Fans watching Raw this past Monday were treated to quite the spectacle. Earlier that day, TMZ broke the news that Rusev and his former manager, Lana, had gotten engaged. The story picked up mainstream coverage, and while WWE probably should have chosen to ignore the news - at least on television - they promised to address the storyline-damaging events live on the Raw broadcast. When Rusev's segment on the show rolled around, the former possessor of a year-long undefeated streak was jobbed in three minutes, then verbally ripped to shreds by his current manager, Summer Rae. While it is possible that there's a longer plan at work, the booking of Raw certainly seemed counterproductive to keeping Rusev over as a strong heel. This wasn't the first time that a wrestler has been punished for breaking "kayfabe" - the law of upholding storylines and angles both on and off TV. Granted, it may have been the pettiest punishment for the strangest reason - especially given how haphazardly kayfabe is enforced these days - but many wrestlers have found themselves in trouble for pulling back the curtain. For good reasons or bad, they were jobbed out, suspended, or even fired...
Advertisement
10. Koji Kitao
Sumo wrestler-turned-pro wrestler Koji Kitao found quick success in wrestling. He became a part of Genichiro Tenryu's Super World of Sports promotion, and he and Tenryu actually had a brief run in WWE, defeating Demolition at WrestleMania VII. The two companies had a working relationship, and when WWE sent John "Earthquake" Tenta - also a former sumo - to wrestle Kitao in SWS, the Japanese star almost ended his own career with poor decision-making. For reasons only he knows, Kitao refused to cooperate with Tenta, and the match quickly broke down. Before it turned into a full-blown fight, though, Kitao rolled out of the ring, grabbed the house microphone and announced to the fans that wrestling was fake, and if it were real, Tenta could never beat him. Other wrestlers pulled Kitao to the back, and he was subsequently fired from SWS.
9. Shawn Michaels
While the two have patched things up in recent years, it's no understatement to say that, in the mid-1990s, Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart absolutely hated each other. They were feuding on TV at the time as well, and while the animosity made things more exciting, it also made the situation particularly volatile. The two had a verbal exchange on an episode of Raw in 1997, but Michaels went off-script and commented that Bret had been having "Sunny days" lately - implying that Bret was having an affair with Sunny. Needless to say, Hart wasn't happy. A few weeks later, things boiled over. Hart confronted Michaels backstage, and the two ended up getting into a skirmish. The fight was separated, but most agreed that "The Hitman" got the better of HBK. After that, a disgruntled Michaels took a leave of absence from the company. He wasn't officially punished, but the whole incident certainly didn't work out in his favor.
8. Matt Hardy
After an abysmal feud with Kane in 2004, Matt Hardy suffered a knee injury and was put on the sidelines for several months. In the spring of 2005, hardcore Hardy fans noticed that the still-convalescing former World Tag Team Champion took down all the photos of his longtime girlfriend, Lita, from his website. Hardy told fans who questioned him that they should ask her why, but he soon stopped holding back, detailing on his site that Lita and his close friend, Edge, had had a real-life affair. Without warning, Hardy was fired in April of 2005. Many fans assumed that his dismissal was a result of his airing of dirty laundry, and soon chants of "You screwed Hardy!" began to dog Edge and Lita. Recognizing the money in a potential feud between the two, WWE rehired Hardy in July.
7. Serena
Serena Deeb joined WWE as part of CM Punk's Straight Edge Society, renouncing her past as an addict and accepting a head-shaving en route to a cleansing from the increasingly Mansonesque Punk. Along with Luke Gallows, she did Punk's dirty work, aiding him in his self-righteous quest to preach his message and annoy those who disagreed with him. In August of 2010, Serena was suddenly fired - reportedly for not living out her straight edge gimmick in real life. While wrestlers aren't expected to continuously stay in character, decision-makers at WWE clearly thought it was important for Serena to abstain from any non-straight edge activity for the sake of storyline, and she didn't feel the same way. Just a month prior to her firing, WWE ran an angle where Serena was caught on camera entering a bar, earning a chastisement from Punk. In retrospect, many viewed that as a not-so-veiled message from the company for her to live the gimmick.
6. Paul London
On June 11, 2007, Raw played host to Mr. McMahon Appreciation Night, a special episode filled with interviews from McMahon's longtime coworkers and associates - most of whom insulted the WWE Chairman. At the end, a distraught McMahon took a long walk out of the building - receiving no comfort from his employees, who simply stared at him solemnly - and entered a limousine, which exploded. The whole "Who killed Vince McMahon?" storyline was dropped two weeks later after Chris Benoit murdered his family and killed himself, but some bad blood from the initial angle didn't go away. While all the wrestlers did their best to look serious as McMahon took his final walk down the hallway, Paul London - who smiled at the boss - was the exception. He soon lost his push, and by the next year, he was unemployed. In a later interview, London claimed that he was never told what the angle was all about, only that Vince was walking down the hallway and he was told to react accordingly. He didn't confirm punishment as a result, but when asked if he was approached by McMahon about his behavior, he said he had been confronted by the boss "several times."
5. William Regal
Few wrestlers in history have had the talent of William Regal, but early in his career, a drug addiction hampered his performance and left his conduct unpredictable. While he had a successful run in WCW, it came to an end following a Monday Nitro match with Bill Goldberg in early 1998. Goldberg, on his way to becoming the top star in WCW, was amassing a winning streak that typically involved him squashing his opponents in under two minutes. The Regal match was different. The two went for six minutes, with Regal - who began wrestling in shoot matches at English carnivals - appearing to work stiff with the rookie. Goldberg still won cleanly, but Regal was fired shortly afterwards. While rumor has it that Regal's firing was a result of his lack of cooperation in the ring, he attests that he was told by WCW management to have a competitive match with Goldberg.
4. Daniel Puder
When Tough Enough wasn't renewed for a fourth season, the competition became part of Smackdown, and what was once an entertaining reality show was reduced to a series of bizarre skits involving wrestlers, rookies, and no script. On the show's November 4, 2004 episode, the contestants were forced to participate in a squat thrust contest, with the winner getting the grand prize of a shoot wrestling match with Kurt Angle. Chris Nawrocki had the honor, and Angle quickly broke his ribs and tapped him out. Angle made an open challenge to any of the rookies, and front-runner Daniel Puder - who had MMA experience - accepted. The two tussled and Angle took Puder down, but the rookie applied a kimura lock, nearly breaking the Olympic Gold Medalist's arm. Angle managed to hold on through the pain and he pushed Puder to the man, "pinning" him despite the fact that Puder got his shoulders up. Puder, who was seen as disrespectful to Angle, became the most hated man in the locker room. He won the contest, but his only WWE appearance after that came in the 2005 Royal Rumble, where Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, and Hardcore Holly chopped him repeatedly. After the guaranteed first year of his contract ended, WWE offered him a standard developmental deal and he left the company.
3/2. "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan & The Iron Sheik
Once upon a time, kayfabe was a very real thing - fans really believed that wrestlers hated each other and fought with the intent of winning, and that belief, it was felt, was what made wrestling a draw. When Vince McMahon took over ownership of WWE from his father in the early 1980s, he started classifying what he did as "entertainment," but an incident in 1987 made it clear that McMahon was still very much interested in protecting the business. Following a WWE event in May of that year, The Iron Sheik and "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan were pulled over by police officers in New Jersey for driving erratically. Duggan, it was determined, was under the influence of marijuana, while Sheik had been using cocaine. The two were arrested, and when the story broke, fans were absolutely shocked to see that the patriotic Duggan had been traveling with the USA-hating Sheik, Drugs were rampant in WWE in those days, but such an unforgivable breach of etiquette led to Duggan's temporary dismissal and Sheik's firing. Filmmaker Chris Bell of Bigger, Stronger, Faster fame cites the arrest as the moment he learned wrestling was scripted.
1. Triple H
Today, Triple H is Vince McMahon's son-in-law and the heir to the WWE empire, but two decades ago, he was an employee who got in deep trouble with his boss. Triple H was part of The Kliq, a backstage affiliation also consisting of Shawn Michaels, Kevin Nash, Scott Hall, and Sean Waltman. At a Madison Square Garden house show on May 19, 1996, Triple H wrestled Hall and Michaels wrestled Nash in separate matches. Hall and Nash, though, were about to leave WWE for WCW, so after the Michaels-Nash main event, Hall came to the ring and hugged Michaels. Triple H - a heel - followed suit and joined in and Diesel - also a heel - completed the group hug and celebration. McMahon was angry, but he couldn't punish Hall and Nash, who were leaving, and Michaels, who was WWE Champion (at least not without screwing up his booking plans). He had to take his frustrations out on Triple H, who soon saw his win/loss record suffer. Nevertheless, Triple H weathered his punishment - earning respect in the process - and soon achieved the success for which he had been slated. With HHH out of the picture in the summer of 1996, though, McMahon was forced to give his push to a WWE newcomer named "Stone Cold" Steve Austin. We think everybody ended up happy.