10 WWE PPVs That Could Replace Payback

Could there be an air of 'Genesis' about WWE's first post-WrestleMania pay-per-view?

By Jamie Kennedy /

A fair portion of the pro wrestling fan base likes to imagine that they know everything that's going to happen in WWE. Scan any social media platform or virtually every internet forum, and the same old complaints crop up. WWE, they argue, is far too predictable. Whilst this could be argued to an extent, few can claim with any accuracy that they foretold Shane McMahon's re-arrival on WWE television come Monday Night Raw. For WrestleMania, a Hell In A Cell bout has been set up pitting Shane against the might of The Undertaker. Some have their reservations about such a match, but it's more interesting than a prospective battle between 'Taker and Braun Strowman which was rumoured late last year for the big event. The stipulation states that should Shane win, he will take storyline control of Raw. Rumours are currently circulating online that WWE are set to do away with the Payback pay-per-view name. Originally, the show was scheduled for May 22, but it has since been moved to May 1. This makes it the first PPV after 'Mania, and if rumours are true that the event is set for a name change, just what could it be? This article looks at ideas which might be the most fitting. The archives of WWE and even WCW are analysed to see what names would be best, and a few new concepts are offered along the way.

10. Uncensored

From 1995 until 2000, World Championship Wrestling presented Uncensored. Each year, the pay-per-view became synonymous with being one of the worst shows of that 12 month period. The idea was simple, Uncensored would produce the wildest matches in WCW, but it usually ended up being a car crash of ideas and overkill. Even so, the name was an awesome one. If WWE wish to present a changing of the guard post-WrestleMania, they could do a lot worse than digging into the WCW archives to drag this event title out of retirement. Some long time fans would get a kick out of it, and the McMahon-led company would probably produce a better pay-per-view than WCW ever did with the name. There is one slight problem, the pay-per-view after the May 1 show is scheduled to Extreme Rules. There's a chance that Uncensored would clash with that, but WWE wouldn't necessarily need to make the show all about hardcore matches and weapons. Instead, it could be a new beginning, like the promotion has been let off the proverbial leash by Shane McMahon.

9. No Mercy

There was always something cool about the No Mercy name. It was so nifty in fact that the then-WWF decided to use it twice in 1999 alone. The first time was for a UK exclusive pay-per-view, and the second was when management decided they liked it enough to make it an annual show. No Mercy stuck around until 2008, when the last event was headlined by Chris Jericho vs. Shawn Michaels. Just like that epic Ladder Match, No Mercy deserves to be seen again. It could become a tag line of sorts for The Authority in response to Shane McMahon's reappearance. Vince, Stephanie and Triple H would be so keen to get rid of Shane's influence that they would claim they are willing to show no mercy whatsoever on him at the upcoming pay-per-view. This could pave the way for Triple H vs. Shane, or perhaps it would just represent a catchy title. It's a lot more striking than Fastlane, or even Extreme Rules. There's something dangerous about No Mercy, and it'd be great to see it back in the WWE cannon as a proper standalone event. It's been almost 8 years, and that would help the event feel fresh again.

8. Elimination Chamber

Admittedly, the Elimination Chamber idea has been done to death by WWE over the past decade or so. Even before the pay-per-view was named after the infamous match, No Way Out became home to the Chamber bouts. It was discarded following the 2014 event, replaced by Fastlane from 2015 onwards. It seems like the February slot is no longer an option. That doesn't mean the company should completely shelve Elimination Chamber as a concept outright, it could slot nicely into the early-May position. After all, it's difficult to build feuds for the Chamber matches, because they house multiple participants. Post-WrestleMania is traditionally a difficult time for WWE in terms of sparking interest, this could be just the ticket. The Elimination Chamber is a match premise that pro wrestling fans immediately identify with. A lack of blood has taken away from the danger of the bout, but it still remains a draw. In 2015, WWE presented Elimination Chamber as a WWE Network exclusive, and whilst it was seen as a throwaway show, it was much more effective than a limp Payback was the same year.

7. Rebellion

When Shane McMahon showed up on Monday Night Raw, the overwhelming feeling of the segment was that he was rebelling against Vince. Therefore, WWE could decide to pick an old name out of their own history to fit the May 1 pay-per-view. Naturally, it depends whether or not they're going to go the whole way with having Shane wrestle some control from his father and sister. A lot of casual fans in the United States may never have heard of Rebellion. To those of a certain age in the United Kingdom, it will be instantly recognisable. The title was used for a UK-only pay-per-view series between 1999-2002. For the last event, it was a Smackdown exclusive, falling just after the initial 'Brand Extension'. That's interesting, because the idea of a brand split has been discussed as something which make make a comeback since Shane's return. Due to the fact that the McMahon son has effectively went against his family, Rebellion would be a fitting title. The crux of the show could be to portray the idea that Shane is trying to usher in a new era for WWE, whereas The Authority are trying to crush it. Better yet, the name works in a literal sense, because Shane is rebelling against authority.

6. Backlash

In similar fashion, Backlash works nicely. Unlike Rebellion, most fans of the WWF/WWE are aware of the pay-per-view name. The very first Backlash event took place under the 'In Your House' series in 1999, before doing away with that subtitle and becoming a standalone show the following year. There's a nice ring to the name, it rolls off the tongue extremely well. It also has a threatening vibe to it that only adds intrigue, and is the perfect moniker for an event immediately following what happened at WrestleMania. In many ways, Backlash became a place where feuds from 'Mania could be rekindled and then put to bed, reacting to what had happened on the grand stage. It was ripe for rematches, and whereas it's unlikely WWE will promote a Shane vs. 'Taker retread, the essence of the rivalry could still be there. Shane's problems appear to be mainly with The Authority, so they may want to push for a Backlash after WrestleMania 32. May 1 would be their first pay-per-view opportunity. Admittedly, it's similar in tone to Payback, but there's more history behind Backlash.

5. King Of The Ring

There's an argument to be made that WWE have killed interest in the King Of The Ring due to years of cobbled-together tournaments and poor follow up. Some younger fans may be surprised to learn that there was a time when the event was one of the premier shows on the pay-per-view calendar, largely shaping the rest of the year and providing a lot of entertainment along the way. Fast forward to 'King' Barrett's 2015 disaster, and it's clear that it'd take some work to rekindle the spark King Of The Ring once had. However, it's not impossible, and a pay-per-view tournament to crown a new top contender to the WWE World Heavyweight Title may just work. WWE would have to tread carefully, but it's far from impossible. There's still love for the concept, it's just that fans realise WWE view it as a secondary concept nowadays. In order for it to work, that would need to change. The performer who won the next King Of The Ring would simply have to be meaningful, instead of throwing a cornball outfit as someone and claiming them as royalty.

4. Judgment Day

From 1998-2009, Judgment Day existed in WWE parlance. The event was missing from the 1999 pay-per-view lineup, because the '98 version was part of the 'In Your House' series. It flows right back to the hottest period of the 'Attitude' Era, and became a beloved event in 2000 when The Undertaker made his return as a biker character. Fans know what Judgment Day is all about, and it'd be an entirely fitting title for the ongoing storylines. It works both ways too, which makes it an even better choice. If Shane McMahon were to defeat The Undertaker at WrestleMania, he could claim that the May 1 show would be time for Vince, Stephanie and Triple H to be judged as The Authority. Similarly, if 'Taker wins, Vince could claim that Shane's 'Judgment Day' will be upon him, with his future being decided at the show. Much like many others on this list, there's a nice ring to Judgment Day. It sounds bad-ass, dripping in that foreboding undertone that many events of the late-1990's and early-2000's had. It could also signal a change in WWE, which many feel is long overdue, whilst still fitting into the angle between Shane and the rest of the McMahon clan.

3. War Games

Similarly to the Elimination Chamber concept, this one would perhaps be hampered badly by a lack of blood. That said, claret wasn't the only hook to the War Games matches, it's simply an utterly fantastic premise overall. Ever since the McMahon family swallowed up WCW in 2001, there have been fans waiting with baited breath to see one in WWE. Thus far, it hasn't happened, so now could be the ideal time. Again, post-WrestleMania usually sees things take a terrible lull in WWE. War Games would freshen things up and offer a carrot for older fans to see dangled in front of their faces. It may prove to be too enticing for many, and the promotion of War Games on pay-per-view could convince some to sign up to the WWE Network. It also fits the paradigms of a McMahon vs. McMahon rivalry. Both could have their teams, perhaps even Monday Night Raw's top stars against those of Thursday Night Smackdown. This would launch the new 'Brand Extension' perfectly without the need for another WWE Draft. Instead, top stars would be encouraged to pick a side, and the feuds resulting from this could carry WWE far beyond May 1.

2. Armageddon

Traditionally, the tag line for Armageddon was 'The End Is Here'. That could be perfect for Shane McMahon's ongoing feud with Vince, Stephanie and Triple H. Back in 1999, it was actually 'The Game' who fought Vince over Stephanie's loyalty. The return of the event title would hark back to those days, only that trio are now united against a common threat. '99 featured the first Armageddon event in WWE history, with the last taking place in 2008. The show was skipped in 2001, replaced temporarily by Vengeance, which just so happened to be the night on which Chris Jericho became the first ever Undisputed Champion. That was a first, the next iteration of Armageddon could be promoted around the idea of a last. Imagine Armageddon had Vince McMahon's future up in the air. Vince has (apparently) previously spoken a few years ago about wanting to step away from any role on screen, and this could be the perfect opportunity to finally write him out of things for good. That would necessitate some real thought, but it's an interesting concept at least.

1. Genesis

If Vince McMahon did depart his on screen role, going forward Shane McMahon would be the owner of Monday Night Raw. On the other side, Stephanie would probably once again be put in charge of Smackdown. Another 'Brand Extension' could be discussed on screen, splitting the roster in half across both shows. Therefore, WWE may wish to have a fresh pay-per-view title for May 1. One idea would be Genesis. The actual definition of the word states that it refers to the 'origin or mode of formation of something'. That lends itself well to the brand divide, because it would be somewhat of the dawning of a new era in WWE. It would also instantly spark some intrigue, because what would such a pay-per-view entail? In the past, WWE haven't managed to convince the paying audience that Raw vs. Smackdown is a viable pay-per-view idea. Their last big push in that direction - Bragging Rights - was not a great success at the box office. This time however, people may be more receptive to the idea of change, because it would help switch up what is considered a desperately stale product at times.