10 WWE Feuds Where The Wrong Person Won

The most unfortunate victims of John Cena, Triple H and co.

By Jack G King /

Feuds are the lifeblood of wrestling, giving meaning to the action going on inside the ring, and hooking the fans' emotions along the way. A well-built rivalry with a satisfying payoff can give both men involved a valuable boost, especially the winner. The only problem is getting it right, a task far easier said than done...

Advertisement

Sadly, even the biggest promotion in the world can mess up a feud with startling regularity. Over the years, the WWE have built incredibly promising rivalries...only to fall at the last hurdle, giving the rub to the entirely wrong man and drawing the ire of countless fans.

The consequences of a bad feud aren't just felt by the loser; a bad ending can seriously derail the winner's momentum, especially if fans react in a particularly disgruntled manner. Sometimes, even if a feud's conclusion seems infuriatingly obvious to everybody watching, the entirely wrong course of action can be taken. The WWE's stubborn refusal to go back on a bad decision usually makes everything worse, although they have occasionally relented in instances of extreme fan pressure.

Here are ten feuds where just about everybody knew which superstar should have gone over, only for the WWE to maddeningly defy expectations.



10. Sheamus Vs. Daniel Bryan

One of the more modern entries on this list, Daniel Bryan's humiliating treatment at the hands of Sheamus must go down as one of the biggest miscalculations in recent WWE history. The Irishman's 18-second defeat of then-heel Bryan at WrestleMania 28 was seemingly intended to be a hilarious, feel-good babyface win to open the show.

Advertisement

But Bryan's simmering undercurrent of fan support finally burst to the surface, sparked by the indignant nature of his loss. Sheamus, having won the World Heavyweight Championship in the process, suffered a great deal of abuse - especially when the WWE attempted to transfer Bryan's wildly popular "Yes!" chant onto him.

Bryan lost his rematch at the following PPV, losing a feud he should have unquestionably won in hindsight. However this decision must go down as the least damaging on the list, as the loss ironically helped Daniel in the long run, generating an outpouring of sympathy and support which eventually made him the hottest babyface in the company.

9. Big Show Vs. Brock Lesnar

Back in 2002, Brock Lesnar was on an unforeseen tear, winning the WWE Championship just five months after his explosive debut. He was universally considered the next hot superstar of wrestling, one who could potentially define the future of the WWE. He suffered his first pinfall loss just two months later.

The fact that Brock lost his title to the Big Show, rather than a top-tier star such as Kurt Angle or The Undertaker, makes such a booking decision all the more baffling. Show benefitted from the betrayal of Lesnar's manager, Paul Heyman, to win the title at Survivor Series, only to then drop the belt to Angle at the very next PPV.

Lesnar fortunately lost little momentum, winning the Royal Rumble and regaining his WWE Championship at WrestleMania XIX. However, his loss to Big Show remains a curious blip at the start of an otherwise mightily impressive run at the top of the wrestling world.

8. John Cena Vs. Bray Wyatt

Of all the promising young stars on the current WWE main roster, Bray Wyatt is probably the most unfortunate victim of uninspired booking. His feuds lack any solid reason, falling lazily into the realm of "he's evil and he attacks people", and rarely result in a win for the Eater of Worlds.

Advertisement

It's always disappointing to see a wrestler as promising as Wyatt so badly misused, especially given the uniquely creepy nature of his character.

False hope was given to Wyatt fans in the build to WrestleMania XXX, when Bray and his stable turned their attention to John Cena, seemingly determined to convert him to their dark ways. This could have been the logical starting point for that eagerly-anticipated Cena heel turn, or at least an angle which saw the fan favourite in some sort of real danger.

Instead, Cena cleanly defeated Wyatt at 'Mania and buried him under a mound of production equipment at Payback, before winning his 15th WWE Championship soon after. It was the lazy way out of an initially intriguing feud, and the booking team took it without hesitation.

7. John Cena Vs. Wade Barrett

A feud with eerie similarities to the last entry on this list, Cena's earlier feud with Wade Barrett saw a very similar conclusion tarnish a storyline which looked to be heading somewhere unique. Having lost a match to Barrett, forcing him to become a member of Wade's NXT stable, Cena refused to play along with the rules of the stipulation.

Advertisement

The idea of Cena struggling with his own morality while helping Barrett achieve his heelish goals was a naturally compelling one, especially when applied to a character of John's squeaky-clean nature. Instead the storyline followed a far more predictable pattern, which Cena continuing to foil Wade at every turn.

He was eventually "fired" from the company as punishment, but continued to run-in from the crowd and generally made Barrett's life a misery.

The pair eventually faced off in a blow-off match at TLC 2010, in which Cena literally buried Wade under a mountain of chairs (see the similarities with Wyatt?) to end their feud. Barrett quickly fell into the midcard, and is yet to recover.

6. Randy Orton Vs. Christian

Christian's World Heavyweight Championship win at Extreme Rules 2011 was seen as vindication for his many years of service to the WWE. A midcard favourite of the Attitude Era, he had finally captured an elusive World Championship - a moment made even more jubilant by the involvement of old tag team partner Edge.

Advertisement

Five days later, his reign was ended in a seemingly innocuous television match.

Randy Orton won a fan poll on Smackdown to determine the number one contender, and went on to cleanly defeat the veteran, killing his sentimental reign before it had even properly begun. Christian, and a sizeable chunk of the WWE fanbase, were aghast.

To make matters worse, the Smackdown writers decided to turn Christian heel in his pursuit to regain the title. Edge turned on him, a transparent move intended to throw support behind the babyface Orton, and Christian won the title back by virtue of a screwy DQ stipulation.

He then immediately lost the title again, falling victim to a spectacular (but ultimately heartbreaking) RKO at SummerSlam. Christian's time in the sun was over, and must sadly be remembered as a disappointment.

5. The Rock Vs. CM Punk

No matter what your opinion on CM Punk's acrimonious departure from the WWE is, the decision to end his record-breaking 434 day reign to make room for a horribly-telegraphed Rock/Cena rematch must go down as an infuriating one. 

Advertisement

The Rock's title shot at the 2013 Royal Rumble perfectly summed up everything Punk had griped about in his landmark "pipebomb" promo of 2011 - an old beloved veteran returning to steal the spotlight from a younger, hungrier, more deserving superstar. 

From the moment the match was announced, fans predicted the same booking pattern in the build to WrestleMania XXIX. The Rock would defeat Punk for the championship, Cena would win the Royal Rumble itself, and the pair would square off in the main event of 'Mania - in which Cena would finally get his win back. 

But the WWE surely couldn't be that obvious, could they?

Actually, they could. Events unfolded exactly as everyone suspected, with CM Punk's red hot title reign casually ended as a result. Punk later revealed that he had pitched a triple-threat 'Mania main event to Vince, pitting himself against The Rock and Cena. 

This would have at least added a dash of unpredictability to the mix, instead of the stiflingly predictable booking fans were treated to instead.

4. Triple H Vs. Randy Orton

2009 saw Randy Orton on the rise as an immensely evil heel, the sort of character fans had been crying out for him to portray since his ill-advised face turn after splitting from Evolution. A natural villain, he tore into the McMahon family, punting Vince in the head, RKOing Stephanie, and staking a claim to Triple H's WWE Championship.

Advertisement

The stage was set for the main event of WrestleMania XXV, a match which would surely kickstart Orton's rise to become the greatest heel of the era. The match was unfortunately an underwhelming one, and drew a mixed reaction from fans burned out by the five-star Undertaker vs Shawn Michaels classic that had taken place a short time before.

However, the result of the bout was far more offensive than its average nature.

Triple H beat the tar out of Orton in the closing stages of the match, smashing him with a sledgehammer and several Pedigrees en route to the most decisive of victories. Randy would win (and lose) the title several times over the following few months, but such a huge loss on the grandest stage of all denied him a career-igniting moment.

3. Hulk Hogan Vs. Randy Savage

Sometimes the outcome of a feud is decided by circumstances outside of the bookers' control, be it injury, impending retirement, or commitments outside of wrestling. This was an issue facing the 'Mega Powers Explode' angle of WrestleMania V, which saw former best buddies Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage turn on one another.

Advertisement

WWE Champion Savage had grown immensely jealous of Hogan's friendship with Miss Elizabeth, leading to a heel turn and vicious beatdown of the fan favourite. Although slightly early in the history of WrestleMania for a straight-up heel victory in the main event, it would still have made sense for Savage to somehow escape with his title.

Hogan was about to star in No Holds Barred, and surely wouldn't hog the belt while taking time out to film and promote the movie.

Oh yes he would: Hogan won cleanly at 'Mania and embarked upon his second WWE title reign (which lasted over a year). Ludicrously, his next major feud was against Zeus, the villain his character faced in No Holds Barred.

Issues of a fictional character appearing to challenge the actor portraying his onscreen nemesis were never properly explained.

In the meantime, Savage was relegated to the role of Zeus' sidekick, a role entirely unbefitting a man of his immense talent and charisma.

2. Triple H Vs. Booker T

Storylines with racist undertones should always be handled extra carefully, be they in the world of cinema, literature or television - and professional wrestling is no exception. The booking of the Triple H vs Booker T feud of 2003 paid little attention to the sensitive nature of its subject matter, instead tackling the issue with uncomfortable heavy-handedness.

Advertisement

Booker's criminal past was highlighted repeatedly, while World Heavyweight Champion Triple H explicitly told the challenger that "guys like him" could never win the title, and even suggested that he was merely there to "dance around" and entertain "people like" himself.

Although the WWE have since denied allegations of racism, it's hard to avoid when looking at this storyline.

Surely, after such a controversial build, the feud would logically end with Booker T triumphantly defeating The Game, proving once and for all that he is just as viable a champion as his tormentor. Right? Instead, Triple H cleanly defeated Booker at WrestleMania XIX, and the challenger was quickly shuffled into the Intercontinental title scene instead.

It leaves a bitter taste in the mouth of many WWE fans to this day.

1. WWF Vs The Alliance

The Invasion angle had so many fundamental issues, it's difficult to know where to begin. The overwhelming superiority of Team WWF, the fact that Stone Cold and every ex-ECW star had to jump ship to make the Alliance seem like a threat, and the lack of Goldberg, Sting, Hogan et al. rendered the feud a toothless one from the beginning.

Advertisement

However, it could have been saved had the Alliance won the climactic 5-on-5 elimination tag match at Survivor Series 2001. The angle was supposedly pencilled in to last much, much longer than it did, leading to the establishment of Nitro as a rival brand to Raw - only for Vince to label the WCW roster as "weak" and utterly crush them in the space of a few months.

Had the Alliance won with Austin at the helm, they could have been rebuilt as a credible heel force, one capable of seriously challenge the stability of the World Wrestling Federation. The most disappointing angle in wrestling history could have been saved, and Diamond Dallas Page fans would perhaps have seen their hero actually achieve something under Vince - instead of being wasted as the stalker of The Undertaker's wife.

Instead, Kurt Angle revealed himself to be a double-agent at Survivor Series, blindsiding Austin and allowing The Rock to vanquish the invading forces once and for all. It garnered a big pop, but nixed a floundering storyline instead of attempting to save it with sensible, patient booking.

Advertisement