10 Wrestling Tag Teams That Should Never Have Split
Ain't broken? Don't fix it!
The old adage, "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" should be applied to tag-teams in wrestling.
Naturally, there are those teams who split naturally and for good reason; the APA calling it a day in 2004 led to the biggest push of Bradshaw's career (as rich moron JBL) and came at a time when Ron Simmons was hanging up the tights anyway, the implosion of Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage as The Mega Powers in 1989.
The problem is, it's rarely ever that easy.
If the individuals making up the team don't go on to do anything worthwhile afterwards, then surely attempting to force a tag-team split negates the entire purpose of a tiff to begin with. Solid tag-teams have been left picking up the pieces of a failed split once too often...
10. Cryme Tyme
It's understandable why WWE officials would take one look at Shad Gaspard and see the potential to turn him into a singles force. Shad possessed size, charisma and a connection with the fans, but the importance of fellow Cryme Tyme member JTG to Gaspard's cause only became apparent when the team split up in 2010.
On his own and rethought as a menacing heel, the big man lacked much of the sparkle that had helped his union with JTG shine. Suddenly, instead of a streetwise tag team fans could get behind and be entertained by, the feuding Cryme Tyme members ironically looked more small time than before (pun intended).
A Strap Match at Extreme Rules designed to paint JTG as the sympathetic babyface to Gaspard's ruthless villain elicited little heat from the watching audience, and instantly proved why Cryme Tyme should have been left well alone by WWE.
Together, JTG and Gaspard were viable. Removed from their tag-team bubble, though, both were rendered expendable.
9. Owen Hart & The British Bulldog
Neither Owen Hart or The British Bulldog found success for any sustained period of time in the main event scene of the WWF during the 1990's; Bulldog in particular flirted with the WWF Title mix, but he was often a secondary figure in the challenger slot than a full on headliner.
Before being teamed with Bulldog, the resourceful Owen did work with partners like Jim Neidhart, Koko B. Ware, Bret Hart (briefly) and Yokozuna. None of these tandems worked out, and that only made his alliance with Davey Boy Smith look even better.
Together, the Hart family members shone throughout 1996 and into 1997. It was confusing then that even when both worked under The Hart Foundation banner as heels, the duo randomly stopped teaming together in '97 and went their separate ways.
Gelling expertly as a tag-team, Owen and Davey should have been together for years instead of re-launching their respective singles careers. The WWF could have even kept them as occasional partners, but seemed intent on moving away from a formula that had handed Owen his first truly successful tag-team run.
8. America's Most Wanted
TNA are often derided nowadays for being a company bereft of fresh ideas. Much of that derision has been merited over the years, yet it shouldn't gloss over the fact that Impact Wrestling has produced some of the best tag-teams in modern times.
America's Most Wanted, a team formed between 'Cowboy' James Storm and 'Wildcat' Chris Harris, must be considered one of them.
TNA originals, the pair worked from 2002-2006 as a team and had a lot of gas left in the tank when those penning storylines decided it was time for a split. Dissolving AMW did nothing for Harris, because the former tag star failed to ignite as a singles performer.
For his part, the beer-drinking Storm went on to form another successful team with Bobby Roode as Beer Money, but that just highlights how he struggled on his own too. America's Most Wanted had a super-slick, cool vibe to them that should have stayed in TNA rather than being dismissed just for the sake of it.
7. The World's Greatest Tag-Team
Aside from superior microphone skills, the ultra-athletic Shelton Benjamin had every tool necessary to make a splash on his own in WWE upon being drafted to Monday Night Raw in 2004. His split from regular partner Charlie Haas didn't work out at all though, and the removal of one man from the other's side revealed weaknesses hidden as a unit.
Although Benjamin did win several singles titles, he wouldn't become any bigger of a star flying solo than he had been as one half of WWE's top tag-team.
Introduced in 2002 as Team Angle, Haas and Benjamin would go on to re-dub themselves as The World's Greatest Tag-Team. That name was proven true through endlessly brilliant in-ring performances against everyone from Los Guerreros to The APA.
The alliance with Angle did have a limited shelf-life, that can't be denied, but WWE should have realised that both OVW graduates were much more effective together than they ever were apart. A reunion years later in Ring Of Honor proved that WWE were wrong to separate Benjamin and Haas.
6. The Outsiders
The very nature of the way in which Scott Hall and Kevin Nash landed back on WCW television in the Summer of 1996 should have kept them together forever. A renegade alliance between two men fans knew were genuine friends away from the ring, The Outsiders could never realistically be written to oppose one another.
That didn't stop WCW's braintrust from trying in May, 1998 at the Slamboree pay-per-view.
During a title defence of the WCW Tag-Team Titles against Sting and The Giant, the splintered (not to mention convoluted) nWo story took another turn when Hall smashed Nash and left him for dead. Hall had joined the nWo Hollywood faction rather than sticking with Nash's Wolfpac, or at least that was the reason given on air.
It didn't pan out though, because people refused to believe that such good friends were really at loggerheads. This is one angle that should have been left on the cutting room floor, and it didn't do much other than temporarily remove one of WCW's best units from screens.
5. The Hollywood Blonds
Steve Austin still scratches his head when talking about the break up of The Hollywood Blonds in October, 1993. Via his podcast, the confused Austin once said that he couldn't comprehend why WCW's top brass would want to split Brian Pillman and himself, especially because they had only been put together as a team due to a lack of momentum individually.
Without much rhyme or reason, a union both men had made work for themselves fractured and led to nothing substantial for either as singles stars. That must have been incredibly frustrating; displaying a good level of chemistry during promos and inside the ring, The Blonds had turned their team from a random alliance into one of the hottest acts in WCW.
The creative team in charge of booking a program pitting Austin against Pillman didn't do the break up justice either, and their rivalry petered out quickly.
Obviously, Steve Austin went on to greater stardom in the WWF, but WCW failed to capitalise on his talent and he still feels that keeping him aligned with Pillman would have been the best thing for his career in the company.
4. The Hart Dynasty
There are numerous examples of tag-teams splitting because those calling the shots believed one member to have potential as a singles star. The Rockers, The Hart Foundation and The APA are all classic examples, although their success shouldn't be taken as a blueprint that will work 100% of the time.
The Hart Dynasty, a team made up of David Hart Smith and Tyson Kidd, should prove that.
WWE were high on Smith, likely viewing him as a performer who had more to offer than being part of a mid-card tag-team. Looking to split the team, the writers penned an angle which had the smaller Kidd refuse to tag in and eventually attack his partner; this didn't make much sense, because the team had only really been together on the main roster for just over a full year.
The break up was premature if anything, and it completely spoiled any and all momentum The Hart Dynasty had built up as popular babyfaces. It's criminal that less than two years into their run together on shows like Raw and SmackDown, the natural union between Smith and Kidd was destroyed.
3. The Dudley Boyz
WWE do deserve some credit for trying something different with The Dudley Boyz during the first ever brand extension in 2002. Bubba Ray Dudley continued as a babyface brawler on Raw and D-Von Dudley was completely recast as a Baptist preacher who extorted money from fans over on SmackDown.
Whilst the idea was interesting, it was a million miles from what fans wanted to see from the table-breaking tag-team and wouldn't work out. Proving the split was a failure, WWE elected to reunite the storylines brothers at Survivor Series and in turn pretty much pretended that D-Von's religious gimmick hadn't happened.
The Dudleyz shouldn't have been split in the first place though. There was no reason to mess around with a formula that hadn't yet grown stale.
Keeping both Bubba Ray and D-Von on one brand would have strengthened the tag-team division on that show and would have avoided the need for both to fight for space in the mid-card pack on Raw and SmackDown. The fact they were shunted back together so quickly shows that WWE knew they had made a mistake with The Dudley Boyz.
2. The New Age Outlaws
In similar fashion to Steve Austin and Brian Pillman, the tag-team of Billy Gunn and Road Dogg was only formed due to creative having nothing for either man individually.
Toiling horribly in a feud against one another, the then-Rockabilly and 'Real Double J' Jesse James agreed to put their differences aside and align; this came at the expense of The Honky Tonk Man, who had up until that point been working as Billy's manager.
Dubbing themselves The New Age Outlaws, the heel tandem went on rants against older teams like The Legion Of Doom and eventually joined D-Generation X shortly after WrestleMania XIV. This led to a successful period for the team, one which was briefly interrupted by Gunn's tryout as a main eventer in 1999.
Following that hiccup, The Outlaws once again teamed together until Billy was kicked out of DX in early-2000. The fresh, hip aura of both guys diminished after this and they'd never recapture the same magic even when reuniting in 2014.
The saccharine team Dogg formed with K-Kwik afterwards and Billy Gunn's boring 'The One' gimmick showed why WWE had to keep The New Age Outlaws together. Individually, they struggled, but together they were dynamic.
1. The Rock N' Roll Express
Robert Gibson and Ricky Morton could never be blamed for possessing killer physiques, but bulging muscles weren't part of their charm as a duo. The Rock N' Roll Express were underdogs who fought valiantly against larger men by using slick double-team moves and teamwork.
One of the top tag-teams of the 1980's, Ricky and Robert needed one another to be valuable. Leave it to WCW then, because that company believed there was money in a feud between the well-established partners.
Morton turned on Gibson at Clash Of The Champions XV in June, 1991 to align himself with The York Foundation as a heel. From there, the ex-partners feuded with one another, but it was clear that fans wanted to see them tear the house down together and not as singles wrestlers.
Why WCW felt the need to split such a successful team who were clearly better off together than apart is anyone's guess. Thankfully, The Rock N' Roll Express reunited in 1992 shortly after leaving the company.
What other wrestling tag-teams do you believe should never have been split? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!