10 Wrestling Matches That Were Difficult To Watch Live
Real revulsion in wrestling's fake world.
Wrestling is a ghoulish, stomach-churning business in which workers are grossly exploited as "independent contractors," death is trivialised for storylines, and bigots and criminals are lionised posthumously, but the violence portrayed in its kayfabe world isn't usually part of this.
Outwith the remaining cluster of deathmatch promotions, video nasties aren't the sport's goal. Matches are calibrated to generate drama and provoke a gamut of emotions from its audiences. Shock, awe, and in some cases, revulsion, are all part of this, but bouts aren't supposed to be so ghastly they leave viewers struggling to watch, questioning their fandom, or worst of all, tuning out entirely.
But it happens. A sport that regularly pushes the envelope so far were inevitably cross over to the wrong side of the line every now and then, and whether intentional or otherwise, the matches within left viewers wincing.
Deathmatch wrestling isn't without merit, but their unparalleled brutality would cheapen the rest of the list, so they're excluded. So too are honourable mentions like Cactus Jack vs. Vader (1993), Abyss vs. Sabu (2004), and the entire Heroes Of Wrestling card (1999), all of which are best viewed through one's fingers...
10. Kurt Angle Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XIX)
Brock Lesnar and Kurt Angle usually had awesome matches together. This WrestleMania main event was among the finest, but closed with one of the most worrying bumps WWE fans had seen in years.
When 'The Beast' was down in OVW, wrestling media had him pegged as a freak athlete capable of executing moves usually reserved for performers 100lbs lighter, with his Shooting Star Press regularly picked out for praise. He abandoned the move when he was called up to the main roster, but, depending on who you believe, was talked into doing it at 'Mania XIX by either Angle or John Laurinaitis.
It went horribly wrong. Lesnar dived off the top rope, came up short, and barely even connected with his opponent. He was knocked loopy as soon as his head hit the mat. This left Kurt to walk an obviously concussed Lesnar through the mercifully short closing stretch, with 'The Next Big Thing' emerging victorious following an F5.
This brief portion was easily the hardest to endure, but watching a wrestler in Angle's declining physical state going against one of WWE's most brutish competitors was tough enough in the first place.
9. Mike Awesome Vs. Masato Tanaka (ECW One Night Stand 2005)
Any of Mike Awesome and Masato Tanaka's big ECW matches could've occupied this spot, as each one is carried by sheer recklessness and a mutual disregard for each other's wellbeing. November To Remember 1999 was probably their most memorable, action-packed scrap, but One Night Stand 2005 beats it in terms of pure brutality.
It was peppered with the usual nutty spots, and enhanced by Joey Styles' unfiltered hatred for Awesome (who'd "sold out" by trading ECW for WCW in 2000) on commentary. Mike put Tanaka through hell, and the Japanese scrapper responded with trademark fire, popping straight up from a number of huge moves throughout, though he almost certainly lost a few dozen braincells along the way.
A particularly nasty Awesome Bomb saw Masato dropped straight onto his head, with his cranium taking further damage through several unprotected chairshots. These were gut-wrenching. Not only did Tanaka absorb each blow with his skull, but, in a ghoulish tribute to their older bouts, he no-sold several, roaring at Awesome for more.
The shots are even tougher to watch today than 13 years ago, but there was nothing fun about them at the time either.
8. Mike Bell Vs. Perry Saturn (WWF Jakked - 7 May, 2001)
If you've ever wondered why Perry Saturn spent part of his WWE career romancing a mop, here's your answer.
The former Radical shot on jobber Mike Bell when they met on an otherwise uneventful episode of Jakked. The opening stages were fine, but Bell soon dumped the former European Champion on his head with a couple of botched arm drags. That's when Saturn lost it. He awkwardly shoved Bell out of the ring, leading to Mike taking a gruesome head-first bump to the outside, but that wasn't the end of it. Perry, overcome by the red mist, gored his opponent into the steps, then continued battering him around the ring, before eventually - mercifully - putting him away.
Neither man was significantly hurt, but that didn't make the sight of the menacing Saturn bludgeoning a hapless local enhancement guy any sweeter, and management were incensed. Perry was saddled with the awful 'Moppy' gimmick immediately after. This effectively killed his credibility, and he was eventually let go from the company upon suffering an injury not long after concluding his feud with Raven and ex-girlfriend Terri Runnels.
7. Brock Lesnar Vs. Zack Gowen (SmackDown - 19 August, 2003)
We realise that human chimney stack Brock Lesnar didn't really beat up a one-legged man on this episode of SmackDown, but it was rough, particularly as WWE had presented Zack Gowen as he was: a plucky, sympathetic underdog who'd had his limb amputated following a potentially fatal bout of cancer when he was eight years old.
'The Next Big Thing' ducked out to mock Gowen's mother before the bout had even started. Zack jumped him, diving out of the ring, then hitting his beastly foe with his prosthetic, but that was the end of his offence. Gowen, who was just 20 years old with less than 12 months' wrestling experience, ate a chairshot. Brock's disqualification didn't get the beatdown, though. He threw his bloodied opponent into the ringpost leg-first, then, in a final "f*** you," bundled Zack from his stretcher as the paramedics were taking him away.
While Gowen has since called it one of the funnest matches of his career, the sight of Lesnar picking him apart in front of his family, in his hometown, was wince-inducing, and Zack wrestled just three more televised bouts before the company released him.
6. Hiromu Takahashi Vs. Dragon Lee (NJPW G1 Special In San Francisco)
The 18th singles match in one of the most thrilling in-ring rivals in the world, this clash guaranteed danger. Their bouts are always wild, reckless, and unhinged, with Lee and Takahashi's willingness to completely disregard their own health and safety part of what makes them so exciting. Unfortunately, it finally came back to bite them when they met on New Japan's latest G1 Special.
In a clash replete with the usual array of dives and sick bumps, Hiromu landed on his neck following a botched Phoenix-Plex. It's a move Lee has executed hundreds of times before, with Takahashi himself taking the bump on at least a dozen occasions, but the luchador couldn't get enough rotation on his release, and after bumping, 'The Ticking Time Bomb' slid across the mat on his head.
A horrific impact made worse by NJPW's insistence on showing multiple replays, it knocked Takahashi for six, and he was visibly struggling from there. Though he finished the match, the closing minutes were ropy. Hiromu could move, but he was glassy-eyed, and barely able to execute his own finisher.
It was revealed afterwards that Takahashi had been rushed to hospital with a suspected broken neck, confirming the audience's fears.
5. The Rock Vs. Mankind (Royal Rumble 1999)
Mick Foley's inclusion was a given. There has never been a more giving major-league professional wrestler in terms of bumping, with the former Cactus Jack perfectly willing to destroy his own body in the name of entertainment. His back catalogue is so ghoulish we could populate an entire 20-point list built around him alone, and this is one of the worst, with the Hall Of Famer taking absurd levels of head trauma against The Rock.
Their "I Quit" match spilled all oveer the arena, with Mankind out to destroy his Corporate foe. Foley, of course, bumped like a madman, and consented to one of the dumbest finishes of his entire 27-year career.
Rock, driven mad by his inability to make Mankind quit, handcuffed his masked foe, effectively leaving him helpless. He couldn't fend Rocky off, telling 'The Great One' he'd "have to kill [me]" to win the bout... and then came the chairshots. 11 of them in total, with several straight to the head, sans protection. Awful.
Finally, Mankind quit. It was hard not to breathe a relieved sigh when he did, because this was bad, even through the Attitude Era's lens.
4. Jeff Hardy Vs. Sting (TNA Victory Road 2011)
Though this match wasn't even 90 seconds in length, it remains one of the most bizarre debacles ever screen on a live wrestling pay-per-view, and the most infamous moment of Jeff Hardy's career.
He was set to compete for Sting's TNA Heavyweight Championship, but it took a full 40 seconds for him to emerge once his music start playing. An intoxicated Jeff then shambled out of the back, sloppily swaying his way down to the ring, with referee Brian Hebner immediately throwing up the dreaded "X" sign.
Jeff was messed up. Sent out in absolutely no condition to compete, he was accosted by Eric Bischoff, who turned the clash into a No DQ to facilitate a quick finish. The "wrestling" itself was turgid. Hardy spent close to a minute teasing the audience with a t-shirt throw, before Sting, ever the professional, called an audible, forcibly pinning his foe to retain the strap
A 120-day rehab program awaited Hardy, whose long-standing drug and alcohol issues manifested in the most shambolic match in TNA history. Even Sting couldn't help but break character, shouting "I agree!" as chants of "bulls***" filled the building.
3. Eddie Guerrero Vs. JBL (Judgment Day 2004)
Though bloodletting has largely gone in the way of the dodo in WWE's PG era, drawing colour remains an effective in-match tool, adding ladles of ghastly brutality to any heated bout, whether intentional or otherwise.
This, however, is way too far.
Eddie, the sympathetic babyface hero, was hit by a steel chair, then bladed as he hit the deck. Plasma streamed from the wound. In his haste, Guerrero had cut too deep, caught an artery, and set forth a crimson torrent that wouldn't be stemmed until Eddie, JBL, and their environment was coated in claret.
For those who could stomach them, the visuals were compelling. Layfield and Guerrero's brawl became a bloodbath, adding an extra layer of hatred to what had already been a stormy rivalry, during which JBL had supposedly given Eddie's mother a heart attack through his antics. Still, it was borderline stomach-churning at points. The sight of blood literally spurting from Guerrero's cranium will stay with you forever, and the mat resembled a gory Jackson Pollock painting by the end.
Unsurprisingly, Eddie went into shock after the match. Fair play to him for working through it though.
2. Jeff Jarrett & Debra Vs. Val Venis & Nicole Bass (Over The Edge 1999)
Over The Edge 1999 was the night Owen Hart died.
This was the first segment to take place after Vince McMahon made the call to keep the show going.
... exactly.
Regardless of whether or not Over The Edge should have been cancelled following the fall, nobody wanted to watch wrestling a mere 15 minutes after the incident. Everyone was stunned. Though Owen's status was still unconfirmed, the audience had just watched a man plummet 70ft into the ring, and WWE neglected to share any updates with the live crowd.
WWE employees were put in a terrible bind, too. Bass, Debra, Venis, and Jarrett tried to work their respective acts, but each was so obviously shaken up that they needn't bother, while Jim Ross was barely able to hold himself together on commentary.
A pointless six-minute intergender tag bout followed, with Venis and Bass taking the victory, but those who witnessed it live were likely in such a state of worry that it didn't even register, and less than an hour later, it was announced that Hart had perished. By that point, nothing else that happened on this fateful PPV mattered.
1. Mankind Vs. The Undertaker (King Of The Ring 1998)
More nightmarish spectacle than wrestling match, Undertaker vs. Mankind at King Of The Ring nonetheless spawned one of the most famous spots in wrestling history, as 'The Phenom' tossed the company's biggest crash test dummy from atop Hell In A Cell and through the announcement table.
Jim Ross' "Good God almighty! That killed him!" remains one of his most iconic calls. From that point, it was tough to do anything other than watch through one's fingers. Fans were used to Foley's stunts, but never on this scale, and though Mick suffered a dislocated shoulder from the fall, it continued.
Minutes later, he was sent crashing from a near-identical height as 'Taker Chokeslammed him through the roof. Mankind's bump was so hideous that his opponent legitimately thought he was dead, and struggled not to break character, but while Foley obviously survived, his body was ravaged.
Cameras lingered on Mankind smiling through a bloody mouth, a dislodged tooth hanging beneath his nose. He left with a concussion, a dislocated jaw and shoulder, bruised ribs, internal bleeding, and numerous puncture wounds, having paid a hefty price for his death-defying immortalisation.