10 Wrestling Romances That Ended In Disaster

When shoot relationships don’t work out, the finish can be brutal.

By Jack Morrell /

All pro wrestlers are a little mad.

Advertisement

Professional wrestling is a bizarre stew of live stunt work, broad panto, improvisational theatre and public speaking. To stay at a high level, it requires constant maintenance of a specific look and a specific level of fitness and diet - all while constantly travelling. It’s painful and hard and for most it’s not even a decent living - to paraphrase CM Punk, you throw yourself at the ground for twenty minutes a night to make back the money you spent to get to the building.

It’s not a normal thing to do with your life in the first place, and it isn’t something people just dip into. For many, it’s a vocation, rather than an occupation: a fever, an obsession.

That’s why it’s completely understandable that people in the wrestling business would gravitate towards one another. After all, who else could possibly understand the odd lifestyle and unique stresses of life on the road; the hang-ups, the hassles and the headaches?

But all pro wrestlers are a little mad, and they don’t all make the best partners, lovers or significant others. Here’s ten little slices of there-but-for-the-grace-of-god: ten cautionary tales of romance gone off the rails like a runaway train...

10. Seth Rollins & Zahra Schreiber

If Seth Rollins wasn’t one of the WWE’s golden geese, this ugly and embarrassing car crash could have derailed his career.

Advertisement

Back in early 2015, Rollins was living the dream and loving it: engaged to a woman back home, hair stylist Leighla Schultz, and holding the Money In The Bank briefcase, making him a shoo-in for WWE Champion at some point in the next few months.

Unfortunately, he was also having an affair with NXT trainee Zahra Schreiber. Although details are sketchy, it seems likely that Schultz suspected something, rooted through his phone and found messages between the two that confirmed it… including nudes the two had exchanged.

Schultz posted the nude image of Schreiber to Rollins’ Facebook, Instagram and Twitter accounts shortly before Monday Night RAW went on the air on 9 February. Later that evening, she also used her own Twitter account to tweet the nude images of Rollins himself, captioning them with his lover’s name, and reportedly vented about the affair on her personal Facebook account.

Needless to say, Rollins and Schultz were done - but Rollins and Schreiber would end up moving in together and remained an item… until a few months later, when Schreiber was let go from NXT after it was revealed that sometime in 2012 she had Instagrammed a picture of Nazi memorabilia on her wall at home, along with a cartoon of a My Little Pony dressed as Hitler.

Nazi-fetishism was the last straw for the ambitious Rollins: he and Schreiber were over by Christmas.

9. Carmella & Cass

For a while it looked like Carmella and Big Cass were the WWE’s new It Couple: two newly minted stars at the beginning of two separate but significant pushes on the main roster. They even appeared as a couple on Total Divas (which totally represents wrestlers’ real lives and is absolutely not more of a work than any wrestling storyline).

Advertisement

Unfortunately, it appears it was a case of too much, too fast. The couple purchased a house together, despite openly voiced reservations from Carmella’s family, who were reportedly convinced that her not-at-all-seven-foot-tall boyfriend wasn't marriage material.

Then, in August 2017, the night after going over the Big Show to cement his status as up-and-coming talent, Cass tore his ACL. Reports suggest that he grew depressed during his months on the shelf, convinced that his spot, fragile as it was, had been given to someone else - and Carmella, on the road as the Money In The Bank briefcase holder, a SmackDown! Women's Championship reign in her future, didn't know what to do with him.

The relationship died a death then and there... but that wasn't the end of it. From all reports, Cass developed an attitude problem following his return, drinking heavily on the European tour and getting in hot water with the boss for failing to follow instructions on a number of occasions.

The straw that broke the camel's back was a backstage altercation between the former lovers in June 2018. Cass was released shortly afterwards.

8. Jerry 'The King' Lawler & Stacy 'The Kat' Carter

Jerry 'The King' Lawler may be mostly familiar to today’s wrestling audience from his heel colour commentary work for the WWF during the Attitude Era, but in Memphis he was the biggest pro wrestling star in the area's history, having held the John Cena role - gritty, never say die babyface overlord - for the entire of the eighties.

Advertisement

That's how a man as nondescript as Jerry Lawler gets the girl. Lawler cheated on his wife with Stacy Carter in the summer of 1989 when she was eighteen, less than half his age. Thing is, this one seems to have been a little different. Ten years later they were still together: they married in 2000, shortly after he'd introduced her to WWF audiences as Miss Kitty, later just The Kat.

The Kat persona was, from all appearances, Carter turned up to eleven. Brazen even by fin de siècle WWF's standards, she was the titillation factor for much of WWF's programming in the eighteen months she worked there until she was let go in February 2001. Persistent rumour was that the company had simply had enough of her attitude problem backstage.

What they didn't count on was that Lawler was genuinely smitten with his young trophy wife, and had been since he'd met her: in solidarity with the woman he loved, he quit the company on the spot.

Sadly, the May/December fairytale wasn't to last. Shortly after making his big gesture, Lawler discovered that his wife had been cheating on him with a wrestler in WWF developmental. The marriage collapsed, and by the end of the year Lawler was back in the WWF, presumably grimly ignoring the I-told-you-so looks.

7. John Cena & Mickie James

Talking of John Cena, it's a fairly open secret that, despite being with his high school sweetheart throughout the majority of his wrestling career, America's hero was as faithful as pro wrestlers usually are when on the road.

Advertisement

Before he divorced Elizabeth in 2012, Cena was rumoured to have been hitting his five moves of doom on porn star Kendra Lust and WWE wrestlers Kelly Kelly, Melina and Victoria. No, not all at once, you filth-monsters.

The scuttlebutt (like gossip in a fireman's carry) was more solid when it came to his affair with Mickie James: the two RAW talents were hooking up on the road for months.

Supposedly, this was why Ken Doane was transferred to SmackDown in summer 2007. Doane, James’ erstwhile fiancé, had split with James after he caught her googling to find out whether rumours of the affair had hit the internet. He informed management: but in WWE, the squeaky wheel only gets the grease if it's by the driver's seat. After spending most of 2008 at home, Doane was released.

James didn't fare any better. The story goes that when - now single - it became clear to her in mid-2009 that Cena, far from leaving his girlfriend, was going to marry her, she threw an epic fit backstage. Her inability to cope with the end of the affair resulted in her also being transferred to SmackDown in November 2009.

It got worse. Saddled with the horrendous 'Piggie James' storyline as WWE's way of punishing her for making a scene, she too was released the following spring.

6. Kevin Sullivan & Woman

For obvious reasons, this article won't be dipping into the relationship between Chris and Nancy Benoit. However, Benoit wasn't the first pro wrestler that Nancy was married to.

Advertisement

Kevin Sullivan is so old school he should be valedictorian - and when he was booking WCW in the late nineties, he set himself up to get Benoit over, writing himself to become the eventual loser in a year long feud during which Benoit would 'steal' Sullivan's valet (and real life wife) Nancy 'Woman' Sullivan.

That old school booker's mentality bit him in the behind, however - because Sullivan insisted that Benoit and his wife travel together to better sell the angle. That same attitude that insisted that heels room with heels and babyfaces drink with babyfaces essentially forced two people playing lovers on television into close working proximity with each other off camera as well as on.

This almost inevitably left Sullivan, Benoit and Nancy in the horrible position of having to play out a shoot break-up in a worked environment. Pro wrestling relies on cooperation between the parties to work. Sullivan had written himself into a corner: to do his job, he had to do the job for the man who'd stolen his wife.

Their matches were fierce and stiff - but, incredibly, no one ever went into business for themselves. Old school to the end, Sullivan stuck to his booking strategy and made Benoit look as good as he could: of course, no one had any way of knowing what was in their future...

5. ‘Stone Cold’ Steve Austin & Debra

Previously married to former Chicago Bears linebacker and sort-of pro wrestler Steve McMichael, Debra worked in WCW alongside her husband before making her way to the WWF after divorcing him in 1998.

Advertisement

Although the beginning of her tenure in WCW crossed with the end of Steve Austin's run with the company, it was in WWF that they began spending more time together, and the two married in Las Vegas in September 2000.

However, by early 2002 Austin began having serious creative issues with Vince McMahon, balking at losing to a returning Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8 and temporarily walking out on the company.

He’d do the same thing a couple of months later when told to do the job for Brock Lesnar, no-showing the RAW on 10 June. Debra, always much more on the valet side of the women's division in WWE, left with him.

Days after having walked out over losing his spot in the company, Austin attacked his wife, beating her about the head and back. The police were called, documenting her injuries: Austin was charged with assault and, pleading no contest, received a year's probation and 80 hours community service. It was the end of their marriage - and, chastened, Austin returned to WWE in 2003 shortly before the divorce was finalised.

In recent years, Debra has claimed that that was the third time that Austin had beaten her during their relationship, all with the knowledge of the company they worked for, who helped her cover up her bruises for television.

4. Matt Hardy & Lita

Probably the most public real life break-up in wrestling, Matt Hardy and Lita initially seemed as though they were fated to be together. Forming Team Xtreme with Matt's brother Jeff, the three were one of the WWF's hottest properties for several years.

Advertisement

Suffering a serious knee injury in August 2004, Hardy was on the shelf for months while Lita stayed on the road, travelling with Hardy's real life best friend Edge. It turned out that travelling wasn't the only thing the two had been doing together, if you know what I mean and I think you do.

When Hardy found out, alone at home and with a lot of pent-up anger, he vented his feelings on the subject online. Unfortunately, given that Edge and Lita were involved in high profile angles, Hardy was the least valuable point of the triangle and was released in April 2005.

But the fans knew why Hardy had been fired, and the live crowd booed underdog babyface Lita everywhere she went, derailing her storyline with Kane. In an early instance of online gossip affecting a wrestling angle, plans were changed: Lita was paired with her real life lover Edge, bizarrely turning heel by turning on the abusive maniac who'd made her life hell.

It got weirder: hearing the crowd chant for Hardy, the company brought him back to feud with the two people who'd broken his heart in real life. Still, it revitalised his career in the midcard, and he continued to wrestle for WWE for another five years.

3. Triple H & Chyna

The late Chyna and Triple H were together for the whole of her tenure with the WWF, having met when he and Shawn Michaels had lobbied for her to be hired into the company as a heater for D-Generation X.

Advertisement

Triple H was a teetotaler, as obsessed with the business back then as he is now. Chyna, on the other hand, had her demons, exacerbated by her issues with drugs and alcohol. The two lived together, but reports suggest that Triple H wanted a family while Chyna, worried this could mean the end of her wrestling career, resisted the idea.

The way Chyna told it, she found a love letter from Stephanie McMahon and, confronting Vince McMahon, was told to take some time to deal with it and then simply let go. Other stories have it that she asked for an impossible number during renegotiations, and the personal situation only made the company's decision easier.

Chyna's fall from grace in the years following her release is a matter of tragic record. She and Triple H never spoke again - years later, she would accuse him of having hit her during their relationship. Whether that was true or not is impossible to say - at that point, her substance abuse problem and mental health issues had been feeding off one another for so long that she wasn't the most reliable narrator of her own story.

However, it's pretty clear that the circumstances surrounding her release haunted her and left her isolated. Who knows what might have happened had things been handled differently?

2. Chyna & X-Pac

While the majority of the car crash liaisons detailed in this article are stories of good times gone bad, X-Pac and Chyna's rocky relationship seems to have been more of a motorway pile-up where the car was on fire to begin with.

Advertisement

From all reports, Chyna's issues with drugs and alcohol already existed when she left the WWF. When she began seeing X-Pac two years later, they had worsened: an addict himself, X-Pac couldn't bail Chyna out because he was in the same boat.

The couple fought, reconciled, broke up and got back together over a tumultuous four year relationship, becoming engaged more than once during that time, and even appearing together in a sex tape that appears to have been recorded specifically to market to the porn industry.

Both helpless in the face of their addictions and mental health issues, Chyna and X-Pac fought like cat and dog, culminating in her January 2005 arrest for allegedly beating him up in front of his children. Weeks later, she dramatically fell apart on television while taking part in celebrity housemate reality show The Surreal Life, confronted by X-Pac in a staged attempt at an intervention storyline that went pear-shaped.

Chyna would appear in professional porn a few years later as her life spiralled further out of control - she tried to reinvent herself in Japan, but couldn't stay clean or healthy. While X-Pac has quietly gone from strength to strength since his sobriety, Chyna slid further downhill, leading to her death in 2016 while still trying to resuscitate her career.

1. Lex Luger & Miss Elizabeth

‘The Macho Man’ Randy Savage was, from all reports, controlling and paranoid when married to Elizabeth - but her post-divorce relationship with Lex Luger is the trainwreck that makes this list, a litany of bad decisions, drama and substance abuse that tragically ended in her death.

Advertisement

Luger and Elizabeth began an affair in 1998 while working in WCW: she ended her marriage to her second husband and moved in with Luger shortly afterwards. However, Luger had begun taking opiate-based painkillers. Hopelessly addicted, Luger's partying was out of control and Elizabeth soon joined him on the downhill slope.

When the WWF purchased WCW in spring 2001, Luger wasn't one of the wrestlers who joined the new company. At home with Elizabeth, they continued the wasted lifestyle they'd led on the road. In April 2003, he was arrested for beating her; two days later, he was arrested for driving while intoxicated, the latest in a list of driving offences that had already caused him to lose his licence.

Nine days later, Elizabeth was dead: the victim of an overdose of pills and vodka. When their home was searched, police found a significant cache of illegal narcotics, including performance enhancing drugs and painkillers. Elizabeth's death was ruled an accident; Luger got five years probation and attempted suicide. The spinal stroke he suffered in 2007 would define the next few years of his life as he gradually recovered his mobility.

Still clean in 2020, Luger is still in a wheelchair, lives with his mother and spends his days working as a faith-based public speaker. However, many still blame him for what happened to America's sweetheart, Miss Elizabeth.

Advertisement