10 WWE Disasters That Saved Themselves

Snatching glory from the jaws of abject failure.

By Andy H Murray /

Cody Rhodes left WWE a stifled, frustrated midcard burnout in 2016.

Advertisement

Requesting his release when his employers refused to let go of the failed Stardust gimmick, he bet on himself, did the work, and made himself the star he never could have become in Vince McMahon's machine, and now, with All Elite Wrestling's televised debut looming, he is legitimately one of the most influential figures in the sport. His transformation over the past few years is borderline remarkable.

'The American Nightmare' is an excellent example of a performer who valued himself more than the McMahons and willed his way back to relevance. Still, it'd be a stretch to call his WWE run a "disaster." Yes, it ended poorly, and yes, he failed to fulfil his full potential, but he left with eight championship reigns to his name. That's more than 99% of pro-wrestlers will ever accomplish in the game.

Not that this should detract from the comeback story as few are truly able to rebound when a WWE run doesn't pan out as planned, and while the wrestlers within haven't all hit the same heights as Cody over the past couple of years, each arguably clawed themselves out of a darker abyss...

10. Hideo Itami

His signing may have helped kickstart WWE's indie talent raid, but Hideo Itami was never a good fit for several reasons:-

Advertisement

1. An inability to cut promos in English.

2. Having to abandon signature moves like the Go to Sleep and Busaiku Knee Kick because other WWE wrestlers had already adopted them.

3. Being made to tone down his bruising, concussive style to fit WWE's safer mould.

4. Debuting as a babyface. KENTA excels as a d*ckhead piece of sh*t. Why wouldn't you let him be a d*ckhead piece of sh*t?

Throw his rough injury record into the mix and you have a recipe for disaster that was only slightly assuaged with his late-run NXT heel turn, before Itami left to enter a listless period on 205 Live, where he was visibly out of shape and disinterested.

Negotiating an early release from his WWE contract may have saved KENTA's career. Departing in January, he re-emerged in NJPW in June, embarking on a G1 Climax run rife with flashes of his former badassery. A jaw-dropping heel turn to join Bullet Club preceded the year's most emotional memorable angle as he scrapped with training partner Katsuyori Shibata on finals night and while he'll never be the wrestler he once was, the new NEVER Openweight Champion hasn't felt so alive since leaving Pro Wrestling NOAH.

9. Kassius Ohno

Kassius Ohno's promising first NXT run peaked during an awesome feud against William Regal which concluded following an acclaimed April 2013 bout with the veteran scoring the victory, leading to an Ohno face turn. Things started going wrong for him shortly after. Pulled from TV amidst reports that he wasn't committed to his conditioning training, Kassius was released by November.

Advertisement

A stellar independent run followed. When people call him the greatest indie wrestler of all time, the period he spent grafting around the globe between 2013 and 2016 is the argument-winning cherry on top, as promotions like PWG, EVOLVE, and Beyond played rost to Chris Hero's staggering rebirth. The Ohioan's in-ring creativity had been turned loose once more. He was delivering big at almost every time of asking, and barely weekend passed without him making indie headlines.

This buzz led directly to his WWE return in December 2016. Some may point to his lack of NXT focus since then as a downer here, but Ohno likely secured his long-term financial future by rejoining WWE. He's a walking wrestling encyclopedia who'd make a great Performance Center coach after hanging them up. He didn't come back to be a TakeOver headliner, either; he came back to give back in a complimentary midcard role putting younger wrestlers over, and to finally rest after grinding himself to dust on the indies.

8. Jinder Mahal

A nothing performer before his WWE release in 2014, Jinder Mahal's most memorable period came as a member of 3MB. That should say it all. They were an entertaining trio, but jobbers, and their own highlight came while acting as secondaries to Hornswoggle in his WeeLC feud with El Torito.

Advertisement

Mahal was let go from the promotion on the same day as stablemate Drew McIntyre in June 2014. While the Scot would eventually make his way back to WWE after a stellar indie run, Jinder was the opposite. He barely got booked at all. In 2015, he worked just 25 indie matches and only six more in 2016's first half before WWE scooped him back up, reintroducing Mahal through a 14-second squash of another ex-3MB'er - Heath Slater.

So, what prompted Vince McMahon to reacquire Jinder after such a dismal indie run? Those gains, baby.

Mahal got himself in phenomenal, ripped shape in his time away from the company. Suddenly, he was a chiselled Adonis, and it's hard to imagine this wasn't a factor in his rapid ascension from undercard goober to WWE Champion, which provided one of 2017's biggest stories.

Jinder fell back down the card as soon as he lost the bet, but he's probably set for life financially.

7. Mark Henry

History will be kind to Mark Henry, whose Hall of Pain spell is genuinely one of the most compelling heel runs of WWE's decade, with the former Olympian finally finding a menacing aura to compliment his simple, impactful power-based in-ring arsenal. At his peak, the big man felt like an indomitable wrecking ball. Years later, he'd find further (albeit fleeting) success on the back of his "salmon jacket" moment with John Cena, after which he should have become WWE Champion.

Advertisement

More than just a great gimmick change, the Hall of Pain was a full-on career rehabilitation. His reputation had improved from his grim early days, but for the most part, Henry was still seen as an expensive disappointment.

Famously signed to a mammoth ten-year contract after competing in the 1996 Olympics, Henry's size and power caught the eye, but he was clumsy, out of his depth, and pushed way over his head. The big fella was sent back to developmental for further training twice. Make no mistake, it took him a long, long time to get it together, shake off his old reputation, and finally soar as a monster. Embracing the Hall of Fame was key to this.

6. Goldust

A perennial fixture on any credible "most underrated" list, Goldust debuted as a bold, provocative WWE character in 1995, and his early run was great, with 'The Bizarre One' pushing boundaries, delivering big between the ropes, and emerging as one of his era's most vital midcarders.

Advertisement

Then things went off a cliff. Fast.

Dustin Rhodes' performances depreciated to the point that it was hard to believe this was still the same performer behind the facepaint. This continued for years, as he left WWE in May 1999, returned for another run in 2001 highlighted by his hilarious alliance with Booker T and lowlighted by increasingly tried in-ring performances, before eventually rediscovering his awesome upon starting his penultimate run in 2008.

Visibly healthier, Goldust looked like a man reborn - inside the ring and out. His ECW run was low-key excellent and while never pushed particularly strongly, his performances were extremely consistent. Later, he'd further prove his worth by joining forces with brother Cody Rhodes, knocking it out of the park as his family raged against the authority, further enhancing his status as an underappreciated pro-wrestling gem.

5. The New Day

Whether you like their act or not, The New Day are over as hell. They usually draw big crowd reactions, their merch sells by the bucketload, and their brand power is such that it's hard to see Vince McMahon ever splitting them up. Why throw a marketable commodity on the bonfire?

Advertisement

That they've been able to stay so successful for so long is borderline miraculous, considering their early disasters. Their formation wasn't smooth at all. They came together under the assertion that they were done "kissing babies and shaking hands," and would now take "their time to shine," before disappearing for a couple of months. Videos portraying them as clapping, singing positivity beacons then started airing, and they were atrocious, making Big E, Xavier Woods, and Kofi Kingston look more cartoonish than uplifting.

The project reached a nadir when the "New Day rocks!" chants turned to "New Day sucks!" with the group still technically babyfaces. Demonstrably, it wasn't getting over, but WWE were smart. They used this heat to turn the trio heel. Fast-forward four years and one babyface later to the present day, when The New Day remain amongst WWE's most bankable acts.

4. CJ Parker

Perhaps CJ Parker's eco-warrior gimmick could have worked under different circumstances. The performer's look fit the act, he drew heat in Full Sail University, and he was obnoxious as hell, but WWE weren't interested in promoting him as anything other than an enhancement talent. Thus, he struggled to make an impact, with accidentally breaking Kevin Owens' nose in KO's TakeOver: R Evolution debut his most memorable moment.

Advertisement

Parker saved himself by becoming Juice Robinson. He joined New the New Japan dojo just six months after escaping developmental hell. With his career in the toilet, he grafted through the most intense educational system in wrestling, spending the rest of 2015 competing and learning as a Young Lion, before slowly, surely working his way through the card's lower tiers, finding himself as both a wrestler and a character.

New Year Dash 2017 provided a key turning point for Robinson, who scored a shock pinfall on NEVER Openweight Champion Hirooki Goto that night. He hasn't looked back since, continuing to grow as an expressive, charismatic midcarder with two IWGP United States Championship reigns under his belt, and his journey far from over.

3. Goldberg

It can't be overstated just how harmful Goldberg's original WWE run could have been to his lasting wrestling legacy.

Advertisement

His Rock-baiting debut was as awesome as his WrestleMania XX departure was humiliating, with the infamous Brock Lesnar stallfest still mentioned amongst the 'Show of Shows'' most boring bouts. Goldberg left WWE on a career low. While much of this was down to the way he'd been presented, this failed run solidified the cynical opinion that WCW had captured lightning in a bottle with him, that he was never any good, and most significant of all, that he couldn't cut it on Vince McMahon's watch.

This take became increasingly popular over time. It would have become Goldberg's legacy had he not returned in 2016.

While the comeback wasn't without its bumps, that its highlights drew so much acclaim and attention helped redefine the former WCW Champion. Goldberg understood its importance more than anyone. He poured everything he had into making it work, and he couldn't have asked for a more fitting finale than WrestleMania 33's ballistic rematch with Lesnar which not only ensured he signed off in style, but helped cement him as a big, big star.

2. Dean Ambrose

When evaluated as a whole, it'd be extreme to call Dean Ambrose's WWE run a "disaster." The Shield will go down as one of the promotion's greatest ever stables and he was WWE Champion for several months, leading SmackDown when the brand split was revived in 2016. Unquestionably, he put forth some excellent, memorable work while under WWE's employ.

Advertisement

That doesn't mean his last few months weren't a complete calamity, though.

Turning heel on the night Roman Reigns announced his leukaemia had returned provoked a huge reaction by capitalising on raw, real emotion, but everything after it stunk. He had needles stuck in his arse so he wouldn't catch Seth Rollins' "disease" and wore a gas mask to the ring. When news that he'd requested his WWE release broke, Ambrose became a pseudo-jobber in a weird, brief feud with EC3, before mailing it in throughout a forced final chapter designed to convince him to change his mind about walking away.

It failed. By that point, Dean was too burned out by the Such Good Sh*t era that he had no choice but to leave, rediscover himself, shake off that Sports Entertainment stench, and become Jon Moxley once more.

One month later, he'd debuted for both AEW and NJPW. His record since then speaks for itself.

1. Baron Corbin

WWE Raw was largely built around 'Constable' Baron Corbin as a main event authority figure in late 2018. Objectively, this was a disaster. Corbin scored two record-low ratings figures during this period, with the backlash so severe that he was scapegoated as the source of all WWE's problems live on the air.

Advertisement

Eyes rolled when Corbin returned to prominence for a length feud with Universal Champion Seth Rollins in 2019. By Extreme Rules, Baron looked cooked. He was done. The project had failed.

Now, in September, there's an argument to be made that he's the most improved wrestler in the world.

Baron's game has gone through the roof over the past few months. This was most apparent in the recent King of the Ring tournament, with the 'Throne Wolf' (h/t Michael Hamflett) flipping a switch to go from dull, unengaging resthold merchant to bruising, explosive, hard-hitting bully. Matches with The Miz, Cedric Alexander, and Chad Gable drew acclaim from those who'd labelled him boring in the past, and he has found a happy home on the midcard, where he can pull real heat without fear of resistance.

Advertisement