11 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynamite (7 Sept)
AEW proves it can have a great Dynamite without CM Punk, Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks.
Swimming down Sh*t Creek and somehow coming out clean has been an AEW hallmark since day one - and Tony Khan and co. have spent the past week trying to not get swept away by their biggest torrent of excrement yet.
The backstage chaos that has engulfed all post-All Out coverage made last night's Dynamite appointment viewing. How the promotion would address the fallout from CM Punk and The Elite's fight, including the fate of the vacated World and Trios Championships, was the biggest selling point of a night that demanded a show joyous enough to take the heat off Khan's creaking operation. Similarly, AEW had to demonstrate to messrs Jackson, Brooks, and Smith that it could put on a great show without them.
And it succeeded. Spectacularly.
This was one of the most electric Dynamites in some time. For the umpteenth time in its short history, AEW delivered big when circumstances were at their worst, showing that while the promotion's real world might be in chaos right now, its fictional world doesn't have to be.
Whether or not last night was a case of Tony Khan papering over the cracks will become clear in time. For now...
Let's light the fuse.
Down...
1. Stokely & Co. Don't Connect
Stokely Hathaway's new group addressed the Dynamite crowd after helping MJF win All Out's Casino Ladder Match, battering a stagehand in a segment that unfortunately stands as the only thing that failed to connect with the live audience on the night.
This fell flat. Hathaway was fun on the microphone, calling himself 'The King of Ladder Matches' and putting over All Out, where he scaled a ladder without resistance and handed a poker chip to MJF, the greatest night of his career. When a stagehand told him to move on, that stagehand ate dirt.
Beating up a defenceless staff member is theoretically good heat, though it didn't resonate in Buffalo and it didn't resonate through the television either. AEW must work harder to get this group over.
Ups...
11. A Workable Solution
#AEW President & CEO @TonyKhan is here to address both the #AEW World Championship & #AEW World Trios Championship. Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS right now! pic.twitter.com/jZbNwOQgZL
Advertisement— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) September 8, 2022
Tony Khan gets flak for the number of tournaments he books, but what was the AEW chief to do in this impossible situation?
CM Punk is injured. Independent of the disciplinary issues, he had to drop the AEW World Championship. Again. Khan has already gone down the interim route. MJF has a guaranteed title shot, but him holding onto it is the wiser move, presenting him as a clever, calculating heel picking his own shot. Plucking the two top-ranked wrestlers in the men's singles division and having them face off is a one-week story that doesn't come with the same attention-grabbing potential as multiple bouts through a tournament.
So the Grand Slam Tournament of Champions was the right way to go under difficult circumstances. Theoretically, it'll help television numbers for the next couple of weeks, building to a big Grand Slam main event.
For the Trios Titles, perhaps something could have been engineered through a more robust competitive framework. But Death Triangle vs. Orange Cassidy and Best Friends was right there. An easy solution to a complex problem.
Khan delivered these announcements himself, sticking rigidly to the teleprompter he appeared to be reading from. A wise choice, given his lack of composure in previous live promos.
10. Action Bronson!
Action Bronson has the kind of personality built to thrive in professional wrestling. One of hip-hop's biggest, boldest characters, he came off well in his short segment with Hook. "Hook is crazy, but you don't know about me" was a particularly nice line ahead of what looks like a Grand Slam showdown with Matt Menard and Angelo Parker.
Opposite the babyfaces, the 2point0 boys were their usual manic selves. It's impossible for these men not to be entertaining when they hit Full Rant, which they did here, brazenly saying they'll meet Hook and Bronson in their own backyard later this month.
Where they'll inevitably get their heads kicked in again.
9. The Locker Room Leader Leads
A celebratory Jericho Appreciation Society update us on their massive week coming up in the wake of #AEWAllOut! And apparently, they don't like turtles.
AdvertisementTune in NOW to #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS! pic.twitter.com/qSo4lNsZGD
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) September 8, 2022
Chris Jericho has come in for strong praise for his calm, level-headed approach to helping AEW navigate its recent chaos, so it was appropriate to bring him in to cut a promo hyping the tournament caused by this rough situation.
The Jericho Appreciation Society leader was good here. Claiming he was drinking in the fountain of youth, man, after defeating Bryan Danielson, he promised victory in the Grand Slam Tournament of Champions and put his two boys, Sammy Guevara and Daniel Garcia, over huge in their own endeavours. Guevara faces Darby Allin in the tournament while Garcia had his shot at Wheeler Yuta's ROH Pure Title on deck.
This served to further the story of Garcia's inner conflict, too. The 'Dragon Slayer' remains at the heart of a tug of war between conflicting ideologies in AEW.
8. Following Up On The Acclaimed
Structurally, the segment wasn't anything to write home about, but that AEW is running with The Acclaimed following their breakout performance at All Out is a very good thing indeed.
The promotion is often guilty of letting things cool off through inactivity as soon as they have heated up. Max Caster and Anthony Bowens entered the performance of their careers at All Out, sending their overness through the roof against Swerve Strickland and Keith Lee, who were as effective as heels as The Acclaimed were as babyfaces. It wouldn't be uncommon for Caster and Bowens to now go missing for a few weeks, losing much of what they gained on Sunday.
But that isn't happening. The rematch is booked for Grand Slam - and AEW is striking while the iron's hot.
Swerve interrupted The Acclaimed before Caster could get a bar of his rap out, drawing big heat in Buffalo. Caster, Bowens, and Daddy Ass are coming for the gold, now, and they have more support behind them than ever before.
7. Toni Storm Stays Strong As Interim Champion
It was nice to see Penelope Ford getting a more substantial workout following her recent return from injury. An exciting prospect before she disappeared, she will hopefully enjoy more opportunities to do cool things as time progresses.
She looked good opposite Toni Storm. Their Interim Women's World Title eliminator bout was tight, brisk, and competitive, with the two wrestlers fighting for parity before Ford kicked Storm in the gut after a handshake, turning the match into something more heated. Ford's control period was a success, as evidenced by the support generated for Toni's comeback, which was rubber-stamped by another brutal-looking hip attack then a DDT engineering out of a Northern Lights Suplex for the pinfall.
Good, solid stuff and an effective way to get a champion that people like onto the show.
6. Welcome Back To Wardlow's World
What an effective way for AEW and Wardlow to remind fans of who the TNT Champion really is.
An emphatic squash victory over an overmatched Tony Nese saw Wardlow pin his goober opponent with a boot on his chest, conducting the crowd through a three-powerbomb Symphony. Afterwards, 'Smart' Mark Sterling almost ate dirt before Josh Woods pulled him out of the ring, saving the manager from his own Wardlowing.
A p*ssed off Wardlow then grabbed the microphone, saying he'd read nonsense online about how he'd lost steam, how he'd lost momentum, and wasn't hot anymore. Now, he spat, it's time to remind the people who've been with him from day one that this is Wardlow's World.
Buffalo was hugely into Wardlow, who exuded Goldberg energy here.
5. A Most Excellent Spotfest
AEW's new World Trios Champions were determined in a pulse-pounding spotfest, the likes of which the promotion has specialised in since day one.
It was exactly the kind of match AEW needed to keep the show's energy going after MJF and Jon Moxley's promo segment. The popcorn-and-fireworks opener is an easy, easy win near the start of the show. It always has been - and Death Triangle, Orange Cassidy, and Best Friends more than upheld their end of the bargain.
A bout full of nutty spots saw Chuck Taylor cannonball dive off the ramp onto a pile of human beings, the usual array of excellent Cassidy reversals (his interactions with PAC were particularly great, as you'd expect), and Trent Beretta and Taylor going for simultaneous pinfalls after hitting the Crunchie and Awful Waffle respectively. Eventually, once the dives and bombs and chaos had cleared the ring, PAC hit the Black Arrow on Taylor for the pin.
Death Triangle would've been many a fan's pick to become the first title-holders when the Trios Championships were first rumoured in 2020. May they now do a great job in The Elite's absence.
4. Daniel Garcia Does It In Buffalo
95% of the time, the best way to handle a wrestler's homecoming is to avoid overthinking it and do right by the performer, giving them a night to remember and something for the audience to savour. There is unquestionably value to breaking this formula every now and then, but not too often. Continually booking hometown wrestlers like losers on their own turf comes off as cruel.
AEW has never had that problem. Generally, the promotion handles these things the right way, which was the case with Daniel Garcia last night.
Rapped to the ring by Westside Gunn (also of this parish), Garcia was over huge in Buffalo, New York. He continued his long-running rivalry with Wheeler Yuta in another technical chess battle in which the performers barely left touching distance of each other. The Pure Rules limitations play to both wrestlers' strengths, too, and while this wasn't the duo's best match together, it was a great, strategic battle between two wrestlers who know each other better than anybody.
Catharsis came for Garcia in the form of a Dragon Tamer with jerky torque on Yuta's legs, forcing the Pure Champion to tap out. Afterwards, Daniel had the honour of sharing the moment with his favourite wrestler, Bryan Danielson, who strapped the belt around his waist after the Code of Honour had been observed.
And on the ramp, Chris Jericho aghast at Garcia once again demonstrating split loyalties as Danielson's pro wrestling ideology's tug of war with Jericho's sports entertainment continues.
3. The Worst Guy
MJF's fake babyface act is tremendous. The All Out returnee is a master of crowd control, who plays his audiences like a career politician, encouraging them to cheer for him even when deep down, they probably know they are being played. That they go along with it shows MJF's skill. Classic, cheesy babyface tropes permeate his work in this role, as he walks out in hometown sports shirts, tries to pass off previous misdeeds as light-hearted jibes, and plays to the audience.
Here, in his home state, MJF equated himself to Moses parting the Red Sea, then immediately played that down. He alluded to backstage problems and claimed Tony Khan was paying him a boatload of money to navigate these tough times. And rather than entering the Tournament of Champions, he is retaining his poker chip so he can use it anytime, anyplace, whenever he wants.
Jon Moxley soon emerged, trying Max's veil to pieces. Friedman had no choice but to revert to type when faced with AEW's grandest folk hero. Turning on the audience was all the more heated for the work he had done to build them up beforehand, while referencing Cody Rhodes and Triple H is such easy, no-brainer stuff.
We'll get to Mox in a bit. For now, take a moment to appreciate the work MJF put forth last night. It's likely that he had to rethink much of this segment in the wake of recent goings-on, but he still delivered big, setting his new course following an All Out comeback unfortunately swallowed up by the controversy.
Never forget that this man was the television wrestler of the year prior to dipping in June.
2. Round Three Delivers
Putting a match with a ****1/2+ ceiling on last night's Dynamite was necessary last night. Tony Khan would have likely wanted to deliver a show that was quintessentially each of Dynamite's biggest strengths. So after delivering the all-action spot-heavy blast early on, he put established in-ring rivals 'Hangman' Adam Page and Bryan Danielson together to complete their trilogy.
This perhaps wasn't as stunning as the duo's first two instalments. Still, it was appropriately great. Revolving largely around Danielson softening Hangman's right arm up to neutralise the Buckshot Lariat and soften Page up for the LeBell Lock, it also had Page utilising his power and explosiveness advantages to good effect, dropping the majority of the match's biggest bombs to generate rich, organic drama.
Danielson's hard work ultimately paid off. He had scouted the Buckshot, which may have landed had Page had more strength to swing his arm, and countered it into an O'Connor Roll. This produced the three-count for Danielson's first win over Hangman in AEW.
This is the kind of match you get into All Elite Wrestling for.
1. The Best Guy
Jon Moxley is the best guy.
How many times has AEW been able to count on its heart and soul to carry things when times are tough? It happens so often that any other performer would likely buckle under the weight, but not Moxley. The man has positioned himself so far above the petty bullsh*t that drags others down that he is now operating in a different strategy. Drama-free and full of thunder, it's hard to imagine a man who cares less for pro wrestling politics, and that he is currently delivering greatness at a more consistent rate than ever before helps a lot, too.
Moxley's promo was phenomenal. After running MJF, he conceded he was embarrassed and p*ssed off about a great many things, including his World Title defeat to CM Punk. That belt is the only material possession that matters to him for what it represents. It is everything he loves about the business and the people that make it great. Delivered with conviction, his work landed as strongly as they did in the pandemic, where it often felt like Moxley was the one bastion of light an impossibly grim period that would have killed a company anchored by a lesser man.
Fortunately, Jon Moxley is the man.
In times of chaos, who else are you going to rally around in such a way? The man's burning spirit is incomparable.
Tony Khan should send him and Danielson to the finals.