10 WWE Wrestlers Who Should’ve Got One More Title Run

Nostalgia runs, career revivals and the so-called 'Birmingham screwjob'

By Elliott Binks /

Not everybody’s as lucky as Goldberg.

Advertisement

Not in the sense that he was recently able to sign a big-money contract working minimal dates, but in that he was able to notch one more title run before seemingly bowing out for good.

Back in February at Fastlane, Goldberg won the Universal Championship to capture his first world title in over 13 years, which in some ways atoned for that disappointing reign of 2003.

Generally speaking, though, Goldberg seems to be the exception rather than rule, as plenty of others before him have appeared to be deserving of another title shot, only to see the opportunity pass them by. And this isn’t something that’s exclusively affected top-tier guys, with former champions from up-and-down the card being denied that one last title run on a number of occasions over the years.

From stars who enjoyed a big-name return to others who simply enjoyed a renaissance – as well as the odd example of guys being overlooked whilst still in their prime years – here, we look back at ten instances of wrestlers who should’ve got one more title run, when it should’ve happened and why.

10. Chris Jericho

What? Universal Championship

Advertisement

When? Late 2016, early 2017

Why? After initially only intending to stick around until WrestleMania 32, Chris Jericho’s 2016 return ended up lasting some 17 months and producing one of the best runs of his career.

His creation of the List of Jericho, the ridiculous scarf-and-trunks combo and a catchphrase as simple as “stupid idiot” were enough to see the six-time world champion totally reinvent himself at 45 years young.

Eventually aligning with Kevin Owens in mid-to-late 2016, the pair’s antics consistently produced the most entertaining segments on Raw, while they also found success in the ring with Owens winning the Universal title.

From there, the timing seemed perfect for their partnership to implode at some point down the line and have Jericho go after Owens’ title. Though the team did disband, Owens would lose the strap to the aforementioned Goldberg before he and Jericho feuded for the US title instead.

Naturally, that didn’t have quite the same impact, while it also saw Jericho miss out on a world title swansong that few would’ve begrudged him based on his recent work.

9. Tajiri

What? Cruiserweight Championship

Advertisement

When? Early 2017

Why? In September 2016, WWE brought the Cruiserweight Championship back to its main roster. Four months later, the company also brought Tajiri back, a former three-time holder of the previous incarnation of the belt.

Tajiri had featured in the 2016 Cruiserweight Classic, where he not only proved he could still cut the mustard but that he was also still over with a WWE crowd. That led to him later debuting on the new 205 Live show in January 2017. However, his run was cut short by a knee injury and by the time he was cleared to return, the company no longer wanted him.

Age was said to be a factor, but with 205 Live faltering and Tajiri still being over with the audience, one last run with the revived belt would have been a fitting finale for the 46-year-old, while it may also have benefited the perception of the division to have a familiar face at the top of it.

8. Mark Henry

What? WWE Championship

Advertisement

When? Money in the Bank 2013

Why? As a former Olympian, you could argue Mark Henry was deserving of more than just one world title reign in WWE (not including the ECW belt) and the company had a chance to do something about that in the summer of 2013.

Heading into Money in the Bank, Henry showed up on the 17 June 2013, Raw to seemingly announce his retirement. Tagging onto the end of a John Cena promo, Henry gave a heartfelt, teary-eyed speech that had everybody watching fooled – including Cena, who’d shortly be taking a World’s Strongest Slam once Henry revealed the swerve.

The whole thing had been a ruse, and a thoroughly believable one at that. A match for Cena’s WWE title was scheduled as a result, but Henry lost in his one-time shot.

On top of his Olympian credentials and the Oscar-worthy performance with the retirement tease, June 2013 was something of a lull period as far as the WWE title picture was concerned, so where was the harm in giving Henry one last run on top, even if it were only for a week or two?

7. Goldust

What? Intercontinental Championship

Advertisement

When? Mid-2014

Why? At the 2013 Royal Rumble, Goldust made one of his many returns to WWE, except this time he looked better than ever. A combination of sobriety and DDP Yoga had seen him get into the shape of his life at 44 years of age, and though the Rumble appearance was just a cameo, the comeback became a full-time one nine months later in September.

Teaming with his real-life brother Cody Rhodes, an awesome angle saw the pair get one up on the Authority and save their jobs in the process, before the duo won the Tag Team Championship on the 14 October showing of Raw.

Though the pairing ultimately ran its course, the run had rejuvenated Goldust’s career to the point that one last Intercontinental title reign – some 18 years after he first held the belt – wasn’t out of the question.

Instead, the summer of 2014 saw the mid-card belt flip-flop back-and-forth between The Miz and Dolph Ziggler, while Goldust gradually slipped down the ranks as the momentum he’d gathered was lost.

6. Christian

What? World Heavyweight Championship

Advertisement

When? Anytime before he was phased out…

Why? While you can usually pinpoint an exact point in time at which someone should’ve won back a championship, it’s difficult to do that with Christian, mainly because his in-ring career was concluded so abruptly.

After several years of service, Christian was quietly demoted to pre-show discussion panels and talk show segments with no actual announcement of a formal retirement – not the best reward for risking life and limb in all those TLC matches…

Plus, there was unfinished business as far as Christian was concerned when it came to his previous world title runs.

Having waited almost 13 years to capture his maiden world championship, he’d lose the belt just five days later – two days, if we don’t include the tape delay. Even his second reign only lasted four weeks before dropping the title back to Randy Orton at SummerSlam 2011.

In short, Christian deserved one final stint as world champion, partly to give him a proper send-off and partly to atone for the brevity of his earlier spells with the gold.

5. The British Bulldog

What? European Championship

Advertisement

When? Late 1997

Why? Unfortunately for the British Bulldog, he was robbed of a title run while he was still going strong with the company.

Back when the European Championship still meant something, at the September 1997 One Night Only show, a last-minute change of heart saw the Bulldog booked to lose the belt to Shawn Michaels in Birmingham, England. The logic was that he’d then regain the gold at a subsequent pay-per-view in his hometown of Manchester, England.

However, that Manchester PPV never materialised, and neither did Bulldog’s rematch.

Instead, Michaels held the belt for three more months before laying down for Triple H in December, making a mockery of the title in the process. During that reign, the infamous Montreal Screwjob also went down, which saw relations reach a nadir between the company and the British Bulldog (Bulldog being the brother-in-law of the departing Bret Hart).

In October ‘99, he did get another run with the belt, but it was two years too late and by then the championship had been devalued beyond repair.

4. Mick Foley

What? WWF Championship

Advertisement

When? Royal Rumble 2000

Why? At the turn of the millennium, Mick Foley’s feud with Triple H saw him almost go out on the highest of high notes. Almost, because there was no world title win to show for his efforts.

After defeat in a Street Fight at the Royal Rumble, Foley then lost in a Hell in a Cell match at No Way Out and in doing so was forced to retire.

Five weeks later he was back in the ring, once again challenging for Triple H’s title at WrestleMania 2000.

So, if Foley wasn’t retiring after all, did Triple H really need to beat him at three successive PPVs? Surely the challenger could’ve won at least once before dropping the belt back to Triple H, which would ultimately still put the new guy over.

If he’d won the title at the Rumble, where he returned as Cactus Jack for the occasion, he’d have got his deserved nostalgia run that his performances had warranted, while there’d also have been time for Triple H to regain the belt either inside Hell in a Cell or at 'Mania.

3. Jerry Lawler

What? WWE Championship

Advertisement

When? Elimination Chamber 2011

Why? It's hard to say what’s more astonishing – Jerry Lawler’s purported record of 168 career title wins, the fact that none of those reigns came in WWE, or how he almost ended that drought in 2011 at the ripe old age of 61.

Though it sounds bad on paper, Lawler’s feud with The Miz exceeded expectations, in both arenas and the ratings, to the point that a one-off TV match ended up becoming a full-fledged PPV programme.

After stealing the show but coming up short in a TLC match on Raw, Lawler won a battle royal in the New Year to set-up a rematch at Elimination Chamber.

With this being Lawler’s one-and-only shot at sensationally entering WrestleMania as champion, there was already plenty of emotion behind the feud. Then, a week before the PPV, Lawler’s mother passed away.

That, combined with Lawler’s age and his recent resurgence, meant that crazily enough, the timing and circumstances just felt right to pull the trigger on a true feel-good title win. Plus, having Miz immediately win the title back, possibly even the very next night, would likely have given him a fair amount of heat heading into 'Mania.

2. Ric Flair

What? WWE Championship

Advertisement

When? Monday Night Raw, 26 November 2007

Why? In late November of 2007, and in his hometown of Charlotte, NC, Ric Flair showed up on Raw for the first time in months. It was teased he might’ve been there to formally announce his retirement, and though Flair himself shut those rumours down in declaring “I’ve got too much juice left,” Vince McMahon clearly had other ideas.

Just because he could, McMahon emerged to issue Flair an ultimatum – lose your next match and your career would be over. And the first order of business? A match with WWE Champion Randy Orton, and a match that Flair would go on to win, typically, by rolling up Orton and grabbing a handful of tights after hitting a low blow.

However, Orton’s title hadn’t been on the line, so while Flair had saved his career, he wasn’t crowned champion and nor did he get another shot.

Given the location and the backstory, this was another case – much like with Lawler in 2011 – where the timing just felt perfect to give a soon-to-be-retired legend one last moment in the sun.

1. Sting

What? WWE World Heavyweight Championship

Advertisement

When? 2015

Why? Having avoided WWE his entire career, Sting finally signed on the dotted line in 2014 at 55 years of age. Don’t let the number fool you though, because the former WCW stalwart had barely missed a step.

Initially feuding with Triple H, Sting proved at WrestleMania 31 that he very much still had it, before going above and beyond at Night of Champions in a WWE title bout with Seth Rollins.

Of course, a neck injury sustained in the latter of those matches would ultimately force him to hang up his boots, meaning that the only man to have held the NWA, WCW and TNA World Championships bowed out without adding the WWE title to that list.

Whether it was at ‘Mania 31, during the build-up to Night of Champions or at that September PPV itself, one last world title run would’ve cemented Sting’s legacy and given him an idyllic sign-off. And just in like so many of these instances, he could still have gone on to drop the title back to Rollins to ensure the new guy went over in the end.

Advertisement