10 WWE Tag Title Challengers After Extreme Rules

Can a current NXT duo be the next best team?

By Mitch Nickelson /

This Sunday in Chicago the WWE Tag Team Championships will be defended live on the WWE Network. During the pre-show of Extreme Rules, Big E and Kofi Kingston will represent The New Day as they challenge Tyson Kidd and Cesaro for their titles.

Advertisement

Regardless of who wins between these two teams there is a very thin pool of challengers that can be considered 'next in line.' The United States and Intercontinental Titles have received added value recently but the Tag Titles still seem to barely get much thought. It really is a shame that the belts don't mean more.

When really trying to analyze who could be the next best team to challenge the champions one has to get a little creative. The Usos are really the franchise of that division but Jey is out on injury. Who's left to step up?

There are a few teams on the roster that can be used, but not many. A few singles wrestlers were paired for the sake of creating possible challengers. NXT has also been dipped into to find the next pair of challengers.

Sorry, but Enzo & Cass were not considered for this since they are currently challenging for Blake & Murphy's NXT Tag Championships. They are one of the best acts on that show but they have those belts in their sights right now.

The following 10 teams are some of the best options to challenge the winner of this Sunday's pre-show bout...


10. The Ascension

The Ascension moved up from NXT a few short months ago in what seemed like a soon to be decent push in the tag team division. After cutting several promos on retired (and even deceased!) legendary wrestlers that were not received well, WWE balked on them.

Advertisement

Sadly, Konnor and Viktor are mostly on this list just because they exist. They are warm bodies that might serve as a transitional heel team for the babyface duo of Tyson Kidd and Cesaro to feud with until a more formidable team came along.

Given this opportunity, maybe a few subtle changes to The Ascension could be offered in hopes of getting a more valued crowd reaction. Even if booked solely for the sake of losing, WWE might luck out and accidentally find a way to make this team work.

9. Los Matadores

Sorry Primo and Epico but Los Matadores are one of the lesser desired tag challengers on this list. But could it still happen in a moderately sensical manner? Sure.

Advertisement

It was just a mere month ago that this team was being presented as legitimate contenders in the build up to WrestleMania. They shouldn't have fallen that far since. Fans mostly knew better and didn't buy into the idea that they were leaving Mania as champs but it doesn't erase that they were in that title match.

If New Day wins on Sunday and needs a soft challenge for the following Pay-Per-View then Los Matadores would be an acceptable fit. They'd be the bridge to a more credible challenge, giving New Day a successful defense to help establish a more lengthy reign. 

8. The Vaudevillians

962571

Aiden English and Simon Gotch have a real standout of a gimmick. Their 1920's-inspired gentleman strongman presentation made them an instant hit when they debuted in NXT during the summer of 2014. 

Advertisement

Despite being very over, the duo would lose in the finals of an August 2014 Number 1 Contender's tournament to the Lucha Dragons. Their next closest taste of tag gold came during an October loss to the same Lucha Dragons in an NXT Tag Team Championship match.

The two have not had a serious run at the titles in a while and it could be because they are on deck for a main roster debut. Their entrance is incredibly unique and their personas are so creative. If WWE introduced them to challenge for the Tag Team Championships, it could work out very favorable in getting these guys over.

7. Heath Slater & Curtis Axel

Where can AxelMania go now that WrestleMania season is over? Also, since former Slater Gator member Titus O'Neil has reformed the Prime Time Players what is left for the former 3MB frontman?

Advertisement

The obvious answer to both of these questions is that both of these men need to become  legitimate title contenders. They've already been teaming frequently on television and at live events so WWE should cement this union with a challenge against whomever are the current champions.

The two might not be in a position to win the titles but a challenge would serve as a vehicle to establish them as a comedic mainstay in the division.

Both guys are entertaining. Axel has turned his Hulk Hogan-inspired shtick into a funny medium with merchandising potential. Slater's likability stems from his underdog appeal. The best example of this was when he scored a fluke win on the then-Money In The Bank briefcase holder Seth Rollins. People went nuts for him when he beat Rollins.

They have potential. What would it hurt if they were on next month's pre-show to compete for the WWE Tag Team Championships?

6. Dolph Ziggler & R-Truth

This is a hypothetical team that may or may not be well received. Give it a shot, it might have hope.

Advertisement

Dolph Ziggler is everyone's favorite singles star that seems to not get his due credit. While he has charisma and in-ring skill that is among the best in the business he's currently battling it out in the second-tier Intercontinental Division. 

Ziggler has a match with Sheamus at Extreme Rules that he will likely lose because WWE is in more need of heels. He might not be in line to carry the IC strap for some time again, so why not give him a few months feuding with a heel New Day?

R-Truth is another singles guy who's not in line for any singles pushes either. He surprised many with how entertaining he could be during the buildup to the WrestleMania ladder match he competed in.

Truth can be funny. Given the opportunity to receive a hot tag from Ziggler, people could get behind him. And if he was the guy who took the pin when it's time for the pair to lose it would help protect Dolph until he's ready for a serious singles push again.

5. Luke Harper & Erick Rowan

783521

If Tyson Kidd and Cesaro retain their titles at Extreme Rules then WWE might need another heel team ready to feud with them. It is a wise move to reunite the former Wyatt family duo to be that team.

Advertisement

Luke Harper isn't in a desperate need for a change because he seems settled into the Intercontinental Title hunt. However, he's not challenging for it at the moment and might need something to hold him over for a few months.

Erick Rowan absolutely needs a change. His babyface solo run has not worked well despite the repeated character tweaks. Turning him heel and reuniting him with Harper would give him purpose again.

If the now face team of Kidd and Cesaro do win on Sunday have Harper and Rowan come out and absolutely wreck them. The rowdy Chicago crowd would eat a beatdown like that up.

4. J&J Security

As main eventers like Randy Orton and Roman Reigns find themselves battling the tyrannical Authority it might help them to recruit some allies. A babyface team of Tyson Kidd and Cesaro would be a good choice, especially if they are the Tag Team Champions.

Advertisement

As Kidd and Cesaro align against their bosses they would find their titles in jeopardy. The unlikely stooge pair of Jamie Noble and Joey Mercury are former title holders in WWE, so Noble's previous Cruiserweight reign and Mercury's former Tag Championship reign can be mentioned for credibility.

An Orton or Reigns (or both) alliance against The Authority would give opportunities to raise the prominence of the Champs and their belts. J&J could be booked in Raw multi-man main events on their path to a Payback title match.

3. Prime Time Players

As seen in the above video The Prime Time Players seem to be positioning themselves into a rivalry with current WWE Tag Team Champions, Tyson Kidd and Cesaro. If the champs retain at Extreme Rules then Titus O'Neil and Darren Young are likely to be the challengers to those titles.

Advertisement

After tearing his ACL in 2014, Young was forced out of the ring for the remainder of last year. Now that he's back and reunited with O'Neil it appears that they might get closer to capturing their first Tag Championships.

The two have all the potential of carrying those belts well. Titus has a massive size. Darren has an athletic build. Both seem more than capable of handling a promo.

Their current verbal backstage insults do seem to rely a little too heavily on piped in crowd noises but that could be smoothed over once they get their chance to back up the talking in the ring. Let them challenge for the titles and let them win.

2. Hideo Itami & Finn Balor

When the duo who used to be known as Fergal Devitt and Kenta debuted in NXT, it was to do battle with the former NXT Tag Champions The Ascension. Hideo Itami would be the first on the scene to challenge Konnor and Viktor, being overwhelmed and outnumbered be his lonesome.

Advertisement

Finn Balor would eventually join Itami and they would ultimately defeat The Ascension. This formula successfully introduced them into NXT so why not do something similar for their main roster debut?

There would be more pressure to have them defeat whichever team happens to be the champions. A very angry internet would arise if they were fed to The New Day on their debut. But if they did conquer the tag division it could be a positive step in elevating the worth of the lower priority titles.

1. Lucha Dragons

The Lucha Dragons are the best choice for the next team to challenge for the WWE Tag Team Championships. Kalisto and Sin Cara are high energy and have a cohesive bond. They not only look like a tag team but they look like a darn good one with loads of marketing potential.

Advertisement

Since Kalisto and Sin Cara joined forces in NXT during the middle of 2014 they've been a hit. They had a short run with the NXT Tag Titles but were rightfully moved up to the main roster where they have been much needed.

Kalisto is one of the most exciting on-screen performers today. He's innovative and quick, really conveying the lucha style to the WWE audience. Sin Cara has greatly benefited from the pairing as well. This is the most purpose the character has been given since Hunico accepted the role of the masked man.

They would most likely put on great matches with both teams that are fighting at Extreme Rules but the heel New Day would be a better fit. Since the crowd takes to the 'lucha' chants so well that could plant seeds of jealousy by the New Day, who only hear 'New Day sucks' from the audience.


What other teams should get a shot at the WWE Tag Team Championships? Let us know in the comments below!

Advertisement