10 WWE Nightmares Vince McMahon MUST Regret Booking

Even Vince McMahon must wish these dreadful WWE moments never happened!

By Jamie Kennedy /

Rest easy.

Advertisement

The 'Montreal Screwjob' isn't here. Why? Well, it's something Vince McMahon did because he thought he'd be protecting his company (including everyone in it) and stop Eric Bischoff from parading Bret Hart around on Nitro with the WWF Title. So, whilst it's likely McMahon wishes things could've been done differently, saying he regrets that 1997 incident completely would be pushing it.

Not to worry, 'cause there are other nightmares McMahon definitely would like a second stab at. He's borderline wrecked one of the most beloved gimmick matches in history, enabled his son's ego to inflate like a balloon by booking him like some wrestling machine, forced unhappy wrestlers to keep playing characters they don't want to in bizarre 'take it or leave it' power plays, and much more.

That's before one even digs into Vince's own wrestling career, and the questionable decisions made on his TV direction, or what happened to his most iconic creation. Let's just say The Undertaker's legacy wasn't rewarded for Mark Calaway's inability to "say no" to McMahon.

These nightmares must sit atop Vince's own list of WWE misgivings.

10. Referee Stoppage Inside HIAC

Every wrestling fan gets PTSD whenever they attend concerts and bands flash red lighting all over the place. No, they don't think Kane is coming to chokeslam them - they cast minds back to Hell In A Cell 2019 when Vince McMahon smashed any remaining credibility his annual pay-per-view series had left.

Advertisement

People watched in horror as the referee stopped a Cell match between Seth Rollins and The 'Fiend'. His reason? Bray Wyatt was buried beneath some furniture, and Seth was belting him with a sledgehammer. Inside Hell In A Cell, which is...supposed to be some ultra-violent place to settle the score.

What was McMahon thinking here? Did he believe fans would stomach this stoppage when they'd witnessed greater atrocities inside and outside of HIAC? It was a quite terrible decision, and one that probably lived rent free in the boss man's head for a while.

It's taken a while to restore HIAC to some semblance of respectability.

9. Jinder Mahal As WWE Champ

Jaws hit the deck when Jinder Mahal pinned Randy Orton at Backlash 2017 to become the new WWE Champion. That was a booking call not even Puerto Rico's rowdy live crowds could've saved. Unfortunately for those in Chicago, this happened in Illinois rather than elsewhere.

Advertisement

Mahal as champ was surely a bid to crack into the Indian market and further WWE's global reach. Fair enough, but at least build Jinder up for a while first. He was elevated from career midcarder (and a bit-part one at that) to World Title status too suddenly, and nobody was prepared for it.

His reign was abysmally booked too. Mahal feuded with Shinsuke Nakamura after Orton, and WWE reached into lazy xenophobia to explain it. Then, Jinder dropped the belt to AJ Styles because Brock Lesnar didn't want to work with him at Survivor Series in November.

It was a mess. McMahon wasted much of 2017 on an unconvincing title reign nobody asked for.

8. Shane McMahon Is “Best In The World”

Shane McMahon infamously p*ssed everyone off backstage by trying to book the 2022 Royal Rumble match around himself. It was a preposterous thought, and wasn't going to fly. Later, Vince fired his own son for chucking his weight around, but he only had himself to blame.

Advertisement

The 'Boy Wonder' received a baffling sustained push on TV between 2018-2019. That seemed to make Shane believe he was the next coming of Kurt Angle, and capable of working with all comers in hot, must-see matches. The truth, of course, was somewhat different.

Shane won an unfortunately-titled "Best In The World" trophy, and worked awful feuds vs. everyone from Kevin Owens to Braun Strowman. For his grand comeback, WWE stuck him in an impromptu 'Mania 39 match with The Miz, but he got injured and replaced by Snoop Dogg.

You'd think you couldn't write this stuff. Vince did, and appeared to fill his boy's head full of nonsense.

7. Batista’s Comeback Royal Rumble Win

WWE would like everyone to believe that you run the show. Don't like a certain wrestler? Then they can kiss their chances goodbye. Fancy seeing someone main event? It'll happen if you cheer loudly, people! Or, you'll be forced to troll the company until they actually listen to booming live crowds.

Advertisement

Case in point: Daniel Bryan.

He was everyone's darling back in 2014 (he still is), but Vinnie Mac fancied bringing Batista back and having him win the Royal Rumble instead. Cool, but his audience made it clear immediately they didn't want to see it. Regardless, McMahon ploughed ahead with his plans anyway, and a miffed-looking big Dave wondered what the f*ck was going on when everyone booed him.

Batista still got a main event payday for WrestleMania XXX, but the response to his Rumble win was brutal, and booking him to win the 30-man match was a clear mistake. This was pigheaded WWE ignorance at its absolute worst.

6. ‘King’ Mabel

Admit it, you knew this would pop up.

Advertisement

Yours truly once heard someone passionately defending Mabel's monster push by pointing out that Vince was only trying to create new stars during an era that didn't have many. It put a unique spin on the 1995 disaster, but wasn't enough to sway. No, no having Mabel win the '95 King Of The Ring was crap and that's that.

Attempting to fashion fresh stars is one thing, but quality matters. Mabel might've been physically huge and impressive-looking, but he was far too clumsy and uncoordinated to handle regular main events. That's why his KOTR win and subsequent SummerSlam push is roundly regarded one of the worst of all time.

McMahon must've regretted it almost immediately. 'King' Mabel put on some epically bad performances, then almost injured WWF Champ and top babyface Diesel come title shot time. The whole episode was a vicious reminder that talent needs to meet marketing might halfway.

5. Himself As WWF Champion

Everyone tut tuts the living sh*t out of Vince Russo for putting the WCW World Title on himself in 2000, but Vince McMahon beat him to the punch approx one year earlier. Sure, McMahon was a much better on-screen character than Russo, but did he really need a measly four-day run (six off TV) with the top strap in September 1999?

Advertisement

No, not really.

Vince won the thing from Triple H on the 16 September SmackDown, but vacated it in a lame promo on the 20 September Raw. The WWF then proceeded to use this as an excuse to put the belt on someone new and push them hard. Oh no, wait. No they didn't. They stuck it back on Triple H at Unforgiven.

Why did McMahon even bother then?! His brief title reign was 100% pointless, didn't aid Trips' quest to become a household name, and only lasted one little week anyway. This was either an ego trip, or a decision even Vince realised was stupid as soon as it happened.

4. His Own On-Screen Demise

"A decision even Vince realised was stupid as soon as it happened".

Advertisement

The same could be said for WWE's exploding limo angle on the 11 June 2007 episode of Raw. Obviously, McMahon couldn't foresee the Chris Benoit tragedy that'd follow and render the stunt even more objectionable, but it was just a stupid move to think his character needed to go out like some Eastenders (UK-based soap opera for international readers!) villain.

Pro wrestling doesn't really do finality in storyline with any credibility, so everybody knew Vince was going to appear on screens again someday anyway. Explaining away his limousine bursting into flames would've been a challenge, but you just know WWE would've tried.

McMahon had very little in the pipeline even if the storyline had been seen all the way through. It was one of those 'we'll figure it out later, pal' booking decisions that happened on a whim/because he'd told Bruce Prichard he couldn't "be on TV if [he] was dead".

3. The So-Called “Summer Of CM Punk”

There was a time when nobody could move without someone in a white CM Punk tee talking about the "Summer Of Punk", and reminiscing with a smile about CM's win over John Cena at Money In The Bank 2011. Unfortunately, time hasn't been kind to that whole period. WWE bloody ruined it by refusing to stand still.

Advertisement

McMahon crowned an interim WWE Champ right after MITB, and cited Punk's departure with the original belt as his reason why. Rey Mysterio won that, dropped it to John Cena, then Punk beat Cena at SummerSlam only for Alberto Del Rio to cash in his briefcase. From there, Kevin Nash got involved for...reasons.

It was horrible, horrible booking that dumped all over the promise of a rebellious Punk holding Vince/WWE to ransom until meaningful change was affected. If he had a do-over, McMahon would likely hold off on Del Rio's MITB cash-in so Punk had more time to breathe, and he'd keep Nash on the bench.

That was seriously poor casting.

2. You’ll Play Stardust And Like It!

Speaking of poor casting, it's Rhody Codes!

Advertisement

Keeping Cody locked under the face paints as Stardust was a rotten idea. It left one hell of a talent disillusioned, and Rhodes eventually left WWE in 2016. From there, he had a merry old time on the independent circuit before going on to help form AEW.

It's not out of the question to suggest that a happy Cody, sans Stardust and pushed properly, would've stayed put. In short, All Elite Wrestling as everyone knows it might never have even created had Vince just agreed to let him shed the Goldust-lite gimmick. That's a powerful thought.

In a way, McMahon aided the creation of his own competition by driving one of his own wrestlers to the brink. In retrospect, he'd surely view that as a botch. Yes, Cody is a much better performer now than he was in 2016, but his potential was obvious to anyone not named Vincent Kennedy McMahon.

1. The End Of The Undertaker

Bonkers ‘Boneyard’ cinematic match vs. AJ Styles and a stirring tag match at Extreme Rules 2019 aside, The Undertaker’s final years as an active worker were dire. Bouts vs. Goldberg, D-Generation X, Triple H (one last time), Roman Reigns and more struggled to meet the mark or live up to his legacy.

Advertisement

Later, ‘Taker’s documentary series revealed that he kinda wanted to step away, but “couldn’t say no to Vince”. McMahon might regret sullying one of his greatest creation’s legacy with some stinkers before finally letting him retire and stopping himself from pushing the 'Deadman' panic button.

The Goldberg match alone was a clanger.

Seeing 'Taker watch back footage of that, and of his 'Mania 33 misery vs. Roman, was sad. His body couldn't do what he needed it to do anymore, but Vince just couldn't let go. There's something upsetting about that thought too for older fans.

Boo.

What other booking decisions do you think Vince McMahon must regret? For more like this, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After Night Of Champions 2023 and 10 New Directions For AEW After Double Or Nothing 2023!

Advertisement