11 Biggest Missteps On The Road To WrestleMania 38

Plots with potholes, stories with speedbumps, dead-end angles. And yet, here we are.

By Scott Carlson /

Let’s let everyone in on a secret: WrestleMania 38 itself is probably going to be a really fun time for most fans. There’s going to be a lot of glitz and glam, a ton of pyro, big entrances, flashy presentations, and yes, some good wrestling sprinkled in.

Advertisement

But none of that means that the road to get to WrestleMania is enjoyable, logical or well-constructed. In fact, several of the paths are laden with potholes, speedbumps, detours and outright “road closed” signs, to continue the metaphor. If you’re a fan who doesn’t care about the journey, just the destination, then you’re probably OK with this and willing to overlook a lot of the crap.

For fans who remember the long build of angles and matches in the weeks and months prior to each year’s Mania, watching stuff get slapped together in a loose haphazard way can be maddening. Hearing one wrestler complain they can’t get booked on Mania while others just get added to bouts by existing defies any logic. Teasing an encounter with a legend where expectations are questionable leaves you confused. Having celebrities booked above your actual champions in mind-boggling.

Sure, there have been some successes in the lead-up to WM 38, but this isn’t the article for those. These are the shortcomings that WWE is hoping its fans will quickly forget once the pomp and circumstance of Mania begins.

Let’s get to it…

11. WrestleMania SmackDown (And Raw)

A recent phenomenon for WWE, the company apparently has decided that not only is WrestleMania too big for one night, two nights aren’t big enough to contain everything.

Advertisement

Enter: WrestleMania SmackDown. What could only be described as a desperate way to make fans care about the last show before the big PPV – er, PLE – now sees WWE booking an Intercontinental Championship match and the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal for the blue brand go-home show rather than finding space over the course of two nights.

The go-home show should be the hard sell for Mania, tying up loose ends, and possibly adding some late stakes to any other matches. At worst, any matches on that show should have ramifications for Mania. Instead, it looks more and more like a spillover for the excess of WM 38 and less like something of importance.

For God’s sake, the Andre battle royal, once a 30-man match that produced the near-iconic moment of Cesaro slamming Big Show out of the ring, now consists of 17 men because “budget cuts” have shrunk the rosters to the point where you can’t even get to 20 viable entrants.

And of course, we also got “WrestleMania Raw” this Monday, so the Mania branding continues to expand.

10. Vince’s Involvement And Disappearing Act

It wasn’t long ago that Vince McMahon was thrust back onto television into his new role as a mumbling Crypt Keeper mentor to Austin Theory.

Advertisement

As baffling and silly as this role seemed, at least WWE was committed to the bit, to give Theory a proper rub by being Vince’s new protégé/henchman, right?

Wrong.

In recent weeks, McMahon has been name-dropped several times, but he’s disappeared from WWE programming. He hasn’t been seen with Theory as he had previously. Even in the wake of his appearance on Pat McAfee’s podcast, where he offered the announcer a match at Mania, we haven’t gotten a great (or really any) explanation of why Vince then booked his protégé against McAfee.

There actually was potential here for this rivalry to be something interesting by being Vince-adjacent, but now it’s just a supposed up-and-comer fighting an announcer who has just two NXT matches to his name. When you talk about dropped balls, this has to be right up there.

9. Celebrity Involvement

WrestleMania always has had celebrities and non-wrestling personalities involved in some capacity. Nearly every Mania has one mainstream celebrity figure, even if it’s some D-list reality TV star. (No, Miz doesn’t count.)

Advertisement

Taken individually, the inclusion of Logan Paul, Johnny Knoxville or Pat McAfee in WrestleMania 38 are fine ideas. Each one can carry themselves through a smoke-and-mirrors match that has the potential to over-deliver.

But booking all three men in matches, while your United States and Intercontinental Champions sit on the sidelines? Come on. You’re going to have three matches with guys who have a collective three matches (if you count Knoxville’s appearance in the Royal Rumble this year) between them. Rey and Dominik Mysterio will be selling for Paul, Zayn will flail around for Knoxville, and Theory will heel it up against McAfee.

It's overkill, even with two nights of Mania.

8. WWE Championship Hijinks

It’s hard to believe but there already have been three WWE Championship title changes in three months this year, when there were three in all of 2021.

Advertisement

We saw Big E enter 2022 as the WWE Champion, with fans happy that the big man finally was getting the recognition he deserved (but disappointed in the lackluster title reign). He dropped the title to Brock Lesnar at Day One in a match where the Beast was added to the multi-man field at the last minute. Then Brock dropped the title to Bobby Lashley at Royal Rumble due to Roman Reigns’ interference.

Brock then won the Rumble that night and then won the WWE Championship back at Elimination Chamber. Now, Big E is home with a broken neck sustained in a nothing tag match as part of a mid-card feud, and Lashley returned from the sidelines to challenge Omos in an instant grudge match.

The hot-potato nature of the WWE title is a bit silly when you think about it, and when you realize that Roman Reigns has had his title on lockdown for 575+ days. That flux in the build to WrestleMania is just haphazard and a bit disjointed, and it makes the title seem secondary to the blood feud between Lesnar and Reigns.

And really, is there a reason for needing the WWE Championship as part of this feud, other than for the marketing of the match? More on that later…

7. So, Is Austin Wrestling?

This really is a simple question that deserves a simple answer: Is “Stone Cold” Steve Austin going to actually wrestle on Saturday, or are we just getting a brawl punctuated by a Stunner?

Advertisement

There is really nothing wrong with either option, but WWE has been building this up for weeks as if Austin is coming out of retirement at WrestleMania 38. That, or they assume every fan has the memory of a goldfish.

The popular talking point is that it’s been 19 years since Austin stepped in the ring. And that’s mostly true: He retired from in-ring competition after WrestleMania 19 and hasn’t had a match since. However, Austin has gotten physical numerous times throughout the years, as a guest referee at WM 20 and 23, and in a talk show segment at WM 21. Hell, he hit a Stunner the last time WrestleMania was in Dallas in 2018 at WM 32!

If you’re billing this as some monumental moment, you have to deliver way more than some verbal sparring between Austin and Kevin Owens, and way more than KICK, WHAM, STUNNER! Right? If so, wouldn’t you announce it as such or bill it as such? And if it’s the former, then why overhype it? The only excuse here would be Austin himself refusing to actually have a match, because he retired, but he’ll do an extended brawl to show he’s still got it.

Regardless, Austin and KO should deliver a memorable moment for fans, but all of this, including the weird build with Owens carrying the entire “feud” himself – because the hook is supposed to be a verbal confrontation at Mania.

6. Secondary Titles Ignored

If you’re one of those fans who fondly remembers the legendary WrestleMania III match between “Macho Man” Randy Savage and Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat for the Intercontinental Championship, you’re not alone.

Advertisement

But if you’re lamenting how WWE has managed to leave defense of both the IC title and United States Championship off the biggest show of the year (while including three celebrity matches across two nights), then you haven’t been paying attention.

It’s absolutely disgusting – but not surprising – that WWE put their secondary titles on two underutilized but fairly popular superstars in Ricochet and Finn Balor, then treated them like second-class citizens, keeping their feuds off Mania.

Ricochet lost twice to two talented tag wrestlers in separate singles matches last week to set up a triple threat IC title defense – at WrestleMania SmackDown. And Balor – who defeated Damian Priest in a match viewed as a vehicle for Priest’s full heel turn and presumably to set up a Mania rematch – is just participating in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal on WrestleMania Smackdown. Finn's feud with Priest seems to have faded to the background.

But hey, Logan Paul, Johnny Knoxville and Pat McAfee have gotten plenty of TV time and build for their respective Mania matches.

5. They’re Fighting Over A Talk Show

Longtime fans might remember an infamous WrestleMania match between Edge and Booker T that saw them fighting over the right to be the spokesman for a Japanese shampoo.

Advertisement

Well, we got the pseudo-equivalent last month when former tag partners Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins wrestled for the right to host a WrestleMania talk show with “Stone Cold” Steve Austin as the guest.

What made this particularly deplorable was that Owens seeded the entire feud, called out Austin, and then succeeded when Stone Cold responded because he was p*ssed off at KO. So then Rollins tried to copy the idea, leading the idiot authority figures to book a match between the two for the talk show. Never mind that Austin was coming because of Owens, not to just gab, we had a nonsensical Raw main event to book.

The entire deal was mind-numbingly stupid and made no sense… and then they repeated it the following week with Rollins and AJ Styles! Worse, WWE then undercut the entire angle Monday when Vince McMahon mocked the Drip God for jumping through those stupid hoops instead of just asking him for a Mania match.

Idiotic.

4. THE BIGGEST WRESTLEMANIA MATCH OF ALL TIME

Sorry, but that needs to be screamed at you in all-caps.

Advertisement

WWE is very prone to overhyping and overselling matches with superlatives they don’t deserve, but calling the third WrestleMania match between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns the biggest Mania match of all time is just a bit too much, isn’t it? We’ve seen them tangle at WM 31 and 34 (with Brock winning both), plus a few other PPV matches sprinkled in.

Oh, but this one is now for two titles. Yeah, let’s look at that. Roman cost Brock the WWE Championship at the Royal Rumble PLE, so Lesnar entered the Rumble and won the match, then announced he was challenging Reigns. Done. Easy.

But then Brock won the WWE Championship, adding that title to the mix. At first, they called it “Champion vs. Champion,” then “Winner Take All,” and finally settled on “Championship Unification.” So that would suggest that one of the two titles is going away, right? They wouldn’t actually do away with the WWE Championship, the most prestigious title, a 59-year-old championship with an unparalleled lineage (and Jinder Mahal), in favor of the Universal Championship, would they?

Regardless, this sell-job is overkill. The plot and interactions between Roman and Brock are selling the match, not the fact two titles are involved, or that the official tagline for this match is: “The Biggest WrestleMania Match of All Time, Winner take all, Championship Unification Match!”

Like we said, overkill.

3. Stupendous!

Marketing is obviously an important component of the WrestleMania machine.

Advertisement

But marketing is often thought of as a smart, well-thought-out effort that uses logic, time-tested practices and maybe even focus groups. In WWE, it’s just Vince McMahon plucking an obscure word from the dictionary, slapping it on a graphic and making his announcers and talent use the word repeatedly in all conversations about Mania, as if that is some genius strategy.

And thus, “The most STUPENDOUS two-night WrestleMania in history!” was born. For the record, this literally is only the third two-night Mania in history, the first being the empty Performance Center WrestleMania 36 that is never shown on TV. But yeah, let’s go with it.

It’s just an insanely stupid “marketing” ploy that feels riveted onto every comment from an announcer or wrestler at this point, as even some superstars are using it in an almost derisive or sarcastic way.

But the fact that a billion-dollar company heading into its 38th annual version of the Super Bowl is just using mindless and meaningless buzzwords to set the template for marketing is another head-shaking moment on the Road to WrestleMania.

2. Edge’s Inexplicable Heel Turn

We should all be able to agree that Heel Edge, the Rated-R Superstar, is much better than Grit Edge, the family man.

Advertisement

But then, Blue Man Edge, the walking thesaurus, made his debut last month, and suddenly fans are looking back fondly at Grit Edge. You would think that a feud between AJ Styles and Edge would be a dream where you want to watch every step along the way, but instead, you find yourself wanting them to hurry up and get to the fireworks factory and have the WrestleMania match.

This version of Edge is legit change-the-channel energy. His promos are melodramatic nonsense, filled with ridiculous phrases like, “mountain of omnipotence,” all illuminated inexplicably with a blue light.

It has to be seen to be believed, but it’s just awful. Worse, it’s just made the journey to WrestleMania look worse and less appealing. If you can’t enjoy a Hall-of-Famer feuding with one of the best wrestlers in the world in the lead-up to Mania, then that’s an indictment of the company booking them.

1. Seth’s Challenging Road

To be fair, this item already had the top spot before WWE Raw this week. But Monday’s developments cemented its dubious position.

Advertisement

Seth Rollins, a multi-time world champion who has main-evented WrestleMania in the past, just couldn’t seem to find a path to WrestleMania 38. First, he and Kevin Owens failed to win the Raw Tag Team Championship. Then he tried to steal KO’s idea and ended up in a match to determine who would host a Mania talk show with “Stone Cold” Steve Austin.

Failing there, he tried the same thing with AJ Styles, trying to get his match with Edge. And once again, the idiot authority figures booked a match that Rollins lost. Finally, Seth went berserk and threatened to hold Raw hostage, which led to a meeting with Vince McMahon that just unravelled the previous month.

You see, Seth could have just asked for a match at Mania. In fact, Vince thought he was an idiot for jumping through all of those hoops, and by extension, we fans were idiots for watching and following along on this storyline. Literally, none of it mattered, and the end result was Rollins dancing and cackling around McMahon’s office.

This was supposed to be a significant storyline, as it presumably is leading to the return of Cody Rhodes, and yet, it was all rendered meaningless, making fans fools for getting invested. Worse, none of it was logical, interesting, or even good in the first place.

Epic failure. And yet, Mania might still deliver on multiple fronts, so what does that say about all of this?

Advertisement