The evolution of man is charted by representations of each species; Australopithecus, Homo Habilis, Homo Erectus, Homo Neanderthalensis, Homo Sapiens. There were crossovers and periods between each stage, but with perspective and hindsight we can mark distinct eras. The evolution of WWE can be charted in a similar fashion; Bruno Sammartino, Bob Backlund, Hulk Hogan, Stone Cold Steve Austin, John Cena. Single superstars who were chosen to represent the values of the WWWF, the WWF and then the WWE. The face of the company, the poster boy, the Top Guy. Going all the way back to the territory days, there were two ways to run a wrestling company. Either you run a babyface territory, or a heel-based territory. The WWE method or the NWA method. As always, if you want an articulate description of a pro-wrestling practice, ask Paul Heyman. He was recently interviewed on Steve Austin's podcast, where he described the idea that the WWE has always built their company around one guy. One face is the embodiment of the company and everything else is an offshoot. Each story is based on the idea of the babyface revenge. Our hero was wronged and we want to pay to see him right that wrong. The NWA and, by extension, WCW, was a heel-based company. The faces fight from underneath. We pay money to see Ric Flair finally lose his title or to see the nWo finally overthrown. Heyman cements his genius in a way only he can manage with this summation: WWE is about the destination, NWA/WCW is about the journey. Put simply, the WWE business model relies on one wrestler embodying the spirit of their entire company. The Number One Guy; our hero. Oftentimes, in looking for that guy, the WWE pin their hopes on the wrong shoulders. Here's a few examples of the times when Vince McMahon chose the wrong Top Guy...
10. Lex Luger
When Hulk Hogan left the WWF in 1993, the company didn't really know what to do. Hogan was all they had ever really known. Going way back to the days when Vince McMahon abandoned the old territory system and got WWF programming syndicated nationally, McMahon was only able to do that when he signed Hulk Hogan. Individual territories and independent promotions had booked a Top Guy for decades, but this was different. A company's lead babyface not only needed to get cheered by the whole town, but by the whole country, and Hulk Hogan was the first to do it. So, in 1993 when Hogan left the company, they saw Lex Luger as his natural replacement. They turned him face, gave him an "All-American" gimmick (sound familiar?) and pushed them as far as they could. But it just didn't quite take with the fans. It never really felt right. Perhaps his gimmick was to similar to Hogan's at a time when the wrestling world was pining for something different. Or perhaps Luger simply wasn't good enough. Either way, when the Royal Rumble came around, both Luger and Bret Hart were declared "co-winners", both getting a shot at Yokozuna's title at Wrestlemania 10. The WWF had given themselves an option of two big stars to be the one to take the title from the monster Yokozuna, and lead the company from then on. They chose Bret Hart. Lex Luger's WWF career was pretty much done by this point. The company let his contract run out so he was free to go wherever he liked. Eric Bischoff, who was hiring for WCW at the time, was not a fan. But Sting was. Bischoff, trying to please Sting, offered Luger 20% of what he was making at WWF thinking that Luger would decline the offer. Luger accepted. This meant that Luger spent the end of his career at WCW not really wanted by management, so he was used mainly as a nostalgia act and as a body in the nWo angle. So, in the end, he did emulate Hulk Hogan. Just not the way he hoped.
9. Shawn Michaels
Like most legends, Shawn Michaels' career can be clouded by nostalgia. He was one of the WWE's biggest stars, and retired in 2010 as a bona fide legend, respected by fans and peers alike. In 1996 though, it was a slightly different story. WCW Nitro was spending huge money trying to take control of the industry, and were spending that money on luring top-name talent from WWF. Scott Hall and Kevin Nash had defected, joining Hulk Hogan, Randy Savage and numerous others, leaving the WWF with a real lack of top talent. Watch any "historical" documentary produced by WWE and you'll learn that this was the reason that WWF flourished. They were forced to develop their own talent and, hey presto, Stone Cold, The Rock, Triple H and Mankind were born. But there's a period of time that these documentaries always gloss over. After the now famous 60-minute Iron Man match at Wrestlemania 12, Bret Hart took time away from the business. This left the company with Shawn Michaels in the Top Guy spot. HBK was an incredible talent, of course, but a mixture of bad timing and a bad attitude stopped him from thriving as the face of the company. He was pushed and over-protected relentlessly, and then faked an injury just to avoid dropping the title in a Wrestlemania 13 rematch to Bret Hart. Instead of leading his company into a new era, he let his company down. Of course, when he vacated the title before Wrestlemania 13, that meant that Bret Hart had to move down the card and have a match with a rising star called Stone Cold Steve Austin. It was that match that helped create the star that Vince McMahon could build his company around. And who did Stone Cold beat for his first world championship, causing Jim Ross to famously yell "the Austin era has begun!" at Wrestlemania 14?
8. The Undertaker
Despite his unrivalled charisma, his loyalty to Vince McMahon and his undisputed position as an all time Legend, Undertaker was never really able to cement himself as the "top guy" during any of his runs with the WWE. When he debuted in 1990 he was used mostly as a typical monster heel. In fact he was used as a heel for most of his early career. Even in his most prominent role in the Corporate Ministry, his role was beneath Vince McMahon (he was beneath McMahon, Austin! He was beneath McMahon all along, Austin!). When he took time off and returned as the American Bad Ass character, he was a full-on babyface. This was his first real opportunity to be the true face of the company, but unfortunately the Attitude Era was in full swing. The company was led by Stone Cold or, to a slightly lesser extent, The Rock. There's no disputing he had a major role in the company during these years, and was still a big star, but he wasn't "the guy". Then, Cena came along. An interesting point of note that helps illustrate how the Undertaker never quite made it as the Top Guy is raised by a quick look at how many times he's main evented Wrestlemania. Even with the streak in full swing, the Undertaker match has only closed out the biggest show of the year three times. First at Wrestlemania 13 against Sid, in the year when Shawn Michaels refused to drop his title to Bret Hart. His next main event was 11 years later against Edge at Wrestlemania 24, and his last was at Wrestlemania 26 in Shawn Michaels' retirement match. Of course, three Wrestlemania main events is a great achievement, and The Streak is an achievement that will never be matched, but it goes to show what a particular kind of characteristics are required to be the top guy in WWE.
7. Diesel
Kevin Nash's 358-day title run has become the go-to example of bad title runs. Appearing near the top of all the "worst champion" lists, Nash's reign from November 1994 to November 1995 is held responsible for WWF surrendering their ratings to WCW, not getting them back again until the Attitude Era was in full swing. Whether you pin all of WWF's failures at that time on Kevin Nash or not, it certainly seems to have cemented Vince McMahon's belief that a top babyface is needed to drive a wrestling company forward. Hogan had left, Lex Luger had failed, so back in 1994 Vince had begun to question his ideal of booking a face-led company and turned to a heel. Nash, playing his Diesel character at the time, was booked as the monster champion that nobody could stop. He was chosen to be the guy who represented what the company was about. Going back to Paul Heyman's description, McMahon was banking on us wanting to see a babyface fight from underneath to overcome Diesel, but it backfired. When Bret Hart finally took the championship from Kevin Nash instead of feeling rewarded that Hart had finally pulled it off, we felt relieved that Nash was no longer champion. You can trace this failure directly to why the current WWE relies so heavily on John Cena. McMahon's foray into a heel-led company failed miserably, and he hasn't really tried it since. Sure, there were brief moments when the heel has been on top, particularly between "eras" where there was a distinct Top Guy, but never to the extent of being a heel-based company.
6. Anyone Not In The nWo In WCW
Not strictly speaking a WWE entry, but lets include it. WWE own it all now anyway, right? And this is an argument for why WWE were in a position to own it now, instead of the other way around. Being a heel-led company is one thing, but the point is still to have the babyface win in the end. That's what wrestling is. It's good vs evil, where good triumphs over evil after all. When WCW booked the nWo angle, they started writing the perfect "face overcomes from underneath" story. They had an all-powerful heel super-group, taking control of the company. Act One had the new group storm in, looking completely cool, doing things nobody had seen before. Act Two saw them take full control, making it seem impossible that any hero could overcome their supreme power. Then, in Act Threenothing really happened. That was sort of it. WCW had the opportunity to make several wrestlers their Top Guy by beating the nWo. The best example being Goldberg. His undefeated streak was the hottest thing in wrestling in 1998. He was perfectly placed to be the guy to take back the company from the nWo and lead WCW forward. And for a while, he was. The "Goldberg on the rise" story is an undoubted highlight of WCW's run, and when he finally pinned Hollywood Hogan for the WCW World Heavyweight Championship on Nitro in Atlanta on July 6th, 1998 a change was felt throughout the company. They finally had their Number One Guy. Then, after 174 days as champion, he lost the title to Kevin Nash and the nWo were on top again. Just like that. As if it never happened. Goldberg's momentum was as broken as his streak, and his character was so built around not losing that he never really recovered. It made the entire push feel rather pointless, and the nWo became the embodiment of WCW, again. After Goldberg, the title was hot-shotted to a number of WCW stars including DDP and Sting, none of which becoming the leading face of WCW and none of which getting the credit for dismantling the nWo. Eventually, after some nonsense about a Wolfpac, an Elite and some sort of B-team, the nWo just sort ofended, leaving the company without a leader.
5. Randy Orton
When Randy Orton rose to prominence as part of the Evolution stable, the WWE made no secret of the fact that he was being groomed for world championships. An amazing run as "the Legend Killer" in 2003 to 2004 enabled him to get wins against high-profile legends such as Shawn Michaels and Mick Foley which helped establish him as a guy who could one day lead the company. By this point, Stone Cold and The Rock had left, and still burned from their failed attempts at forcing the matter when Hogan left, this time WWE tried to let it play out naturally. Or as naturally as wrestling can get. John Cena was fast becoming their top star, but Orton was getting reactions too. At SummerSlam 2004, Randy was given the honour of being the youngest ever World Heavyweight Champion at only 24, at the same pay-per-view that John Cena was defended his United States Championship, a clear sign that Orton was being positioned ahead of Cena in their "next big star" ranks. After his title win, Orton was turned face to feud with Triple H and Evolution so he could make that final push towards becoming a Top Guy, but it didn't really take with the fans. He was over as a face at this point, but never quite to the extent that the WWE expected. Now, Orton is a legitimate top-tier talent in WWE, trusted to be the guy to unify the WWE and World Heavyweight Championships late in 2013. Interestingly though, he was only ever able to cement his position as a lasting major player in the company after being used as foil for the man who truly forced himself into the role of Top Guy: John Cena.
4. Booker T
Despite being a five time (five time, five time, five time, five time) WCW Champion, he was never really the main attraction during his time there. A mixture of WCW's intent on keeping the nWo strong and Booker having to compete with the likes of Sting and Goldberg meant that he was never really the true focus of WCW. In fact, he only won his fifth WCW title from Scott Steiner on the last episode of Nitro because WWF wanted the title on someone they had under contract during the Invasion angle. As far as his WWE career goes, Booker T had the opportunity to take his career to the next level at Wrestlemania 19. Booked in a World Heavyweight Championship feud against Triple H, all of the build-up seemed to point to the fact that Booker would beat Triple H at only his second Wrestlemania. Triple H made a few comments in the run-up to the match that seemed to refer to Booker's race, something that would never had happened if the original plan was for Triple H to win. Unfortunately for Booker, the plans were changed and Triple H did win the match. Booker never quite recovered momentum. Either in WCW or WWE, Booker T was never quite placed in the position to lead the company, despite seemingly having all of the abilities required to do so. At both companies, perhaps it was just the wrong place at the wrong time for Booker T.
3. Ultimate Warrior
Firstly, Warrior's star power cannot be disputed. The mainstream attention in the aftermath of his untimely death this year was telling: it was heartwarming to see just how many people Warrior had inspired during his life. He was, and still is, a genuine legend of the wrestling business. Back in 1990, at Wrestlemania 6, Ultimate Warrior defeated Hulk Hogan for the WWF Heavyweight Championship. This was Vince McMahon's first attempt to create a new Top Guy for the 1990s. Hulk Hogan had been around for a while, and McMahon thought he had found a new man to build his company around. Warrior defeated Hogan with both the WWF and Intercontinental Championships on line, in what may as well have been called a "This Is Our New Hero From Now On By The Way Guys" match. Everything about how the match was built and booked was setting up Warrior as the new leader of the WWF. All of this however, went to Warrior's head. Backstage politics and Warrior's ego kept him from thriving as the company's Top Guy and he ended up leaving the company in the summer of 1991. Though he returned (briefly) shortly after, his momentum had broken. Vince had returned to Hulk Hogan as his leading star and Warrior was never able to ascend to the heights he reached at Wrestlemania 6. This experience is another reason why the modern-day WWE rely so heavily on John Cena. Vince has been burnt before by people like Warrior putting themselves before the company.
2. Triple H
On May 21st, 2001 on an episode of Raw, Triple H tore his left quadriceps muscle clean off the bone. Despite somehow managing to finish the match, the injury ruled Triple H out for 8 months, causing him to completely miss the Invasion angle. He returned in January 2002 to one of the loudest pops in wrestling history. Just listen to this reaction:You can barely hear his music when he comes out. With The Rock taking more and more time out to film movies, and Stone Cold growing increasingly frustrated with his angles with the re-formed nWo, everything was in place for Triple H to make a push for the Number One guy spot. An on-screen divorce from Stephanie McMahon helped get that out of the way (she was a heel, there was no way around it) and Triple H won the Undisputed Championship from Chris Jericho at Wrestlemania 19, making him perfectly positioned to lead the company from then on. But on July 22nd, 2002 Triple H turned heel again. Shawn Michaels had returned to in-ring action and a feud with Triple H seemed too good to refuse. And there was only one heel in that situation. Besides, you just get the sense that Triple H just loves working as a heel too much. He's just so natural at it. But the turn took away the opportunity for him to become the Top Guy in the company at that point, and before long John Cena had cemented that role for himself.
1. CM Punk
After CM Punk cut his "pipe bomb" promo in June 2011, he made wrestling cool again. When he won the WWE Championship against John Cena at the Money In The Bank pay-per-view in Chicago, he made it cool to be a wrestling fan again. People were wearing CM Punk t-shirts out to pubs, people were posting CM Punk clips on their Facebook pages; the people had a new champion. A few title switches later and CM Punk began his run as the longest reigning WWE Champion of the modern era. He was a huge draw, was main eventing pay-per-views and was the first wrestler to have his merch out-sell John Cena in years. But he just couldn't make that final push to usurp John Cena as the Top Guy. His title matches were often earlier on the card than John Cena's matches (most notably at Wrestlemania 28) and the company just didn't want to plant it's future on CM Punk's shoulders. One of the reasons why is similar to the reason that Triple H was never the Top Guy: CM Punk is just too good as a heel. Mid-way through his lengthy WWE title reign he turned heel and aligned with Paul Heyman, creating one of the most memorable heel runs in a long time. Another reason, perhaps, is backstage politics. We don't know why Punk left the WWE this January, but we do know that he obviously wasn't happy. He often complained backstage, and whether he was right to complain in these situations or not, that's not the sort of behaviour you want from the face of your company. John Cena is the current Top Guy because he has an un-matched connection with the WWE fans, and because he is an excellent ambassador for the WWE. He lives and breathes the company and, for better or worse, the same cannot be said for CM Punk. It just goes to show what a unique set of attributes are required to lead a wrestling company. A set of attributes that few in this business have ever had.