10 Wrestlers Who Peaked In Their First Match
It was all downhill in WWE, WCW and AEW for these wrestlers after ONE match.
Sometimes, even making a good first impression isn't enough.
That's the saying, right? "You only get one chance to make a good first impression". Well, these pro wrestlers did, but that initial bow in front of fresh eyes ended up being the apex of their entire runs in WWE, AEW and WCW. No, that doesn't sound very fair at all - it happened though.
There are some heavy hitters here too. The likes of Ronda Rousey, Keith Lee and even cherished legend Bret Hart are all included. Perhaps oddly, one of them worked a blistering bout on WWE's biggest stage, one blitzed their way through a short squash, and the other had a dream match that wound up being a false dawn for his proposed career renaissance.
Good luck getting those in the right order!
Let's make one thing crystal clear before starting though. These wrestlers didn't suddenly suck after experiencing the highs of these matches. No, they'd simply peaked as characters or important figures in a certain company. Maybe that's not too surprising when it comes to the talent merry-go-round that is modern-day AEW, or the car crash that was WCW.
Dig in.
10. Fandango
'FandangoMania' was a thing for the shortest of windows.
The dancing gimmick's Raw after WrestleMania 29 experience was...bizarre. Fans in attendance belted out his catchy theme tune, and the song even charted in the UK for a period. What's more, 'Dango had beaten none other than Chris Jericho on WWE's grandest stage.
He'd never top that. The only way was south for Vince McMahon's new ballroom dancer, chiefly because the boss and his creative sorts didn't really have any follow-up plan in mind. Nah, they just had Jericho put Fandango over, then realised that the hokey gimmick (like most OTT characters) had a definite shelf life.
The dude swivelling his hips didn't become a bad worker overnight though. Fandango continued showing potential in-ring, but 'Mania 29 was very-much the peak of his entire WWE run. At least he'd earn critical praise for his work alongside Tyler Breeze - those "Fashion Files" skits were a giggle.
9. Bam Bam Bigelow
Mobile powerhouse Bam Bam Bigelow traded ECW's bouncing payoffs for WCW stability (not a word most use when talking about 'Hotlanta') in late-1998, and he was rewarded by being thrust straight into a feud vs. Goldberg. That spotlight would fade relatively quickly.
Bammer actually went to a spirited non-finish with Goldberg on the 7 December 1998, but that was as good as it'd get in WCW for him. Sure, the company did book him opposite Bill again months later at SuperBrawl IX, but it was obvious to everyone watching that Bigelow wouldn't be a main-eventer.
He was relegated to the Hardcore Title mix soon thereafter.
Bam Bam was the latest beneficiary of WCW's bid to shock wrestling fans by gobbling up as much talent as they possibly could, but he only had a brief flirtation with relevancy in the company. Post-brawl with Goldberg, he started sliding down the pecking order towards literal garbage matches on the undercard.
8. Keith Lee
Man, it all started with a bang.
Keith Lee debuted amidst much fanfare on the 9 February 2022 edition of AEW Dynamite, and the wrestling masses roared with approval. Finally, people opined, big Keef would be treated with the respect he deserved, and defo wouldn't be asked to reinvent himself for Vinnie Mac's viewing pleasure.
That squash match win over Private Party's Isiah Kassidy would prove to be a false dawn for Lee, sadly. Like many All Elite incomers, he found it difficult to jostle for house room on an increasingly-busy roster, and Tony Khan shunted him sideways to the tag-team division pronto.
Lee has formed tags with both Swerve Strickland and Dustin Rhodes since. Those duos have been stricken with some of the lamest names in doubles history too - "Swerve In Our Glory"? "Naturally Limitless"? Such crummy names perhaps sum up Keith's fortunes in AEW thus far.
That Kassidy squash already feels like a lifetime ago.
7. ‘Dr. Death’ Steve Williams
It's a bit mad to think that Steve Williams was once a candidate to wrestle WWF kingpin Steve Austin in a series of matches throughout 1998. That's something Jim Ross hoped for when he signed his old pal, at least, but things didn't work out that way. 'Dr. Death' wasn't a hit in federation circles.
No, your eyes are not deceiving you when you glance at the pic above. Yes, the dreaded 'Brawl For All' was Williams' apex in the fed. He beat Pierre on the 14 July 1998 edition of Raw. This objectively awful introduction proved be the highlight of Death's entire run in the promotion.
He'd go on to lose to eventual tourney winner Bart Gunn on the 27 July episode, and that was a wrap on Steve's chances of ever standing across the ring from 'Stone Cold'. If only someone had suggested that maybe booking a dude you've got plans for in a shoot-fighting tournament wasn't smart, eh?
P*ss poor.
6. Pat McAfee
Say it ain't so!
Yep, critically-acclaimed former SmackDown colour commentator and Shinsuke Nakamura cheerleader Pat McAfee gets a spot on this list. He's had six matches in WWE, but it's the very first one that deserves your attention the most. Pat would never better that NXT TakeOver: XXX scrap.
Adam Cole showed his in-ring prowess by layering the bout with some huge (but deceptively straightforward) spots that made McAfee look like a super-worker. Of course, Pat had to meet Cole halfway and hold up his end of the bargain. The future announcer certainly did that, and he deserves a ton of praise for nailing his in-ring debut.
Future bouts, including a WarGames brawl in NXT, wouldn't show off the best of McAfee. The least said about bog standard showings vs. Baron Corbin, Austin Theory, The Miz and even Vince McMahon, the better too. None of those came close to matching what he'd achieved with Cole.
5. Bret Hart
Incoming obvious statement alert: Bret Hart was downright miserable in WCW, and seldom seemed at ease in the company. Introducing him as a special ref for Eric Bischoff vs. Larry Zbyszko was frankly stupid, and you can probably count the number of memorable moments for Bret in Atlanta on one hand.
Souled Out 1998 was one of them.
WCW handpicked Ric Flair as the ideal first opponent for Hart, and that was a shrewd call. Despite rarely seeing eye-to-eye outside it, Bret and Ric had more in common inside the ring than even they'd freely admit. The result was a worthy addition to the pay-per-view lineup, and a fine start in WCW rings for the 'Hitman'.
How many good-to-great matches did he have for the promotion after that? A handful at most? Anyone hoping to see Hart put on clinic after clinic in WCW would be teased by the Flair bout - it was the peak of Bret's post-Montreal stint.
4. Shinsuke Nakamura
This might be a fairly controversial one, but Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Sami Zayn at NXT TakeOver: Dallas back in April 2016 remains the only time WWE fans have witnessed the Shin who tore up New Japan rings on the regular. Other bouts, like those vs. AJ Styles and GUNTHER, have only offered fleeting moments of magic.
Meanwhile, the Sami debut showing was a tour de force.
Looking back on those old TakeOver specials is a real treat nowadays, and they honestly show how far NXT has fallen. Shinsuke played a part in that rise, and it was obvious to everyone watching that WWE had something special on their hands if they just let Naka's wrestling do the talking.
Unfortunately, attempts to "give him more personality" on the main roster flopped, and Shinsuke eventually settled into a WWE comfort zone he's struggled to get back out of. He's never come close to matching that clash with Zayn.
3. Ronda Rousey
Teaming with Kurt Angle against both Triple H and Stephanie McMahon was the perfect intro to WWE life for Ronda Rousey. Anticipation for Rousey's in-ring debut was off the charts, but creative smartly protected her by booking a tag that'd let Ronda pick her spots and rest up in between.
What a showing it was.
The wrestling world watched bright lights cascade down at WrestleMania 34 as Trips, Stephanie and Kurt did everything in their power to make Rousey look like the most dangerous fighter on the planet. They succeeded, and Ronda can also be proud of her efforts in such a highly-pressurised environment as 'Mania.
Like others here, she'd never top that first impression. Rousey has worked good matches here or there, sure, but none of them were as well-laid out or executed as flawlessly as 'Mania 34's tag bout. The place went bonkers when she took Hunter down and stretched Steph during the finish.
2. Tazz
It really sucks to put Taz/Tazz here, because any old-school ECW mark could tell you he should've been more in the WWF. The 'Human Suplex Machine' probably signed for the promotion in the wrong era - he'd have been awesome during the peak NXT days, for example, and would likely experience even greater success now.
Still, Tazz's Royal Rumble 2000 debut was a scorcher. Then-rookie Kurt Angle bumped like a madman for the debutant, so much so that WWF management worried some of Tazz's suplexes looked a bit reckless. That'd come back to bite him hard, which seems totally unfair considering some of the dangerous sh*t others in the company had been doing.
If only he'd been leaping off high structures, eh?
As a wrestler, Tazz's WWF/WWE career would never be better than it was on 23 January 2000. He looked like the man by demolishing an unbeaten Olympian, and Madison Square Garden greeted his arrival with a pop that must've made Vince McMahon see dollar signs spinning.
1. Dustin Rhodes
This battle of brothers will go down in history as one of the greatest AEW matches ever. It doesn't matter how many five-star-rated bouts Tony Khan's group produces - people will always come back to Cody vs. Dustin Rhodes at Double Or Nothing 2019, and with good reason.
It was bloody, passionately-worked and excellent from start to finish.
The whole thing was a spectacle, and a clear example of what's possible when older workers back themselves for more. Dustin was going nowhere in WWE, and hadn't really been doing much of note for years. Then, suddenly, he was on AEW's first pay-per-view working a show stealer vs. his sibling.
Rhodes hasn't really been expected to, but he hasn't topped the majesty of DoN 2019 since. Most of his bouts are functional, whereas the match with Cody was truly special. It's must-see if you were living under a rock in May 2019 and missed out live.
For more wrestling content, check out 10 Best Candidates To Win WWE’s New World Heavyweight Title and 10 Problems WWE Must Solve In The 2023 Draft!