As hard as it is to make it as a WWE Superstar, finding success as a WWE Diva is that much more difficult. While some may argue that a little sex appeal is all that it takes to get the eye of the company's talent recruiters, the truth is that Divas compete over fewer spots, have shorter shelf lives, and suffer under a very low glass ceiling when it comes to potential stardom. Still, many women work hard to make it to the WWE, and someTrish Stratus, Victoria, the Bella Twins, and Natalya, to name a fewforge long-term careers for themselves. Usually, though, that's the exception to the rule. Many a Diva is cast out once she outlives her usefulness, or quits after being marginalized in a role where she feels like she can't show off her talents. Some are driven out by the other workers, while still others are exposed as having little to no interest in, or familiarity with, wrestling (ah, the dangers of hiring models and teaching them how to wrestle). Here are ten Divas who've all made their way onto our TV screens, but have all been forgotten by history. Whether wrestling was their dream, a detour, or simply a quick buck, they all gave something to WWE and we salute them for it.
Advertisement
10. Ariel
When the new ECW started on the SyFy Network in 2006, there was a clear influence exerted over the product by the channel the hardcore nature of Extreme Championship Wrestling was present, at least initially, but side by side with it were cheesy horror-themed elements. On the first episode, for instance, The Sandman brutally beat a grunting, groaning, one-and-done competitor by the name of The Zombie. The most blatant sign of the network's string-pulling, though, came in the form of the vampiric Kevin Thorne and his escort, Ariel. Whether or not the two were creatures of the night or simply enthusiasts was never revealed, just as a planned stable with Gangrel never came to fruition. Instead of character insight, the two traipsed around the land of extreme, feuding with the likes of Balls Mahoney and Mike Knox. When Thorne formed the "New Breed" faction with Matt Striker, Marcus Cor Von, and leader Elijah Burke, Ariel came along, and when Thorne left the group, Ariel was still by his side. Unfortunately, she never got the chance to show what she could do on her own she was released in May of 2007, allegedly after a confrontation with Dave Batista.
9. Katie Lea Burchill
A note about Vince McMahon for years, it seemed as if he's wanted to run an incest angle. He's alluded to it (Mark Henry, Beaver Cleaver, and so on), and proposed angles that never made TV (Ken and Ryan Shamrock in 1999, and later a family member as the father of Stephanie McMahon's baby), but he never quite got his chance. In 2008, it looked like he would finally get the opportunity to see it though when English wrestler Katarina Waters became Katie Lea Burchill, sister of former pirate Paul Burchill. Paul was very protective of his sister, all while heeding her every demand. "What Katie wants, Katie gets," he would say. Sadly for McMahon, in the summer of 2008, WWE signed a lucrative toy contract with Mattel, and as a result, all of their programming became TV-PG. The angle with the Burchills, which hadn't yet evolved past the "mild insinuation" stage, was dropped. Now, Paul and Katie were nothing but a pair of jerk siblings. Still, they were both talented. Katie contended for the Women's Championship, but was unable to capture the title. Both Burchills moved to ECW, where they played medium-sized fish in a small pond. When the brand shut down in early 2010, Paul was released. Two months later, Katie followed.
8. Nicole Bass
Female bodybuilder Nicole Bass first entered pro wrestling in ECW in 1998, but she hit it big at WrestleMania XV when she debuted as Sable's bodyguard. Standing 6'2" and weighing 240 pounds, she was quite the intimidating backup, manhandling men as needed and out-Chyna-ing Chyna. The alliance with Sable dissolved and a romance angle with Val Venis started, but didn't really go anywhere. Bass puttered around a bit, but left the company shortly thereafter, filing a sexual harassment lawsuit against WWE. According to the lawsuit (which was dismissed in 2003), Bass was sexually assaulted backstage by "The Brooklyn Brawler" Steve Lombardi. While the allegations were never proven, it's not hard to imagine that, at the very least, Bass was victim to a hostile work environment one infamous Raw segment saw Shawn Michaels, on guest commentary, repeatedly refer to Bass as "Mister" and "him," which reportedly had the imposing Diva in tears afterwards. Today, Bass makes appearances as part of Howard Stern's "Wack Pack."
7. Joy Giovanni
Despite failing to win the 2004 Diva Search, Joy Giovanni was offered a role on Smackdown... as a massage therapist. Well, you've gotta start somewhere. When Luther Reigns made a pass at her, though, The Big Show stepped up to defend her honor and what followed was a budding romance to melt even the stoniest of hearts. Well, not really. She more served as The Big Show's Achilles heel, the reason for him to come down, make a stand, and have his vulnerability exploited. A convenient plot device, really. Giovanni would go on to have a feud of her own with Amy Weber (more on her later), but when Weber left the company, Giovanni was high and dry. She showed potential for a comeback, winning a four-way contest (over, among others, Michelle McCool) to be named Rookie Diva of the Year, but by the middle of 2005, she was released. Still, Giovanni would return to make one more appearance, in the WrestleMania 25 women's battle royal. You know, the one Santino won? The one right after the Kid Rock concert? A fitting end to her career.
6. Maxine
Before it was a developmental territory, NXT was a game show/wrestling program that ran on the SyFy Network. The premise was that a group of "rookies" would each be assigned a veteran from the WWE roster who would coach them and help improve their skills. Then, fans would vote to eliminate contestants, with the last one left getting a contract and a shot at a championship. Hopes were not high for the third season, though not only was the show cancelled and forced to become an internet-only broadcast, but the entire cast was made up of would-be Divas. Some, like Naomi and AJ Lee, have proven themselves as competent workers, but others, well, didn't. Maxine (who wrestled future Divas' Champion Kaitlyn in what was voted the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Worst Match of the Year) never really got much of a chance. She failed to win the show, then returned on the fifth season of NXT, subtitled "Redemption." After running romance storylines with Derrick Bateman (now Ethan Carter III in TNA) and Johnny "Fandango" Curtis, she finally debuted on Raw. Still, her career went nowhere, and in June of 2012, she requested her release from the company. Today, she is part of the Mark Burnett/AAA production Lucha Underground.
5. Cherry
When independent wrestler Kara Slice was signed to a developmental contract, she was made the manager of Deuce Shade (Sim Snuka) and Dice Domino (Cliff Compton). She took the name Cherry Pie, and the three did a 1950s style gimmick the men were greasers, and Cherry was a roller-skating, gum-chewing, poodle-skirt-sporting anachronism. By the time they came up to WWE in early 2007, their names were changed slightly now we were simply dealing with Deuce, Domino, and Cherry but the gimmicks were the same. The team quickly found success, as they ended the 11-month WWE Tag Team Championship reign of Paul London and Brian Kendrick however, it was short-lived. They lost the belts by the summer, their win-loss record started to falter, and Cherry soon split from her fellas. The rift led to a face turn, a mini-feud with Maryse, and a running-afoul of Vickie Guerrero. Still, none of these turned into long-term success for Cherry, and she was released in August of 2008.
4. Amy Weber
Amy Weber was a part of the inaugural Diva Search in 2004, finishing in 4th place. She was signed to a contract and immediately put into JBL's Cabinet, taking the role of the WWE Champion's image consultant. She was brilliant in her role; just as in the Diva Search itself, where she embraced each challenge wholeheartedly and seemed to be having a great time, she dove into the inherent silliness of her character. In perhaps her best-remembered appearance, she accidentally shot JBL with a tranquilizer dart, causing him to strip to his underwear and assault an inflatable dinosaur in the ring. Before a big championship match, she told JBL, "No matter what happens, I'll always be your image consultant." Unfortunately, that wasn't true. Weber disappeared shortly after the dart angle, later stating, "I wasn't happy with the pay and I wasn't happy with the 'frat house' like environment." Rumors swirled that Randy Orton, infamous for hazing Divas during his younger days, had targeted Weber, bullying her to the point where she decided she'd rather not have the job. She has since started a family and gone back to pursuing a career in acting and music.
3. B.B.
One could argue that in late 1999/early 2000 WWE hit its peak in terms of exploitation of women it was during that time that Stacy "The Kat" Carter famously disrobed on Pay-Per-View and a bikini contest at the Royal Rumble turned into an excuse to show then-septuagenarian Mae Young wearing a pair of prosthetic breasts. During this time period, we were introduced to the WWE's newest Diva, B.B. Though initially she appeared to be a paramedic, her attempts to help The Kat during a gravy bowl match led Ivory to tear her shirt off and throw her in said gravy. B.B. (which stood for Barbara Bush surely a feather in the cap of some writer with high school-aged friends) began a feud with Ivory that led to her getting her shirt torn off repeatedly. She faded into the background and, only three months after her debut, was written off television after taking a top-rope Powerbomb through a table from Bubba Ray Dudley. You see, she apparently still had a job as a paramedic, so she checked on him after he appeared to be injured, one thing led to another, and smash. Of course, this is wrestling, so no WWE star is ever gone forever, no matter how briefly their candle burned. B.B. would turn up in WCW as Papaya, the wife of Kwee-Wee, then later in TNA as Taylor Vaughn. No word on which experience was least pleasant.
2. Amy Zidian
Amy Zidian was part of the 2006 Diva Search class, an impressive line-up that included Maryse, the Bella twins, Rosa Mendes, and eventual winner Layla El. Zidian also managed to snare herself a contract, though, at the behest of John Laurinaitis. She was briefly sent to OVW, then brought up in late 2006 to play the role of Jimmy Wang Yang's redneck girlfriend. Immediately, Zidian began rubbing other Divas the wrong way. Seniority goes a long way in WWE's hierarchy, and when you're new, everybody's more senior than you, so it's best to keep a low profile. Zidian took the opposite road, antagonizing her coworkers. Reportedly, she asked Vickie Guerrero why she was a WWE Diva, then proceeded to insult her appearance. An affront of the sort on the recently bereaved Guerrero would have been enough to end Zidian's career in and of itself, but Laurinaitis stepped in to smooth things over. The final straw came when Zidian, filming a TV segment, was given direction by Stephanie McMahon which the WWE's newest Diva didn't take well. She asked McMahon who she thought she was to give her advice, and "The Billion Dollar Princess" told Zidian exactly who she was. Shortly thereafter, she was fired.
1. Muffy
Stuntwoman and actress Caryn Mower was convinced to try wrestling by Ultimate Pro Wrestling's Rick Bassman the same man responsible for breaking in John Cena, Samoe Joe, and a host of others. She quickly took to the sport, and when WWE talent scouts came to take a look at the UPW roster, she was signed up by the company. Given the gimmick of a crazed fitness instructor, Muffy, Mower would cut promos before televised shows, insulting fans and their exercise habits. Still, it would be months before she was brought up to WWE TV. Muffy's time came in April of 2000, when she debuted on Smackdown as Stephanie McMahon's personal trainer Muffy the Fat Slayer. She shrieked at the fans, promised to get Steph into ring shape, made one further appearance at her client's side, then disappeared forever. According to rumor, McMahon was uncomfortable with the idea of having a storyline trainer, the implication of having one arguably meaning that she was in less-than-ideal shape. Mower was taken off TV, then released in September of 2000. She would return to UPW, then resume her successful stunt career. She may not have made it in wrestling, but she'll always have a distinction as WWE's least memorable Diva.