10 WWE WrestleMania Matches NOBODY Wanted
Why the hell did WWE book these unwanted WrestleMania abominations at all?!
Working a match at WrestleMania is supposed to be a banner moment in someone's pro career. It is, after all, the biggest event/weekend of the entire year, and it should pad bank accounts with a huge payoff that goes hand-in-hand with creative satisfaction for both fans and wrestlers alike.
Or not.
Yes, everyone involved here would've made a good lump sum of cash for their evening's efforts, but they definitely didn't come away from 'Mania with a smile. These are the matches on WWE's biggest platform that nobody really wanted - that included the men walking down often-lengthy entrance ramps amidst pageantry and pyro.
Sometimes, you could see it on their faces too. There was a CJ from GTA: San Andreas, "Ah sh*t here we go again!" look to these dudes, and rightly so. The build towards their so-called 'Mania epics was totally crap, and then the actual match itself ended up stinking the place out.
It's kinda cheating, but one of the bouts examined hasn't even happened yet. WWE fans would be totally shocked if it became an in-ring winner next month at 'Mania 39 though...
10. Big Show Vs. Akebono (WrestleMania 21)
This was a terrible idea from minute one.
Charging punters actual money to see Big Show squat in a thong should've been considered illegal, but WWE did exactly that at WrestleMania 21. There, they drafted in sumo star Akebono for one of the worst "spectacles" Vince McMahon has ever had the cheek to promote.
Being sandwiched in between Shawn Michaels vs. Kurt Angle and JBL vs. John Cena defo didn't help matters, but this nightmare of a marquee effort would've been trash following/preceding anything. It's the kind of thing pro wrestling fans watch with mouths agape, but only because they can't believe it's on the card in the first place.
It's somewhat remarkable that getting sweaty vs. Akebono wasn't the only duff 'Mania match of Paul Wight's career. However, at the very least, other bouts were more in-line with what fans expected to see on the card. "SumoWrestleMania" just doesn't have the same ring to it, eh?
9. Goldberg Vs. Brock Lesnar (WrestleMania XX)
Check the knowing look on Steve Austin's face above; he'd been through something vaguely similar to Brock Lesnar and Bill Goldberg a few years before their WrestleMania XX disaster, but didn't have to suffer the indignity of a sold out Madison Square Garden letting him know he was unwanted.
MSG went hard on Brock and Bill in 2004.
News had spread that both planned to leave WWE shortly after the pay-per-view, so the typically-fired up New York masses decided to shove them through the federation exit doors. People took an almighty dump on what was supposed to be the star attraction on the undercard, and 'Stone Cold' cringed his way through it as special ref.
The whole exercise was approx 14 minutes of torture for Goldberg and Lesnar. They didn't want to be there at all, and MSG sure wasn't going to politely sit around applauding any of their exchanges. Nah, this was a real 'f*ck you' to both men.
8. The Undertaker Vs. Big Show & A-Train (WrestleMania XIX)
It perhaps says everything that colossal numpty Nathan Jones was chosen to represent a dire moment in The Undertaker's iconic career. He sprinted out to help his mentor following a quite-awful handicap bout pitting 'The Deadman' vs. Big Show and A-Train at an otherwise-excellent WrestleMania XIX.
Y'know what people remember most from this bout? Fred Durst of Limp Bizkit fame rapping 'Taker to the ring. That's it, and there's a reason for that - the legend (The Undertaker, not SmackDown: Know Your Role unlockable Fred) couldn't squeeze anything out of two monster foes.
It was like Giant Gonzalez all over again, people. Yep, permission to shiver.
Originally, Jones was pencilled in to be 'Taker's tag partner for the match, but WWE chiefs didn't think he was ready for that spot. So, basically, things could've been even worse for this lower-card clanger. It was painful enough without big Nathan, and fully deserves a spot on this list.
7. Steve Austin Vs. Scott Hall (WrestleMania X8)
Here's that bout referenced a few entries back.
Most fans figured the then-WWF would try to book Steve Austin vs. Hulk Hogan at 'Mania X8, but then ol' Terry got programmed opposite The Rock and 'Stone Cold' had to pick up sloppy seconds. It was either Kevin Nash or Scott Hall, and Austin landed on the ex-Razor Ramon.
Sadly, Hall was nowhere near the performer he'd been even five years ago when he rolled into Toronto for WrestleMania. So, around one year after blowing the roof off 'Mania X-Seven vs. The Rock, Steve was forced to stumble around with a past-his-prime Razor on the biggest show of 2002.
They went less than 12 minutes. It felt like 112. Even Jim Ross on commentary, who had provided legendary soundtracks to some of his pal's best moments, struggled to add energy to the worst 'Mania match of Austin's run.
What a depressing situation this was for everybody.
6. Brock Lesnar Vs. Omos (WrestleMania 39)
Some out there will crucify yours truly for including a match that hasn't even happened yet, but there's surely no way Brock Lesnar vs. Omos was atop wishlists when everyone sat down to thrash out dream bouts for WrestleMania 39. It's...a quite-baffling choice for next month's weekender.
Initially, it seemed Brocky boy would be tangling with supernatural spook Bray Wyatt in Hollywood on either 1 or 2 April. WWE ditched that in favour of a possible Wyatt vs. Bobby Lashley clash (which has still to be confirmed) and Lesnar sort of going nose-to-nose with the towering giant known as MVP's Omos.
A collective, 'Huh?!' could be heard all over the wrestling map.
It's cool that WWE wants to push a newer star to the forefront, but Omos doesn't seem worthy of a spot opposite Brock at 'Mania just yet. Worse, reports leaked that management didn't think world-travelled veteran GUNTHER was ready to wrestle Lesnar - but Omos is?!
5. Michael Cole Vs. Jerry Lawler (WrestleMania XXVII)
Admit it, you knew this would be here at some point.
Even Michael Cole giggles when he realises WWE handed him 13 in-ring minutes (20+ when one takes entrances/stalling into account) at WrestleMania XXVII. It shouldn't be lost on anyone that Cole vs. Jerry Lawler was longer than Edge vs. Alberto Del Rio, and only one minute shorter than the main event pitting John Cena vs. The Miz.
Steve Austin was drafted in as some 'Emergency: Break Glass' mediator that'd make the bout more appealing to horrified fans, and Jack Swagger was called upon to take some bumps too. None of that could change the fact that nobody wanted to see this eat up so much time at 'Mania.
Christ, Sheamus vs. Daniel Bryan was relegated to a four-minute scrap on the pre-show just so Michael f'n Cole could cosplay as every amateur wrestler ever and undeservedly gobble up precious minutes on the annual supershow.
4. Braun Strowman Vs. Goldberg (WrestleMania 36)
WWE deserve a ton of credit for attempting to make the best of a dreadful situation back in 2020. The ongoing pandemic wrecked plans for WrestleMania 36, and forced the company to lock their biggest event behind closed doors at the quaint/outright f*cking odd surroundings of the in-house Performance Center.
They get a pass for that, and a standing ovation for putting the event(s) on at all. However, they shouldn't get a pat on the back for replacing Roman Reigns with Braun Strowman. That was a poor decision - a last-minute one, granted, but a poor one nonetheless.
Braun vs. Goldberg was not a Universal Title match people wanted to watch.
It also led to Strowman's rotten championship reign, and somehow managed to stink up the joint despite only lasting two minutes. Revenge for Bray Wyatt's 'Fiend' might've been a better strategy, then he could've defended the belt vs. John Cena in a barmy 'Firefly Fun House' match the next night.
3. Vince McMahon Vs. Pat McAfee (WrestleMania 38)
A lapsed fan friend of your writer laughed upon hearing that Vince McMahon worked a match at 'Mania 38. "Wait, you're not serious?", he asked. "Deadly serious" was the reply. His mind was then blown all over again when learning that "the NFL guy" Pat McAfee was McMahon's opponent on the grandest stage.
It was a fun conversation to have, one way more fun than watching the bout itself.
Here's the thing: A carefully-built Vince tag-team match could've worked as some midcard oddity in 2022, but the build would have to be really good. Tacking his first singles showing in 12 years on as some leech for McAfee vs. Austin Theory was a strange decision though.
McMahon was unsteady on his feet and just didn't need to be out there throwing clotheslines. This was a dude who once ripped Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan for being too old in 1996, and here he was booking himself in bouts aged 76.
2. Bart Gunn Vs. Butterbean (WrestleMania XV)
Alas, it's another horror show you knew would pop up.
1998's entire 'Brawl For All' concept was a calamity from start to finish. It p*ssed on the product generally by presenting "real fights" that cramped the worked nature of literally everything else, and then had the cheek to resurface in time for WrestleMania XV.
'Toughman' contest fighter Butterbean was booked to punch the t*ts off tournament winner Bart Gunn to the enjoyment of very few. One got the sense going in that Bart was being punished for daring to win the 'Brawl For All' shindig instead of Dr. Death, and he was very-much a sacrificial lamb to Bean.
The big baby-looking f*cker wearing USA flag shorts decked Gunn within seconds, and that was a wrap on the shoot-fighting world for WWF officials. Poor Bart, who was only guilty of being pretty tough himself, probably struggled to remember his only solo showing at 'Mania afterwards.
1. Baron Corbin Vs. Kurt Angle (WrestleMania 35)
WWE should be ashamed of themselves for the way Kurt Angle's retirement was handled.
One of the greatest all-rounders ever was shoved off to the side in a nothing six-minute plodder vs. Baron Corbin on the 'Mania 35 undercard, then held his hands aloft post-defeat in some half-hearted wave goodbye. It must've been humiliating for the Olympian, and he deserved better.
This isn't meant as a predictable attack on Corbin, but he was never the right opponent for Kurt's final match. Fans yearned for more; they'd be forgiven for wanting Triple H, or some other icon from Angle's career, in that spot instead.
It absolutely wasn't much for Kurt to ask that WWE show him proper respect. He'd literally broken his neck for them in the past, and now he was staring at the lights for a mediocre heel in a match only memorable for how rubbish it was.
Yuck.
For more WWE and wrestling content, check out WWE 2K23: 10 Best Looking Characters and 10 Last-Minute WWE WrestleMania 39 Pitches For Steve Austin!