10 Wrestling Legends WCW Buried

Steve Austin, Ric Flair, and the other times WCW turned blue chips into pink slippers.

By John Cunningham /

WCW pulled off some amazing feats during the Monday Night Wars. The nWo remains one of the greatest angles in history, regardless of how frivolous it got in later years. They also introduced lucha libre and a sterling cruiserweight division to US wrestling, impressing audiences while the commentators harped on about the main event instead.

Advertisement

Ted Turner's promotion kicked off in response to the Black Saturday disaster. Miffed by McMahon's antics and dead-on-arrival ratings, Turner bought JCP and formed WCW in 1988. With new booker Eric Bischoff on the rise by the mid-90s, the company started poaching WWE stars with giant contracts.

While the money was mind-blowing, many stars found themselves in poor creative spots or, worse still, no spot at all. A bad case of letting the inmates run the asylum, WCW's status as no.1 soon gave way to topsy turvy booking, chaotic backstage politics and botched angles. There was also the key issue of older, more established stars refusing to open the main event scene to fresher figures, a problem that plagued it even at the best of times.

WCW becoming a thing of the past was even quicker than its rise to the top. Dragging a boatload of star power down with it, countless workers suffered the setbacks of a promotion that ultimately had no idea what the hell it was doing...

10. Raven

Scott Levy's misanthropic sociopath was a smash hit with the ECW faithful. An effective heel cashing in on the 90s grunge craze, Raven became a dependable heat magnet for the land of extreme. When he arrived in WCW in late 97, it didn't take long for him to get under fans' skin there either.

Advertisement

Sadly for Raven, Eric Bischoff and co. were not into grunge (or nu metal, an aesthetic Raven would later adopt to keep the persona hip) and found his dark persona depressing. Despite the high quality of his promos and psychology, Raven found himself looking up at the lights far too often to be a credible threat. Even the interference of the Flock, a WCW take on his old Raven's Nest faction, wasn't enough to realign his win-loss ratio adequately. A US Title win during his feud with perennial fan favourite Diamond Dallas Page offered a glimmer of hope. Unfortunately, he was demolished by Goldberg in a notorious squash match the next night.

The decision to reveal Raven as secretly a spoilt, rich kid brat in 98 provided some funny segments but ultimately became character assassination. Now devoid of the menace and dramatic flair he had in ECW, Raven understandably ditched WCW soon after.

9. Mick Foley

Cactus Jack quickly became one of WCW's scariest, gnarliest characters upon his 1991 debut. Brutal and unpredictable, the heel Foley was a menace to wrestling during his feud with then WCW champ Sting. The first signs in the promotion's lack of faith showed during Foley's classic Beach Blast bout with the Stinger: it was non-title. Despite losing the contest, WCW weren't even comfortable letting the hardcore legend be presented as a contender.

Advertisement

A hit with fans thanks to his ultraviolent bouts and creative promos, Foley turned face for an initially awesome blood feud with greatest big man of all time contender, Vader. The fearsome Vader was unpopular among his peers due to the wreckless stiffness of his ring work. A potato punching machine on the level of Stan Hansen, Vader found his perfect dance partner in the fearless Foley.

After a terrifying concrete power bomb, Foley took time off to sell the injury, hoping to return as a sympathetic babyface for a final grudge match between the 2. The booking team were blind to Foley's babyface potential and repackaged him as a comical goof, sullying his edge in the process. While their matches remained horrifying, the heat was diminished. After Vader ripped off one of Foley's ears in Germany, he briefly attempted a new injury angle to reheat his character but was turned down.

Frustrated at his position and lack of progress, Foley left in 94, eventually finding a creative team that appreciated his talents far more in WWE.

8. Lex Luger

A major star in WCW's early years, many believed Lex Luger could one day be a babyface sensation on the level of his pal Sting or even Hulk Hogan. While such lofty expectations were questionable, the WCW faithful clearly loved Luger during both of his runs with the company.

Advertisement

After a lacklustre WWF run, Luger returned in a poor choice of outfit. Regarded as the first major shot in the Monday Night Wars, Luger's defection to his old stomping grounds occurred just 8 days after Summerslam 95 and less than 24 hours since his last house show. Going behind Vinnie Mac's back was a risky move for the Total Package. It seemed questionable initially thanks to his middling time in the Alliance to End Hulkamania. It appeared to ultimately pay off though when he defeated Hollywood Hogan for the WCW title in 1997. His second reign with the title arrived to immense fanfare and was going great right up until it ended just 5 days after it started.

Looking like a chump less than a week after ascending the mountain, Luger never held the big gold again. Soon enough fans grew to dismiss him as a choke artist and his babyface credibility took a nasty tumble. His joining nWo Wolfpac in 98 sullied his long-running feud with the faction and was surpassed in stupidity only by Sting doing the same. An attempt to repackage him as a heel during the dreaded Russo era quickly went bottoms up. So shot was Luger's credibility that WWE never bothered calling him for the Invasion and nWo angles they ran in the early noughties. Luger should've been a pillar of WCW's main event scene but thanks to topsy turvy booking, he never reached his drawing potential.

7. Curt Hennig

One of the most technically skilled, gifted wrestlers of all time, Curt Hennig was never quite the same after a severe back injury in 1991. After several uninspired comebacks in WWE, he jumped ship and debuted on Nitro in 97 where he went back to wrestling full-time (much to the chagrin of Lloyds of London).

Advertisement

Decent as a face and effective as a traitorous nWo heel, Hennig was a solid hand mostly kept out of the main event scene. In 1999, he finally fulfilled his decade-plus long dream of doing a cowboy gimmick when he formed the West Texas Rednecks. With popular rapper Master P now leading the No Limit Soldiers faction, the Rednecks were presented as southern country musicians. The feud leads to the deliberately daft song 'Rap is Crap', a surprise hit that gained some traction on country radio stations.

WCW really should've turned the increasingly popular Rednecks face at that point. A few more singles from the group might've provided more mainstream exposure and revenue for the promotion. Instead, seemingly angry with fans for preferring the Rednecks to the No Limit Soldiers, WCW dropped the angle entirely.

Hennig moved onto a series of bogus retirement angles in 99 before losing a feud to Shawn Stasiak in 2000. The Stasiak feud was the deepest cut of all in hindering Hennig. Posing as a Mr Perfect imposter, Stasiak beating his apparent idol made Hennig look weak and past it. An even worse burial than that time Kane bizarrely lost to imposter Kane.

6. The Ultimate Warrior

The Ultimate Challenge II: Wrestling Boogaloo is a rock-solid contender for the worst major wrestling match of all time. From the Hulkster bidding farewell to his eyebrows during a botched fireball spot to the cumbersome Horace Hogan's run-in, the whole thing stank to high heaven.

Advertisement

Despite his rather debatable abilities as a wrestler, Warrior was over with fans in a way you rarely see anymore. His brief (and abysmal) 1996 run in WWE proved fans were still interested in the face-painted wild man. Still bursting with head-shaking energy, Warrior in 1998 could've been a huge nostalgia draw for WCW.

Sadly, it soon became apparent the former double champ had been signed for one reason: the Hulkster needed his win back. A Warrior vs. Sting feud could've been a cash cow for Bischoff and friends. Instead, we got some of the worst acting ever caught on camera when Hogan sees his WrestleMania VI foe in the mirror but get this, no one else can...

With just 3 poor matches under his belt, Warrior vanished as he so often did, now with a dreadful, minus 5 stars loss on his record.

5. Bret Hart

There was a cruel irony in Bret Hart disliking the raunchy direction WWE was taking only to get saddled with unbridled Russo booking in WCW.

Advertisement

Screwed over, betrayed and subsequently mocked by that no good Shawn Michaels, Bret Hart was the most sympathetic figure in the industry by December 1997. WCW had a mega babyface on their hands with the Hitman. A poor debut moved into a whole year of confusing storylines, more heel and face turns than PG era Big Show and dream matches ruined by overbooking and tainted finishes.

Failing on all fronts to cash in on fan interest in the Canadian hero, WCW killed the integrity of the Hitman character. Obvious, blockbuster feuds against the nWo and Sting were frustratingly bungled beyond belief. Certain key WCW figures such as Eric Bischoff have claimed that Hart's heart wasn't in it anymore. Hart himself has simply buried Bischoff's booking abilities, claiming he had zero idea what he was doing week to week ( a sentiment echoed by various roster members from the time).

By the time WCW finally committed to pushing the Excellence of Execution at the world title level, he had been stripped of his star aura. An unwieldy, inconsistent character approaching past his prime status, Hart was never the draw he could've been for the company.

4. Chris Jericho

One of the funniest characters in company history, the Man of 1,004 Holds was a midcard favourite throughout his WCW tenure. The only problem was that Jericho was clearly cut out for more.

Advertisement

Going from strength to strength in his mic and ring work, a proposed Goldberg feud might've been Jericho's ticket to a bump up the card. Sadly, Goldberg believed Jericho lacked the mutant-levels of muscles mass necessary to be a credible threat to him (an absolutely hilarious notion given how the real-life scuffle between these 2 went). Even a squash match with the bald-headed beast was turned down despite the positive reception to Jericho's promos on him.

Trapped in TV title purgatory with no upwards trajectory in sight, Jericho grew disillusioned and signed with WWE. With a few months left on his WCW contract, the company turned Jericho into a total ceiling starer before taking him off TV entirely. Signs and chants from audiences confirmed they were none too happy with his disappearance from TV. His subsequent classic debut on RAW was another key win in the Monday Night Wars for WWE.

3. Rey Mysterio

One of the most influential wrestlers of the 21st century, Rey Mysterio found his first major mainstream exposure in WCW. A speciality act in the cruiserweight division, Mysterio stunned crowds with his groundbreaking, imaginative take on the lucha libre style. Classic feuds with the likes of Dean Malenko, Eddie Guerrero and Psicosis were among several key reasons Nitro dominated RAW in the ratings for 83 weeks.

Advertisement

It went without saying to just about everyone bar Kevin Nash that the mask was an essential component of the Mysterio character's allure. Determined to get more heat (and go over everyone on the roster thanks to his dreadful creative control), Nash caused the unmasking of Mysterio to occur at Superbrawl IX. With the option of it either being the mask or his job, Mysterio begrudgingly went along with the angle. A brief flirtation with moving Mysterio up the card gave him surprise giant killer wins over the likes of Nash, Bam Bam Bigelow and Scott Norton. Sadly, the heavyweight angle did little to replenish Mysterio's ailing stock and he eventually fell further.

His WWE debut in 2002 lead to a total reboot of the character with the company all but pretending the unmasking never happened. A wise decision and one that's served the living legend well ever since.

2. Steve Austin

The biggest star of his generation got off to a cracking start in WCW. Presented as a star of the future, the prodigious Austin engaged in top-notch tussles with the likes of Ricky Steamboat and Dustin Rhodes. His earlier tag team work with Brian Pillman as the Hollywood Blondes (a bizarre gimmick to see these two with in hindsight) also proved successful. A natural heel, Stunning Steve's stock was on the slow burn, gradually rising year to year until Hulkamania invaded Atlanta.

Advertisement

From hot prospect to cold turkey, Austin's acclaimed work with the US title came to an abrupt end at Fall Brawl 1995. Old Hogan pal and Cartoon Era fan favourite Jim Duggan decimated Austin in a credibility-destroying 35 seconds. A laughable defeat, Austin never regained the title or a decent spot on the card. Dealing with a grim triceps injury later that year, Austin was heartlessly given the sack via fax. When asked why, Eric Bischoff claimed he saw zero marketability in Austin and disliked working with the future Rattlesnake.

Understandably furious, a silver lining in this one can be found in Austin's hilarious lampooning of the company in ECW. Finding his voice and forging a new attitude, Austin's setback wound up propelling him to superstardom.

1. Ric Flair

The Nature Boy, even more than Sting, was the true face of WCW, whether anyone wanted to admit it or not.

Advertisement

Monumentally over with the core audience, it's a real head-scratcher why promoters kept throwing him under a bus. The first time WCW weren't fair to Flair comes with Jim Herd believing Flair was dated and in need of a reboot as a head-shaved, earring sporting oddball named Spartacus. Flair got off light via defection, having a profitable but disappointing run in WWE.

He never escaped the clutches of WCW's star-killing schemes again. When the Hulkster arrived, WCW booked the ultimate 80s dream match immediately. Flair lost and then just kept on losing to Hogan, eating leg drops like they were going out of style. Presented as totally beneath his fellow peroxide enthusiast, Flair slipped down the card. A fresh wave of Hogan-related destruction kicked off when the nWo set the wrestling world on fire. With the Four Horsemen officially jabronified, Flair and co. were made fools of by everyone including new nWo recruit Curt Hennig whose duping of the team in 97 was in many ways the final nail in the coffin. Not once did Flair get any proper revenge on the cool heels. He even lost to Eric Bischoff, the main architect of Flair's destruction in the promotion.

Appalling Jerry Springer-esque angles with his son David and Vince Russo were just the icing on the cake of a decorated career getting flushed down the toilet. Flair became so miserable that he's since admitted he was happy when the promotion folded.

Advertisement