10 WWE Wrestlers Destroyed By Backstage Politics

Sometimes talent, work and luck just isn't enough...

By Michael Palmer /

They say all it takes to "make it" is the right combination of talent, work ethic and luck. Take your natural gift, work on it as hard as you can and, if the breaks go your way, you'll make it all the way to the top, son. But what about the other cases? What about the guys who have what it takes, who work as hard as they can, who get a little bit of luck on their side but still don't make it to the top of the pile. Where did it go wrong for those guys? You see, the people who made up the saying about the talent and the work and the luck missed out the valuable thing. The thing that seems to matter most. They missed out politics. In a business that's dominated by one company, that's run on the whims of one man, it is extremely hard to make it without playing politics. Piss off Vince McMahon and you're finished. Do something to upset an executive and you're done. Don't impress the right WWE agent and you never even get a chance. Many wrestlers who seemed to have had all that it takes to make it to the top in professional wrestling have had their careers cut short because they fell out of favour with the wrong person. Here are 10 careers hampered by backstage politics...

10. Shane Douglas

"Without Shane Douglas, there would have been no ECW." That's a quote straight from WWE.com. It's even right at the very top of the Shane Douglas wikipedia page. Douglas is often credited (along with Paul Heyman, of course) as the guy who helped create ECW after an angle in 1994 where he won the NWA World Heavyweight Championship. After winning the title, he threw down the NWA belt to create the ECW Heavyweight Championship. The Company changed the meaning of its initials to Extreme Championship Wrestling and the "real" ECW was born. As "The Franchise" he played an integral part in making ECW a force to be reckoned with. In 1995 he left for WWF, changing his name to Dean Douglas and adopting a college dean gimmick. This was 1995 WWF after all. After a decent start his career never really took off, and by 1996 he was back in ECW. If you're wondering why, we got two words for ya: Shawn Michaels. Michaels and the Kliq (Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, Triple H, and X-Pac) were apparently not fans of Douglas at all, and spent a lot of time bad-mouthing him to Vince McMahon. Michaels even refused to drop his Intercontinental Championship to Douglas, instead vacating it so that Douglas would lose the title just minutes after getting it. Either Vince had so much trust in the Kliq that he changed his mind on Douglas, or he was on the fence to begin with and let the group convince him. Either way, Douglas was let go, never truly getting the chance to show what he could do in a major company.

9. The Nexus

The ending of the June 7th 2010 episode of Monday Night Raw in a contender for one of the most shocking of all time. At the end of the main event, the entire eight-man strong cast of the recently finished "reality" show NXT appeared and tore everything to pieces. Dismantling the ring, destroying everything in their wake; it was an incredible debut. The group, despite an infamous tie incident, started incredibly strong and before long were given a prestigious program with John Cena. This feud culminated in a match at Summerslam 2010, when The Nexus faced "Team WWE", a team of John Cena's choosing. Which, of course, they lost. For€some reason. According to a conversation on Chris Jericho's podcast between himself and Edge (who were both on John Cena's team) they were desperate for The Nexus to win that night. Why would the strongest faction since the nWo be booked to lose their first major match? But even if the plan was never to have The Nexus win, it was the way the match ended that really screwed the group. According to Jericho and Edge, Cena's plan was to have Wade Barrett deliver a DDT to Cena on the floor, which John would then kick out of and beat the two remaining Nexus members. Despite Jericho and Edge fighting for The Nexus to go over and telling John that his idea "was dumb", it went ahead and The Nexus, with their threat nullified, were essentially finished. Afterwards, Cena mentioned to both Jericho and Edge that he was wrong but by then it was too late. Whether he meant to or not, John Cena had used backstage politics and had ruined the career of the most promising heel faction in years.

8. Ken Anderson

Ken Anderson, who wrestled in the WWE as Mr Kennedy, was released from his contract on May 29th, 2009. Not that remarkable, except that he was released only four days after a much-hyped return from injury on the May 25th episode of Raw. This though, could perhaps be the rare case of backstage politics doing some good, as the big name stars threw their weight around to get Anderson fired for a reason. In his return match on the May 25th Raw episode, a 10-man tag match, Mr Kennedy delivered a botched back suplex on Randy Orton. In some pain, Orton is clearly angry after the spot.After the incident, Orton told management that he would no longer work with Anderson, despite being good friends with him at the time. A number of other big stars had also complained to management about working with Anderson, including John Cena. In 2007, Cena had to vacate his WWE Championship after suffering a torn pectorals muscle as a result of a botched Anderson hip-toss. Vince McMahon, despite seemingly liking Anderson and his Mr Kennedy persona, was happy to terminate his contract just days after a big-deal return in order to protect his top stars. Anderson signed with TNA shortly after his release, but has never really made the push to the top level of stars at the company that other former WWE talents like Kurt Angle or Jeff Hardy managed to get to.

7. John Morrison

Are you ready for WWE: The Soap Opera? No? Tough. It's happening. Let's talk about John Morrison and Melina... Right, so John Morrison and Melina are a couple. They were a couple for most of their careers with WWE. At some point, according to some people somewhere, Melina slept with some other wrestlers behind Morrison's back. Batista, they say. And others. Whatever. When this happened, Morrison didn't try and fight the other guys, and is therefore considered "weak" by many backstage, including Vince McMahon. This, apparently, is the reason he never appeared in a Wrestlemania main event. Not, as you might expect, the fact that he basically just jumped around the ring for a few minutes and couldn't cut a promo. Nope, definitely the "weak" thing. A less ridiculous story that could explain why WWE decided to not renew his contract in 2011 involves Melina and Trish Stratus at Wrestlemania 27. Melina was reportedly upset that Trish was used in a mixed-tag match at the event in Atlanta instead of her. According to Trish, Morrison was difficult to work with, rejecting all of her ideas in the match and generally not treating her all that nicely. This is backstage politics at it's murkiest, but there's no doubt that John Morrison's career didn't hit the heights it should have. Sure, whether or not he could make the jump to the main event level is debatable, but it seems that his relationship with Melina and his general behaviour led him to be considered more hassle than he was worth.

6. Christian

Edge & Christian will go down as one of the greatest tag teams of all time. And few will argue that they may just be the most entertaining. Both exhilarating in the ring and genuinely funny out of it, their list of achievements is as varied as it is memorable. Their legendary Ladder/Table/TLC matches with the Hardy Boyz and the Dudley Boyz sit alongside their five second poses and backstage rapport with Mick Foley. This legendary tag team launched Edge into an incredible career that saw him win 11 World Championships and main event Wrestlemania 24 against The Undertaker. The same cannot be said for his partner Christian. When Edge & Christian broke up in 2001, the pair were on fairly even footing within the company. Although it can be said that Edge was given more opportunities directly after the split, that can be attributed to the fact that he was the babyface coming out of the group. Both were given mid-card title reigns and the TV time to try and get themselves over in the days of a roster that had just been flooded by newly acquired WCW stars and a main-event scene that was more or less locked down. Both spent a few years building their characters and attaining a following from a crowd unsure of they could make it as singles stars. Then, in November 2005, Christian let his WWE contract expire and moved to TNA. Two months later, by January 2006, Edge won his first WWE Championship. With hindsight it's easy to point at Edge as the more gifted of the two, but at the time it never really seemed that way. Both were generally considered fairly even, and when Edge was awarded the first ever Money In The Bank contract, it was considered a big gamble. Christian left for TNA because he felt burned out and wanted a lighter schedule. But his WWE career never recovered. He re-signed with WWE in 2009 and was used in the new ECW brand, but he was always considered an afterthought. He finally won a World Championship in 2011, as a gesture to his former partner Edge, who had to suddenly retire. Christian dropped the title to Randy Orton just two days later. There are rumours that Vince McMahon has never seen Christian as a viable main event player, but the biggest blotch by his name is his departure for TNA. McMahon does not like disloyalty. Christian's talent and his Attitude Era nostalgia factor would surely had set him up for a main event career had he not made the move in 2005.

5. Vader

Ladies and gentlemen, let's welcome back The Kliq. This is another famous case of the infamous group of wrestlers apparently ruining someone's career because they didn't like him all that much. Vader made his WWE debut at the Royal Rumble in 1996. After the required few months of monster-establishing, Vader met then-WWF Champion Shawn Michaels at Summerslam. Rumours claim that Vader was originally booked to beat Michaels, but Shawn was unhappy about the finish and insisted that it changed. In the end, Vader beat Michaels by count-out (so didn't win the title) before the match was restarted and he beat him by disqualification (so didn't win the title) before the match was restarted and he lost. So didn't win the title. Vader moved on to other feuds, notably a few with The Undertaker, but didn't really take off. The Kliq, not only concerned with guys they're feuding against, continued their dislike for Vader and their backstage politicking eventually led to him leaving the company in 1998. Would Vader have made it huge without the backstage influence of The Kliq? Who knows. Probably not. Monster heels never last long. But The Kliq's insistence on the weak booking of the supposedly monstrous Vader certainly did him no favours. While Vader is remembered fondly by a handful of wrestling fans, the WWE audience-at-large so fondly named the "WWE Universe" doesn't really know who he is.

4. The WCW Guys During The Invasion

If you were to pinpoint any day that changed the course of wrestling history the most, the definitive answer would be the day that Vince McMahon bought WCW. It was perhaps the first day ever that professional wrestling had only one leading company. It also allowed Vince McMahon to book a feud that every single wrestling fan dreamed of: WWF vs WCW. Except not really. When McMahon bought WCW, he acquired the contracts of every wrestler signed to WCW. Unfortunately for Vince, the top level, main event, A-calibre talent at WCW weren't technically signed to the company, they were signed to Time Warner. And Time Warner had no interest in letting those guys out of their incredibly-high paying contracts. So McMahon was faced with a situation where he had no choice but to book an invasion angle with no Goldberg, no Sting, no nWo, and nobody that Time Warner considered valuable enough to sign to a contract. As such, the WCW guys who did now work for WWF were resented and looked down upon; thought of as secondary talent. The invasion angle had to be re-balanced with WWF guys switching sides and the whole story is generally considered a flop. Unfortunately, this meant that several genuinely talented wrestlers who hadn't quite made the jump to the WCW main event (which was pretty impenetrable at the time) got unfairly judged as not good enough. Aside from a select handful, the careers of these guys was destroyed by something as "backstage" as which corporation owned their contracts.

3. Matt Hardy

Alright, it's soap opera time again. Strap in... Matt Hardy and Lita were both an on-screen and off-screen couple for a while. In 2005, Lita cheated on Matt with Edge. Matt, understandably, was rather upset and said that he could no longer work in the same company as Edge and insisted that Edge be fired. WWE management, agreed with the first part €“ the part about them no longer being able to work together €“ but not the second part, and so they fired Matt instead. Edge, of course, was the bigger star. So after a brief spell working for some indie promotions, Matt returned and began a true-to-life program with Edge, with the cheating incident as the focal point of the story. According to Edge himself, he regretted the way he hurt his friend Matt, but did not enjoy turning the whole thing into a wrestling angle. That was all Matt's idea. After the feud, Edge became incredibly over as a top heel, and went on to become WWE champion. Matt, well, didn't. While the "worked shoot" aspect of the story was thoroughly entertaining, it didn't really do any favours for Matt's character. He was extremely over in the story, but once it ended it didn't leave him with much. Now, Matt can be found wrestling with his brother Jeff (again) in TNA.

2. The Montreal Screwjob

It's the most infamous example of backstage politics in WWE, and probably also the most public. Bret Hart had agreed to sign a deal with WCW and leave WWF but, whoops, he was also the WWF Champion at the time. Bret had agreed to drop his title to Shawn Michaels, but he didn't want to do it in Montreal, his home town. So he, Michaels and Vince McMahon agreed that the match in Montreal would end in a disqualification and Bret would drop the title another time. Of course, that's not what happened. McMahon told the referee to act as though Hart had submitted, and everyone went on pretending he had. Hart didn't, and went to WCW angry, with a point to prove. Now, this didn't exactly destroy Bret's career. It did, however, destroy his relationship with the WWE. It took 14 years for Bret Hart to forgive McMahon and Michaels. And his run in WCW was patchy at best. From McMahon's point of view though, this incident is often cited as one of the launching points of the Attitude Era. It gave him the idea of the on-screen heel authority figure "Mr McMahon" right at the point where Stone Cold Steve Austin was becoming the "man of the people". An indirect line can be drawn form this incident to WWF winning the Monday Night War. There's a time for backstage politics becoming centre stage after all, then.

1. CM Punk

Nobody knows why CM Punk left WWE in January. There are theories, stories and rumours but neither Punk himself nor anyone from WWE management has commented on the record about Punk's reasons for leaving. It is fairy well established, though, that Punk has a history with being unhappy with the WWE. There are several confirmed stories about Punk being unhappy with his role in the company, and all of these stories are drenched in politics. It was never the wrestling that Punk had a problem with. In 2009, for instance, CM Punk became the best heel in wrestling with his Straight Edge Society. CM Punk came up with the concept himself, and it was clearly something he truly believed in. And on TV, it showed. It was utterly compelling television. Punk was completely hated, and had an amazing program with Rey Mysterio culminating in a match at Wrestlemania 26. But after that, management seemed to lose interest and the angle fizzled out. At Wrestlemania 28, Punk was the WWE Champion and still didn't get to fulfil his dream by headlining the event. That spot went to The Rock, a part-timer who had only appeared on a handful of Raw episodes before the match. The final straw seemed to be the plans for Wrestlemania 30. It would make sense, given his past, that Punk would be unhappy about being relegated down the card to face Triple H. There are also rumours that he didn't like the idea of Batista being hot-shotted straight into the main event only a few months after his return, taking a spot that should go Daniel Bryan, or Punk himself. It seems that, in this case, backstage politics has cost WWE one of their most talented stars. Perhaps for good.