10 WWE Pay-Per-View Matches That Surpassed Expectations

John Cena actually carried The Great Khali to a fantastic match at One Night Stand 2007...

By Jamie Kennedy /

In a perfect world, every single match would be great. Unfortunately, that can't be the case and there are always going to be bouts that don't live up to pre-match expectations.

Advertisement

Using a classic example, John Cena and The Rock were unable to improve on their match from WrestleMania XXVIII when they locked horns for the second time at 'Mania 29.

The first match was, arguably, better than expected, but it felt like something was lacking during their rematch. Cena and The Rock weren't able to surpass the hype, defying expectations to produce a match worthy of the main event slot. 

They're far from an isolated case, but what about those clashes that actually do exceed themselves?

For a match to surpass expectation, it doesn't need to have been considered a surefire disaster. In fact, it doesn't even need to be a match people felt would be bad going in. Those listed here were all enjoyable matches, but it's true that they achieved a level far beyond what many expected going into them. 

As a result, most of them are revered as memorable, but let's look at what helped make them stand up and be counted...

10. Charlotte Vs. Sasha Banks Vs. Becky Lynch (WrestleMania 32)

Hopes were high that the women of WWE would produce a match to be proud of at WrestleMania 32, but nobody expected them to steal the spotlight.

Advertisement

Charlotte, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks worked wonderfully well together, crafting a piece of work that must be considered one of the greatest female matches in company history.

Everything came off without a hitch, the match was one of the smoothest on the card. Watching back over the bout reveals that it's just as fun second time around, which is a huge compliment.

There was a lot of pressure on these women to deliver, such had been the hype surrounding the 'female revolution' in WWE beforehand.

They didn't only put together a solid showing, the trio smashed expectations and have thus set the bar extremely high for themselves going forward.

It's unfair to say there may never be another match as good for the WWE Women's Championship, but it certainly remains to be seen whether anyone can top this.

9. Ric Flair Vs. Chris Jericho (SummerSlam 2002)

In his second autobiography (Undisputed), Chris Jericho revealed quite shockingly that 'Nature Boy' Ric Flair was far from confident going into their match at SummerSlam 2002.

Advertisement

Flair had returned to the company the previous November and he wasn't delighted with his Royal Rumble bout against Vince McMahon. He viewed the match with Jericho as a chance to prove himself.

For Jericho, this was preposterous. What did the legendary Ric Flair have to prove to anyone? One of wrestling's greatest entertainers was suffering a crisis of confidence, and he badly needed a match he could point to as a landmark moment. Together, Jericho and his elder peer pulled a diamond from the rough.

The match had the unfortunate task of following a sterling Kurt Angle vs. Rey Mysterio opener, but Flair's goal was achieved. There was a moment -when the legend grabbed Jericho by the head to line him up for a suplex - that the swaggering confidence he once exuded naturally seemed to flood back into him.

Afterwards, Flair thanked Jericho. He realised what everyone else already knew; the match had trumped expectation going in.

8. Stephanie McMahon Vs. Trish Stratus (No Way Out 2001)

In 2001, Trish Stratus was still considered a fitness model who had been hired by the then-WWF to provide eye candy for those watching.

Advertisement

She certainly wasn't considered someone who could work a watchable match, meaning there were fears that her bout against Stephanie McMahon at No Way Out could have been a colossal flop.

Both had the benefit of a strong storyline the company were willing to back and put effort into. Stratus was Vince McMahon's mistress, something his daughter Stephanie wanted to correct. Defending her mother, she brawled wildly with Trish in third match on the pay-per-view. The clash was a success right from the off.

That wasn't guaranteed, especially considering the pair were in the slot directly after a hot Fatal Four Way between Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, X-Pac and Chris Jericho. Keeping things under the 10-minute mark was a smart decision, as it allowed Trish and Steph to storm through the task at hand without any need to stall.

What perhaps should have been a throwaway match turned into a real hidden gem and provided a glimpse of the great in-ring performer that Trish would become years later.

7. John Cena Vs. The Great Khali (One Night Stand 2007)

John Cena is someone who will perhaps never get the credit he deserves as an in-ring performer. Chants of 'You Can't Wrestle' have followed the man over the past decade, this despite the fact he has had great matches with the likes of CM Punk, Brock Lesnar, Seth Rollins and Randy Orton to name but four.

Advertisement

Those men all have something in common in that they're all great performers in their own right. The same could never be said for the awkward, ambling Great Khali, a man wrestlers had to work wonders with in order to get even a passable match.

Cena was tasked with getting something decent out of the Punjabi giant at One Night Stand 2007, and he passed with flying colours.

The pay-per-view had, over the past few years, been known as an ECW-branded event. Therefore, the headliners were up against it from the start. Avoiding that potential banana skin admirably, they had a fine 'Falls Count Anywhere' scrap that has to be considered one of Khali's best ever WWE matches (not that there are too many contenders to choose from).

Nobody expected Cena vs. Khali to be good, but the realisation started to kick in around half way through that it was wholly entertaining.

6. Bret Hart Vs. Hakushi (In Your House I)

The very first match on the then-WWF's new pay-per-view concept, In Your House turned out to be one of the best the event series would ever see.

Advertisement

On the surface, it'd be easy to attribute that to Bret Hart, but to do so would be incredibly unfair. Hakushi more than played his part in the success of the bout.

The WWF of 1995 didn't see a lot of innovation, and that fact only made Hakushi vs. Hart all the more striking. Later, Bret was scheduled to face Jerry Lawler in his second match of the night, but that didn't stop him from working his tail off against the underrated Japanese performer.

Even Vince McMahon on commentary seemed impressed, wowing along with the audience as Hakushi deftly executed high-risk dives and Hart underpinned the match with some solid ground work.

If anything, officials likely expected this opening match to thrill fans due to a Bret Hart win. They surely didn't expect to get the match of the night from both men, but that's exactly what ended up transpiring.

5. The Hardy Boyz Vs. Edge & Christian (No Mercy 1999)

During the closing months of 1999, there was something akin to a revolution happening in the WWF's tag-team ranks. Young duos like The Hardy Boyz and Edge & Christian were coming into their own, and the addition of The Dudley Boyz from ECW seemed promising.

Advertisement

Little did anyone know what this would lead to down the line.

Those TLC epics between that trio of teams will never be forgotten, but the foundations were laid by The Hardyz and their Canadian counterparts at No Mercy in October 1999.

A tag team Ladder Match was on offer, sitting snugly in the middle of the card. It was the first of its kind, but that didn't necessarily guarantee any sort of success.

During an earlier entry, innovation was mentioned, and there was a whole load of it in this one. Following this match, ladders were looked upon in entirely different fashion by wrestling fans, and credit must go to the quartet featured at No Mercy for that.

The next evening on Raw, fans were so taken with what had happened on the pay-per-view that they treated the foursome to a standing ovation. There was no looking back as far as their respective careers were concerned.

4. Chris Jericho Vs. Ricky Steamboat (Backlash 2009)

At WrestleMania XXV, brash heel Chris Jericho faced a 3-On-1 Handicap situation against 'Rowdy' Roddy Piper, Jimmy 'Superfly' Snuka and Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat.

Advertisement

Both Piper and Snuka looked aged and slow, but Steamboat rolled the clock back to deliver an inspiring performance worthy of the 'Mania stage.

That evening, the audience informed the legend that he still had what it took to perform. It must have been a proud moment for Steamboat, but there was an even better one to come.

At the following pay-per-view, Backlash, Steamboat faced Jericho in a singles encounter. The results were quite marvellous.

People may have been expecting a short match during which the veteran was allowed to shine. What nobody imagined was that Steamboat would look like he hadn't lost a step for 12 minutes, hauling himself back over the ropes and skinning the cat, whilst also performing dives to the outside of the ring.

It was incredible to see someone in their 50's look so agile and raring to go. Later, Jericho himself admitted his surprise that Steamboat was so fluid and capable of working such a great match despite his age.

3. Hulk Hogan Vs. The Rock (WrestleMania X8)

It's surprising to think that Hulk Hogan still talks about making a return to the ring today, especially considering his body was a wreck by 2002. Knee and back pain aplenty plagued Hogan, but he was determined to put on a show for his return to the promotion with which he made his name.

Advertisement

Hulk's comeback as part of the nWo in February parlayed into a match at WrestleMania X8 against The Rock. Many of Hogan's later matches in WCW hadn't exactly been thrillers, so few could foresee a spectacle, even with the youthful Rock to help shore things up.

During the bout, Hulk and The Rock raced through many of their trademark spots, but that was all the people really desired. There was an overwhelming affection for Hogan in 2002, everyone was clearly happy to see him back in the WWF.

There was no slow pace here, and Hulk came out looking like a million bucks as he ran through his familiar routine.

WWF management must have been equally as impressed, they handed Hogan a WWF Heavyweight Title reign just a month later.

2. Mankind Vs. Shawn Michaels (In Your House 10: Mind Games)

1996 was a tough, pressure-filled year for Shawn Michaels. Finally realising his boyhood dream at WrestleMania XII, he became WWF Heavyweight Champion, but that's when the real challenge started. Struggling to deal with the weight of expectation, Michaels stuttered through a Summer feud with Vader.

Advertisement

By October, cracks had appeared in his title reign. Michaels needed that one big match to prove he deserved to be 'the man', and Mick Foley was the perfect foil to help deliver that.

As the deranged Mankind, Foley was one of the most genuinely compelling characters WWF fans had witnessed in years, and he was the top challenger for HBK's belt at In Your House 10: Mind Games.

The match turned out to be a blistering affair, even though Michaels looked lacking in confidence beforehand and Mankind wasn't a proven commodity at the top of WWF cards quite yet.

For years, this was Foley's favourite match, and it's really not too difficult to see why.

What was originally a diversionary match for Michaels on his road to the Survivor Series turned into a bonafide classic.

1. Triple H Vs. Shawn Michaels (SummerSlam 2002)

If 1996 was a challenge for Shawn Michaels, 2002 marked a rebirth of sorts. Defying doctors to return to the ring following a serious back injury four years earlier, Michaels was slated for an 'Unsanctioned Street Fight' against Triple H at SummerSlam.

Advertisement

It would be the start of a second run that arguably topped his first in the 90's.

The 'Showstopper' looked like he hadn't missed a beat as the match was enthralling everyone and in progress, but that couldn't have been predicted with any real accuracy going in.

There were genuine fears that Michaels could break down physically in the midst of the bout, which would have spelled disaster.

Thankfully, that didn't happen. Surpassing any and all expectation, Triple H and Michaels had one of the best matches SummerSlam had ever seen. Many expected the match to be enjoyable, but few could have predicted it would steal the show and kick start another 8 year run for HBK.

What other matches can you think of that surpassed expectations? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

Advertisement