In the Rock 'n Wrestling Era, it was Andre the Giant, Big John Studd, and King Kong Bundy. Into the nineties, The Undertaker, Psycho Sid, Yokozuna, and Diesel dominated main events. Undertaker held over well into the Attitude Era and beyond, standing shoulder to shoulder with the likes of Kane and The Big Show. Undoubtedly, the Vincent K. McMahon-era of WWF/E has been haven to a number of memorable goliaths, colossal immortals presented on the merit of immensity and intimidation factor. Since the closing of the Attitude Era, however, WWE has failed to yield many brand new monsters with lasting power. Brock Lesnar and Batista qualify to an extent, but they're also promoted with human qualities. If you're talking 'larger than life' in the sense of going beyond human qualities, you can add Umaga to the list of successes, as well as to a very small degree, The Great Khali (who was obscenely limited as a performer, but a considerable draw for the emerging wrestling market in his native India). Sheamus and Rusev could be considered, but again, they're far more humanized than the looming Yokozuna, or the mythic Andre. Brodus Clay had a chance, but playing the smiling 'Funkasaurus' (popular with kids as it was) was far removed from his previous life as a no-nonsense monster, now restored in his current TNA run as Tyrus. The latest project from the monster-machine is Braun Strowman, who is possibly going to work with The Undertaker at WrestleMania 32. The granite-thick Strowman hasn't exactly captivated audiences, outside of a well-executed debut angle in which he obliterated Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose last summer. McMahon is gambling that Strowman can ascend to the pantheon of awesome big men of years past, while a number of fans fear they're getting the second coming of Giant Gonzalez. Time will tell if Strowman can silence the doubters. Until then, here are twelve 'big men' from the post-Attitude era that just didn't work out. Maybe they were pushed, and the audience didn't buy in. Maybe they were quick studies, even by the office standard, and done away with regardless of size. Either way, in McMahon's Land of the Giants, these brutes just didn't make it. QUALIFICATIONS: At least 6'4-6'5 (or pushed as being tall), at least 270-280 lbs, and had to be presented as a threat based on size. It helps more if the character was mostly silent, and let their 'brutality' do the talking.
Advertisement
12. Nathan Jones
Few wrestlers had the debut vignettes that this Australian strongman was imbued with. Trading on his real life criminal past, Jones narrated a series of uneasy-feeling camera pans through an abandoned prison, calmly speaking about the ravages of solitude, with promises of violent reprisal. The videos always ended with a 'gotcha' lunge for the camera as the music bed spiked with violent guitar thrashes. If only Jones' in-ring ability matched the awesomeness of those videos. Instead, Jones was removed from a WrestleMania XIX tag team match due to his readily-apparent inexperience as a performer. Originally presented to the home audience as a cerebral, Hannibal Lecter-esque sociopath, Jones was instead dumbed down and made into a bumbling protege of The Undertaker's, one needing help to learn even the basics. By the end of 2003, Jones quit WWE, citing discomfort with the travel involved with the job.
11. Heidenreich
Ignoring his initial run as The Hurricane's goofy friend, Heidenreich was reborn in 2004 as an uncontrollable lunatic that would attack fans and fellow wrestlers. While he no doubt had the look (as well as some swank Rammstein-esue theme music in which Paul Heyman rhythmically chanted his name), his awkwardness was a negating factor. The infamous segment where he kidnapped Michael Cole, re-enacting the 'Zed and Marsellus' scene from Pulp Fiction with him, made it hard to take Heidenreich seriously. After a mediocre feud with Undertaker, Heidenreich suddenly turned face, marching around with children and reciting silly poetry. He eventually became Animal's partner in an unwanted Legion of Doom reunion. By early-2006, Heidenreich was gone. Bob Holly makes it clear in his book that Heidenreich was unstable outside the ring, and unreliable in the eyes of company officials.
10. Luther Reigns
The frightening musculature and no-nonsense glare made Reigns the ideal bodyguard for Kurt Angle, who was briefly working as a heel authority in 2004. Reigns held the potential to be the modern-era Big Bubba Rogers, the silent enforcer to a detestable loudmouth villain like Angle. While Evolution flourished on Raw, Angle's stable on Smackdown, featuring Reigns and former WCW talent Mark Jindrak, fizzled with little impact. Reigns' one-year run on the main roster came at a time when Smackdown was beginning a creative nosedive, and he just couldn't keep his head above the current of redundant booking. Reigns asked for his WWE release in May 2005 due to creative differences, and left the business not long after. Since then, the real-life Matt Wiese survived a 2009 stroke, and in 2015, took part in a class-action lawsuit against WWE regarding brain injuries.
9. Matt Morgan
Another legit seven-footer, Morgan dropped out of the second Tough Enough due to injuries, but certainly got another look in developmental on the merit of his frame. Morgan ascended to the main roster for a spell in 2003-04, joining the aforementioned Jones as a heavy of Paul Heyman's. After appearing in the 2004 Royal Rumble match, and getting some moments of shine, Morgan disappeared from the main roster for over a year. Upon returning in the spring of 2005, Morgan was given Bubba Ray Dudley's old stuttering gimmick, a comedic kiss of death for someone that should be taken seriously as a towering figure. Morgan briefly ran interference for an increasingly-popular Carlito before getting released in the summer of 2005. Beginning in 2007, Morgan embarked on a six-year run with TNA, where he was given a little more dignity to work with.
8. Mordecai/Kevin Thorn
In 2004, vignettes began airing for Mordecai, a white-clad saint with vengeful intentions. Beyond the videos and the impressive aural entrance, Mordecai didn't make his mark in the ring, slowly moving (a probable character quirk) through wins over Scotty 2 Hotty and Hardcore Holly on pay-per-view. Mordecai was planned to feud with the contrastingly-dark Undertaker later that summer, but was pulled from the main roster after two months. Part of the problem may stem from the fact that Mordecai was only 6'3, and his presence would have been exposed next to 'Taker. In 2006, he reappeared on the new ECW brand as Kevin Thorn, a vampire flanked by the sinfully-buxom Ariel. The two joined with the ill-fated 'New Breed' that tried make ECW their own, before cleanly jobbing out to legitimate ECW veterans at WrestleMania 23. Thorn kicked around developmental throughout 2008 before leaving WWE behind early the following year.
7. Dan Rodimer
You may be thinking, "Who?" Rodimer took part in the ill-fated fourth edition of Tough Enough, and actually had a greater career upside than eventual star contestants The Miz and Ryback. At 6'7 and close to 300 lbs, Rodimer looked like JJ Watt with a permanent smirk. Believe it or not, Rodimer wrestled WWE Champion John Cena at a house show on June 17, 2007, with Randy Orton in his corner. At one point, Rodimer (who wrestled as Dan Rodman) figured big into company plans, and was penciled in as a bodyguard figure for Orton and Edge in early 2007. Despite lofty hopes, Rodimer negotiated a release from the company in August 2007, leaving the business entirely at the age of 29. Two months earlier, he was working with the WWE Champion.
6. Sylvester Terkay
Terkay had more success as an amateur wrestler, winning four National Heavyweight titles in his career. He also wrestled Kurt Angle in 1992, losing narrowly on points 2-1. The unfriendly grimace and wild mane of hair made Terkay, who had frequently wrestled professionally as "The Predator", a big man worth keeping an eye on. Understandably, WWE came calling in 2006. Terkay was paired with former boxer Elijah Burke (TNA's Pope) as a mixed martial artist duo on the ECW brand, following a short and forgettable run on Smackdown. Terkay's most notable WWE moment came at the ECW December to Dismember, when he received faint 'TNA' chants after hitting Samoa Joe's Muscle Buster on Little Guido. Terkay quietly received his release six weeks later.
5. Vladimir Kozlov
The pointed scowl and simplistic brawling of Ukranian Kozlov were a throwback to the days of wrestling yore, when America-hating Russians were once a fad. A full generation after the Cold War ended, and WWE trots Kozlov out on television playing an antiquated gimmick. Fans didn't care, and they cared even less when he and Triple H slogged through resthold after resthold at Survivor Series 2008. Kozlov would eventually improve in the ring, turning face and forming a decent team with Santino Marella, but he never reached his potential as a monster villain. That quick push to the moon in his first year as a main roster player faded just as quickly when Triple H summarily dumped him out of the 2009 Royal Rumble match.
4. Eli Cottonwood
Whomever thought of giving such a name to a seven-foot monster should have been pink-slipped on the spot. Imagine if Undertaker debuted in 1990 as Abraham Hufnagel. He's not starting any streaks with that kind of moniker, is he? 'Cottonwood' was doomed from the start, and that was before his 'eyes' promo from the second NXT season. Ah, the days where NXT was a silly game show instead of the superior brand. Cottonwood had to cut a promo about 'eyes', and showed the improv skills you'd expect a novice wrestler to have. Cottonwood's only other notable WWE footnote is that he was Bray Wyatt's original henchman, standing idly by while the former Husky Harris quickly worked out the kinks of his brilliant character.
3. Jackson Andrews
A former Booker T trainee that stood 6'11, Andrews lasted approximately one month on WWE television in late-2010. The entirety of his role on the main roster was to serve as bodyguard for the floundering Tyson Kidd, during Kidd's extremely-brief feud with former partner David Hart Smith. By month's end, Andrews was taken off television after being pummeled by Mark Henry. He would be released in May 2011. Andrews resurfaced in the summer of 2012, when WWE Diva Rosa Mendes filed battery charges against him, claiming that she was afraid that Andrews (real name Steve Slocum) was going to kill her. The two were engaged, but it was revealed that Andrews was engaged to another woman as well, for four years and counting. Aside from that sordid story, Andrews has all but vanished from the public eye.
2. Mason Ryan
Fans rubbed their eyes when Welshman Ryan debuted on Raw in January 2011, saving CM Punk from the clutches of John Cena. Many wondered aloud if the excessively-muscled brute was a returning Batista, or even a genetically-engineered clone with all of the tattoos removed. Ryan figured into Punk's new Nexus stable, receiving 'Batista' chants from time to time, and some jokingly labeled him 'Batis-two'. Later in 2011, Ryan turned face, briefly feuding with US Champion Dolph Ziggler. A few times on Raw, Ryan frighteningly dropped Ziggler out of press slams, with Ziggler landing awkwardly. At Survivor Series, Ryan was booed out of Madison Square Garden during the traditional five-on-five match, and heel Cody Rhodes got a star's reaction for eliminating him. After that, Ryan only appeared once in a blue moon on TV before his spring 2014 release.
1. Tensai
The former Albert was whisked back to WWE in 2012 after a successful run in New Japan. Upon his return, Albert would be repackaged as Lord Tensai, an American brawler that journeyed to Japan and was there reborn as an unstoppable monster with something akin to a God complex. Tensai was unleashed shortly after WrestleMania 28, and quickly defeated CM Punk (the reigning WWE Champion) and John Cena in televised matches. Fans weren't buying into the act, mockingly chanting 'Albert!' to express their displeasure with the character. Tensai continued dropping down the card throughout the remainder of 2012, and became Brodus Clay's goofy dancing buddy in early 2013, under the sub-header 'Sweet T'. In early 2014, the real-life Matthew Bloom took to NXT as a highly-articulate announcer, and later as the brand's head coach.