10 Wrestling Performances That Proved People Wrong
These wrestlers made their doubters look like fools with one awesome performance.
A wrestling career so often can be made or broken in one single moment in time. Be that an unfortunate slip up on the microphone in front of thousands of less than forgiving fans, or a match so compelling that it's impossible for an audience to stay glued in their seats.
Then there are those performances that are so undeniably excellent that they single-handedly make supposed experts and self-professed die-hards look like complete and utter fools for ever openly doubting the star in question's ability to get the job done inside of the squared circle.
In hindsight, it may seem a little ridiculous to suggest that some of these names weren't destined for greatness from the second they laced up a pair of boots.
Yet, history has taught us that it wasn't always plain sailing for some of the most recognisable faces the business has even seen. Ultimately, though, it only takes one spellbinding turn - be that in-between the ropes or on the stick - to turn a wrasslin' doubter into a fully fledged believer.
So, buckle up as we take a closer look at the exact performances that left certain critics with an uncomfortable amount of egg on their face...
10. Roman Reigns - Vs. Brock Lesnar, WrestleMania 31
2015 was a bit of a bittersweet time for Roman Reigns.
The new chosen one managed to become the first Shield member to win the Royal Rumble match and found himself bounding towards an epic WWE title battle against Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania 31. The only problem was the fact that just about every single person in the numerous arenas WWE hit on the Road to WrestleMania was against the idea of The Big Dog having the proverbial rocket strapped to his tactical vest.
In short, most folks felt that Daniel Bryan deserved to be in that spot instead. So, when it became abundantly clear that there would be no last-minute alterations to this sacred clash (in the lead-up, at least), few had faith in the relatively green face being able to hang with The Beast.
But hang he did.
Producing by far his most impressive and well-rounded display between the ropes to date, Reigns sold like a warrior and fully had Levi's Stadium believing he'd all but sealed his first WWE Championship before a certain Architect made his presence known.
Whether they liked it or not, fans had to acknowledge the arrival of a bona fide main eventer there and then.
9. Pat McAfee - Vs. Adam Cole, NXT TakeOver: XXX
Few folks have taken to sports entertainment quite as easily as Pat McAfee has over the last 12 months. But with his outrageously enthralling SmackDown work beside Michael Cole and numerous above average NXT displays fresh in most fan's minds, it's easy to forget that the former NFL punter had his fair share of doubters before taking his relationship with WWE to the next level.
Coming into his scheduled grudge match with Adam Cole at NXT TakeOver: XXX, McAfee was all too aware of how fans were feeling about yet another celebrity stepping in to take a spot from a full-time worker. He even admitted that, as a hardcore fan, he used to hate seeing outsiders put themselves over and leave.
By the time the dust had settled on his in-ring debut opposite the most successful NXT Champion in the brand's history, though, few could claim McAfee was just a name being used to draw in casual eyes. After backflipping off the top rope, nailing Cole with a superplex, and even eating a vicious Panama Sunrise, absolutely nobody would turn down the chance to see this former footballer step in-between the ropes again.
8. Becky Lynch - SmackDown 2018
Just in case you ever needed a reminder, Vince McMahon may be one of the greatest promoters in the history of entertainment, but not every thought/idea that pops into his head is on the money.
For an example of this, look no further than when the boss refused to allow Becky Lynch time on the microphone because he felt that fans simply wouldn't be able to get their heads around what she was saying in her Irish accent. As we now know, those frequently tuning into SmackDown and paying their cash to watch the Lass Kicker do her thing on the blue show were having none of it and pushed for Lynch to be given the spotlight more often.
Then, in the wake of a botched attempt at a heel turn at SummerSlam 2018, Lynch was finally given some significant time on the stick on the next edition of SmackDown. Despite WWE trying their best to frame her as a detestable heel, the thousands in attendance praised her every word. They understood their anti-hero clearly, and were more than willing to show McMahon how wrong he was to keep The Man away from The Mic.
7. Daniel Bryan - & Shane McMahon Vs. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn, WrestleMania 34
For the longest time, it looked like all hope of ever seeing Daniel Bryan perform inside of a WWE ring had been lost forever. After discovering a chronic lesion on his brain after suffering multiple concussions, the former WWE Champion was told that he'd never wrestle again by doctors. This news ultimately led to Bryan's shocking decision to retire in 2016 and opened the door for a new role as SmackDown's General Manager.
But Bryan had not given up on his dream of once again donning his gear in the squared circle.
After spending over two years working towards getting his career back on track and undergoing frequent medical evaluations, news broke in March 2018 that The American Dragon had been giving the all-clear to return to the job he loved - being one of the greatest professional wrestlers on the planet.
Three years on from his last 'Mania, Bryan found himself teaming with Shane McMahon and taking on the dastardly duo of Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn inside of the same stadium where his Miracle on Bourbon Street came true. Against all the odds, and despite being told it'd never happen, Bryan was back.
6. Eddie Guerrero - Vs. Brock Lesnar, No Way Out 2004
There was no questioning the fact that Eddie Guerrero was well and truly over with the WWE fanbase by the time 2004 came into view. The latino star had captured the hearts and imaginations of all who took in his cheeky antics over on SmackDown, and he appeared to be riding a huge wave of momentum coming into the most important part of the WWE calendar.
Then, the news of then-WWE Champion Brock Lesnar being done with the company coming into 'Mania XX seemed to open up the opportunity for Guerrero to finally reach the top of the mountain. However, not everyone was convinced he had what it takes to get over on such a big stage.
Bruce Prichard confessed on his Something to Wrestle With pod that people in the back felt his size and "the fact that he was Mexican" (his words) would mean that the general audience would struggle to connect with him. Yet, once the roof very nearly ripped off the Cow Palace, and both Eddie and Brock had put the finishing touches on a match for the ages and brilliantly executed underdog story, not a single soul doubted just how over Latino Heat was.
5. Braun Strowman - Vs. Roman Reigns, Great Balls Of Fire 2017
For an event that is often seen as something of an afterthought in the land of WWE, Fastlane has actually housed some out-and-out bangers over the years. And in the case of this next entry, it provided the backdrop for one star's coming out party.
Following on from being given the chance to spread his wings as a singles star, Braun Strowman enjoyed a bit of buzz after battering James Ellsworth and Sami Zayn. But many still weren't convinced the star had it in him to put it all together to form part of an acclaimed contest.
Once Strowman eventually got these hands on The Big Dog at Fastlane in 2017, though, his potential as a crowd-popping force of nature was finally realised. The Monster Among Men's ability to ragdoll the unwanted face made him a cult hero of sorts and teased the creation of a new bona fide star at the top of the card. Sure, it would all go t*ts up in the end, but for a moment, this soaring giant showed that he could absolutely deliver the chaotic goods.
4. Cactus Jack - Vs. Triple H, Raw 1997
Before he finally made his debut inside of a WWE ring back in 1996, Mick Foley was told by some people in the know that Vince McMahon was wholeheartedly against bringing Cactus Jack to the promotion, with boss even going as far as to say "Cactus Jack will never step foot inside of a WWE ring."
Even when the star was ultimately brought on board the WWE ship, McMahon made a point of covering up his face with a mask and clearly had no intention of turning Foley into one of his next top stars. However, once he saw the masterful worker connect with those in attendance in the one-of-a-kind way only Foley could, the boss knew he had something special on his hands.
Before the company knew what had hit them, Foley was boasting not one, but three different gimmicks, with Mankind, Dude Love, and lastly, Cactus Jack all going down a treat with the paying public. Proving McMahon wrong once and for all, Cactus Jack would eventually go to war with Triple H, on the night Foley debuted his trusty character on WWE television, in a brutal Falls Count Anywhere match on Raw in 1997.
3. Kenny Omega - & Hangman Page Vs. The Young Bucks, AEW Revolution 2020
AEW may have gotten off to a hell of a start during its first few months of existence, but the same couldn't be said for one of its supposed top tier stars in Kenny Omega. Or at least that's how a fairly vocal portion of the internet felt.
In fairness to The Cleaner, he'd set a ridiculously high bar for himself in the lead up to agreeing to becoming All Elite, putting on numerous matches that completely destroyed Dave Meltzer's star rating system. So, with Omega appearing to get lost in the main event shuffle somewhat, many were quick to suggest that the former IWGP Heavyweight Champion simply couldn't cut it on American TV or connect with a western audience.
Cue one of the most pulsating weekly storylines in AEW's already illustrious history involving the simmering tensions felt within The Elite as Omega and Hangman Page routinely threatened implosion en-route to meeting their Young Buck pals in one of, if not the greatest tag team match you ever did see.
Once the team's Revolution 2020 epic was in the books, Omega not only proved that he could "do American TV" but that he was already a master of it.
2. 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin - Vs. Jake 'The Snake' Roberts, King Of The Ring 1996
'Stone Cold' Steve Austin was never supposed to be the guy getting the rub when it came to 1996's King of the Ring. That honour belonged to a pre-Curtain Call Hunter Hearst Helmsley, but we all know how that turned out.
For clarity on precisely what was going through Vince McMahon's mind around this time when it came to The Texas Rattlesnake, we give you a conversation the boss had with none other than the person Austin would eventually face in the very final of that iconic event - Jake 'The Snake' Roberts.
As the poisonous star recently recalled, McMahon was less than convinced by Austin as a performer and even went as far as to say "That guy, he’ll never make it past fifth, sixth match. He’s not a main-eventer." With Roberts refusing to allow Austin to slip through the cracks, though, he forced the boss to seriously consider Austin's 'it' factor.
Fast forward to '96 and Austin, fresh off of going over 'The Snake' and becoming the new King of the Ring, cut one of the most important promos in wrestling history, establishing himself as the biggest star in the industry not long after.
1. John Cena - Vs. CM Punk, Money In The Bank 2011
He'd main evented numerous WrestleManias. He'd won pretty much everything there is to win. Hell, he'd gone toe-to-toe with just about every top star of his day. But "John Cena couldn't wrestle", and so the chants and discourse began.
That noise and critique only intensified when Cena found himself going up against the self-proclaimed 'Voice of the Voiceless' as the two geared up to lock horns at Money in the Bank in Chicago back in 2011. But then something marvellous happened.
Catching pure lightning in a bottle, the WWE Champion and the hometown hero put on an absolute classic, with Cena playing the reluctant company man with aplomb and Punk firing up those inside the Allstate Arena at the flick of a knee to the chin.
Everything from the nail-biting drama, including Cena socking Johnny Ace mid-screwjob attempt, to the actual in-ring work on show here was pitched to perfection and there's a reason this holds the honour of being one of WWE's few legitimate 5-star matches.
It may not have been cool to say it, but Cena most definitely could wrestle and on that night in Chicago he made fools of many an ignorant diehard.