10 Wrestling Characters Played By Multiple Wrestlers

Turns out wrestlers can regenerate just like The Doctor.

By Jacob Simmons /

The similarities between wrestlers and actors are plain to see.

Advertisement

Both tell stories, both follow scripts, and both end up going through multiple divorces. The only difference is Lawrence Olivier never hit anyone with a piledriver... that we know of.

So, if wrestlers play characters in the same way actors do, then it makes sense that they can be recast just as easily as in the world of film, TV, or the stage.

Whilst a wrestling persona's popularity is often closely tied in with the actual performer, that hasn't stopped promoters from attempting to present different people as beloved characters.

Equally, sometimes a wrestler notices a character getting over and decides to "liberate" so of its qualities for themselves. Stealing finishing moves is one thing, but stealing an entire gimmick? It happens, you know.

We've rounded up ten copycats, epigones, and imitators who all attempted to pass for an existing wrestler.

Sometimes this went well, and the impersonators actually had better careers than those they were impersonating.

In most cases though, their time pretending to be someone else was short-lived, often serving to remind us how good the original was...

10. The Nature Boy (Buddy Rogers/Ric Flair/Buddy Landel)

Buddy Rogers was famously the first man to ever hold the WWE Championship. Ric Flair is the joint most decorated world champion in wrestling history (the most if you ask the man himself). And Buddy Landel was... well, he was a wrestler too.

Advertisement

All three men had one thing in common though - they all shared a very famous nickname.

Rogers started going by Nature Boy in the early 1950s. A cocky, strutting villain with bleach blonde hair, Rogers reinvented what it meant to be a wrestling heel and set the standard for all baddies who followed him.

One of said followers was Ric Flair who, in the 1970s, also adopted the moniker. As well as that, he also copped Rogers' look, attire, and finishing move. Well, they do say that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

As for Landel, he was even more brazen, using the Nature Boy persona and gimmick at the same time and in the same promotion as Flair! Although, he wasn't nearly as successful as the two that came before him.

Three men, three very different careers, one nickname, absolutely no idea what it means.

Seriously, what is a Nature Boy?

9. Sting (Steve Borden/Jeff Farmer)

Steve Borden has been wrestling under the moniker of Sting since 1986 and has made a lot of memories and money with the character.

Advertisement

However, for one night in 1996, his claim to the name came under threat.

In the early days of the New World Order, WCW wrestlers were constantly questioning each other's loyalties. Lex Luger accused his friend Sting of being in cahoots with the evil group, when a man who looked like him attacked Luger in the parking lot.

To be fair, that's a pretty good reason to be suspicious.

At Fall Brawl, Sting seemingly turned on the good guys by joining the NWO's team in War Games. However, the plot thickened when a second Sting came out to join the fray!

Whaaaaaaaa?

It turned out that the first Sting was Jeff Farmer, a wrestler hired by the NWO to portray the Stinger and convince his friends that he'd betrayed them. The plan worked, as the real Sting left the match in disgust to allow fake Sting to tap out Luger for the win.

After Fall Brawl, Farmer would take on the mantle of "NWO Sting" and wrestled using the gimmick as recently as 2019.

8. Mr. Wrestling (Tim Woods/Johnny Walker)

Wrestler Johnny Walker was semi-retired in 1972 when promoter Paul Jones made him an offer. Jones wanted Walker to return under a mask as "Mr. Wrestling II" and be a top star in the Georgia territory.

Advertisement

Walker accepted the offer, changing his life forever.

But what happened to Mr. Wrestling I?

The OG Mr. Wrestling was George Woodin, who also wrestled under the name Tim Woods. Mr. Wrestling became a top babyface across the Southern states of America and even had a few matches in the company that would become WWE.

Walker's new character was introduced as the original Mr. Wrestling's partner, although their relationship was never explained. Father and son? Brothers? Lovers? We'll never know.

Both men were extremely successful under their respective masks. Woods won several NWA titles and Walker was so popular that future President Jimmy Carter once requested to meet him!

Insert joke about politicians wearing masks here.

When Woods retired from wrestling in 1983, Walker carried on using the Mr. Wrestling name. The gimmick eventually found a new home in the form of Steve Corino who, as Mr. Wrestling III, teamed up with Mr. Wrestling II to win a set of tag team titles in Hawaii.

7. The Conquistadors (Edge & Christian/The Hardy Boyz)

Los Conquistadores was the name given to a jobber tag team who worked for the WWE in the late 80s and early 90s.

Advertisement

Rather shockingly, this gold-covered duo made their return to WWE TV in the year 2000, although all was not as it seemed.

The pair acted suspiciously like Canada's favourite sons Edge and Christian, right down to their move sets. But it could have been E&C - video footage existed of them talking to the Conquistadors backstage!

The "Puerto Ricans" eventually unseated Matt and Jeff Hardy for the World Tag Team Champions at No Mercy 2000, using an Unprettier to win. Hmm, suspicious.

It turned out that Edge and Christian were the ones under the masks at No Mercy and had hired body doubles (one of whom was Christopher Daniels) to play the role backstage.

However, when the heels tried to consolidate their victory the next night on Raw, they were beaten by the Hardy Boyz dressed as the Conquistadors, which reverted the titles back to them.

Yes that is needlessly complicated, but the only thing that matters is that four of the most famous wrestlers in history all got to wear gold gimp suits on live TV.

6. Sin Cara (Mistico/Hunico)

The original Sin Cara in WWE was, to put it politely, a total disaster.

Advertisement

You'd hate to read what our impolite description of him.

As Mistico, Luis Urive was a sensation in Mexico, which prompted WWE to bring him in under the new name of Sin Cara. However, something happened when Urive put on his new mask, something that made him forget how to wrestle.

He botched move after move, to the point where it became a meme, and got himself suspended for a Wellness Policy violation just three months into his first run.

Not wanting the character to fade away, WWE introduced a new version of the gimmick called Sin Cara Negro played by Jorge Arriaga.

When the Urive returned from suspension under the name Sin Cara Azul, the two masked men actually had a feud that resulted in the evil Sin Cara unmasking and taking the name Hunico.

However, Arriaga's time under the mask wasn't done yet. He returned to the role in late 2013, whilst the original Sin Cara was having difficulties with WWE management. He eventually went back to Mexico, leaving Hunico to play the character for the next six years.

5. Kane (Glenn Jacobs/Luke Gallows)

Wrestler-turned-politician-turned-bad tweeter Glenn Jacobs played a lot of rubbish characters in wrestling (one of which we'll get to later), but the one role that stuck with him throughout his career was Kane.

Advertisement

The fiery demon half-brother of the Undertaker, Kane was a big deal right from his debut at Badd Blood 1997, winning multiple championships and accolades across his Hall of Fame career.

He also had the honour of fighting himself at Vengeance 2006.

After being haunted by the words "May 19th" (which was actually the release date for his movie See No Evil), Kane was confronted on said date by a man wearing his old ring gear and mask.

This was Imposter Kane, portrayed by the current day Luke Gallows wearing a wig so large it could be viewed from space. Imposter Kane attacked real Kane, setting up a match between the two on pay-per-view.

And you won't believe this, but the imposter won!

This didn't matter one bit, as the very next night on Raw, Kane ejected his doppelganger from the building and he was never seen again.

Why? Because Vince McMahon didn't like the wig. Fair enough, Vince, that thing was a monster.

4. The Undertaker (Mark Calaway/Brian Lee)

Being impersonated clearly runs in the family, as Kane's brother also had an imposter problem in 1994.

Advertisement

After losing to Yokozuna at the Royal Rumble, the Deadman vanished from WWE TV until Ted DiBiase "brought him back".

In actuality, DiBiase's version of the Phenom was Brian Lee in a dime store Undertaker costume. Not that this fooled the announcers though, who acted as if this was the real deal the entire time!

Things came to a head at SummerSlam, where DiBiase's Undertaker fought the real Undertaker managed by Paul Bearer. This was Mark Calaway's first appearance on WWE TV since the Rumble and, once the two men were stood next to each other, it was super apparent that they looked nothing alike.

Real Taker beat fake Taker in a very boring match that somehow main evented the show over Bret Hart vs Owen Hart for the WWE title.

Lee's version was never heard from again, although he would return to WWE in 1997... as Chainz... a member of the Disciples of Apocalypse.

Ah well, at least he'll always have those few months as the Undertaker to cherish.

3. Diesel & Razor Ramon (Kevin Nash/Glenn Jacobs & Scott Hall/Rick Bognar)

It is well-known that Kevin Nash and Scott Hall left WWE in 1996 to jump ship to WCW.

Advertisement

There, under their real names, they would form the New World Order with Hulk Hogan and change the wrestling landscape forever.

But what happened to the characters they were playing in the other company? What would become of the tall, menacing Diesel and the ultra-cool Razor Ramon?

Well, just like James Bond, they were brought back with new actors! Except, unlike James Bond, everybody hated it.

Reintroduced by Jim Ross of all people, "Diesel" and "Razor Ramon" came back to TV in September 1997. Ramon was played by Rick Bognar, whilst our old pal Glenn Jacobs grew his best goatee for the role of Diesel.

The two competed mostly as a tag team and even entered the 1997 Royal Rumble, where Jacobs reached the final three. This was the two fakers' final appearance though.

WWE were so convinced that people just cared about the characters, that they honestly though recasting two of their most popular performers would work.

It didn't, and this storyline lives on in infamy to this very day.

2. Suicide (A Bunch Of People)

In 2008, Impact Wrestling (then known as TNA) released their first and only console video game.

Advertisement

TNA Impact! put players into the shoes of Suicide, a wrestler with amnesia who had to work his way through the game's story mode to recover his identity.

Not a bad plot, if a little out there, but things got even more ridiculous when the character of Suicide made his actual debut for TNA at the Final Resolution pay-per-view.

The character was initially portrayed by Frankie Kazarian, who would alternate with Christopher Daniels in playing the role over the next two years. After that, a who's who of wrestlers donned the mask and body suit, including T. J. Perkins, Jonathan Gresham, Taiji Ishimori, and Nash Carter

Daniels even won the X-Division championship whilst playing the character, as did Austin Aries, although that was revealed to be a ruse later that same night.

The gimmick more than exceeded its original lifespan and has now become a strange but beloved part of Impact's history.

The character was last seen as recently as 2021, so who knows, maybe the masked man will return again someday.

1. Doink (A Bunch Of People)

The ultimate replaceable gimmick has to go to the sometimes whimsical, sometimes terrifying resident clown of WWE - Doink.

Advertisement

The first Doink, played by Matt Osborne, debuted for the company in 1992 as a cruel trickster. His pranks included throwing water over people, tripping people up with wire, and whacking people over the head with a prosthetic arm.

That last one doesn't seem very clown-y, but let's move on.

Including Osborne, five people have officially played Doink in WWE.

Steve Keirn, who also wrestled as Skinner, played the character's body double at WrestleMania IX and would occasionally play the role on house shows.

Ray Licameli played Doink a handful of times, including in the WrestleMania X-7 Gimmick Battle Royal.

The Brooklyn Brawler Steve Lombardi was the most recent person to wrestle as Doink in 2012, and then there was the version of the character who appeared at Money in the Bank 2020, played by... nobody knows. It's not anywhere on the internet.

Let's just assume it was Bruce Pritchard.

All of this is without mentioning the countless other people who have dressed up as Doink or played him on the indies.

He truly is one of wrestling's most endearing characters, and that is no laughing matter.

Advertisement