10 WWE Moments That Destroyed The 'Fiend' Character

Only WWE could take 'The Fiend' from infallible to laughable.

By Chris Humphries /

Back in the summer of 2019, fans eagerly awaited the arrival of Bray Wyatt's new character in hopes that it would not only entertain but also give the performer a second life in WWE. After the debut of 'The Fiend' at SummerSlam, it appeared the sports entertainment company had finally found its next hit, and Wyatt was destined to conquer the top of the card.

Advertisement

WWE's new homicidal clown intrigued fans with his edgier themes and more vicious presentation. For a moment, everything felt like it was going to be perfect. However, naysayers were still quick to suggest the company would fumble its hottest act, and they were quick to be correct.

Only two matches in and many fans had already given up on 'The Fiend.' All he had to be was a disturbed masked man who plowed through credible talent. Instead, WWE subjected Wyatt to turbulent booking that often tarnished his gimmick's appeal.

Even so, there have been many entertaining spots involving Wyatt since he reared his head again around 16 months ago. Unfortunately, there were also many more moments that risked completely destroying 'The Fiend' for good.

10. Acme, Inc Finish - Hell In A Cell 2019

On paper, a Hell in a Cell match between 'The Fiend' and Seth Rollins didn't sound so bad. All the company had to do was let the evil clown be an evil clown. However, the Universal Championship quickly became an albatross for Bray Wyatt.

Advertisement

WWE wasn't quite ready to put the strap on Wyatt, but it also knew he couldn't afford the loss so early into his return. As expected, the company tried to play things down the middle, resulting in a total dumpster fire.

Not to mention the awful red lighting, the bout was sluggish and often included goofier spots like 'The Friend' retrieving a cartoonishly large mallet and Rollins dogpiling Wyatt with every weapon he could find ringside.

Wyatt was said to suffer a concussion early on, which changed the ending. Either way, the finish was always going to be an over-the-top series of shenanigans to keep the belt on Rollins while attempting to spare 'The Fiend' a definitive loss. Ironically, the fans didn't want 'The Architect' to be champ after the match, and Wyatt's reputation still took a hit.

9. Jobbing To Goldberg - Super ShowDown 2020

Despite missteps along the way, 'The Fiend' was booked as a dominant Universal Champion for nearly 120 days after capturing the strap (which later became an actual strap) at Crown Jewel. Although some fans gave up on Bray Wyatt after the aforementioned Hell in a Cell match, the championship reign gave those holding on some hope for the future. Booked as though impervious to damn near everything, Vince McMahon & Co were determined to make the character work, or so it seemed...

Advertisement

What 'Big Mac' loves more than Wyatt's new character, though, are his good ole legends. Because the WCW veteran didn't know when to call it quits, Goldberg showed back up just in time to set up a Universal Championship match with Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 36.

The only issue was neither man held the title.

Rather than protect 'The Fiend,' he was thrown to the wolves during his bout with Billie. At the very least, WWE could have made Wyatt look strong even in defeat, but instead, he was steamrolled by his 54-year-old foe.

For many, the loss to 'Oldberg' was the last straw. For all intents and purposes, it seemed as though the company threw away a character with so much potential just for one match at 'Mania.

The decision ultimately bit WWE right in the ass. Once the pandemic hit, Reigns was off of WrestleMania, leaving Goldberg to drop the belt to Braun Strowman, who then dropped it right back to 'The Fiend.'

8. The Swamp Fight - Extreme Rules 2020

While it has required trial and error, a tip of the hat must go out to WWE for getting inventive and exploring new concepts during crowd-less times, such as cinematic matches. The movie-like contests are a dream come true for the chairman, as Vince McMahon has always tried to dip his toes in waters outside of pro-wrestling's pond.

Advertisement

The Boneyard Match at WrestleMania 36 showcased what cinematic matches could have been, whereas the FireFly Funhouse was a combination of what good and bad could come from these overproduced pieces. Along the same lines, The Money in the Bank ladder match was absurdly entertaining, whereas the Swamp Fight at Extreme Rules 2020 left much more to be desired.

The likeness between Bray Wyatt's 'The Fiend' persona and classic horror movies had always been apparent, but that didn't mean creative needed to merge the two completely. The Swamp Fight was an opportunity to show off just how sinister 'He' could be. Unfortunately, it was squandered by far too much talking, random stunt men catching on fire, and minimal actual fighting despite its name.

The throwback to 'The Eater of Worlds' character was a fan-pleaser for sure, but just like Wyatt's old character, it was a lot of smoke and very little fire. To top it off, one of the best things about 'The Fiend' was 'His' originality. At Extreme Rules, what fans witnessed were reenactments of pivotal slasher flick moments, rather than a creative exploration into Wyatt's split personality.

7. Alexa Bliss Hot Potato - Raw 30 November 2020

Tracing back to his 'Eater of Worlds' persona, Bray Wyatt fans have awaited the addition of a female companion. During his cult leader days, his partner in crime would have been Sister Abigail. WWE tried to pull the trigger on this idea but decided the best way to do so was to have Wyatt cosplay as Abbie during his 2017 feud with Finn Balor. Of course, this was far from what anyone wanted.

Advertisement

Lately, Alexa Bliss has joined 'The Fiend' in a bizarre union that has yet to be fully explored. After Extreme Rules 2020, the two ghoulies had an affliction for each other. Such an entanglement suggested Wyatt had a vulnerability, one which Randy Orton tried to exploit before their match at TLC.

Orton later discovered fire to be much more efficient, but on the 30 November 2020 episode of Raw, he baited 'The Fiend' with Bliss. The segment not only showed a crack in Wyatt's armor, but it also made him look like an outright softie.

Unraveling his portrayal as a heartless killer clown, the skit saw 'The Fiend' beg for 'The Viper' to hand over Bliss unscathed. Orton complied, gently tossing Bliss into Wyatt's arms before quietly exiting the ring.

What threat Bliss posed to 'The Fiend's' invulnerability, we still don't know. Nevertheless, if WWE intends on keeping this pair together for a while, it would be best to treat them as a dark, violent duo rather than two emo kids falling apart without each other.

6. Daniel Bryan Gets A Hair Cut - SmackDown 29 November 2019

Fans went nuts whenever 'The Fiend' committed one of his peek-a-boo assaults, largely due to their unique gritty presentation. Repeating old ghoulish tropes and resorting to more hokey antics played against the more original creative efforts of Bray Wyatt.

Advertisement

Alas, Vince McMahon has a certain way of categorizing wrestlers that often leads them down dull and well-beaten paths. Oh, 'The Fiend' is like The Undertaker and Kane? Better have him come out of the ring!

In addition to revisiting the ring trapdoor schtick, WWE also placed Wyatt in a more awkward scenario than a terrifying one.

At the time, Daniel Bryan needed to transition from environmentalist heel back to yes-chanting babyface. From WWE's viewpoint, what Bryan associated his eco-friendly evil ways with the most was his shaggy hair. You know, hippies or something. Regardless, because his messy look was part of his identity, 'The Fiend' ambushed 'The Leader of the Yes Movement' during an in-ring promo and dragged him underneath the ring.

After a few moments, chunks of what was presumably Bryan's hair were tossed up from the conspicuously square hole in the ring.

The use of tired parlor tricks, such as the ring trap door, wouldn't have been quite as offensive if WWE gave them a little extra creative elbow grease. Not only did this stunt make Wyatt come off more as 'The Boogeyman' than 'The Fiend,' it was as though the billion-dollar enterprise couldn't spare a few extra dollars on increasing the production value.

5. Muscle Man Dance 2.0 - SmackDown 29 November 2019

What made the original FireFly FunHouse segments so appealing was that they weren't simply absurd. More often than not, there were layers of storytelling within Bray Wyatt's ramblings that strengthened the ongoing storyline. When Wyatt introduced wrestling fans to the original "Muscle Man Dance," they were oddly entertained by what sounded like madness but actually added some depth to his new persona. It wasn't just a tune WWE tried to get viral; it also explained what he had to do to come back better than before.

Advertisement

"Muscle Man Dance 2.0," on the other hand, did very little to entertain or inform.

Wyatt interrupted a Daniel Bryan promo with the song during the 29 November 2019 episode of SmackDown. When it first popped on the screen, it had the promise of following up its predecessor. By the time it was done, many fans had voiced their opinion about how the vignette was ridiculous for the sake of ridiculousness and contained little material relevant to 'The Fiend's ongoing feud. Lastly, it was nowhere near as catchy.

For 'The Fiend' to work, Wyatt and WWE need to be inventive constantly. Rehashing old ideas, especially for the worse, is a quick way to bore audiences of the mostly well-received FireFly FunHouse segments. It would have also made the battles with Bryan (as well as future feuds) that much better if WWE focused on Wyatt's more sinister acts than the comical ones.

4. The Firefly Funhouse Match - WrestleMania 36

If WWE ever had a chance to spare cult leader Bray Wyatt from being booked into oblivion, it was at WrestleMania 30. 'The Eater of Worlds' wasn't presented as the most formidable threat to John Cena, but he had an extremely vocal fanbase supporting him. To score a victory over him would have righted many wrongs.

Advertisement

Still, WWE just couldn't let 'Big Match John' count the lights.

As 'The Fiend,' Wyatt had a chance to seek vengeance in 'Mania 36. The build was executed well, focusing on how Cena's arrogance essentially gave birth to 'Him.' By the time the FireFly FunHouse match drew near, fans wanted to see the murder clown absolutely wreck the human G.I. Joe.

And he did, sort of.

Rather than see anything close to the match Wyatt had with Finn Balor, WWE produced a cinematic match that was less of a slobber knocker and more of an unusual viral video. What ensued was a series of random skits examing Cena's psyche while paying homage to professional wrestling's past.

The FireFly FunHouse match polarized fans. Some felt it was a step down from the Boneyard Match, while others enjoyed the absurdity. Either way, Wyatt's character would have looked like a juggernaut if he made short work of his old nemesis. Instead, 'The Fiend' headed down a path similar to the slasher films that influenced him, focusing more on dark (and cheesy) humor and less on what made him terrifying in the first place.

3. An Invulnerable Force - SummerSlam 2019

Bray Wyatt's 'Eater of Worlds' gimmick was buried so far down in the dirt that no one saw him as a credible threat anymore. Therefore, capitalizing on a lengthy hiatus was a terrific opportunity for WWE to reintroduce him with a little more gravitas.

Advertisement

When puppets started popping up on weekly shows, though, fans weren't so sure they were ready for the former cult leader's return. Gradually, the vignettes (later the FireFly FunHouse) became darker and more entrancing. The build to the debut of 'The Fiend' ended up being masterful by WWE standards.

Many would argue 'The Fiend's' first match against Finn Balor at SummerSlam 2019 was well-executed, giving fans enough to salivate and nothing more. So what was so wrong with the murder clown's debut?

At the time, nothing. It seemed perfect. However, in hindsight, there was one major flaw with the presentation of 'The Fiend:' His invulnerability.

It might have looked cool when Wyatt no-sold every one of Balor's attempts at offense, but this precise moment led to some rather nasty ones down the line.

Since 'The Fiend' was omnipotent, WWE struggled to develop creative ways to keep the mad clown down, leading to ridiculous sights such as him kicking out of a thousand finishers and weapon strikes, being lit on fire, and being (sort of) electrocuted by pyrotechnics. At this rate, it might not be long before one of those WrestleMania military jets shoots him dead with a freakin' rocket.

2. Second Universal Title Reign - SummerSlam Through Payback

In spite of a few creative faux pas, Bray Wyatt was off to a dominant reign as Universal Champion until a part-time Goldberg returned to treat him like a tackling dummy at Super ShowDown 2020. But once he picked up the strap for the second time at SummerSlam, it appeared WWE intended on resuming 'The Fiend's' mega push.

Advertisement

Once again, Wyatt was tossed aside for a returning performer though. Coming back from his spring hiatus, Reigns showed up to make short work of Braun Strowman and 'The Fiend' moments after the Universal title switched hands. For a brief second, there was hope that Wyatt would be more than a transitional champion, and just as quickly, it was gone.

While fans may have rejoiced in the fact Reigns finally turned heel with his new 'Head of the Table' gimmick, it still left the question over what was next for Wyatt.

The answer turned out to be a meaningless championship run after Reigns recaptured the belt within a week. If WWE had any foresight into the 'Tribal Chief's' return, it would have made more sense for him to take the title off of Braun Strowman, who ate the loss at Payback anyway. Instead, the fleeting second reign only served to ding the credibility of 'The Fiend' further, especially since he was quickly distracted from pursuing the strap by Randy Orton.

1. Roll That Clown Up & Smoke It - TLC 2020

Things got a little hairy for 'The Fiend' by the end of 2020. Once an unstoppable force, WWE had haphazardly booked Bray Wyatt into a corner, where he would either be destroyed or have a chance to take a breather in hopes of coming back stronger. (Sounds familiar, no?)

Advertisement

A glaring issue with 'The Fiend's' presentation was his invincibility, as it pigeonholed creative more often than not. Every time Wyatt needed to be knocked down, WWE had to take a greater leap.

To write 'The Fiend' off TV for a while, WWE decided the best idea was to burn the creepy-ass clown to a crisp at the end of the FireFly Inferno match.

There had always been a fire theme between Wyatt and Randy Orton, but it was a bit of a stretch for 'The Viper' to light his adversary on fire. He was already going to get burned from the match, anyway, so why not pummel him afterward?

Instead, WWE will have to explain how 'The Fiend' didn't actually die once he returns. Sure, there's a supernatural aspect to the clown character. Still, to buy into pro-wrestling, you have to suspend your disbelief, and it's rather difficult to ignore the fact you saw a character die before your eyes. Then again, we all accept the fact Mr McMahon is still kickin', so...

Here's hoping fire actually does cleanse for Wyatt's sake.

Advertisement