WWE history is lined with Superstars who had the look, the talent and the charisma to be major stars for the company but, for whatever reason, never panned out the way both they and management would have hoped. Whether it was poor timing, inability to live up to potential, backstage politics or the company heading in a new direction, there are several hugely talented men and women that have seen their time with the biggest wrestling promotion on the planet come to a premature end. Some more than once. With a roster as overcrowded and extremely talented as the one the company has today, it is likely that several very talented performers will be let go before they have the opportunity to really showcase what they can bring to the table. With that in mind and with hindsight being what it is, here are 11 Superstars gone from World Wrestling Entertainment far too soon.
11. Christy Hemme
The winner of the 2004 Diva Search, Christy Hemme became a major player in WWE's women's division quickly after her victory. Just seven months into her career, she was featured on the cover of Playboy magazine and was booked in the Women's Championship match against Trish Stratus at WrestleMania 21. Christy was featured on the cover of the 2005 Divas swimsuit special and was presented as the top female babyface on the roster following Lita's injury in January. Yet, despite the major push she was given, she was quickly drafted to SmackDown and paired with the latest incarnation of the Legion of Doom, Road Warrior Animal and Heidenreich. Then, suddenly in November of 2005, she was released from her contract with little or no reason for such a drastic move. Sure, she was still in the infancy of her wrestling training and had not delivered much in the way of good matches but to release her so soon was shocking. She would go on to TNA, where she showed great promise as a spunky underdog competitor, especially in matches against Awesome Kong, but a neck injury ended her time in the ring before it could really get going. She has served as a ring announcer for the company for quite some time now and recently joined the creative team, where she can put her mind to use by coming up with new and exciting concepts for the marketing of the company, as well as the occasional storyline idea. Had WWE kept her around, Christy could have become the face of the Divas division or, at the very least, been key in the marketing and merchandising of the company's female performers.
10. Rene Dupree
"The French Phenom" made his WWE debut in 2003 at the ripe age of 19 and almost immediately became World Tag Team champion with Sylvain Grenier in La Resistance. The team was a solid heel team for WWE but it was clear that Dupree was significantly better than Grenier and capable of starring on his own. In April of 2004, he was drafted to SmackDown for what was meant to be his first singles push. After a brief feud with John Cena and a few months in the United States Championship hunt, he was thrown into a tag team with Kenzo Suzuki. From there, he floated around the SmackDown roster with little or nothing to do. After a months-long absence from television, he eventually popped up on the relaunched ECW brand. After a few losses, he disappeared again, returning to ECW in early 2007 and reuniting with Grenier. Unfortunately, Dupree would fail a Wellness Policy test and be suspended. Not long afterward, he was released from his contract. Dupree was a physical specimen. He looked every bit the part of a professional wrestler and at only 19 when he made his debut, many envisioned him as the star of the future for World Wrestling Entertainment. While he clearly had a presence about him and a measurable charisma, he was given too much, too soon and was never allowed to properly develop. Had the company taken its time with Dupree, he is a competitor who could easily still be starring for them today. Especially since he is still only 30 years old today.
9. Chris Masters
The Masterpiece was fired not once, but twice, both times far too early. Debuting in 2005, Masters' entire gimmick was centered around the idea that he looked like a Greek god. He had an elaborate entrance in which he did a few poses while pyro rained down behind him. He was a physical specimen whose look was his gimmick and whose wrestling skills paled in comparison to the Superstars who he beat on a weekly basis. But, despite his look and the push that came with it, Masters always put in great effort. It was clear to see that he was not a performer willing to rest on his laurels because he was handed a push right out of the gate. Matches with John Cena, Shawn Michaels, Kane and Big Show indicated that there was more to Masters than a bunch of muscles. Every bit of work he put in to improve with each passing match, however, was undone by two Wellness Policy suspensions and a subsequent release from his contract. The first firing was completely Masters' fault. He had been popped with a positive test once before and still continued to put things into his body that he knew would not be tolerated. It was a harsh lesson for the talented young star to learn but one that he absolutely had to if he wished to ever succeed in the industry. Masters would make a splash on the independents scene, cutting down his weight and mass and becoming a much better worker as a result. He was smoother, had a better understanding of psychology and learned from working with wrestlers of varying styles. It was his improvement and the buzz surrounding his work on the indies that got him a second shot with WWE. To the fans that had seen him before, the Masters that returned to the company was almost a completely different person. He was faster, better and smarter than he had been before and it showed as he competed on SmackDown against the likes of MVP and Matt Hardy. When he was drafted back to Raw, it looked like he may have a chance at achieving the success the company had hoped for him in his first go-round with them. Unfortunately, he became a lower midcard star whose biggest accomplishment was appearing at WrestleMania XXVI and popping his pecs. Masters was released on April 25, 2011, ending his career with WWE. This time, it felt as though WWE had made a big mistake. Masters was still young, still had a great look and could have easily been a contender for the company's Intercontinental or United States Championships. Unfortunately, the stigma that surrounded him following his first run haunted him and made those in management hesitant to see him as anything but a utility player.
8. Nidia
The Tough Enough season one winner, Nidia was a great character during her days on SmackDown with Jamie Noble. Straight out of the trailer parks of West Virginia, Nidia and Noble were the epitome of redneck trailer trash. Their idea of a fancy meal was a night out at Applebees and they had absolutely no problem engaging in explicit displayed of public affection. With Noble as the Cruiserweight champion, or at least a top contender to it, they quickly became one of the most entertaining acts on SmackDown. Nidia, in particular, had a knack for entertaining the audience. Whether it was outside the ring during Noble's matches, in pre-taped segments or in matches of her own, the camera was drawn to her. Not only because she was smoking hot but also because of the little things she would do to get the character over. While Noble was a great wrestler, the steak to Nidia's sizzle in the pairing, it was clear that the young Diva was the star of the group. When she was drafted to Monday Night Raw in 2004, many believed she was finally going to get her opportunity to become a star in the Divas division. He ring work had steadily improved over her two years on SmackDown and she was clearly ready to prove her worth against some of the most decorated women's wrestlers in the industry. She did just that, putting in strong performances in matches against Molly Holly, Victoria and Jazz before earning a shot at Trish Stratus' Women's Championship. She lost that match but there was a buzz building around Nidia and the indisputable potential she was showing on a weekly basis. Then it happened. On November 3, 2004, she was released from her WWE contract. No one knew why but the impending invasion of models-turned-wrestlers from the much-maligned Diva Search likely had something to do with it. Which is a shame because WWE could have had a highly successful young performer on its roster who suddenly found herself thrown away like a piece of garbage in favor of girls who had no passion for the industry that they were entering. Since her release, Nidia has stayed out of the public eye for the most part. She made a handful of independent appearances and still pops up for the occasional autograph convention but by and large, she remains out of the spotlight.
7. Shad Gaspard
As part of Cryme Tyme for the better part of four years, Shad Gaspard was a very popular performer for WWE. With JTG by his side, the athletic big man tore through the tag team division, becoming the most over duo the company produced during that period of time. Highly stereotypical and slightly offensive, the Cryme Tyme gimmick still managed to strike a chord with the audience, who loved the hijinx they played on opposing teams. In 2007, the team was briefly released from their contracts following a controversial incident in which they put their hands on a referee during an unplanned spot at a house show. When they returned to the company, the team proved to be as over as ever and even appeared by John Cena's side during his feud with JBL in the summer of 2008. By 2010, however, the team had become somewhat stale and despite the fact that they remained hugely over, the decision was made to split them up. Shad turned on JTG and adopted a more aggressive, meaner attitude. At Extreme Rules in April of 2010, they met in a Leather Strap match. JTG won the match but in the weeks that followed, Shad began to introduce a new character to the WWE Universe. It was dropped before it ever debuted, however, and Shad was released from his contract in November. While many would consider what Shad had as part of Cryme Tyme to be a successful stint with WWE, one cannot help but wonder what could have been had he been able to debut that new character on television. He looked the part, was cutting solid enough promos under his new persona and could have at least been a fine part of WWE's midcard, where he could have worked with the likes of Kofi Kingston, Dolph Ziggler, Cody Rhodes, Ted DiBiase and the members of Nexus, potentially growing into a very good worker before all was said and done. Potential does not buy groceries, though, and the company thought he was expendable.
6. Ted DiBiase
The third-generation star had a ton of hype surrounding him as he made his WWE debut in 2008. A great looking young kid with tremendous fundamentals and a bloodline that produced one of the greatest villains of all-time in "Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase, the young man seemingly had every tool needed to achieve greatness in the biggest wrestling company in the world. John Cena, the face of WWE and this generation's biggest star, even listed DiBiase among those young talents good enough to one day end The Undertaker's much-celebrated Streak. DiBiase's first claim to fame came as one-half of the WWE Tag Team champions with partner Cody Rhodes. Eventually, that tandem would go on to partner with Randy Orton in Legacy, a group of second- and third-generation stars that became the lead heel stable on Monday Night Raw. They often feuded with Triple H, Shawn Michaels, CM Punk and Kofi Kingston and produced some very fine wrestling matches in the fall of 2008 and spring of 2009. DiBiase and Rhodes' star power increased ten-fold when they feuded with a reunited D-Generation X in the fall of '09. Two high profile pay-per-view matches resulted, including the main event of Hell in a Cell in October, and both men looked to be well on their way to achieving everything the company ever had planned for them. The breakup of Legacy in March of 2010 adversely affected DiBiase in ways that few could have imagined. A solid wrestler with the a great last name, he lacked natural charisma. He was not an over-the-top persona, nor did he have particularly strong verbal skills. When the bell rang, he was fine but unfortunately for him, the wrestling business is as much show as it is ring performance and he was lacking that element. Today, WWE has reintroduced managers to the product. Paul Heyman, Zeb Colter and Lana do a superb job of speaking for talents that are not talented enough to connect with audiences through interviews but are tremendously skilled from bell to bell. Cesaro, Jack Swagger and Rusev are three competitors on today's roster benefiting greatly because of their spokespeople. Ted DiBiase was in dire need of a manager during his time with the roster. Had he been given Colter or Heyman, he would still be in the company today and may even be in the mix for a main event push. Instead, he was given Maryse as a heater. As drop dead gorgeous as she may have been, she was hardly the spokesperson type and DiBiase continued to fail to make that all-important connection. In 2013, after two years of doing very little of substance in WWE, DiBiase allowed his contract to run out without signing an extension. While he was not sacked by WWE as were the rest of the performers on this list, the company still let DiBiase go before they really exhausted all efforts to make him the star so many expected him to be. He is at peace spending time with his family and participating in many faith-based organizations today,
5. Luke Gallows
The former Festus improved significantly under the guidance of CM Punk, becoming his right hand man in the critically acclaimed Straight Edge Society faction. A big man with great agility and speed, he was the perfect muscle for the mouthy Punk, who often times needed help in battling the likes of Rey Mysterio, The Undertaker and Big Show. Able to stand up to any competitor based on size alone, he was absolutely an asset to Punk and the vision that he had for the SES. As was the case at the time with Punk, management seemed to go out of their way to the hold him back, to prevent him from reaching the next level of success in WWE. When the faction got as hot as it did, to the point that old ladies were referring to Punk as the devil, it was clear that there was a ton of money to be made with them as the lead antagonists in WWE. What that meant then was that Punk had to be humbled. After all, the group was his creation, his baby. The Straight Edge Society was routinely beat in handicap matches by Big Show until it was brought to a premature end in the fall of 2010. Rather than coming up with something else for Gallows to do, something that could have been useful to the company, they released the big man in November of that same year. At only 30 years old, it is still quite shocking that WWE could not have sidelined him for a few weeks, maybe months, and come up with something for him to do rather than letting him walk away and be of use somewhere else. Luckily for Vince McMahon's company, TNA did not know how to get the most out of Gallows either or they may have been kicking themselves over making a major mistake.
4. Elijah Burke
One of the few standouts during the first year of the relaunched ECW was Elijah Burke. A young, charismatic talker with great athleticism and an unconventional style, he carried himself as a star and came across the way whenever he appeared on screen. His cadence and delivery while cutting promos was completely different than any other on the show and he began gaining a groundswell of support from fans across the internet that perceived as cool and different. When WWE devised the New Breed faction, made up of some of the bright young heels from ECW in early 2007, Burke was the natural leader of the group. He was the spokesman and the clear breakout star. After several very solid showings against Rob Van Dam, CM Punk and Tommy Dreamer, it was clear that he had the tools necessary to succeed in the sports-entertainment world of WWE. Yet after the New Breed angle wrapped up, Burke became somewhat irrelevant. Sure, he had a pay-per-view match against CM Punk and was one of the talents drafted to SmackDown later that year but he was largely unused and when he was, it was to put other Superstars over. Everything he accomplished in the short lifespan of the group came undone thanks to the way he was used immediately afterward. Becoming lost in the shuffle and with no particular momentum to speak of, Burke was quietly released in November of 2008. He would go on to star in TNA Wrestling as "The Pope" D;Angelo Dinero. He was an upper-level performer who competed in the TNA Championship main event of Lockdown in 2010. It was there that the full scope of Burke's abilities were realized and though his stint with that company was short-lived as well, fans got a taste of what should have been in WWE.
3. Mike Awesome
The stench of World Championship Wrestling was all over Mike Awesome when he made his WWE debut in June of 2001 and the all-time great big man was never fully able to recover. The "Fat Chick Thriller" and "That 70's Guy" gimmicks had so deteriorated the reputation of a performer who had become one of the best workers in the world just months prior in ECW that he was damaged goods when WWE picked up his contract during their purchase of WCW, which is a shame because at his best, Awesome was a revolutionary worker, the likes of which the wrestling world has not seen since. Awesome was a big man by height and weight standards but he could move with the quickness and agility of a cruiserweight. He was a hard hitter, a brawler by nature, but could fly through the air with nearly unmatched grace. He built a name for himself thanks to barbaric wars with Masato Tanaka in both Japan and ECW and earned the respect of every fan he ever competed in front of. WCW, a company that never truly understood how to market a competitor to their strengths, saddled him with ridiculous gimmicks rather than letting him be exactly what his name indicated: awesome. When he arrived in WWE, he won the Hardcore Championship but held it very briefly. From there, he formed a tag team with Lance Storm, whom he partnered with in the dying days of WCW, but the tandem never gained any traction. On September 27, 2002, he was released from his contract after a year of doing absolutely nothing. The backstage politics had clearly taken their toll on Awesome, who stayed out of the spotlight in America, for the most part, and returned to Japan. In 2005, he returned to WWE for ECW: One Night Stand, where he defeated Tanaka in an outstanding match. Sadly, Awesome's life was cut short in 2007, when he committed suicide. He was just 42.
2. Gail Kim
When Gail Kim arrived in World Wrestling Entertainment in the summer of 2003, she made an immediate impact. She captured the Women's Championship and looked to be poised to become one of the company's top female talents. Unfortunately, the creative team did a miserable job of expanding the character, never giving fans a reason to care about the beautiful young competitor and as a result, she was greeted with silence upon her entrance to the squared circle. She quickly lost the title and was paired with Molly Holly in an attempt to get her some heat. It did not work and for two years, Kim wasted her time and potential as a bit player in one of the most talented women's divisions WWE has ever assembled. In November of 2004, she was released from her contract. Rather than sit around and complain, the former Women's champion set out to make sure it was the biggest mistake the company could have made. She worked the independents before signing with TNA Wrestling in 2005. After serving as a manager for two years, she was finally allowed to prove herself in the ring against the likes of Awesome Kong, Angelina Love, Velvet Sky, ODB and the underrated Roxxi Laveaux. It was against those women, particularly Kong, that Kim proved to be among the best women's wrestlers in North America. When TNA foolishly let her go rather than paying her more to stay, WWE signed Kim to a second contract. As they did the first time, they left her off of television, stuck her in meaningless matches on B- and C-level shows and wasted her prime. She would occasionally challenge for the Women's and Divas titles but otherwise, she was the fifth or sixth most important part of multi-Diva tag matches rather than the star of the division, as she should have been. At times, it almost seemed as though McMahon signed her so that TNA could not, leaving the performer herself stuck in a miserable predicament. WWE released her for a second time in 2011. Later that year, she returned to TNA and continued building her legacy as the greatest Knockout in that company's history.
1. Daniel Bryan
Okay, so this one may be cheating given the fact that Bryan recently finished the greatest stretch of his professional wrestling career, coming off WrestleMania 30 in which he won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship and was solidified as one of the top babyfaces in the company. It was because of his unrivaled skill and unquestionable determination that he was able to over two WWE releases to succeed at the level he finds himself at today. Without the two heartbreaking moments in his career, who knows if wrestling fans at large would even know who the bearded Superstar is. Many do not realize that Bryan had been signed to WWE's developmental territory Memphis Championship Wrestling way back in 2000. A graduate of Shawn Michaels' wrestling academy, he was already on the company's radar. When MCW cut ties with WWE, however, Bryan was released of his contract. That release allowed him the opportunity to work all over the globe, including Ring of Honor, where he gained his greatest notoriety. He helped build that company into the independent powerhouse it is today. Over time, he was recognized as the best wrestler in the world thanks to his striking and technical wrestling ability. In 2009, Bryan re-signed with WWE, After a brief stint in developmental, he appeared on NXT season one. Paired with The Miz as his mentor, Bryan became one of the stars of the show, which was largely garbage and only really focused on humiliating tasks and stupid tests of strength. He voluntarily eliminated himself from the show and popped up again later in the Nexus invasion angle that stunned viewers in June of 2010. It was during that angle that Bryan would partake in an act that would get him fired from WWE for a second time. As the Superstars were assaulting John Cena, referees, ring announcers and commentators, Bryan grabbed hold of Justin Roberts and began choking him out with his own necktie. The act rubbed management, the USA Network and Mattel toy company the wrong way and days later, Bryan was released from his contract. The combined effort of Pat Patterson and John Cena, coupled with continued excellence on the independent circuit, led to Bryan's rehiring. The rest is history.