10 WWE PPVs That Were Doomed From The Start
Crown Jewel may be THE WORST, but it's not the first...
In 1991, Ric Flair and WCW gaffer Jim Herd had a bust-up that finally sent 'The Nature Boy' styling and profiling off to Vince McMahon with the company's Heavyweight Title in tow.
Beyond losing their biggest star to the opposition, the fallout completely butchered the company's Great American Bash pay-per-view. Traditionally one of the biggest shows of the year, the July showpiece was hijacked by a livid crowd. 'We Want Flair' rang out throughout the evening from an informed audience aware that their product had lost its single biggest attraction.
The former Pizza Hut boss never had his finger on the collective pulse in Atlanta, and completely misread how badly things would go with Flair chased out of town. A replacement main event with a replacement title between Lex Luger and Barry Windham was mercilessly booed out of the building. The hatred had transcended pro wrestling - a corporation was under fire for it's supposed insolence.
Ironically, 'Slick Ric' had remained loyal to the NWA and later WCW in the 1980s when WWE came calling with the hope of giving audiences the all-star dream match of the time. Hogan/Flair was a blockbuster of epic proportions once upon a time, but when McMahon actually got his hands on the match...
10. WrestleMania VIII
...he didn't really fancy it.
Much changed in late-1991 and early-1992 that drastically altered the layout of WrestleMania VIII and the trajectory of the company going forward, but even without the scandal engulfing Hulk Hogan and WWE at the time, a dream match between 'The Hulkster' and Ric Flair was already off the table.
The organisation - as was normal practice - sent the match on the house show loop shortly after Flair's debut in order for the two to feel each other out as opponents and test box office response to the combination. The response didn't dazzle Vince McMahon, unlike Sid Justice's vascular frame and grisly intensity.
With the untelevised events earning less-than-perfect reports, McMahon cooled on the concept as a WrestleMania headliner and began programming Hogan against his latest turncoat rival. In that time, the aforementioned troubles saw Hulk needing a quick exit from the spotlight. WWE were forced to promote this first-time meeting as his potential last match ever, undercutting the other half of a double main event featuring Flair's Championship match with Randy Savage.
Both matches were riddled with bullet holes as a result, with the papered Hoosier Dome in Indianapolis the last time the company would look quite so vast in the United States for nearly five years.
9. Breakdown: In Your House
WWE was hot sh*t in August of 1998, but was rapidly reduced to just the latter after some clunky schedule changes for Monday Night Raw and a couple of injuries to key players rendered September a little less than Stone Cold.
A slew of card changes were required for the cobbled-together Breakdown: In Your House, and though a triple threat steel cage match between The Rock, Mankind and Ken Shamrock went down a storm, a main event pitting Steve Austin against an uneasily aligned Undertaker and Kane rather tragically drew a line under 'The Rattlesnake's white hot programme with a babyface 'Deadman'.
Outside of the aforementioned cage clash, fans hadn't been fed enough before the headliner stuttered and stumbled to a finish-free finale. Without injured leader Triple H, DX were a little rudderless in their battle against Jeff Jarrett and Southern Justice, whilst Vince Russo's scripting of the Val Venis/Goldust and Owen Hart/Edge programmes left fans completely confused as to who they should even be cheering.
The last thing the event needed was evil Mr McMahon darting off with the belt after both Undertaker and Kane registered the fall on the Champion. Had Austin not torn Monday Night Raw up in a Zamboni the next night, the company may have found themselves back on thin ice.
8. SummerSlam 1995
SummerSlam 1995's line-up was at one point so internally dispiriting that the organisation effectively had to acknowledge it on air.
It was as though Vince McMahon had already lost faith in his Diesel/Mabel main event (!) before the card took place. Underneath the behemoths doing battle over his top title, McMahon had Shawn Michaels scheduled against yet another monster. Pyscho Sid had decimated 'HBK' the night after WrestleMania, but his comeback resulted in the babyface turn that would eventually lead him to 'Show Of Shows' glory the following year.
In the meantime, he was permitted a final reign with the Intercontinental Title to keep himself busy, but found himself rewriting his own character's history in a scintillating ladder sequel with Razor Ramon. Behind the front of 'fan friendly' Interim President Gorilla Monsoon, the company rebooked the midcard clash to ensure the show had at least something going for it.
In the end, much of the event held up outside of the Kliq epic. Bret Hart did as Bret Hart does getting more than seemingly possible out of Issac Yankem D.D.S, whilst contests 1-2-3 Kid/Hakushi and Barry Horowitz/Skip matches delivered on the promise all four competitors had on their best days.
7. ECW December To Dismember
The Extreme Elimination Chamber rightfully comes in for an awful lot of flack on this website, but spare a moan for the rest of this complete piece of sh*t show too.
Vince McMahon had made a bed Paul Heyman resolutely refused to lie in, with a card bookended by pre-planned matches and stuffed with all the filler the C-Brand could muster on their one and only night on pay-per-view. Barely watchable rather than Barely Legal, if the 'Architect Of Extreme' was on an unimaginable high after his actual maiden supercard, he was sunk lower than the butt-swallowed face on Matt Striker's tights after this.
Heyman had looked out of sorts with (and on) the show for weeks as micro-manager McMahon wrestled more and more control away, but a blow-up row following a Vince re-write was - for several years at least - his tipping point.
Escaping WWE to avoid the creative bankruptcy much in the same way as he'd arrived there in 2001 to avoid ECW's financial one, Paul E's tenure ended as controversially as it began. The final joke of all was probably on him too - fans scarpered during the listless main event and it's likely he got stuck in the rest of the heavy traffic trying to leave early.
6. D-Generation-X: In Your House
It took for Stone Cold Steve Austin to win the Royal Rumble then get into a transcendent shoving match with his former number one fan the next night for WWE to finally help fans forget the events of Montreal whilst still leaving behind Vince McMahon as the company's (and industry's) new super-villain.
D-Generation-X: In Your House was the company's first failed attempt to steer into the support they'd put behind Shawn Michaels and Triple H, but in actuality mirrored WCW's own stable-based effort nWo: Souled Out at the start of the year.
The prevailing theme of absolute b*stards dominating the company left something of a cloud hanging over the entire event, and none of the matches did much to reverse the perception that things were actually pretty f*cked. Shawn Michaels had an underwhelming main event against Ken Shamrock that frankly could well have been by design - he reportedly ribbed the former UFC star into yelling his spots nice and loud, so obviously wasn't too concerned with internal report cards.
Elsewhere, Triple H underwhelmed in a spotlighted role for the umpteenth time against Sgt Slaughter, whilst the smoke and (smashed) mirrors in the Stone Cold Steve Austin/Rock match struggled to obscure how little of the two burgeoning megastars the company were willing to present.
5. Survivor Series 2013
Daniel Bryan was never their guy.
When Vince McMahon relented and let him gobble up the WrestleMania XXX spotlight, he did so under duress and never had the 'YES! Man' in mind for leading the company once the bluster around his win had finally died down. His win represented the end of a frustrating war with his own audience, and if the 'Show Of Shows' was the apex, Survivor Series 2013 was the pay-per-view nadir.
After months of screwy finishes in the Bryan/Randy Orton series, the company went from putting the knife in the crowd's back to jamming it in the front. Bryan was unconvincingly shuffled into a story with The Wyatt Family alongside CM Punk, whilst The Big Show was even more unconvincingly wedged in as a Bryan surrogate against 'The Apex Predator'.
The resultant series was absolutely turgid, and helped bulldoze the largely forgotten Survivor Series main event as it limped home as the worst 'Big Four' topliner of the year. The Daniel Bryan-based disdain cast a shadow on the rest of the card. After a spirited opening battle featuring a still-red hot Shield, the card completely collapsed. Other lows before the main event included an instantly forgotten John Cena/Alberto Del Rio match, another underwhelming Ryback and Mark Henry match p*ss weak wastes of the likes of Big E, AJ Lee and the aforementioned Bryan/Punk/Wyatts quartet.
4. WrestleMania 32
Vince McMahon's 2018 Happy Birthday tweet to daughter Stephanie featured the pair of them sporting huge smiles by the huge AT&T Stadium pitch on the day WrestleMania 32 was officially booked for the 100,000 seater stadium.
It was perhaps the proudest they'd ever felt. McMahon was finally going to do away with the legitimacy row behind WrestleMania III's attendance and break his own record by drawing a six figure house for one of the biggest ever editions of the 'Show Of Shows'.
Soon enough though, his ego was his drowning pool as bodies hit the floor all over the shop. John Cena, Seth Rollins, Daniel Bryan, Randy Orton, Cesaro, Neville, Bray Wyatt and others were all natural card-fillers that were suddenly on the injured reserve list as the company scrambled to produce card that could satisfy their biggest ever seating allocation.
The element of surprise in announcing Shane McMahon as Undertaker's opponent remarkably helped spike sales (even if the match itself was the immediate living, breathing (heavily) example of 'diminished return') but the inevitable Roman Reigns/Triple H main event was doing little to drum up further interest.
Spun figures got them over the line - 101,763 was the announced attendance McMahon had to admit included every single wrestler, security guard, usher and arena staffer in the venue as the show took place.
3. WrestleMania XI
1995 was the year Vince McMahon pretended not to panic.
He'd found himself free of all charges brought against him by the Government in 1994, but with that emancipation came the end of excuses for his product going a little bit mad.
The business end of his business went into steady decline in 1992 as public pressure began to mount, but had completely nosedived by the time he left the courts a free man in July. The very next pay-per-view was headlined by The Undertaker Vs The Undertaker - a contest in which one of the only stars in the company was theoretically promoted to feature two icons for a match that couldn't even deliver the aura of one.
This ethos clearly troubled him around the impending 'Show Of Shows'. Harvesting his time and money out to celebrities, the involvement of Lawrence Taylor in the main event resulted in the entire event being dedicated to 'famous' faces instead of McMahon's faces and heels.
Crawling out of every corner like expensive infestations, the names added little to a card that was already struggling to support itself. Bret Hart ended up having his worst ever pay-per-view clash, a Shawn Michaels/Diesel show-stealer didn't get top billing, and an increasingly disinterest Pamela Anderson undermined the entire roster with her uncomfortable undersell of the show.
2. Clash Of Champions 2017
After a strong start to life as a proper brand again in 2016, SmackDown went off the rails a bit in 2016 thanks largely to a horribly misguided Jinder Mahal WWE Championship run and the persistent need to ensure Shane McMahon had a big programme over the summer.
AJ Styles Vs Kevin Owens was sacrificed for the good of Shane McMahon Vs Kevin Owens, which itself was sacrificed for the good of Shane McMahon Vs Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn, which was finally put to the sword to build up...something involving Shane McMahon and a then-still-retired Daniel Bryan.
This whole mess culminated in one of the worst WWE matches of the year. Randy Orton and Shinsuke Nakamura were sucked into the grim vortex, losing a tag team match against the Zayn/Owens combo when warring refs McMahon and Bryan couldn't pool their supposedly high IQs to garner result they ostensibly both wanted.
And what of AJ Styles, the man at the start of that chump chain?
'The Phenomenal One's phenomenal recent run came to a crushing halt. After dethroning Mahal in the best match of the 'Modern Day Maharaja's reign in order to facilitate one of the company's best contests of the year with Brock Lesnar, Styles couldn't make magic twice with not-so-big Jinder on pay-per-view.
Nobody could. But at least - unlike Mahal himself - 2017 was finally over.
1. Crown Jewel
Not since Triple H pretended to copulate with a corpse has a WWE story felt so much like a hellish reflective milestone.
Much has already been reported on only the second show of a ten-year deal between WWE and the Saudi Arabian Sports Authority, but little of it doesn't bear repeating.
In April, inaugural event Greatest Royal Rumble was held up as a catastrophe for not allowing women to compete. In just six months, the discussion has moved on from misogyny to murder.
As of writing, there's been no update from WWE about if the show will be moved to an agreed location less riddled with human rights infractions and an undercurrent more toxic than the sewer slime in Ghostbusters 2, but they'll almost certainly want it to stay as is if they can get away with it.
The millions (and millions) of dollars at stake being comprised at the second hurdle would almost certainly result in future shows going in the bin too. The daft atmosphere around Shawn Michaels moneyed comeback has quickly been quelled by the story - WWE have mortgaged their biggest retirement return on a show they'll never want to talk about again - but the show going ahead will leave a bigger stain on the company than anything found in Kane's car after his Katie Vick crash.