10 Wrestlers Who Should Hold The AEW All-Atlantic Title

Which champs could take the All-Atlantic Title from undesirable to undeniable?

By Chris Chopping /

Certain fans groaned when AEW unveiled the All-Atlantic Championship. Many had been hoping instead for the long-awaited Trios Titles. Besides, between the AEW and TNT Titles, and the ROH World, TV and Pure Titles, there were already plenty of men's single belts knocking around on Dynamite and Rampage. That’s before you even mention the FTW Championship which, while not officially recognised, is still deemed worthy of promoting for Battle of the Belts or a main event slot on Rampage.

Advertisement

Nor did the commentary team do a great job of putting over the All-Atlantic Title’s unique selling point. The weirdly-named belt - at once both too vague and too specific - was designed to be defended not just on AEW television and PPVs but around the world in various different promotions. Which opens up all sorts of possibilities when it comes to who next holds the strap next.

In the meantime, the belt has looked more and more prestigious in the hands of a certain Geordie Bastard.

Pandemic-related travel issues have blighted much of PAC’s run with AEW, and he’s long felt overdue a title run. Now he has this and those long awaited Trios Championships to his name. “2 PAC” certainly looks good wearing gold across both shoulders, but nothing lasts forever.

So, who else should get a run with the All-Atlantic Championship?

10. “Speedball” Mike Bailey

Trying to secure a US booking without a VISA was nearly enough to curtail Mike Bailey’s promising career. As he watched peers sign with Impact or NXT, the Canadian found himself banned from the US for five years. Instead of giving up, he plotted a new course to success. From 2016 to 2020, Bailey wrestled all over the world - including Japan, the UK and Mexico - before the global pandemic made things even harder.

Advertisement

His exile came to an end earlier this year and the 32-year-old quickly started making up for lost time. He’s now finally working for Impact Wrestling but continues to compete and wow crowds for various independents as well.

Tony Khan loves a good cameo, and the All-Atlantic Title would be a good excuse to give “Speedball” a few showcase appearances in AEW. The former X-Division Champion is more than capable of a showstopping display.

Plus, having an AEW regular lose the belt to an Impact talent and having that champion defend the belt across several promotions would really help get across the All-Atlantic Title’s unique selling point.

Instead of letting fans see the belt as a third tier championship, open their eyes to its possibilities.

9. Matt Cardona

Since leaving WWE, the former Zack Ryder has been something of a revelation. It was all too easy to forget during the tail end of his WWE, but Cardona is a hugely entertaining and creative guy. His Z! True Long Island Story webseries is a direct antecedent of Being The Elite, and he proved that you don’t need a promotion to decide to convey stardom by pushing you. Instead, you can use the internet to tell your own stories and create your own fanbase.

Advertisement

Even though the “Thousand Dollar Broski” didn’t land a full-time AEW deal off the back of some guest spots in 2020, his influence still hangs over The Elite and their joyous creativity. Admittedly, AEW aren’t doing much to celebrate The Elite right now, but hopefully they’ll soon be back in the fold.

Since leaving the Fed, Matt’s been a riot collecting belts and upsetting the purists. He declared himself a death match king and added rare touches of deliberate levity to EC3’s cinematic Free The Narrative shows. It would be great to see AEW get in on the fun and repay his influence by giving him a short reign with the All-Atlantic title.

8. Scorpio Sky

Despite having literally had the poor guy grasp a ludicrous “brass ring” prop to win a ladder match, AEW has twice dropped the ball with Scorpio Sky as a babyface. Which is a shame, because he isn’t nearly as good as a heel.

Advertisement

Sky is a good looking, charismatic dude and his finger-snap-to-black promos were fun, but much of his heel run in Men of the Year consisted of standing behind Dan Lambert and pretending to p*ss himself at bad comedy bits.

As a babyface, he won fans over wrestling in his street shoes and became the first man to pin “Le Champion” Chris Jericho in AEW, but when that Scorpio Sky threatened to re-emerge during his TNT Title run, it turned out to be a Vince Russo-style swerve.

When Sky returns from injury, Tony Khan should make every effort to reboot the AEW original as the heart-on-sleeve babyface he should always have been. Strapping him up couldn’t hurt, but putting him back in the TNT Title picture might bring back suboptimal memories of his dire all-heel feud with Sammy Guevara.

Instead, fighting his way to the All Atlantic Title might be the refresh Scorp needs.

7. Nick Gage

This one might be a shrewd political move by Tony Khan. Up until very recently, Jon Moxley was a semi-regular fixture of Game Changer Wrestling, even holding the promotion's World Title. This past weekend, Mox dropped that championship to Nick Gage in a typically bloody, glass and pizza cutter-strewn war.

Advertisement

News has just emerged of a five year deal that signs Mox exclusively to AEW and their international partners, such as New Japan Pro-Wrestling. This will come as disappointing news for GCW owner Brett Lauderdale, who will now be losing the guy who was one of his biggest draws. Tony Khan has previously pulled other talent from GCW, as well. If Tony wants to leave the door open to a good working relationship with the independent promotion, it might help soften the blow to put an AEW belt on GCW’s own franchise player, Nick Gage.

Besides which, Gage’s one previous match for AEW was an absolute blast. He may have lost against Chris Jericho, but he pushed “The Painmaker” to his limit in the sort of match people don’t normally associate with the eight-time World Champion.

Provided network heads don’t water down the formula too much, it would be great to see Gage making the occasional All-Atlantic Title defence on Dynamite or Rampage.

6. Miro

When “The Best Man” reinvented himself as “The Redeemer” and took hold of the TNT Title, he became one of the most entertaining performers in all of AEW. That title run was arguably the highlight of the former Rusev’s wrestling career. The trouble is, after a spell away to recuperate and film a TV show, Tony Khan doesn’t seem to have much idea what to do next with Miro.

Advertisement

Unless you want to pull the trigger and make him a World Champion, a destroyer like Miro struggles on weekly television. Absorb too many loses and he’ll start to lose his monster aura.

In a way, Miro would be better suited to an earlier era, when he could have monstered a territory for a while before getting vanquished by the local babyface hero and moving on to the next promotion.

Perhaps the next best thing is to give Miro the All-Atlantic Title and send him overseas as AEW’s monster on loan. He can briefly show up and cause carnage in any number of promotions. What’s not to love about “The Redeemer” and his surgically repaired neck rampaging across the world, wrecking guys?

5. Eddie Kingston

Since turning babyface to save Jon Moxley, Eddie Kingston has been massively over with fans. He is a guy capable of drawing cheers against CM Punk, even at the height of “The Second City Saint’s” popularity as the comeback king. But despite tilts at the World Title, TNT Title and Tag Team Titles, Kingston has always fallen short. It’s about time “The Mad King” had some gold to take home to Ruthie.

Advertisement

Kingston doesn’t need to have a long run as All-Atlantic Champion; he’s the kind of sentimental favourite where the chase is more important than the title reign. In fact, Eddie is the perfect foil to get massive heat on a heel challenger who cheats to bring his reign to an abrupt end.

Of course, Kingston might have harmed his case after his recent backstage spat with Sammy Guevara. Eddie apologised, but might he lose his cool again in the future? As Tony Khan looks to steer AEW out of troubled waters, he might be looking for a safer pair of hands to hold the gold. The last thing TK wants is to strip or suspend another champion. Nonetheless, strapping up Eddie Kingston would be a hugely popular move, even if it’s only for a little while.

4. Darby Allin

Darby Allin’s partnership with Sting has been hugely entertaining but how much has it really helped the younger man? The pair have a spotless record in tag and multi-man matches, but generally it’s the age-defying veteran who gets the most memorable moments, performing an impossible aerial or no-selling his rival’s offense.

Advertisement

Meanwhile, it seems as though Tony Khan is happy to have Darby eat singles losses, believing the Sting matches will keep Allin strong. That just isn’t working out for the enigmatic star. While his willingness to take crazy bumps will always be popular with live crowds, it’s undeniable Darby’s popularity has waned somewhat since his days as TNT Champion.

While Allin once seemed nailed-on as a future main event talent, an influx of new stars have made it hard to plot his route to the top. Plus, fans can tell when an act doesn’t feel like a priority, and that hurts their own ability to invest in someone.

If Tony Khan wants fans to see Darby Allin as more than a career midcarder, he needs to give fans a reason to believe. A run with the All-Atlantic Title could help Darby out like the TNT Title did earlier in his AEW career.

3. Will Ospreay

After some initial frostiness, AEW and NJPW were able to build bridges that led not just to occasional cameos from the likes of Jeff Cobb, but an entire Pay Pay View of cross-pacific rivalries. Admittedly, the build for Forbidden Door was a little wonky, and injuries and politics robbed us of a few dream matches, but it was still an incredible show, and FTR remain the reigning IWGP Tag Champions.

Advertisement

Hopefully we will get another go around. With the Forbidden Door long since starting to resemble a revolving one, surely we’ll eventually see the likes of Bryan Danielson vs. Zach Sabre Jr. Tony Khan needs to make sure Gedo is happy with the arrangement, too. With one of AEW’s top teams walking around with NJPW tag belts, it couldn’t hurt to put a belt on one of the Japanese promotion’s big talents.

This would be more than just a political move, though. Will Ospreay is one of the best in-ring performers in the world, and apart from NJPW, it would be great to see him defend the All-Atlantic Title in the UK for RevPro. Plus, fingers crossed we get Kenny Omega back at some point.

If Ospreay holds the All-Atlantic Championship when Kenny returns to action, you know the Englishman will use his status as an AEW champion to further the p*ssing contest between the two of them.

2. Konosuke Takeshita

Despite Tony Khan signing loads of recognisable WWE names in the past few years, it’s still possible for the right guy to transcend relative obscurity and get over in AEW. This DDT stan out is a case in point.

Advertisement

It didn’t take long for Konosuke Takeshita to become something of a fan favourite on his recent US excursion, and plans are apparently in the works for him to return to AEW imminently.

During his first AEW run, Takeshita picked up wins on Dark and Dark: Elevation, plus a Rampage victory over perennial loser Ryan Nemeth, but fell short against the promotion’s big stars, including "Hangman" Adam Page, Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston. That’s fine because he’s still a young guy who can take loses to big names and not look any the worse for it.

That said, as with the likes of Darby Allin, Wheeler YUTA and Daniel Garcia, putting some gold round Konosuke's waist would show fans that AEW are serious about him going forward. Plus, Takeshita could take the All-Atlantic Title with him to defend in his home promotion back in Japan.

Given how WWE has supposedly been looking to pick up a Japanese talent with a large build, Konosuke Takeshita fits that bill perfectly. Seemingly he’s happy working for AEW, but it wouldn’t hurt to make a show of faith in the guy if other promotions are sniffing around.

1. Orange Cassidy

Earlier this year, it felt like we’d seen a new dawn for Orange Cassidy. He was wrestling on top form, massively over with fans, and the recipient of new, licensed entrance music. This was seen as a tacit message from Tony Khan; I’m investing in this guy, so you should too.

Advertisement

However, since then, it feels as though Cassidy’s momentum has been squandered.

Meanwhile, PAC might be a Bastard, but he’s not a cowardly, snivelling heel. He’s a ripped, wrestling dynamo. While other guys might use nut shots, baseball bats and diamond rings as a cheap short cut to victory, PAC’s desperation move is to deliver the kind of dazzling aerial he resents having to drag from deep within his arsenal. So, why has the Death Triangle man suddenly taken to whacking guys with hammers?

All of this needs to be going somewhere. PAC bringing down the hammer on Trent last Friday brought a rare level of emotion out of “Freshly Squeezed”, and now he and PAC are set for an All-Atlantic Title rematch this Wednesday. Surely this is building to a victory for Orange?

Tony Khan needs to reward fan investment in the Orange Cassidy character, and the Best Friends man would look silly to fall for the same trick twice. Expect the gold to change hands on Dynamite.

Advertisement