10 WWE Announcements That Fell Flat

It's going to be The Undertaker versus... Shane McMahon!

By David Cambridge /

In case you missed the memes, Monday Night Raw this week saw the earth-shattering announcement that Jason Jordan is, in fact, Kurt Angle's long-lost son.

Advertisement

It was the culmination of weeks of patient build-up, in which the Olympic Gold Medalist was seen on the phone, in candid backstage segments (camera crew notwithstanding), speaking in hushed tones to a special someone on the other end of the line.

We were expecting something big - the WWE debut of TNA's Dixie Carter perhaps, or at least a reunion between Kurt and former flame Stephanie McMahon - and we got it, sort of. It's not like wrestlers go round revealing themselves as the parents of other wrestlers every week. This should have been big.

So why didn't it feel like it? The crowd on Monday greeted the announcement with what felt like a disarming mix of weariness and surprise, as though they had foreseen the inevitability that WWE would let us down - but in exactly which way was still unclear.

It's far from the first time that the audience hasn't played along, though.

10. Kurt Angle's Son

So let's start with the elephant in the room.

Advertisement

Second only to a weird love affair with Dixie Carter, a long lost illegitimate son was one of the leading theories on Kurt Angle's covert backstage phone calls.

Its proponents, then, must have been delighted when the Olympian announced on Raw this week that, sure enough, he had fathered fellow professional wrestler Jason Jordan some 28 years ago.

If they were, they were pretty quiet about it. Angle's revelation was greeted with such a muted response from the crowd that those tuning into WWE for the first time could be forgiven for thinking that the Raw General Manager lays claim to estranged offspring every week. Perhaps it was merely the disappointment of realising that the writers had gone for something relatively safe (and, for those who were watching in 2007, a little passé too).

Was this really the secret that was going to destroy his career?

9. Snooki At WrestleMania 27

Celebrities have been part of the WrestleMania furniture since Mr T helped Hulk Hogan overcome Roddy Piper and Paul Orndoff at Madison Square Garden in the very first event back in 1985.

Advertisement

Since then, though, the use of non-wrestling personnel on the Grandest Stage of Them All has been very much hit and miss.

Few could argue that Mike Tyson's turn as the guest enforcer of WrestleMania 14's main event didn't enhance the occasion, whilst the bout shared between Floyd Mayweather and Big Show 10 years later was actually pretty solid, all things considered.

But when fans were told that reality star Nicole Polizzi, aka Snooki, would be competing at WrestleMania 27, alongside John Morrison and Trish Stratus, against Dolph Ziggler, Layla and Michelle McCool, it's fair to say they were not amused.

8. You're Fired

There have been so many dismissals that have fallen flat over the years that it's difficult to pick out any one in particular.

Advertisement

The first time Vince McMahon bellowed the words "You're fired" into the face of one of his long-suffering employees, in a manner we imagine Sir Alex Ferguson delivered his half-time team talks, it stirred a considerable reaction from the stands.

But by the 400th time, it began to lose some of its impact. WWE wrestlers are fired and then re-hired with such frequency that it's hard to get excited about one of them receiving their marching orders.

Most of the time they're back on TV within a matter of weeks, and even when Vince himself was sent packing by Triple H a few years ago the audience (if not the live crowd) were pretty unmoved.

7. Roman At No. 30

This wasn't strictly an announcement in the sense of someone grabbing a microphone and making a declaration to the crowd, but - in the Royal Rumble - hearing a wrestler's entrance music is the confirmation that they will be participating in the match (and, depending on what's going on the ring, it can often be confirmation that they are going to win).

Advertisement

Few expected Roman to take the final spot at the 2017 Rumble. He had already been involved in a gruelling match with Kevin Owens earlier on the show, and - given his adversarial relationship with the audience - it seemed unlikely that WWE would risk reinforcing the "Roman always wins" memes at a such a sensitive moment in his ongoing quest to get over.

Unless, of course, they were actually trying to troll us. That's what it felt like when the Big Dog was shoehorned into the match as the final entrant, a spot many were hoping was being saved for a returning veteran or just-signed indie star.

6. The Anonymous Raw GM

There were two major reasons that 2012's anonymous GM reveal didn't work.

Advertisement

First, they only let us in on the identity of the man behind Michael Cole roughly a year after the whole angle had died a slow death. And since WWE wrestlers have the sort of memory spans that only allow them to hold grudges for up to a couple of months at a time, there were no real consqeuences for whomever it was directing traffic all that time.

Second, it was Hornswoggle. They already pulled that trick once when they announced that he was the illegitimate son fathered by Vince McMahon in 2007, and fans by this point had long since grown weary of seeing Finlay's side-kick all over the WWE product.

As the old saying goes: fool me once...

5. The Undertaker Vs Shane McMahon

To stave off any accusations of revisionism, let's be fair here: the initial announcement of Undertaker's WrestleMania 32 match with Shane McMahon did elicit a fairly enthusiastic response from the live Monday Night Raw audience.

Advertisement

But how could it not? We only got to see the Deadman wrestle once a year, and probably would have cheered the news that he was going up against Linda McMahon (especially if it was inside Hell in a Cell).

When the dust settled, though, fans couldn't hide their disappointment at the fact that one of 'Taker's final WrestleMania opponents would be a man who hadn't wrestled in nearly a decade, the culmination of a last-minute feud which was only conceived as a way to paper over the unfortunate injury crisis that beset WWE in early 2016.

4. The Punjabi Prison Match

This is specifically in reference to the announcement of the inaugural Punjabi Prison match between The Undertaker and The Great Khali (who was later, inexplicably, subbed out for Big Show) at The Great American Bash in 2006 - but the same can be said of many other specialist gimmick matches.

Advertisement

It's just kind of difficult to get excited about a match when you have no idea what it actually entails, that's all. What exactly is a Punjabi Prison? Or, for that matter, a Samoan Strap? What's an Ambrose Asylum? And what the hell is a House of Horrors match?

(To be honest, in the case of the latter, we're still no closer to the answer two months after it actually happened).

3. John Cena Vs Kevin Federline

At the height of John Cena's mega-run, he was being jeered with such fury that the only way to get the audience behind him was to put him in the ring with someone even more insufferable.

Advertisement

Step forward Kevin Federline.

The short-lived feud between Cena and K-Fed was less one-sided than it perhaps should have been, with Britney Spears' former spouse scoring a pinfall victory over the then-WWE Champion (albeit with the help of Johnny Nitro and Umaga) in a no-disqualification match on the New Year's Day edition of Raw in 2007.

Fans weren't exactly over the moon about the prospect of seeing a Z-list celebrity hogging the WWE limelight, and the tepid response to the announcement of their match was probably the first sign that it wasn't going to result in the viewership spike they had originally envisaged.

2. Celebrity Hosts

If there's one thing we've learnt from this list it's that wrestling fans don't really care very much about celebrities.

Advertisement

But WWE didn't get this memo in 2009, when they announced that Monday Night Raw would be hosted by a series of A-listers (plus Sharon Osbourne) for the foreseeable future, an initiative apparently conceived by Donald Trump originally - which ought to tell you all you need to know about its merits.

On paper, this was supposed to be a ratings winner, but it was largely greeted with indifference from the audience, most of whom would have preferred a permanent General Manager to tired comedy skits involving Santino Marella and celebrities mis-remembering the names of the wrestlers whose matches they were supposed to be scheduling.

1. Vince McMahon's Million Dollar Give-Away

Vince McMahon is the businessman here, but if your new marketing strategy involves giving away one million dollars, then hadn't you better make damn sure that said strategy yields, at minimum, one million dollars in return?

Advertisement

You have to hand it to them: it was a bold way to drive up ratings.

For a couple of weeks, the WWE chairman would stand in front of a glitzy set* live on Raw, making calls to viewers - by all accounts (well, WWE's anyway), actual viewers - to whom he would then pledge a cash prize, for no other reason than the fact that he was Vince McMahon and it was his show and this is America and he can do whatever he damn well pleases.

The announcement fell kind of flat though, with fans (justifiably) fearing two likely outcomes: wrestling would be side-lined, and nobody would actually get paid. They were right on the first point, and on the second - that's still very much up in the air.

*The same one he used to fake his death - again.

Advertisement