10 WWE Wrestlers Vince McMahon Loved At First Sight
Chairman WOW! The big men and even bigger WWE stars Vince McMahon just couldn't get enough of
Vince McMahon is an odd fellow.
This isn't news, of course. But the older and odder he gets, the more it becomes so embedded in his product that it becomes the only storyline reason most things happen.
Pay-per-views are traditionally decent these days, moving along at far more palatable clip than your average three hour Raw. But then that doesn't explain how, after nearly a decade, three hour Raws are still typically such a slog? Why has NXT lost virtually all of its charm? Why is good form almost impossible to keep up, as evidenced by SmackDown failing to build on fairly generous takes about it's broader improvement? The answer to all these questions is simple - Vince McMahon is an odd fellow.
We have moved from the left hand not know what the right is doing to - as succinctly put by WhatCulture's own Adam Wilbourn - the little finger not knowing what the index one is. These theoretical fingers are on McMahon's hand, and he's still the only one to make any decisions. If only he could go back to liking who the rest of us liked.
The Chairman has a type, of this we know, and the recent announcement that relative newbie (and 7'3) star Omos would join AJ Styles in a tag team title match at WrestleMania 37 had fans racing to anoint him McMahon's next megastar. It may not be that easy this time, but it certainly used to be...
10. Hulk Hogan
Without hyperbole or sales patter, Vince McMahon’s 1980s affection for Hulk Hogan is the reason North American pro wrestling as viewed today came to be. The blueprint, the benchmark and beta-tested model of a Sports Entertainment success story, the infatuation McMahon had with an AWA star his father had cast aside drove a countrywide takeover and worldwide revolution.
Hogan had been part of New York’s plans as a heel before his decision to accept the part as Thunderlips in Rocky III drew the ire of traditionalist Vince McMahon Sr. Unwelcome in the WWF following the cinematic sidestep, ‘The Hulkster’ ventures to Verne Gagne’s American Wrestling Association and honed many of the details that later became global shorthand for the industry.
In Hogan’s look, magnetic charisma and increasingly shrewd crowd control, McMahon saw his star upon seizing the reins of the organisation from his father. Believing heavily in his grand vision, he booked Hogan as an entirely different babyface figurehead to former WWE Champion Bob Backlund, transforming casual perceptions of the wrestling business in the process.
It was so successful, he tried it again for the rest of his professional career. McMahon can fake or even force enthusiasm for other body types, personality quirks or promo styles, but this package took him from the pro wrestling outhouse to the hoi polloi penthouse. He never forgot his first.
9. Tom Magee
As laboured over in wonderful, wonderful detail when the tape of the match was finally unearthed, Vince McMahon was more than ready to move on from Hulk Hogan as early as 1986 thanks to the minor miracle Bret Hart performed with inexperienced muscleman Tom Magee during an October television taping.
With a backfilp, bodybuilder physique and luxurious mullet, Magee had the lot as far as The Chairman was concerned, not least after he'd shown enough fire in this extended squash to be moulded into a souped-up version of the super-successful 'Hulkster'. He was half-right, though he'd been bamboozled by the magic of his own industry.
There was indeed a man in the ring that could be trusted with carrying an entire organisation on his back, but Magee wasn't that hero-in-waiting. Then a tag team heel and about a third of the size of the type of Champion McMahon desired, 'The Hitman' was the 'Excellence Of Execution' some six years before he was given the WWE Championship to anoint him as such.
Magee couldn't really have that level of match with anybody, whilst Bret managed it with just about everybody. There was an inherent tragedy to this match and their future dynamic - McMahon's heart was never truly with Hart, even when it inadvertently was.
8. Diesel
Vince McMahon was on commentary as relative newcomer Diesel tore through most of the first 10 men to enter the 1994 Royal Rumble. He got to call, as only he could, the remarkable ability of Shawn Michaels' bodyguard let off the leash for the first time as he made mincemeat of the midcard before falling afoul of a numerical disadvantage as the match moved into its second act. He got to hear the deafening "Diesel" chants as he left the ring defeated but not deflated.
'Big Daddy Cool' was born that night in Providence, Rhode Island.
Bret Hart earned a thunderous pop as he gamely battled through the pain of an Owen-inflicted knee injury to co-win the contest. Lex Luger - not yet completely cast as a choker - earned a sizeable number of cheers for all his usual babyface bluster. 'HBK' himself went long in the match for the first time ever, foreshadowing his winning form of the next two years. F*cking Sparky f*cking Plugg even looked alright as the future Bob Holly put in a hell of a shift to get himself over in spite of factors.
None of them mattered. Not really. Only one man was inked in to win the title at the end of the year - the nascent New Generation was readying itself for a refuelling.
7. The Boogeyman
The Boogeyman never should have even made it to the main roster after inadvertently causing fellow trainee Santino Marella to p*ss himself laughing and earn a slapping from incensed trainer Jim Cornette. Nothing that stupid designed to scare crowds should have ever made it to television, not least during the irony-free fun-free actual-good-product-free mid-2000s.
But make it he did, and his boss was seemingly thrilled to facilitate it. Boogeyman worked skits with Donald Trump, provided comedy outs for going-nowhere angles and even snagged a Legends deal after a crowd-pleasing 2015 Royal Rumble appearance.
What's nice about Vince McMahon's adoration of this absurd monster is that it earns the seemingly ageless Martin Wright ocasional paydays as long as he's prepared to eat a few works and cackle demonically in front of the nearest camera. As recently as 2019's Raw Reunion Wright was back at it, lining up alongside luminaries such as Triple H, Shawn Michaels and The Outsiders clapping along to Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair and Steve Austin as if he was making towns, drawing houses and having broadways throughout the 80s and 90s.
Not that any of that would have enticed McMahon - the f*cker eats worms, pal!
6. The Big Show
There was an arrogance to Vince McMahon's attitude about Paul Wight when he first saw him f*cking about with Hulk Hogan in WCW. Earned to a degree, but an arrogance all the same.
By 1995, McMahon was a long way removed from his golden era of finding a monster to be fed to the juggernaut that was Hulkamania or promoting musclebound heroes against musclebound villains in a battle that would have fit better onto a 35-foot-wide cinema screen than his 20x20 canvas.
Nothing was drawing, not least big lugs. Aforementioned tower of charismatic power Diesel wasn't drawing. Ripped and chiseled challenger Sid wasn't drawing. F*cking Mabel Vs Yoko-f*cking-zuna on a f*cking pay-per-view definitely wasn't drawing. Heavyweights, super heavyweights; they were all just bigger lugs failing to sell tickets and failing just as hard as they had for years as McMahon took a leering look at Nitro and believed he'd surely know how to make better use of his future Big Show.
And he showed them alright! Just 20 years and 30+ turns later and he was a star!
5. Lars Sullivan
Lars Sullivan was presumably little more than an 8x10 picture forcibly snatched from Triple H's hand when he was granted the opportunity that could change his life.
A passable work-in-progress on NXT, Sullivan had been carefully protected for the most part after a couple of singles clunkers with reliable hands highlighted how much help he still required. And good thing too! NXT, in a continued effort to be wrestling's coolest brand, has neglected the joy and hope that used to come with taking unknown quantities and making them stars. Sullivan could take as long as he needed to become a new kind of pro wrestling monster...
...until Vince caught wind of his existence.
Bundled together with Heavy Machinery, Lacey Evans, Nikki Cross and EC3, Lars Sullivan made his way to the main roster after months of vignettes pitching him as the company's next terrifying monster, because it's all McMahon knows. What McMahon didn't know was a genuine mental health concern - something Sullivan admitted to when he simply wasn't able to debut as planned. The Chairman stuck with him. What McMahon also didn't know was the damage caused by being problematic on the internet in your past, and Sullivan was also that. None of this was ideal...but McMahon didn't know that.
Injury shortly after his debut relegated him back to the sidelines, and a 2020 comeback was dropped ahead of his dismissal. That he saw more spotlight than three quarters of the Raw main roster in that time serves as reminder of all he had. And all that the sub-six footers never will.
4. Apollo Crews
Apollo Crews, with his body and his in-ring arsenal, should be in main events by now. Unfortunately for the promising young star, Vince McMahon loves pushing giant muscular men and then just stops thinking.
Rather than being pushed for the things he's got, he instead struggled because of the things he lacks. What he lacks are things unfortunately never given to him - good teaching on how to turn his gifts into skills that would set him away as a headliner. There wasn't a chance for Matt Bloom or Terry Taylor or even Triple H to instil some extra knowledge because he never got said teaching is because Vince McMahon loves pushing giant muscular men and then just stops thinking.
Crews didn't really spend long enough figuring out how to work larger crowds before he was in front of them all the time. Why he didn't experience too many of those larger crowds is because NXT predominantly hosted their shows from Full Sail University rather than major arenas and he was called up from NXT far too soon into his development. Will this latest daring gimmick change transform his fortunes longterm despite renewed interest.
But then why would that happen?
BECAUSE VINCE MCMAHON LOVES PUSHING GIANT MUSCULAR MEN AND THEN JUST STOPS THINKING.
3. Johnny B Badd
When Marc Mero came to WWE in 1996, he p*ssed an awful lot of people off. Or, more specifically, his contract did.
Perhaps "Marc Mero & Sable" would make for a more accurate title here - various reports and anecdotal recollections of the first time Vince McMahon met Mero paint the picture of a meeting in which The Chairman had already seen stars in Rena before bothering his a*se to figure out what to do with Marc. He'd see that through and then some too, but his failure to find something stronger than 'Wildman' was because McMahon didn't really want that - he wanted Johnny B Badd.
WCW, in an attempt to compete with WWE years earlier had tried and failed to replicate the profit-making creations coming out of Vince's gimmick factory. In Badd, they'd created one that actually worked. Initially steering hard into the homophobic undercurrent of the fanbase, Badd's heel schtick was tweaked in line with his legitimately impressive in-ring to the point which the origins of the gimmick were barely visible three years later.
It earned him a guaranteed contract when such things were rare, along with a healthy dose of resentment from an undercard making much less. McMahon lost interest within a year of the deal, but pushed Sable to the moon as promised to recoup far more than he put in to the couple in the end.
2. Dr Jerry Graham
Dr. Jerry Graham was a gripping grappling heel that was able to turn Madison Square Garden into a primitive moshpit with his bad guy schtick (a riot he once started resulted in the venue initiating an age-of-entrance policy for two decades), and was, thanks to his propensity for living the gimmick, a young Vince McMahon's absolute favourite wrestler to watch.
A legendary character throughout the 1950s and 1960s, Graham was the man McMahon imitated the most, but ironically also the performer that inadvertently drove The Chairman into promotion of pro wrestling instead.
Desperate to mimic his hero, Vince Sr banned his son from becoming a wrestler in his image. With a thirst for the industry at large, the Junior took on other roles instead until he ended up taking over the entire company in 1982.
Graham died in 1997 and was posthumously inducted into the Hall Of Fame in 2017 with a WWE Network finally set up to present some of his wildest moments in best possible quality.
1. GARY STRYDOM!
Alright, nine wrestlers and one "WBF BODYSTAR, PAL".
It may not seem believable that Vince McMahon thought he could monetise ginormous bodies even more so than he already had done with his wrestling company as the wild west 80s became the p*ss test 90s, but the World Bodybuilding Federation was one of his most embarrassing failed efforts in doing just that. And just like his WWF needed Hulk Hogan, his WBF required the magic and muscles of...
GARY STRYDOM!
McMahon's obvious favourite from all the poor saps lured away from the International Federation of Bodybuilding, Strydom was a headline attraction in the bizarre Sports Entertainment hybrid he attempted to create within the confines of his Titan Sports empire. Muscles on top of muscles alongside a million dollar smile and a full head of hair, he was textbook turn-of-the-decade clickbait for the wrestling-promoter done good.
Make your day better by watching the video above, if you've never seen it before. Or check out the phenomenal WBF retrospective done by the OSW Review lads that captures not just McMahon's fascination but the whole ugly truth behind the formation and rapid decline of the proto-XFL.