12 Ups & 2 Downs For AEW All In 2023

A stunning UK debut for AEW.

By Andrew Pollard /

AEW

Anticipation has been high, excitement was at crazy levels, but finally the biggest show in pro wrestling history is now in the record books.

Advertisement

All In was expected to be a great show, and it more than delivered. In front of more than 80,000 people, All Elite Wrestling delivered a PPV that was spectacular from start to finish.

It's worth noting, this Ups & Downs has been written in live time as the PPV itself has played out, so there's not been a chance to rewatch moments or let certain moments and matches sink in. Either way, there's been enough time to cobble together some words about what really was a proper blast of a show.

Advertisement

Of course, the Wembley Stadium setting helped add to the pomp and circumstance of All In, and that crowd was absolutely nuts for the most part here, but when it came to in-ring AEW delivered on a high level.

So, with that in mind then, as someone who's been up for way too long by this point due to also covering last night's AEW Collision, here are the countless positives and mild negatives about a genuinely record-setting pro wrestling PPV.

Advertisement

Downs...

2. No International Title Match Was Just Stupid

AEW

As this article is being written, the AEW All In post-PPV press conference is happening and Orange Cassidy himself even questioned why his International Title wasn't defended at Wembley Stadium.

Advertisement

Stadium Stampede was great (as you'll read about shortly), but it's just baffling that the International Championship wasn't defended on the company's first truly international event.

All just a bit daft, really.

Advertisement

1. Why No Mercedes For The Women's Match?

Mercedes Moné was highly spotlighted during the Zero Hour pre-show, which many people may not have seen. There, she was shown sat in the crowd at Wembley Stadium, zoomed in on and made a big fuss of.

Okay, that was great, but then surely AEW wouldn't only show Mercedes on the pre-show, right? Well, they didn't, but they bizarrely didn't show her during the sole women's match on the PPV.

Advertisement

Moné would be shown during the AEW Trios Titles contest, but it felt odd that she was referenced but not shown as Hikaru Shida defended the AEW Women's Championship. This isn't saying Mercedes needed to hit the ring or even appear at the top of the entrance aisle, but surely it would've made sense to show the Blue Print as the Women's Title was being contested in a four-way bout; a four-way bout ultimately won by Mercedes' real-life friend Saraya.

It was just weird how Moné was referenced during and after the AEW Women's Title match, but was never actually shown during this contest.

Advertisement

Also, it's once again a huge frustration to see AEW's women's roster get such short shrift in general. As in, on a four-hour PPV - complete with a two-hour pre-show - there was just one solitary women's match, which was bafflingly only afforded less than nine minutes of in-ring action.

Ups...

12. The Zero-Hour Pre-Show

Away from the matches on the Zero Hour pre-show, the two hours as a whole was a whole bunch of fun, with Kip Sabian in particular being a highlight as he, Renee Paquette, Paul Wight, and Anthony Ogogo led the charge in selling the All In PPV for those in two minds whether to purchase what's billed as the biggest event in pro wrestling history.

Advertisement

Sabian is extremely well spoken, offered great insight, and his chemistry with Wight was notably fantastic.

Elsewhere, there were surprise appearances from Powerhouse Hobbs, Miro, Jeff Jarrett, Jay Lethal, Satnam Singh, Sonjay Dutt, Karen Jarrett, Grado, and physicality from Wight and Ogogo. Not to mention, our own Simon Miller rocked up as security for the Hobbs/Miro segment, with the Billington Bulldogs - nephews of the Dynamite Kid - also amongst those joining Miller.

Advertisement

The biggest talking point in terms of appearances, though, has to be Mercedes Moné being shown in the Wembley Stadium crowd.

It was also a lovely touch from Renee Paquette to open the pre-show with a quote from the late, great Windham Rotunda.

Advertisement

11. Well, That Was A Surprise...

AEW

Adam Cole and Maxwell Jacob Friedman are your new ROH Tag Team Champions.

Advertisement

Could these partners coexist ahead of their All In main event for MJF's AEW World Title? Who would turn on who? Would Roddy Strong have a role to play?

In the end, Cole and Max worked brilliantly together, putting on a sprint of a match against Aussie Open. Keeping things short, highlights were the Salt of the Earth hitting the Kangaroo Kick on Mark Davis and Kyle Fletcher, and then Better Than You, Baby sealing the win after hitting the Double Clothesline on Fletcher for the 1-2-3.

Advertisement

Post-match, there was a smidge of tension as Cole and MJF went face-to-face with Max's title held aloft, but the two were still cordial, with Cole heading to the back and leaving his tag partner to soak in the Wembley cheers.

10. Fun Plunder War

Another match that didn't overstay its welcome, HOOK challenging Jack Perry for the FTW Championship was a fun, frenetic brawl fought under FTW rules - basically, anything goes.

As for that anything goes approach, that saw HOOK and his former tag team partner start this war out in the aisleway, by the limo that Jack made his entrance in. The limo doors came into play, the windshield - which Perry made a point of noting was real glass, in response to recent backstage reports - and the one-time Jungle Express man did his best to mock the legendary Rob Van Dam.

Advertisement

A particular highlight here was a phenomenal 360 degree bump Perry took from a HOOK lariat as part of the Cold Hearted Handsome Devil's comeback on his way to tapping Jack out with the Red Rum to become a two-time FTW Champion.

9. Starting Off Extremely Hot

AEW

As soon as CM Punk came out in white attire, chances are that this was going to be a bloody war, and that was indeed what we got. Well, at least bloody on the part of the Second City Saint.

Advertisement

From the get-go, Samoa Joe dominated his long-time rival, brutalising Punk on the outside, slamming him into the barricade, and then even throwing the Real Worlds Champion through the lower part of the announce desk. One mild complaint here is that, from a logic standpoint, referee Paul Turner allowed Joe and Punk to remain outside for several minutes without making any particular threat of a countout.

That mild grumble aside, this match was a belter; the perfect choice to open the main All In card out hot.

Advertisement

Once the bloodied Punker crawled out from the announce desk, Joe put an immediate stop to any attempted comeback, with the majority of the Wembley crowd firmly behind the King of Television. There were kickouts at a 1 count, there was a nice tribute to Terry Funk as Punk applied the Funker's Spinning Toe Hold, and there was a gnarly, nasty level of aggression brought to the table by this two wily veterans.

It would be CM Punk retaining his Real Worlds Title here, digging into his classic playbook to pull out the Pepsi Plunge to secure the 1-2-3 over the Samoan Submission Machine.

Advertisement

8. Action-Packed And The Right Result

AEW

Some may have been hoping to see a Golden Elite win here, but Konosuke Takeshita pinning Kenny Omega was absolutely the right result.

Advertisement

By pinning Kenny, that holds off on the Cleaner getting any real revenge on Takeshita and, more importantly, Don Callis. This gives Callis something more to brag about, it gives Konosuke something else to have a spring in his step about, and it also paves the way for Omega vs. Takeshita at All Out next weekend.

Before we got to that that match-winning roll-up, the first half of the bout was based around the Takeshita, Jay White and Juice Robinson working down Omega and preventing him from tagging out of the match. Our trio of heels nicely targeted various body parts of Kenny's that have previously been known to be injured, with Callis emphasising this fact as he joined the commentary team.

Advertisement

Once Omega was able to tag out, the match kicked up an entirely different gear, with the action barely pausing for breath as all six men got to hit their big moves. There was also a nice dollop of classic King's Road-style stiffness to a particular exchange between Kota Ibushi and Jay White.

As for those big moves, the finishing sequence saw a Buckshot Lariat to Takeshita, a V-Trigger to both White and Robinson, before Takeshita rolled up Omega for the win.

Advertisement

7. Match Of The Year Contender

AEW

Expectations were high for FTR vs. Young Bucks III, and man, did those guys deliver.

Advertisement

Where to even begin with this, right? As this Ups & Downs is being written in live time as All In takes place, it's impossible to recap everything, and we sure did get everything here.

To start with, the Jacksons came out in Freddie Mercury-inspired gear, whilst FTR had custom UK-driven attire and armbands paying tribute to Bray Wyatt, Brodie Lee, and Jay Briscoe. In terms of the work itself, there were so many call backs to FTR and the Bucks' previous meetings, including Cash Wheeler once again missing a springboard 450 splash.

Advertisement

There was (of course) superkicks, both teams attempted a Power-Plex, likewise both teams delivered their own BTE Triggers, and there was also an extremely rare kick-out from the Shatter Machine; Matt Jackson the one to kick out of this highly protected finishing move. That's without even mentioning the Bucks hitting their own version of the Shatter Machine on Dax Harwood for a 2.99 count. Plus, there was a great homage to the finish of the iconic Bret Hart vs. Davey Boy Smith SummerSlam '92 match.

When the finish here did come, it was FTR managing to evade a Meltzer Driver and hit the Shatter Machine on Nick Jackson to score the pinfall.

Advertisement

This was blistering stuff from start to finish, with the pacing - as is so often the case with FTR matches - exemplary in how it built and built into what was ultimately a genuine Match of the Year contender.

Post-match, the Bucks refused a handshake of respect, meaning this rivalry is wide open to revisit at any point AEW so chooses in the future.

Advertisement

6. A Bit Of The Old Ultraviolence

AEW

HOOK may have paid tribute to A Clockwork Orange with his attire on the Zero-Hour pre-show, but it was Stadium Stampede that truly brought a bit of the old ultraviolence made so infamous by Alex DeLarge and his Droogs.

Advertisement

If it's hard to recap FTR vs. Young Bucks in live time, it's utterly impossible to do the insanity of Stadium Stampede justice in that regard. But hey, that's part and parcel of uniquely penning a live Ups & Downs while an event takes place.

Full disclosure, Stadium Stampede is a stipulation that's never particularly done much for your writer previously, but this was a bunch of fun; violent, bloody, nasty, disturbing fun.

Advertisement

Every single person in this match is going to be feeling the impact of this for a good while, and each of the ten men got their moments to shine and also got to take some horrific looking bumps and strikes. There was Jon Moxley sickly receiving the skewers in the head from Penta El Zero Miedo, there was Mox hitting a Brainbuster onto a chair on Orange Cassidy, there was Trent Beretta taking a dreadful looking bump on a ladder in the corner, where he hit his back and neck, and then shortly after was thrown back onto that ladder by Ortiz and Mike Santana.

Speaking of Santana, isn't it great to see him back and looking in the best shape of his life? That dude is absolutely jacked right now.

Advertisement

In other highlights, there were a great few minutes were Moxley seemed to have a personal vendetta against Orange Cassidy, with Freshly Squeezed forever a fantastic fighting babyface. Or in this case, a fantastic, bloody fighting babyface.

The whole Sue stuff isn't particularly for me, and it was a little daft for Penta to leave the match for a substantial spell as he got changed into his Penta Oscuro gear, but they're minor complaints.

Advertisement

For the finish, it was the glass-covered, duck-taped hand of Orange Cassidy which scored the pin over Claudio Castagnoli, but arguably the bigger story here is that there was extremely minimal interaction between Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley. That said, the Mad King did put Mox through a table at the end of the contest, which opened up the opportunity for OC to strike Claudio.

One other small quibble is that Castagnoli's shoulders weren't actually down on the mat for the three-count, but that's kinda understandable when the mat was littered with pieces of shattered glass.

Advertisement

5. Saraya's Big Moment

AEW

Would Saraya have been your writer's choice to walk out of All In as the AEW Women's Champion? Truthfully, I'd have had Hikaru Shida retain, or if there had to be a title change, Dr. Britt Baker, D.M.D. would've got the nod.

Advertisement

That said, it's tough to deny Saraya her big moment after having gone through what she's gone through in her career. Seeing Saraya standing tall, in front of 80,000+ fans at Wembley Stadium, in her home country, with her family present; that was something only the coldest of cold hearts could bemoan.

The match itself was a solid if not spectacular one, and the crowd was clearly a little exhausted after the sheer insanity of Stadium Stampede, but there was plenty of good stuff here. Not least, in seeing Sweet Saraya - Saraya's mother - screeching for her daughter to hand Toni Storm a whooping after Storm accidently punched the veteran in the face.

Advertisement

Of course, a larger part of the story here was the tension amongst the Outcasts, with it now looking likely that either Saraya or, more likely, Toni Storm is done with the group. If it is indeed Storm who's done with the Outcasts, that's nothing but a positive due to the excellence character work she's been doing in recent weeks as she pulls plenty from classic jilted Hollywood stars of yesteryear.

While the finish involved a race between Saraya and Britt Baker - Saraya hitting the Knight Cap on Storm at the same time that Baker tried to get the Lockjaw on Shida - the best spot of the match was Saraya putting her old PTO submission on Storm, as Britt then hit a Stomp on Toni. It looked absolutely brutal and made for a great nearfall.

Advertisement

Will Saraya have a long reign with the AEW Women's Title? That remains to be seen, but if that isn't the case, she at least got to have this huge, emotional moment.

4. Coffin Match Chaos

There was a temptation to give this match a Down due to how you could audibly hear so many 'calls' during the bout, but hey, it's Sting, at Wembley Stadium, in front of 80,000 fans, being, well, Sting.

Advertisement

It's not all about the Stinger, though, for Christian Cage is an all-time favourite of your writer, and he was on his best sh*thouse behaviour here. Then there's Darby Allin, who performed some genuinely insane - but not insane, because it's Darby - attacks and bumps while having his hands tied together. As for Swerve Strickland, that fella may have been the one to lose the match, but he's such a top, top star in waiting.

It wasn't entirely smooth, but Sting & Darby vs. Christian & Swerve was another match that was just fun as a spectacle. As someone who grew up on Surfer Sting, how could I ever give this a Down? Especially when Metallica's Seek and Destroy song was brought back for the the Stinger?

Advertisement

When thinking of the most brutal matches of All In, the Stadium Stampede will jump out, but that's not to say this match didn't have some nasty bumps for those involved.

It was Darby technically getting the win for his team, trapping Strickland in the coffin after Sting had done his best to put Swerve away.

Advertisement

3. Jericho Rolls Back The Years With The Aerial Assassin

To say Chris Jericho isn't what he was ten or even five years ago isn't an insult. Father Time catches up to all of us, and Jericho in the last few years has been a little bit slower than he was in his prime, as is to be expected.

Here, Will Ospreay was the perfect opponent to help the Ocho roll back the years and put on a fantastic bout in front of 80,000+ fans.

Advertisement

Was the Judas performance a tad self-indulgent? The naysayers would certainly say so, but thankfully it was a short rendition of the Fozzy track. And once the bell rang, Le Champion and the Aerial Assassin set about trying to steal the show.

Some would say Will Ospreay is the best wrestler in the world right now, and it's matches like this that help reinforce that notion. Was this the Match of the Night? Not quite, but Ospreay was on his most magnetic form, drinking in the home crowd and delivering as only Will Ospreay can.

Advertisement

This isn't to say Jericho was a passenger here, for the inaugural AEW World Champion brought it at every turn.

Bar one slightly ropey OsCutter from Jericho, this was another cracking match at All In, and it concluded with Ospreay nailing the Hidden Blade to his opponent's chin before putting him away with a final Storm Breaker.

Advertisement

2. Badd Ass Gets One More Piece Of Gold

AEW

As someone who gets to do the Ups & Downs for AEW Collision each and every week, you'll find me forever praising House of Black when it comes to their in-ring game. And once again, Malakai Black, Brody King, and the criminally-underrated Buddy Matthews put on a proper snug 'n' good match, this time against the Acclaimed and 'Badd Ass' Billy Gunn.

Advertisement

If looking to predict a title change beforehand, this was likely the contest most people would've gone with, and it was indeed Gunn, Anthony Bowens and Max Caster who emerged victorious here.

The action was, like the bulk of All In, relentless. But again, this has come to be expected by House of Black matches.

Advertisement

There were admittedly moments that were a little off here, and it feels as if the whole House Rules gimmick is only utilised when it fits the narrative, but HOB brought their usual ever-impressive smash-mouth style and their opponents more than kept up their end of the bargain.

Another intriguing prospect is, with the Trios Titles off them, there's a slew of opportunities for the House of Black guys, whether in terms of tag team action or singles. For instance, what we saw of CM Punk vs. Malakai Black a few weeks ago in a six-man contest certainly raised a few eyebrows.

Advertisement

Also, extra points to Max Caster for referencing Prince Andrew in his pre-match rap. F**k that guy.

1. Best Friends, Better Enemies?

AEW

Oosh, wasn't MJF vs. Adam Cole just the best?

Advertisement

Having won the ROH Tag Team Titles on the Zero-Hour pre-show, questions were present as to whether Adam Cole could trust MJF, and whether MJF could trust Adam Cole, as the two got set to do battle for the Salt of the Earth's AEW World Championship in the All In main event.

When it came down to it, it was Cole who was actually the more heelish of the two, with Friedman having multiple opportunities to take shortcuts but not taking them. Whereas for Adam Cole, he was more than happy to take utilise such underhand tactics.

Advertisement

Of course, at their core, both MJF and Adam Cole are heels, and that made it great to question how things were going to go here. Where it did go, was Max rolling up his Better Than You, Baby with an inside cradle, which only came after the match ended earlier - and was restarted - with both pinning each other

There was the tease of a post-match attack by Cole and the Kingdom, but Adam would put a halt to that as he embraced MJF.

Advertisement

This was nuts, I'm tired after being up since 4:30am and it now being 11pm, so maybe more details will be added tomorrow. Either way, this main event delivered on countless levels, and it also keeps the Adam Cole and MJF 'thing' going for a little while longer.