11 Ups & 0 Downs From AEW Dynamite (May 31 - Review)

CM Punk is BACK and AEW roars back into life with a phenomenal post-Double Or Nothing Dynamite.

By Michael Hamflett /

AEW

Beyond a mixed tag team match booked during Sunday's Double Or Nothing and yet another "Tony Khan big announcement" segment relating directly to the debut edition of Collision, there was nothing else announced for the post-pay-per-view Double Or Nothing until hours before the show.

Advertisement

Strategy, or a reveal of some late changes to a telecast typically all locked in by Wednesday morning at the latest? And either way, is it yet another sign of things to come from an All Elite Wrestling Khan noted multiple times during Sunday's post-show scrum would be going through some changes? It was as though he was trying to cut through recent niggling criticisms there - some iffy booking for the last few months had seen several bad habits creep in, to the point that even Kris Statlander's shocking and euphoric TBS Championship came with concerns about WWE-adjacent impromptu matches.

Nonetheless, it wasn't as if there wasn't anything to get to. New Champions, new shows starting, a new game ready to drop, and some new directions for a roster in need of a shake-up. As matches were drip-fed to the world via Khan's Twitter, the anticipation built, and for more than just whatever was set for June 17th's United Center showcase.

Advertisement

Did the ends justify the means?

Let’s light the fuse…

Advertisement

Ups…

11. Blackpool Combat Club Vs Lucha Bros & Bandido

AEW

A red hot San Diego crowd and giddy Bryan Danielson at the desk kicked off Dynamite in electric style, with the Blackpool Combat Club using a brutal win over their lucha opposition as a way to toast Double Or Nothing's Anarchy In The Arena victory.

Advertisement

A ripper of an opener flashed back to Dynamites of old, thanks to the roar that (still) greets Wild Thing and two sets of over wrestlers beating the sh*t out of each other in the spirit of competition. Mostly just competition, anyway. The BCC have evolved into a quite remarkable heel outfit despite Jon Moxley and Danielson still gaining bloody-throated cheers out of sheer respect, and credit must go to Claudio Castagnoli and especially Wheeler Yuta for pushing forth the group's crueler agenda of late.

Bandido's delayed brainbuster was the peak of the offence for the opposition, but this was a haves/have-nots showcase and The BCC have it all right now. Yuta getting the winning pinfall here built on him claiming the Kenny Omega scalp days earlier, and further made up for his defeat last week. Not only does that put credit back in his account, but it puts over the successful and idiosyncratic methods of the group. Danielson preaches discipline, Mox is the new face of "Death Jitsu", and if you're not working to be as perfect a specimen as Castagnoli, what are we even doing here?

Advertisement

That wasn't entirely rhetorical. The Elite had answers, sort of...

10. The Elite Respond To Double Or Nothing Defeat

AEW

Matt Jackson's recap of the pain he endured (and was willing to dish out) during Double Or Nothing's main event kicked off an awesome post-pay-per-view response from the "heart and soul" of AEW as they tried to make sense of everything that happened on Sunday.

Advertisement

In a segment loaded with development and Elite lore (TM), an economic minute and a half found the group teasing the Blackpool Combat Club into a rematch by calling into question their real toughness, before Hangman Page was interrupted by a p*ssed off Dark Order looking for answers about his loyalty. Flapped by their interjection, he then revealed that Kenny Omega wasn't back home in Canada as reported, but somewhere else.

It didn't take much detective work to figure out where exactly Page was implying he might be, but even if Japan wasn't the location being left to linger, the actual destination could make for another unique twist. Blood & Guts and Forbidden Door are on the way, and these particular stories could easily be folded into both outcomes. Especially when Omega intimated that he was going to find two friends to deal with the problem.

Advertisement

9. Bullet Club Gold Call Out FTR

AEW

Setting the tone for the whole evening, the San Diego audience took an angle that had played as mid and forced it into feeling main event.

Advertisement

Good booking helped too. Jay White and Juice Robinson were rewarded for their awesome sh*t-talking last week by getting an in-ring segment to do more of it, and raised the ire of new rivals FTR in the process. Free for new business after their win over Jeff Jarrett and Jay Lethal, Cash and Dax answered the call, and new ally Ricky Starks saved them from a Bullet Club Gold sneak attack to set up one last singles match with ‘Switchblade’.

Everybody to a man felt part of something heated, and in the case of all but the Tag Team Champions, for the first time in a while. In terms of sequencing and protecting the meritocracy, this was an enormous step up from prior weeks, and the simple folding of an old story into a new one was a welcome sight for a show loaded with freewheeling midcarders for far too long.

Advertisement

8. Tony Khan Announces The Return Of CM PUNK

AEW

With minimal fuss and fanfare beyond dropping it earlier in the show to try and harness the buzz, Tony Khan used this week's big announcement to confirm that CM Punk would indeed be part of the debut edition of Collision.

Advertisement

It's been known news for weeks now obviously, but the need to say his name had increased over the last few weeks, not least to (hopefully) ensure the sale of all remaining tickets at the United Center and ideally boost some of the other figures for the Saturday show too.

After the Chicago destination drop drew one of the biggest pops of the week in Las Vegas, this latest news brought about a mixed response in San Diego. Expect this level of divisiveness for Punk going forward, which is probably exactly what AEW expected and will use. All roads at long last lead to June 17th and all the chaos that follows. Hopefully, Khan can park the "Huge Announcement" graphics for a while now too.

Advertisement

7. Big Bill Vs Swerve Strickland Vs Trent Bareta

AEW

San Diego was in the mood for pro g*ddamn wrestling, and this three-way offered absolutely loads of it even if the awesome Big Bill's shine portion was gobbled up by a picture-in-picture commercial break.

Advertisement

After several middling months trapped in the lamest chapters of his longstanding story with Keith Lee, Swerve Strickland built on an awesome showing in Sunday's Blackjack Battle Royal with a gripping victory here, using his particularly unique style to get around Big Bill's power game and Trent Berretta's veteran experience and skill.

Underpinned by the Double Or Nothing booking - the three all came close to taking Orange Cassidy's title before the Champion retained and made minor headlines in their own rights as a result - this had echoes of a time before rankings were needlessly binned, informed the rising heat by the finish, and set Swerve up for a singles match fans pined for after the weekend's electric exchange. Emblematic of the night at large, the match was a provisional Up before it hit the ring and delivered on its immense promise. The power might actually be back.

Advertisement

6. The Acclaimed & Daddy Ass Speak

AEW

Listen...listen...are The Acclaimed about to kick Daddy Ass to the curb?

Advertisement

It certainly felt like it during an immeasurably tense stage conversation with Renee Paquette that ostensibly ended with Max Caster and Anthony Bowens wanting Billy Gunn to get the one last title reign he deserved.

They failed at this on Sunday of course, and it hung in the air that the veteran had been responsible for their deflating loss to The House Of Black at Double Or Nothing. Whether or not this will lead to a rematch against Malakai Black, Brody King and Buddy Matthews or Caster and Bowens want to support Gunn in a futile singles pursuit was left unclear, but the subtle implication that they weren't prepared to tolerate another setback bled through.

Advertisement

A group scissor at the end could have just as easy been a sneak attack, and if that's the energy to expect for the duration of this angle, it won't be long before nobody loves The Acclaimed.

5. Don Callis & Konosuke Takeshita Can't Speak

AEW

This was perfect.

Advertisement

Pro wrestling done right, Don Callis and Konosuke Takeshita entered to a chorus of boos that would have drowned out any music had some been playing. Instead, fans were forced to watch looping images of the duo's dastardly assault on Kenny Omega, all as the pair dared to wear faces of innocence and confusion. Both elements of the presentation conspired to increase the heat to a new level.

Then Callis hit the ring and increased that.

Advertisement

Further extricating himself from Omega forever, he referred to Takeshita as the son that his "nephew" Omega could never be. Struggling to be heard on mic over the boos, he partially pleaded with Tony Schiavone as if the host that had just referred to him as "the biggest piece of human garbage" was going to help. "What am I supposed to do here" as a faux cry for help ingeniously only riled the fans up more, and the best heel-explains-his-actions segment of all time concluded with the villains barely getting half their spiel out due to the vitriol.

4. Orange Cassidy & Darby Allin Vs Gates Of Agony

AEW

Book a match to build a match featuring wrestlers people want to watch, and cool things happen.

Advertisement

A simple principle, but one that's gone slightly awry in recent weeks and months across most AEW broadcasts. Not here. Orange Cassidy and Darby Allin have linked up before as a babyface superpower unit, and this being a fixture on the same night Swerve Strickland won his way back into International Title contention was the sort of hidden contrivance that should make a worked sport so consistently appealing.

Swerve watched his Mogul Embassy associates attempt to take out the Cassidy from the stage, making it perfectly clear that the Blackjack Battle Royal showdown was, in his mind, a fluke. Gates Of Agony failed to get it done against the fan favourites, but that wasn't the story. As Swerve and Brian Cage approached the ring, Sting made a surprise appearance to ward off the heels, set up a few kick a*s trios matches, and pop the entire building. On a night where AEW felt alive again, the return of 'The Icon' felt like a celebration of the fact.

Advertisement

3. Jungle Hook Ride Again

AEW

"Hook versus a lower card act again" was set to be listed as a "Down" before a surprising reunion for a team that were split apart rather abruptly earlier this year.

Advertisement

Jack Perry arrived, chair in hand, to deal with LFI's Dralistico, Preston Vance and José The Assistant after the three had interrupted the FTW Champion's television time to steal some of their own. It was basic stuff but - like everything else on the card - the San Diego crowd came unglued for it and the segment created a thirst for an obvious tag payoff.

It wasn't without its own table-setting tease either. Perry didn't let go of that chair, and after a bruising few months of him failing to give in to his nastier side, the prevailing feeling was that he'd eventually wrap it around his partner's back. Hook will never see it coming, even if we're being instructed to.

Advertisement

2. Kris Statlander Vs Nyla Rose

AEW

Proving that a special Dynamite was occurring, this maiden TBS Championship defence for Kris Statlander occupied the typical women's match quarter hour spot but never once felt like it.

Advertisement

Hot in the building and heated in the ring, this took advantage of a tried-and-true formula for the promotion and the benefit of two perpetually over performers. Nyla Rose has played first losing challenger multiple times in the past, and this match was a reminder why. Her strength and surprising areal abilities make the task at hand look insurmountable, and the babyface battling back to get it done sets them up as a fighting champion.

And so it went. The fans were wild for Statlander's nearfalls, and wilder still for her win and first retention. For something announced on the day of the show and so transparent in its motives, this couldn't have been better. The new TBS Champion goes to 1-0, and her singular defence ended up as the most memorable match for the belt in months.

Advertisement

1. Adam Cole & Britt Baker Vs Chris Jericho & Saraya

AEW

A television main event vastly superior to the two separate singles outings between all four wrestlers over the last two pay-per-views, Adam Cole and Britt Baker's win over Chris Jericho and Saraya was an incredibly satisfying conclusion to one feud and a useful beat in another. Tonally, it was a perfect fit for the show too.

Advertisement

The work never took the match to an especially elite tier, but it didn't need to. The audience came unglued for Baker grabbing Jericho in the Lockjaw, Hikaru Shida chasing away the interfering Outcasts, and Cole getting more straightforward redemption on 'The Ocho' than he'd claimed at Double Or Nothing.

Baker and Cole looked awesome in their matching entire, carried megastar shine as unified babyfaces, and the heels ate some sh*t as a monster fan service edition of the show faded to black. More of a happy ending than a classic one, a main event had rarely felt as fine and fitting as this one. This was ticket-selling AEW content, and if Dynamite and Collision can continue to provide this, some of those blue dots on WrestleTix might finally start going grey again.

Advertisement