The list of great WCW champions is long. Think of the great main event wrestlers like Ric Flair, Sting and Ricky Steamboat tearing it up in arenas around the world. Then remember the great, cutting-edge Cruiserweight matches with guys like Rey Mysterio Jr. and Eddie Guerrero duking it out for high-flyer supremacy. Then there were the classic tag teams like The Steiner Brothers, The Midnight Express and The Road Warriors. And then...there were the bad champions. And that list is also quite long. Due in part to the company choosing so many bad champions for so many belts, they are no longer in business. But which ones were the worst of the worst? The wrestlers here are ranked from when the company officially became known as WCW in the late 80s through the end of Nitro's run in 2001. A long, strange, and briefly, incredibly successful, stretch of time. All title reigns from every belt were considered for this list. World Heavyweight Championship, US Title, TV, Cruiserweight, Tag Team and, yes, even the Saskatchewan Hardcore Invitational Title. The title runs are ranked on how much damage the wrestler holding it did not only to the belt, but to the company itself. From wrestlers playing politics to score themselves some gold, to flagrant nepotism, to egomaniacs who had no business in a wrestling ring, here are the 12 worst WCW champions ever.
12. Hulk Hogan
Hulk Hogan was one of the men that helped bring WCW to unprecedented heights in the mid 90s. There is no doubt about that. But he had a title reign that was so awful that it drags him down into history as being one of the worst champions the company ever had. It was a 69 day run that began on January 4, 1999. A night that helped doom World Championship Wrestling. At the time, the WWF was red hot, and WCW was reeling. Their 84 week winning streak was over, and they needed something big to get their momentum back. Management had a plan, but an terribly ill-advised one. Hulk Hogan vs. the World Champion Kevin Nash was booked on Nitro, which was a fairly big bout at the time. It wouldn't have been a good match by any means, but anything would have been better than what we got. Hogan poked Nash in the chest, and Big Daddy Cool took the biggest bump of his life. He just simply handed over the gold, which brutally damaged the integrity of the belt and the company. During the rest of the run, Hogan only won one singles match, which was against Ric Flair, and then lost the title to him the next month in a steel cage. But even if Hogan were able to put on four star matches against Eddie Guerrero and Dean Malenko every week, that reign would still have been a fatal mistake.
11. Stevie Ray
When people look back at some of the great tag teams in wrestling over the decades, they often try to find the "Marty Jannetty" of the team. You know, the guy that was good, but completely overshadowed by his partner. To call Stevie Ray the Jannetty of Harlem Heat would be an insult to Mr. Jannetty. The man simply couldn't work. But in WCW, that often wasn't a qualification to having a high paying job. Just ask Rick Steiner and Sid Vicious! Much like the Intercontinental Title, WCW's TV Championship was often considered the worker's belt. Men like Fit Finlay, Chris Benoit, and Booker T were often holding it in the late 90s. But when Booker went down with an injury in July of 1998, Stevie Ray was given the belt due to power of attorney. Apparently it's legal to let your belt be defended by a family member. Imagine John Cena handing over the US Title to one of his four brothers. It was the only time Stevie had a singles title. His reign lasted 27 days, and produced zero good matches. He lost the belt to Chris Jericho, and the world tried to forget the whole ordeal ever happened.
10. The Renegade
As we see now with Curtis Axel and Damien Sandow, you can't base an entire career off of ripping someone else off. It just doesn't work. If only WWE had studied wrestling history, and maybe watched a few of those older WCW shows they have on their network. In 1995, WCW teased that the new arrivals of Randy Savage and Hulk Hogan would have an "ultimate surprise" joining them. Kind of sounds like the Ultimate Warrior right? Wrong! Instead, they got a guy who kind of, sort of, looked like Warrior. But he was a Renegade! Unfortunately, The Renegade had the same wrestling abilities of The Warrior, and none of the charisma. That didn't stop management from trying to make him a star. A couple months into his debut, Renegade defeated the quite talented Arn Anderson (who later called it perhaps the most embarrassing moment of his career) for the TV title and held it for just over three months. During this time, he didn't get over, as fans saw right through the imposter. The rest of his run in WCW was spent working as a jobber. To top things off, he was awarded the 1995 Worst Wrestler of the Year by the Wrestling Observer. Not so Ultimate after all.
9. Hacksaw Jim Duggan
Hacksaw Jim Duggan was the last person to hold the WCW TV Title, but he was also the worst. In 1999, Scott Hall won the belt at Mayhem, when his opponent, Rick Steiner, was unable to compete. A week later Hall realized he didn't even want the gold. He didn't even bother selling it, and decided to throw it in the trash. Nearly three months later Jim Duggan (who was working as a janitor in the storyline) discovered it in a dumpster. This kind of sounds like a miracle. How did no one clear out that dumpster in all that time? Well, he decided to keep the belt and declare himself champion, because that's what a real champ does. Duggan then began to defend the gold on WCW Saturday Night in a series of completely forgettable matches. At this point, due to injuries, Duggan was barely able to bump, so his matches looked better suited for an indy show at your local gym than on national television. When Vince Russo and Eric Bischoff came back to power, they metaphorically threw the title in the trash once more and it was never seen again. Who knows? It could be laying in a dumpster somewhere near you.
8. Crowbar And Daffney
Hmmmm...a man and a woman being the co-holders of a title. That sounds kind of familiar, almost as if the WWF did that exact same thing. Only this time around, it was less successful. In January of 2000, Chyna and Chris Jericho pinned each other in a match for the Intercontinental Title, and were both awarded as winners. Five months later, Crowbar and Daffney somehow accomplished the exact same feat with the Cruisweright title. What are the odds? While both Daffney and Crowbar were talented, it was sad to see the Cruiserweight belt become a joke over the previous year. There were a couple worse champions (which we'll get to in a bit), but the two of them did it no favors. Eventually the two faced off and Daffney won the title for herself, only to lose it to a man named Lieutenant Loco, due to interference in the match from Ms. Hancock, Major Gunns and G.I. Bro. Some people still wonder how WCW went out of business. Long gone were the days of Rey Mystertio Jr., Dean Malenko and Billy Kidman wearing the strap. It was now a prop. Props, though, don't sell tickets.
7. Creative Control
Starting in January of 1999, WCW went absolutely insane with their tag team titles. In that year alone, the belts switched hands an astounding 18 times. In 2000, they changed 18 times again. There are plenty of teams here that could qualify as the worst, but let's go with Creative Control. Their first run with the gold lasted 15 days (which was a fairly lengthy run during that time), and their second go around lasted one day. They beat The Mamalukes at a house show in Germany, and then dropped the titles back the next day. Surprisingly, it didn't make international news. So what made these guys so bad? For starters, they were the former D.O.A. in the WWF, which had to have been one of the least exciting jumps in the entire Monday Night War. Second, their gimmick was an awful, insider act that maybe 2% of the audience understood. You see, Vince Russo had creative control when he jumped to WCW, so he named a team after that fact. Does that make any sense to anyone?
6. David Flair
Poor David Flair. Bless his heart. He seems like a good guy, and a hard worker, but he just wasn't cut out for the wrestling business. If it weren't for his famous father, there's no way he would have ever made it into WCW. He wouldn't have lasted the first day at the Power Plant. But wrestling is a business that gives chances to a lot of people who don't really deserve it. Some dads give their kids a car when they reach a certain age, Ric gave his son the US Title. On July 5, 1999 Scott Steiner was stripped of the gold, and David became a champ because daddy said so and he was the commissioner at the time. While it was a heel maneuver, it was one that put heat in all the wrong places, mainly on the company itself. David just couldn't go in the ring, and he flat out was awkward on the mic. For every thing that made Ric magic, David was the opposite. The reign only lasted a little over a month before Chris Benoit tried to teach him what it's like to be a real wrestler...a lesson he sadly never learned.
5. Madusa
A woman winning the WCW Cruiserweight Title may sound like a progressive idea in hindsight. After all, someone like Ronda Rousey could probably take anyone on the WWE roster not named Brock Lesnar. However, this wasn't done as an inspirational story. It was done as a joke. Madusa won the gold at Starrcade 99 against Evan Karagias in the finals of the Cruiserweight tournament. Her first match against Evan was weeks earlier in a tournament for the Heavyweight Title. That match saw them grabbing each other with lustful intentions, and ending because she kissed him on the lips and he let her pin him. It was inspirational for young women everywhere! Well, at Starrcade Madusa only won because Nitro Girl Spice gave Evan one of the worst looking low-blows in the history of the business. Yes, she turned on her new boyfriend. Hearts were broken, intelligence's were insulted. Madusa was a great wrestler, but her winning the belt had nothing to do with wrestling, it was done for the sake of Crash TV. Actually, one of the only people who had a worse title reign than her was the man that beat her...
4. Oklahoma
In the long line of tasteless, downright mean characters in the history of professional wrestling, Oklahoma ranks near the top. Vince Russo (notice a recurring theme?) and Ed Ferrera were the two top writers in the WWF when they decided to jump ship to WCW. They ended up bringing Jeff Jarrett, The Harris Brothers and Good Ol' JR with them. Actually, it wasn't Ross, it was Ferrera doing a really mean impression of him! He dressed up like him, and called himself Oklahoma, because that's where Ross lived. This was hilarious to the new head honchos, and no one else. Oklahoma tried all of the famous Ross-isms, but sadly mocked his partial facial paralysis due to Bell's palsy. It was a terrible way to try to lure any longtime WWF fans over to their product. Oklahoma set his sights on Madusa and the Cruiserweight title, because he wanted to also be even more offensive by talking about how superior men were to women. In an awful match at Souled Out 2000, Ferrara won the belt in a match that concluded with a roll-up, and then barbecue sauce was poured down his tights. Unfortunately, the Cruiserweight division, has a weight limit and Oklahoma was a tad over it. This is what let to his demise as champion. So much potential. He was stripped of the title, and the Cruiserweight Title was stripped of all the remaining credibility it still had.
3. Judy Bagwell
What in the hell was Rick Steiner thinking? He won the tag team titles with Buff Bagwell, but Buff turned on him mid-match. He was then allowed to pick his own partner to carry the belts with him. Originally he chose Kenny Kaos from High Voltage. A strange pick, but his next one was far worse. When Kenny went out with an injury, Rick got to choose another. He chose Judy. As in Judy Bagwell. As in Buff Bagwell's mom. Now Judy was not an older version of Bull Nakano, Natalya or Trish Stratus. She was a middle-aged woman with absolutely no ring experience. She didn't seem to...well, quite have the physique of a professional athlete either. The only thing she had going for her was that she basically beat Buff as a child, and thought she still could. Perhaps she taught him the Blockbuster? Thankfully, she never did defend the title in a match, but the fact that she held the belt around her waist makes her one of the worst champions in not just WCW, but in the history of the planet!
2. David Arquette
You had to know this one was coming. Many people might think this entry is even ranked too low! There's no doubt that having David Arquette as your world champion is a bad, bad idea. Ever since Vince Russo had taken over WCW, he traded the belt around from one wrestler to the next without any long term plan. So to him, putting it on a C-level movie star didn't seem like a big deal. But boy was it ever. When Arquette was around WCW promoting Ready to Rumble, someone had the idea to make him the champion to create some publicity. According to Russo, Tony Schiavone came up with the idea (Eric Bischoff said he'd never heard that until years after), but it shouldn't matter since Russo approved it! In a match on Thunder, Arquette pinned Bischoff to win the belt (Jeff Jarrett was the champ, but the rules stipulated any pinfall counted). The new face of WCW was a man who had never wrestled before, and was most famous for being Courtney Cox's husband. Sadly, it wasn't just a one and done either. Arquette even defeated UFC fighter Tank Abbott in a match! It was all a ruse, though. Arquette and Jarrett were aligned all along...which makes absolutely no sense. Don't even try to think about it. It will only hurt.
1. Vince Russo
As you can probably tell by now, many of these picks here are quite Russo-centric. For this last one, let's just go with the man himself and crown him the worst of the worst!
"I just wanted to get people talking about that egomaniac Vince Russo putting the belt on himself. So that's why basically we did it. To get people talking" -Vince Russo
So he made himself world champion to appeal to internet smarks who already thought he was an ego maniac? How was that supposed to get anyone to watch WCW programming? Well, Russo only held the title for one week, but it was one of the worst weeks in the history of World Championship Wrestling. He won it because Goldberg speared him through a steel cage, and which meant he escaped first. It doesn't matter. He should have never made himself champ under any circumstances. As much flack as people give David Arquette for winning the gold, as least he was semi-famous. You can maybe, somewhat understand the rational (as misguided as it was) to make him champ as a desperation move. Russo, though, had nothing. He was a guy that only a small fraction of the audience knew months earlier, and was suddenly all over TV in every top angle. He was battling backstage politics, and the thoughts of internet fans, who were a vast minority at the time. Then he became champion. While other wrestlers defended WCW titles more often and in worse matches than Russo, none of them destroyed the integrity of a belt like he did.