10 WWE Superstars That Turned Heel/Face The Most

The Good, The Bad & The Big Show

By Michael Hamflett /

This will not be a list full of statistics and data shouldering the burden of cast-iron proof. Heel and babyface turns are frustratingly subjective as it is in 2018 without going back and trying to identify every single character shift week to week.

Advertisement

Stephanie McMahon is one of the most loathsome characters (yes...characters) in WWE history, yet turns herself from one segment to the next depending on the task at hand. Within one edition of Raw, she's been known to castrate main eventers, take credit for all of women's wrestling and promote a company's marketing/philanthropic (don't delete as appropriate, she didn't) exploits.

She's not the only one.

Kayfabe's death also put a bullet in lots of the things performers used to do to protect their characters. The four men that chewed up the main event scenery - and much of the run-time - at Super Show-Down were so precious about their gimmicks 20 years ago that they didn't even join the rest of the roster underneath the TitanTron when tribute was paid to Brian Pillman after his October 1997 passing. These days the whole crew are summoned to the stage for the opening of a f*cking envelope if said receptacle contains a massive cheque from a car company that somehow relates to kids with cancer.

Just two months removed from the 'Loose Cannon's death, Vince McMahon infamously decreed that wrestling wasn't about "good guys" and "bad guys". He was right, but it'd sometimes have been nicer if he wasn't...

10. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler's last 12 months have been amongst the most eventful in his uneven WWE career, but the heel he plays alongside Drew McIntyre and Braun Strowman isn't remotely the complete buffoon he portrayed this time last year.

Advertisement

Rallying against SmackDown Live newcomer Bobby Roode's bombastic entrance, 'The Show Off' was reduced to running around the ring in an Ultimate Warrior mask as he cosplayed as performers with far greater legacies as his own. It was to make a point about something or other, but that point was about as clear as the one he also failed to make when he abandoned the United States Championship at took Christmas off.

His babyface return wasn't remotely as 'Glorious' as his pithy tribute to Roode. As #30 entrant in the Royal Rumble, he came and went in 2:01, and was back in the Andre The Giant battle royal mix by WrestleMania. Going to Raw and going bad was his latest grasp at salvation. At least as a heel is a gloating douchebag. As a babyface, he's a moaning one.

It's little wonder he's flipped and flopped so much. Even at his peak as a heel in 2013, his World Title victory only resulted in a babyface turn when he was concussed enough to have the belt ripped from his grasp. The sympathy disappeared quicker than his spot at the top of the card.

9. Kane

Kane's early WWE career was littered with turns as much because of the emotional abuse he suffered at the hands of father Paul Bearer, brother The Undertaker and wing-man X-Pac as it was his own tortured soul.

Advertisement

He was forced to shoulder the blame for being a piece of sh*t in later years though - every time Kane seemed keen to harness his inner goodness there was a heel turn just around the corner.

'The Big Red Machine' teamed with RVD, then turned on him when he was forced to unmask. He forced Lita to incubate his "demon seed", then turned babyface defender of the deceased when Gene Snitsky triggered a miscarriage. More needless switches followed - including more unwanted storylines with and against The Undertaker in the process.

In 2018, a Team Hell No reunion was greeted with nostalgic warmth from the audience - they'd somehow managed to forget the time he spent terrorising partner Daniel Bryan and his wife Brie during the 'YES! Man's only WWE World Championship programme. Forgetting is half the battle though - he status was so malleable by 2015 that the company had to literally label him 'Demon' or 'Corporate' depending on his motivations that particular week.

8. The Big Show

Close your eyes and think of a wrestler that has a turned a lot during your time as a fan. Who do you see?

Advertisement

Wellllll....?

Paul Wight's career has been one of the oddest in industry history. A giant with physical and verbal gains beyond anything Andre was ever capable of, The Big Show hasn't ever quite lived up to his storyline-Dad's billing. He hopped back and forth over the New World Order fences in Atlanta as Vince McMahon moaned to anybody in earshot that he'd score a touchdown with the mammoth star.

He's been fumbling since 1999.

Big Show was both a face and heel within his first month in the company, and had turned five times by the time he was celebrating his one year anniversary at February 2000's No Way Out. The pattern never changed. Injuries and subsequent comebacks were almost always augmented with a character shift, with Show often veering from killer to clown depending on the storyline requirement that week.

7. Natalya

Natalya's reached the point in her career where she tragically has to turn without ever actually turning.

Advertisement

She was a heel for all of 2017 after being revealed as Nikki Bella's attacker earlier the prior year. After she'd turned babyface months earlier to furnish that turn. These switches might have resonated had it not been for the fact that during 2013-2016 she was forced into flipping if storylines and matches required her steady hand.

As of her 2018 switch to Monday Night Raw, Natalya is smiling again as Ronda Rousey's best mate, but her mood has swung that much over the past few years that folks have almost immediately assumed a turn will eventually come between the pair when she fancies a run at the former UFC star's Raw Women's Title.

Not unlike her uncle, Natalya's been cursed by her talent in comparison to her contemporaries. Overlooked and under-appreciated at times, she's suffered for her art by virtue of the repeated side-switches. She's only fortunate that the problem is so common in the modern era that her instability doesn't particularly stick out from the rest.

6. Mark Henry

'The Worlds Strongest Man' pulled off perhaps the best swerve-turn in company history when he drew tears from the audience and himself in a worked retirement speech in 2013.

Advertisement

Sporting a now-legendary salmon jacket, Henry was so unflinchingly convincing in the role of a man facing a career crossroads that everybody bit before he bit back on a sympathetic John Cena with a World's Strongest Slam. It was Henry's best ever turn in a career full of them.

After debuting as a babyface, he brutalised Ken Shamrock to reveal his allegiance to The Nation Of Domination in early 1998, but the company's scripting of him as a sexual deviant subversively turned 'Sexual Chocolate' face as the company looked to comedy in order get some return from their ten-year investment.

By the time the contract expired in 2006, he'd miraculously achieved a modicum of success as a killer heel and spent the next several years flip-flopping en route to a remarkable World Title win in 2011. Despite the constant character changes, his work surprisingly endured - the reign was deserved by the time he flattened perennial headliner Randy Orton.

5. Triple H

'The Game' is currently a babyface as part of his D-Generation-X feud with The Brothers Of Destruction.

Advertisement

Possibly.

It hasn't really been made clear either way, but 'The Game' changes at such a laughable rate these days that it's as worthless trying to keep up with his continuity as it is to expect him to do the honours to somebody that could actually benefit from his selflessness. He's been teetering ever close to the insecure bully boy of old with his recent absurd carvings through the main roster.

Hunter cosplayed as a member of The Shield in late-2017 when Roman Reigns got the mumps, but was back working heel as a member of Team Raw at the subsequent Survivor Series. He set up potential WrestleMania programmes with Braun Strowman, Kurt Angle and Shane McMahon, looked comfy against former NXT projects Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode, and went over as one of the only survivors.

Integral to the success of Ronda Rousey's amazing debut, Hunter was where he belonged as a sh*t-talking corporate heel before it was binned for the aforementioned Brothers Of Destruction silliness. He hasn't turned with such frequency since the periods in 2000 and 2001 where he twice teased the biggest babyface run of his career before sticking daggers in the hearts of fans that were never truly removed.

Unlike many of his colleagues, at least audiences were stabbed in the front.

4. CM Punk

'The Voice Of The Voiceless' tried in vain to add a bit of pro wrestling villainy to his 'Pipe Bomb' promo in 2011, but the die was already cast for him as soon as he began ticking terms off the banned list in screen-melting fashion.

Advertisement

Punk's attempts to get over and stay there in WWE were as noble as they were bleakly depressing. His try-hard babyface stint had ran its course long before he finally turned on Jeff Hardy in 2009, but the peak of his heel powers weren't really exploited until a listless de-push resulted in him embodying a near-the-knuckle zealot character guiding the careers of followers in his 'Straight Edge Society'.

The babyface turn proper came after a quasi-turn as leader of The Nexus in a last-ditch effort to make that stable mean something. Despite WWE's 'Summer Of Punk' collapsing within itself, 'The Straight Edge Superstar's rigid efforts to make it work ensured he remained over as both a hero and villain as he embarked upon a legendary 434-day reign with the Championship.

He turned once more before his controversial 2014 exit but many fans considered him the biggest babyface of all for actually walking away - few performers had his deft touch for character work in such an ever-changing universe, or the pride to leave it all behind.

3. The Bella Twins

The Bellas' return to the dark side at Ronda Rousey's expense is the sharpest acknowledgment of the wider audience's attitude towards the twins, and sits in contrast to how they've both been booked over the last several years as stalwarts of a refreshed women's division.

Advertisement

Nikki and Brie have been babyfaces for the last two years, turning face mostly by disappearing rather than through any actual storyline act. As a heel Divas Champion for most of 2015, Nikki started life at the top as her sister's oppressor before getting her onside without any reasonable explanation. This was in keeping with how their careers had panned out since their SmackDown debuts in 2008.

Over the years, the pair took the arms of guest hosts one week and stabbed the backs of the colleagues the next. In defence of their booking, they were rarely featured characters - few women actually were - so the rapid fire heel/face turns were as much to do with rank corporate disinterest in what they had to offer beyond bikini pictures for WWE.com.

Total Divas muddied the waters further, with their actions on the scripted reality vehicle often managing to both endear and alienate viewers also engaging in their main roster adventures.

2. Chris Jericho

'Y2J' has transformed himself yet again in recent years, with hugely successful part-time runs as both a heel and face in WWE between 2016-2017 running into a surprising stint as a psychopathic New Japan Pro Wrestling villain in 2018.

Advertisement

It speaks to his immense flexibility and durability as both over the past twenty years.

After scouting him as a magnificent cruiserweight motormouth, WWE brought Jericho in as a villain but switched him less than six months later as fan support rose for his comedy catchphrases and scintillating in-ring skill. A gripping feud with The Rock turned him back in 2001, and he spent the remainder of his run before a 2005 exit flip-flopping as the storyline required.

Undoing the mundanity of his 2007 babyface comeback, a 2008 heel turn at Shawn Michaels' expense served as a tonal and total reinvention that he again toyed with in shorter returns throughout the 2010s.

Jericho's skill comes not just in reinvention but believable reintegration. He's found a way - as both heel and babyface - to suddenly just belong all over again on a roster full of performers he routinely doesn't interact with. It's this skill which is perhaps his most underrated - and valuable - in 2018.

1. Kurt Angle

Fewer could lay claim to the all-around brilliance of 'The Olympic Hero' during his original WWE tenure, with his ultra-competitive desire to be the best and natural skill in front of a camera combining to make him as much a Sports Entertainment phenomenon as he was 'Wrestling Machine'.

Advertisement

Kurt Angle was birthed as Vince McMahon's brilliant spin on the dated American hero during a time the fanbase couldn't have hated something more, but his incredible work between the ropes eventually turned him babyface when WWE were forced to fend off the invading factions of WCW and ECW in 2001.

A swerve turn during that storyline kickstarted the silly season for Angle. He turned repeatedly between then and 2006, including a period during December 2002 in which he was effectively both until a convoluted ruse with heel manager Paul Heyman was revealed after he lifted the WWE Championship from The Big Show. Angle had the skills to pay it all off, but a bit more consistency during those tumultuous years may have delayed his troubling personal and professional fall from grace.

Advertisement