with Becky Lynch that headlined the excellent No Mercy PLE (the opening titles of which spoofed the N64 game of the same name, released when Stratton was just under one year old).

There’s the obvious fact that Stratton had a skilled and experienced dance partner, but she more than held her own. NXT is a land of especially brash characters, but her vicious queen bee is given a far more believable and human presentation than most. Coupled with a great finisher and an impeccable swagger, she could be main roster bound in 2023.

6. Orange Cassidy

In 2023, the wrestling purists will need to find something else to get annoyed about when it comes to Orange Cassidy. With his incredibly creative and funny slacker gimmick, the king of sloth style has been a bete noire for those who think wrestling peaked in 1983.

Advertisement

Well, this year, Cassidy really tried. During his stint with the All Atlantic Championship, he turned a nothingy, tertiary belt into a prize worth winning, worth headlining PPVs. He wrestled a relentless TV schedule, becoming the most reliable performer in AEW’s arsenal, telling a great, long running story as the sheer workload chipped away at his body.

He did this all without compromising his character, finally falling valiantly to Jon Moxley in All Out’s main event. When injury issues saw the belt land once more in Cassidy’s backpack, the smart money was on the Mox rematch going the same way, the story just restarting.

Instead, Cassidy was given his best vote of confidence to date, triumphing over the former World Champion in a battle of wills. The workload has given OC a phenomenal showcase, and he has risen to the challenge like few could have imagined when this endearingly goofy gimmick first hit the scene.

5. Rhea Ripley

While Rhea Ripley has clearly been positioned for great things for many years now, it hasn’t always seemed likely that WWE would actually pull the trigger. Her main roster debut against Charlotte Flair was WrestleMania 36’s best match but the wrong woman went over, while her first World title run underwhelmed, and for much of 2022 she was lost in the shuffle.

Advertisement

Who knew that the missing ingredient was Rey Mysterio’s greasy son?

Ripley has been a revelation in 2023, the single greatest reason the Bloodline went from Edge’s boring stable to one of the company’s best storytelling tools. She adds value wherever she’s placed, whether gobbing off from the side of the ring or pulling the strings backstage with her gaggle of goth boys.

She’s not always given the most to do in the ring simply because she’s booked so dominant, but when it works - her exceptional make-right with Charlotte at this year’s ‘Mania - she has all the ingredients. And with a big PLE in Australia to kick off 2024, it’s hard to see that momentum disappearing any time soon.

4. Christian Cage

For the first time, in 2023 AEW looked to be making damaging moves in its scooping up of venerable talent. While experience can bring a lot to the product, weird cameos like that of Sabu and signings of Ric Flair and, let’s face it, Adam Copeland seemed to be as much Tony Khan wanting to meet his heroes as good business sense.

Advertisement

Thank heavens for the committed work of Sting, then, and even more so, the career renaissance of Christian Cage. This has been a banner year for the perennially underrated Canadian, who has been let off the leash completely and found a niche as a patricidal malcontent who hasn’t yet found a line he won’t dance over.

Cage’s presentation is career best, from the turtlenecks to the belligerent but captivating mic work to propaganda minister Nigel McGuinness singing his praises from the commentary desk. He’s the nastiest, most cowardly heel in the business, and fans have never been more on his side.

It’s hard to imagine the band not eventually getting back together with Copeland and Cage on the same roster, so it’s important to enjoy arch heel Christian while he's still around, before he’s forced to plod through a best of seven series with the Hardyz for old time’s sake. Maybe Tony will sign Teri Runnels for completeness.

3. Kris Statlander

The booking of AEW’s women’s division has been spotty - often downright disinterested - from the jump, and 2023 has been no exception. A particular bright spot, though, has been the return of Kris Statlander, whose snatching of the TBS Title from Jade Cargill (under bizarrely heelish circumstances, but there you go) has allowed for many of the division’s best matches in the past year.

Advertisement

Like her pal Freshly Squeezed, Statlander’s workhorse credentials have been established during her run with the midcard belt. Every time she showed up, she showed out, bringing out the very best in Britt Baker (who had her finest match in ages) and helping to establish rising stars like Skye Blue and especially Julia Hart.

With all due respect to the undeniable star power of Cargill, this was exactly what the TBS title needed - a holder who could showcase it in diverse, well worked matches on a regular basis.

Most importantly, Statlander dropped the strap without taking the pin. It would be surprising were she not one of the next up for the roster’s main belt.

2. L.A. Knight

Perhaps not since Rocky Maivia has a gimmick been refreshed so completely and so effectively. Even leaving aside the dark days of Max Dupree, at the start of 2023 L.A. Knight was going nowhere. The Bray Wyatt feud was a show of faith to some extent, but he was essentially fodder for the returning Eater of Worlds to plough through, at the behest of Mountain Dew.

Advertisement

It’s difficult to pinpoint exactly where it all changed but essentially: people started listening. Knight’s mic work is unparallelled in WWE. His Attitude Era throwback qualities are much discussed, but he’s way more than a catchphrase machine. His pacing and delivery are perfect, and you never get the impression he’s just getting himself over at the cost of the angle.

Through bluster and bravado, Knight yakked his way to a main event against Roman Reigns, and while the outcome was academic, he didn’t look a bit out of place (he also proved himself universally beloved, a fan favourite from London to Riyadh).

The fact Knight is still in and around the Bloodline story suggests there’s more to come, and while he’s not going to be the one to knock Roman off, you can expect big things in 2024 - otherwise, they’ll have a riot on their hands.

1. Swerve Strickland

Barring injury or some boneheaded stubbornness, Swerve Strickland will become AEW World Champion in 2024. Over the latter half of 2023 especially, he has built himself from an underutilised talent to the heir apparent, and he’s done it all through logical storytelling, character work, and some amazing matches.

Advertisement

Strickland is the best kind of heel - a wrestling villain who makes sense. You might not like his methods (i.e traumatising infants) but when he tells Adam Page that the former champ has squandered every opportunity he’s had, every word hits home. His promos bristle with intensity without ever resorting to shouting and screaming - his descent into evil feels remarkably grounded.

Then there’s the matches. The column inches will go to the Texas Death Match, and rightly so, but his bout with Bryan Danielson was one of the best on TV, and he’s already doing great things in the Continental Classic.

Props should go to Prince Nana, also, whose chalk and cheese partnership with Strickland somehow just works, but few wrestlers can lay claim to the past few months more than Swerve. It’s always been clear he had the stuff - now, he’s truly delivering.

Advertisement