10 Wrestlers WWE Pushed Way Over Their Heads
Steve Austin, these guys most certainly were not.
Whatever you think of him as a booker, that Vince McMahon had a hand in creating some of wrestling's biggest megastars is undeniable. Sure, WWE's star making machine isn't as efficient as it used to be, but they've struck gold plenty of times throughout Vince's 35 years in charge.
Hulk Hogan was the perfect, larger than life superhero for the 1980s. Steve Austin capitalised on Generation X's disenfranchisement and distrust of authority to become the Attitude Era's biggest star. Even the oft-maligned John Cena became a transcendent star in his own right, anchoring the company's main event for over a decade.
WWE's track record is far from immaculate, though. For every main event success story, there are at least two or three spectacular flops, and while failure comes in many forms, Vince's propensity to push wrestlers far beyond their capabilities is one of the most common reasons.
Presence, charisma, a good look, in-ring ability: it takes a near flawless skillset to succeed in this role, and many have been found wanting. It's not their fault, and the level of disdain they receive is often unwarranted - but that's what happens when the boss throws you in at the deep end.
10. Big Cass
Poor old Big Cass. Just when it looked like the seven-footer was being prepped for a main event push, disaster struck. The former 'Realest Guy In The Room' took a nasty bump while wrestling Enzo Amore on Raw, and now looks set to miss up to nine months of action, potentially taking him out of the picture until May 2018.
There's nothing good about such a crushing injury, but WWE may seize this opportunity to rethink their strategy with Cass. His split from Enzo has been a complete flop. The big lad is just as lost without his mouthpiece as Amore is without his brawny partner, and while their feud has produced a handful of memorable promos, the matches stunk, particularly SummerSlam's shark cage bout.
Cass' size meant that WWE were always going to push him over his head. Vince McMahon has demonstrated his fondness for tall wrestlers countless times over the years, with Cass the latest beneficiary. He was immensely popular as a tag wrestler, but his lack of charisma was even more apparent without Enzo, and he's still developing in the ring. That's not to see he can't be a star in the future, but his push came far too soon.
9. Heidenreich
A monstrous flop in the early 2000s, Jon Heidenreich's name will always be synonymous with failed upper-midcard pushes.
In fairness, this wasn't entirely his own fault. He was saddled with a terrible split personality gimmick upon debuting in 2003, and was repackaged as a psychotic poet in 2004. Heidenreich's weekly appearances saw him reciting his hateful "Disasterpieces," randomly interfering in matches, and attacking fans. One week, he assaulted Michael Cole, dragged him backstage, then sexually abused him in a bathroom. How delightful.
WWE often use The Undertaker as an opponent when trying to build their next big monster, and that was the case with Heidenreich. Their feud started following a run-in on 'Taker's WWE Title match with JBL at No Mercy 2004, and continued throughout the year. Snitsky was roped into the rivalry in 2005, but Jon was eventually defeated in a terrible casket match at the Royal Rumble, ending the story.
Widely regarded as one of 'The Deadman's' worst opponents, Heidenreich lacked the in-ring ability and imposing presence to become a genuine top level monster. His career gradually faded away, and he was released following a run alongside Road Warrior Animal in the new Legion Of Doom in 2006.
8. Bobby Lashley
Bobby Lashley has developed into a tremendous professional wrestler in 2017. He has been one of TNA's biggest highlights for years, delivering excellent matches against a wide variety of opponents, and refining his authentic 'Walking Armageddon' gimmick into one of the most compelling in the company. Unfortunately, many fans only remember him for his shoddy WWE work, and that does him a great disservice.
Lashley had the rocket strapped to him in 2005. Introduced as an amateur wrestling standout, he looked like an Adonis from day one, which explains why Vince McMahon pushed him so hard. He was one of the Chairman's hand-picked prospects, and he surged, quickly capturing the United States Title, before moving to the ECW brand and becoming that show's top champion (a move that apparently prompted Paul Heyman to resign).
He played a big role in the turgid Vince McMahon vs. Donald Trump storyline, then left Raw the pursue the WWE Championship in 2007. Unfortunately, Lashley's popularity had greatly diminished by this point. He was green, awkward, and uncharismatic, and the fans couldn't buy into him as a force. He eventually suffered a nasty injury at The Great American bash, sat out for six months, then was quietly released in February 2008.
7. Sycho Sid
At 6'9", 300lbs, Sycho Sid brought great size to the table, and he always carried a sense of menace, but those might be the nicest things you can say about him as a performer. His tired ring work was clunky at best, and you can count the number of times a superior opponent was able to drag even a serviceable match out of him on one hand. Wrestling aside, his screaming promos were legendarily bad, with this gem standing out in particular.
Despite these deficiencies, Sid still became a legitimate main eventer in both of America's major wrestling promotions. He was a two-time WCW World Heavyweight Champion, but the WWF was the first company to give him a monster push, and his first WWF Title win came over Shawn Michaels at Survivor Series 1996.
Sid's first run lasted a couple of months before eventually dropping it back to HBK, but he regained the gold in February 1997, dethroning Bret Hart in the process. This 34-day run ended at The Undertaker's hands, but while Sid was never meant to be anything more than a transitional champ, he still stunk the place up as a headliner
6. Jack Swagger
Jack Swagger will ultimately be remembered as a WWE flop, and this is largely down to the way he was shoved down fans' throats early in his career. Tall and athletic, his amateur wrestling background gave him an air of legitimacy, and he was a good worker too. He was no Kurt Angle, but Swagger's collegiate pedigree helped him develop a balanced in-ring style blending technical mat wrestling with powerful throws and suplexes.
Despite these positive traits, Swagger was badly lacking in the most important department: charisma. Unfortunately, Jack's inability to project a compelling character meant he was never able to forge a lasting connection with the crowd, and therefore wasn't equipped to carry a World Title.
That didn't stop Vince McMahon from eventually making him World Heavyweight champion in 2010. He was booked like a complete loser throughout his 79-day reign, and lost so many non-title matches that the one time WWE did decide to give him a clean win over a legitimate superstar (Randy Orton at Extreme Rules '10), nobody cared.
His main event run will forever be mocked, but Swagger should've never been put in that position in the first place.
5. Jinder Mahal
People have a tendency go go over the top when it comes to judging Jinder Mahal's WWE Title reign. It has been bad, but 'The Modern Day Maharaja' isn't the worst wrestler to ever hold the belt, and he has actually done well to project a star aura while holding the company's top prize. He does have some clear deficiencies, however, and they can't be ignored.
Mahal stinks between the ropes. Everything about him is average, but when the bell rings, Jinder is among the worst in the company. He moves like a superglued Action Man, sends crowds to sleep during his control segments, and even botched his finishing move at SummerSlam. WWE know this, and that's why they try to mask his flash with endless Singh Brothers interference.
Jinder was pushed as a way to capitalise on the potentially huge Indian market. No concrete data has emerged to tell us whether this has been a success or not, but his run has made him one of the most maligned performers in the world.
Sadly, 'The Maharaja' possesses few of the traits that fans want to see in a WWE Champion, and the criticism will persist until the day he drops the title.
4. Mabel
WWE haven't always done the best job when it comes to booking a convincing King Of The Ring winner, but nobody, not even Billy Gunn, can compare with Mabel. The future Viscera won the competition in 1995, and what followed was one of the most ill-advised main event pushes in WWE history.
King Mabel was supposed to become the WWF's top heel, and he entered a feud with WWF Champion Diesel in the lead up to SummerSlam. This resulted in a truly atrocious main event on the year's second big show, and while Diesel was never known for his in-ring finesse, Mabel made him look like Ricky Steamboat. The bout's badness was further enhanced by the fact that it took place directly after Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon's historic ladder match, and the King flopped to defeat in just over nine minutes, ending his main event run.
Kevin Nash has since speculated that Mabel's push was cancelled because he'd developed a reputation as a clumsy, reckless worker, and had already injured "six or eight" wrestlers prior to SummerSlam. Whatever the case, it was abundantly clear that the big man was being stretched well beyond his capabilities.
3. Giant Gonzalez
Another of The Undertaker's worst opponents, Giant Gonzalez's name has become a running joke among professional wrestling fans. His feud with 'The Deadman' was supposed to propel him to stardom, but while Gonzalez was billed at a ridiculous 8' tall, it soon became apparent that height was his only real attribute.
Gonzalez absolutely sucked. The very definition of a "big, lumbering giant," he had no coordination, no skill, and little athleticism. There was absolutely nothing The Undertaker could do to drag an acceptable match out of him, and while their WrestleMania IX bout lives on as one of the worst in the event's history, their rivalry didn't end there.
Unperturbed by the first match's failings, WWE booked Gonzalez vs. 'Taker II for SummerSlam 1993, and it was somehow worse than their first encounter. Gonzalez was still struggling to execute even the most rudimentary of wrestling moves, and his height made it physically impossible for Undertaker to execute a Tombstone Piledriver on him, resulting in a weak clothesline finish.
Perhaps Gonzalez's push would have succeeded if he weren't so subpar between the ropes, or maybe the awful bodysuit doomed him from the start. Either way, he was in well over his head in 1993.
2. Lex Luger
He's often held up as one of the most overrated wrestlers of all time, but Lex Luger wasn't all that bad back in the day. Was he basic? Absolutely, but he was still more than capable of having a decent match against the right opponent, as his old bouts with Ric Flair, Ricky Steamboat and Barry Windham attest.
The problem was that the WWF tried to push him as Hulk Hogan's replacement - a role he wasn't at all capable of playing. Big, muscular, blonde-haired superhero types were on the way out, and fans were pining for the elevation of smaller, more dynamic wrestlers like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. Luger was very much in the Hogan mould, but he lacked Hulk's electric charisma, and that's why he never became a franchise player.
The WWF saddled Lex with a textbook all-American gimmick, and he enjoyed a sizeable push throughout his run. Despite this, the WWF shelved multiple plans to make Lex champion, and he eventually became one of the first wrestlers to jump ship from WWE to WCW in September 1995. Luger has been on McMahon's personal blacklist ever since, and whether justifiable or not, his name remains synonymous with failure.
1. Roman Reigns
Roman Reigns inherited John Cena's mantle as the most widely despised babyface in WWE a long time ago. Like Cena before him, Roman is presented as a "good guy," but regularly draws the company's loudest jeers, and carries himself like a detestable bully. He's a man who rarely loses clean, and when he does, the bookers are quick to give him a convenient excuse or find a way to have him get his own back immediately. Reigns is 'Super Cena' reborn, and many loathe him for it.
Just like his predecessor, Reigns is a victim of the way the company book him. Yes, his push has been extremely obnoxious at times, but that's not his fault. He's an upper-midcard level talent who has been positioned as the face of the company, and he doesn't deserve a fraction of the bile that's thrown his way.
Reigns' resumé of outstanding matches is too vast for the argument that he's a subpar wrestler to hold weight anymore. There are problems with his character work, and his promo delivery isn't great, but nobody would complain about these things if he wasn't being booked like Cena. If anything, his example shows that this kind of push no longer works, and it's a shame WWE haven't moved on from it.