10 Wrestlers WWE Gave Up On In 2019
A graveyard of dead careers and abandoned pushes.
The half-hearted measures with which WWE push wrestlers outside the main event scene these days necessitates a few exclusions here, as at least a handful of these abandoned projects will be revisited at a later date.
While it was reported that Drew McIntyre would become a headliner after dissolving his partnership with Dolph Ziggler, the burly Scot slid back towards the middle of the pack around WrestleMania season. He's massive, though, and a great performer in general. He'll be fine.
Ricochet is a goddamn videogame character between the ropes, which might not make him a World Title contender, but will bring new opportunities. It's too early to put much stock into Humberto Carrillo's inability to become United States Champion. Shorty G still makes television most weeks. There are further examples, though these stick out the most.
Regardless, WWE's colossal talent pool still features many wrestlers whom the promotion have demonstrably lost faith in over the past 12 months. Some are understandable, as not every act is going to deliver as intended, while others, most certainly, are not, with WWE abandoning pushes, programmes, storylines, and performers at the drop of a hat...
10. Drew Gulak
Drew Gulak technically moved up the kayfabe ladder when he joined SmackDown from 205 Live in the 2019 WWE Draft. He's on the biggest show with the biggest audience now, but the problem is that he has gone from Cruiserweight cornerstone to Friday night squash fooder. Creatively, that's a huge step backwards, even if there are more eyes on his work now.
Disappointingly, Gulak has reverted to goofball PowerPoint-peddling type since joining Team Blue. This began with Braun Strowman murder-shagging him ahead of Crown Jewel and he hasn't fared any better since, with Kalisto and Mustafa Ali both topping him in listless three-minuters.
It's a shame to see 'The Philadelphia Stretcher' in this state after a great run as a commanding ring general. It's understandable, of course, because a guy like Gulak was never going to be presented as a big deal in the land of the giants, but why rip him from 205 Live in the first place? Can local enhancement talents not do the same job without the character decimation?
9. Mike Kanellis
Whether WWE ever gave a hoot about Mike Kanellis in the first place is debatable, given how poorly they handled his debut, though the promotion at least tried to do something with him and wife Maria earlier this year.
Their cuckolding storyline was bad. So, so bad. Regardless, it got both on television, showing that WWE at least had enough faith in them to carry a goofy undercard programme the likes of which Paul Heyman has always dabbled in. Mike has always been an effective jobber, too, so him getting battered by Maria's potential baby daddies at least let him play a complementary role.
The pregnancy angle was abandoned without concrete resolution. Bobby Lashley, Lana, and Rusev became the hip new cuck angle, and Mike was removed from WWE's schedule entirely. The man's last match came on the 24 September episode of SmackDown, on which he lost to Chad Gable in 19 seconds. He isn't even working house shows.
This is almost certainly down to Kanellis' decision to ask for his release just four months after signing a new deal with the promotion, though it's clear that his employers gave up on him regardless. He's in career purgatory for the foreseeable future.
8. Mojo Rawley
Continuing the theme from Mike Kanellis, Mojo Rawley is part of a big group of wrestlers that WWE endeavoured to try something with earlier in the year only to abandon a few weeks down the line, leaving the performer drifting aimlessly down Creative Has Nothing For You Creek.
Mojo's rebirth barely got going. A February episode of Raw saw the former Hype Bro talking to himself in a mirror, saying it was time to stop being such a team player. Close to two months passed before this was followed up on, with Rawley back in his mirror, before he shattered it on the post-WrestleMania show. Now sporting blue facepaint, Mojo declared he had found himself. Here comes the push!
Or not. Rawley defeated Apollo Crews one month later but hasn't been seen on Raw since May.
Was Mojo ever a pushable commodity? That's debatable, but what was the plan here? What was the intended goal? What were WWE trying to do, and why did they randomly forget about Rawley for weeks on end before abandoning the project entirely?
A baffling situation.
7. Shelton Benjamin
Shelton Benjamin looked to be heading in a new direction when he started appearing in deliberately awkward backstage interviews on SmackDown. The former 'Gold Standard' would hesitate before answering a question, then shift his gaze around the room, a smile slowly stretching across his features. It was odd and offered little more than a base level of intrigue, but at least gave long-suffering Shelton fans (of which there are surprisingly many) something to cling onto.
Again, the storyline was abandoned before it took off. WWE stopped presenting these segments and Benjamin returned to the ether after losing to Chad Gable in the King of the Ring tournament, though he did find time in his not-at-all-busy schedule to get his head kicked in by Cain Velasquez ahead of Brock Lesnar's (his former Minnesota Stretching Crew tag partner) match with the former UFC Heavyweight Champion at Crown Jewel.
Being realistic, Shelton is 44 years old. He's past his athletic prime and was never particularly charismatic in the first place, making him an unlikely candidate for elevation in any of his post-comeback years, though his sudden abandonment asks similar questions to those of Mike Kanellis and Mojo Rawley.
6. Cedric Alexander
Of all the talented, hyper-athletic undercard wrestlers to be "pushed" by WWE in 2019, Cedric Alexander is the least likely to bounce back. That's how big a hash they made of the former Cruiserweight Champion's attempted elevation.
It began with the laughably bad Gary 'The GOAT' Garbutt angle in which WWE effectively treated Alexander and Roman Reigns' quick loss to Drew McIntyre and Shane McMahon as a victory because they'd "fooled" the heels. You show 'em, boys. Later, Alexander scored a win over McIntyre and popped the internet with a big dive in Reigns' Samoan Summit segment, then entered United States Championship contention, but was phased out after losing to AJ Styles. Not even 50/50 booking or the "cancelled" rematch clause could by the former Cruiserweight standout a reign.
Cedric is now back near the bottom of the pile. Recent Raw outings have seen him lose to Buddy Murphy and Andrade in single-digit runtimes, and he's now farting around with WWE's other abandoned wrestlers on Main Event. The "push," if you can even call it that, didn't work, making this one of the company's most half-hearted attempts at lifting somebody out of a lower midcard in years.
5. Mustafa Ali
Spare a thought for Mustafa Ali, whose 2019 could have gone a lot differently had injury not derailed him ahead of Elimination Chamber.
Ali was set to tangle with SmackDown's biggest and brightest and challenge for the WWE Championship on the show. He had to pull out, however. This led to Kofi Kingston coming in as his replacement, and we all know how that story goes, with KofiMania taking off, The New Day man starring in the year's most compelling main roster storyline, and that epic WrestleMania 35 title win on the back of a match destined to go down as a modern classic.
Mustafa, meanwhile, was a last-minute addition to a WWE Championship match between Kevin Owens and Daniel Bryan at Fastlane, then fell down the ladder. He was on Money in the Bank and remained a regular TV character afterwards, but hasn't come close to the World Title picture since.
None of this is to say that Ali would've enjoyed a similar year to Kofi had he not gotten injured, of course. Still, it definitely altered his trajectory, and that WWE abandoned (then restarted) a lazy Intercontinental Title feud with Shinsuke Nakamura and his positive reinforcement character in the summer further justifies his inclusion.
4. The IIconics
Other than needlessly cutting off what could have been an excellent Sasha Banks/Bayley reign at the knees and popping WhatCulture's Adam Wilbourn, what was the point in The IIconics' Women's Tag Team Championship reign?
This wet fart of a run began at WrestleMania 35. Billie Kay and Peyton Royce took the belts in a match that also featured Natalya/Beth Phoenix and Nix Jax/Tamina. What followed was 120 days of them barely even making television, let alone defending the belts, with their two successful defences combining for just five minutes of cumulative ring time before they eventually dropped the straps to Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross in August.
The titles' prestige rebounded in the aftermath and they now feel more important than ever with Kairi Sane and Asuka as champions. Still, The IIconics went on an immediate slide. Their sparse TV schedule was reduced to the extent that they now go missing for months on end. Where once they were effective undercard heaters, it seems WWE don't even have faith in them to pull this off any more. They're dead in the water.
3. EC3
The most exciting in-ring performer he most certainly is not, but that WWE weren't able to get more from EC3 on the main roster is surprising.
The guy ticks loads of Vince McMahon's boxes. He's big, muscular, looks great in a suit, can draw heat when given a chance, plays a great heel, and is a fantastic talker. He's a born Sports Entertainer, basically, and while this workrate-heavy era makes it difficult for him between the ropes, EC3's positive attributes made him look like a surefire contention for main roster elevation.
Unfortunately, WWE gave up on 'The One-Percenter' somewhere between him leaving NXT and joining Raw.
EC3's main roster run was botched from the start, with WWE deciding to debut the excellent promo guy via a series of backstage segments in which he'd show up, not say a single word, then leave. A short 50/50 feud with Dean Ambrose followed. Afterwards, the former Derrick Bateman became 24/7 Championship fodder, and he's now sat at home nursing a concussion, having not competed since September.
2. Luke Harper
An easy one, here, as there are several moments one can point to where WWE have clearly given up on Luke Harper:-
1. Vince McMahon deciding that he didn't like the guy because he couldn't do a convincing enough southern accent for him.
2. Vince McMahon deciding, again, that he didn't like the guy, this time for his role in a failed dark match that saw Drake Maverick trialled as EC3's manager.
3. The reported scrapped feud with Sami Zayn when both returned from injury over WrestleMania 35 weekend.
4. WWE adding time to his contract and taking Luke off the road when he requested his release in April.
5. Sending Harper back into the abyss after randomly bringing him back to reprise his alliance with Erick Rowan in September.
It's a shame, because Harper is one of the best big men in the business and, by all accounts, a lovely, lovely man behind the scenes. That his career is on ice because he realised he cannot prosper while working to WWE's framework sucks, though applying to trademark his old "Brodie Lee" ring name suggests he's already gearing up for life after the promotion.
1. Kofi Kingston
KofiMania was your writer's favourite main roster storyline of 2019.
A natural, organic coming-of-age tale, it was a great example of WWE stepping away from their usual remit to listen to what the fans wanted from the product bearing fruit. Kingston was the most over guy on the roster as the company sped towards WrestleMania 35. He was popular as f*ck, his efforts were popular as f*ck, and WWE spun it perfectly, leading to the ultimate emotional climax against Daniel Bryan.
It's unfortunate, then, that the WWE Championship reign that followed didn't deliver the same satisfaction. Kofi kept working hard but underdelivered between the ropes. While their presentation didn't help, it's hard to view his bouts with Kevin Owens, Dolph Ziggler, Samoa Joe, and Randy Orton as anything other than letdowns after the awesome story that took him to the top of the mountain.
The chase was incredible. The reign? Not so much.
Brock Lesnar ending Kingston's lengthy reign with a seven-second squash on SmackDown's FOX debut was the moment the company gave up on him as a main-eventer. It was a long run, but not a particularly effective one, and he may never come close to another again.