12 WWE Heels That Nobody Even Cared About

"Go away heat" was a term born for these guys.

By Marcus K. Dowling /

There are times when World Wrestling Entertainment will introduce a character that is ultimately amazing because of the wrestler's ability in portraying the character to captivate the audience into caring about their every move. Of course, given that psychology 101 says that it's easier to be hated than to be loved, the idea that heel characters have a far better chance of engendering derision than fan favorites have in gaining cheers makes sense. However, what happens when a character that seems to be meant to create hatred instead incites nothing more than polite jeers, or worse - complete boredom. There are more than twelve times that WWE has introduced "bad guy" characters that fans could honestly at the end of the day care less about than WWE ideally would like fans to care about them. However, for a plethora of different reasons, these are 12 of the best examples of when WWE created a character, the crowd didn't care, and the wrestler ultimately disappeared or whatever the deficiency was ended up being fixed, and the wrestler went on to considerably greater acclaim with a new character.

12. Mike Knox

Though well over six feet tall, easily 280-plus pounds and eventually sporting a Bruiser Brody-type beard, Mike Knox was done as a pro wrestling bad guy in WWE before he really ever got started. Making his debut in WWE's version of ECW, he was the storyline boyfriend of Kelly Kelly, who portrayed an exhibitionist. Thus, the idea was that in Knox not wanting Kelly Kelly to strip naked in front of a crowd, he'd be perceived as much more of a bad guy. Well, this would have worked in pro wrestling 30 years ago, but in 2006, WWE had already seen so many nude and partially nude women between the ages of 21 and 80 (yes, 80 - Hi Mae Young!) that the idea of a man covering up a naked woman didn't make him so much a bad guy as it made him an idiot. It's hard to get serious heat when you're considered stupid by most of the fanbase, and thus his push was largely stalled. A classic case of never getting a second chance to make a first impression, Knox was pushed solidly in 2008 and 2009, but ultimately to no avail. Ultimately, once branded as someone less than entertaining, even being put in intriguing roles as a Brody-style "big man" and a psychopath with a predilection for knowing about pressure points in order to inflict punishment, it doesn't matter. If the initial presentation is off, then everything following thereafter will likely be less than over.

11. Jesus

Aaron Aguilera probably deserved better. A student of the same UPW Dojo as John Cena, Aguilera was a handsome and charismatic Mexican-American wrestler with excellent athleticism for his considerable size. In 2004 WWE, Carlito Colon as a "cool" Latino guy who spat chewed up apples into the faces of his opponents was a thing. On the surface, that in itself is a horrible gimmick with limited potential, but, at the time he was the United States Champion, so, that shows us how absolutely random pro wrestling can be on occasion. While embroiled in a feud with John Cena over the US Championship, it was revealed that Cena was stabbed in a nightclub. One common rule of wrestling. If at any point you're introduced in a manner that involves you committing a real-life felony, the fans aren't going to care about you. This is the case because well, hitting a guy with brass knuckles behind the referee's back pales in comparison to the other egregious things you've done in your life. Therefore, when the man that stabbed Cena was revealed to be Carlito's friend/bodyguard Jesus, well, Jesus was screwed. If anyone were to legitimately attempt homicide on someone, then why would you be seen in real life? Wouldn't that just put the cops onto you? Cena wrestling his near-assassin in a wrestling match then makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.

10. Nailz

Speaking of wrestling convicts, Kevin Wacholz's portrayal of Nailz, a convict abused by the Big Boss Man, in 1992's WWF was amazing in concept, but flawed in long-term execution. How is a fan supposed to care about a heel when they only serve one purpose, and past that point, theoretically serve no other purpose in being employed as a wrestler. Wacholz had a not-so super-distinguished career as a babyface "Mr. Magnificent" Kevin Kelly in the American Wrestling Association (AWA), one of many babyfaces brought in post-Hulk Hogan to fill the void of him leaving to head to the WWF. However, by 1992 he was re-cast as a balding pale menace in an orange prison jumpsuit and black work boots hellbent on destroying the prison guard from Cobb County, Georgia who had ostensibly made his life in prison a living hell. Though the Big Boss Man was over, after disposing of Nailz, what exactly was Nailz supposed to do? A feud with The Undertaker was planned, but in December 1992, Wacholz violently assaulted Vince McMahon due to a pay dispute, and was released soon thereafter. Likely realizing that such a one-dimensional character was a creative fail, it's entirely possible that not even Vince McMahon himself cared about Nailz.

9. Kenzo Suzuki

Pro-wrestling has a long tradition with stereotypical Asian heels. Pro-wrestling is an inherently American entertainment vehicle (translated by so many other cultures worldwide), so the US' dislike for Japan hearkening back to the December 7, 1941 attack on the US Navy's base at Pearl Harbor, Hawaii has been obvious. However, by 2005, with American children loving Nintendo video games while eating sushi rolls, any of the stereotypical hate of Japan had been replaced with stereotypical love of the country, thereby making Suzuki a less than effective heel. Surely he was booed, but his heat had more to do with being a generic bad guy than being an evil Japanese invader. Unique to Suzuki's presentation was the involvement of his wife, Hiroko. Presented as a traditional geisha, this didn't help much, either. The last Japanese heel that ever got over to any degree was Yokozuna, who aside from being presented as being Japanese (though he was Samoan), was more importantly super-athletic for his gargantuan size that topped off at 600-plus pounds. In having greater dimensions to his heat, where Yokozuna worked is where Kenzo Suzuki ultimately failed.

8. Rodney Mack

As "Redd Dogg" in ECW, Louisiana native Rodney Begnaud wasn't exactly a superstar, but he wasn't exactly at the bottom of the card, either. A perfectly serviceable pro wrestler, when paired with Teddy Long in 2002 WWE as the centerpiece of "Thuggin and Buggin Enterprises," his "White Boy Challenges" weren't exactly setting the world on fire. Again, in a situation wherein race relations will always be a touchy subject in any company, presenting African-Americans as the heels in the situation doesn't exactly make them bad, it proves them to be a) possibly right, and if presented as over-the-top heels, b) comedic. As it was often repeated in many wrestling promotions during the territory era, "funny, no money," meaning that a character presented with more humor than substance will never truly reach the top of the card or be a significant drawing attraction. The "White boy" hating Rodney Mack died a relatively quick death when defeated by Goldberg on June 23, 2002. Though later tagging with Chris Nowinski (held down by "the man" because he was intelligent) and Mark Henry (also black, and similar to Redd Dogg held down because of his skin color) the potential impact of his character had been significantly watered down to the point where there was absolutely no impetus to care, whatsoever.

7. Friar Ferguson

When WWE invoked religion for Wrestlemania 25's Shawn Michaels versus Undertaker tilt, it was arguably brilliant and tastefully done. However, in 1993, when WWE debuted long-time veteran grappler Mike Shaw as "mad monk" Friar Ferguson, the gimmick was in such poor taste that the Catholic Church of New York (which is where WWE was taping Raw at that time at the Manhattan Center) asked the company to discontinue the gimmick after a few weeks. In all reality, Mike Shaw's career was a slippery slope of gimmicks that were well executed but met with considerably less fanfare with each turn of character. Starting as evil Indian heel Makhan Singh in Calgary, his next big run came as mentally deficient asylum patient Norman the Lunatic, followed by Ferguson, and later grotesque hump-backed fat man Bastion Booger. However, in the case of Friar Ferguson, sometimes a gimmick is too offensive for the fans to even begin to consider caring about, and then they're gone before they really even started.

6. The Goon

As one of the Long Riders in the AWA, Wild Bill Irwin was a motorcycle-loving bad ass. Nearly a decade later, Bill Irwin was a wrestling hockey player "kicked out of every league he had ever competed in," as The Goon. Why should anyone care about a bad hockey player making his career as a wrestler. After all, it's not as if we had any official NHL footage of his cheating and illicit ways, so it was all ostensibly based in fantasy. Characters that are based in fantasy that work kind of begin and end with The Undertaker and Kane, so, given that The Goon is neither The Undertaker or Kane, he falls short. Furthermore was the matter of his finisher, the Cross Check. He'd dump his opponent to the outside, then body check them into the ringpost, the side of the ring, or the guardrail, then win a match by countout. While yes, that's a way to win, if anyone stops for a second and considers the regulations of a traditional pro wrestling match, The Goon could never actually become a champion. Why should a fan care about a wrestler who just wrestles in order to win matches in a manner that won't even allow him to become a champion of any sort. A great character that engenders fan derision (and support, too) should never be perceived or created as intrinsically mediocre.

5. Bam Neely

As much as a list of "Heels Nobody Cared About" could be filled with heels from the WWF's 1990-1996 nadir that wrestling fans do (ironically) care about given how many wrestling fan-fests and autograph signings that book those wrestlers dot the collectibles marketplace, let's instead discuss Bam Neely. Justin "The Ox" LaRouche was a hard-working member of the second-wave OVW crew that blessed WWE with MNM (Joey Mercury, Johnny Nitro and Melina) and a plethora of other acts. Called up to WWE in 2008, he was a member of Edge's stable as WWE Champion that intriguingly included zero A (or plausibly even B) level acts besides Edge. There were Vickie and Chavo Guerrero, Curt Hawkins, Zack Ryder and yes, their protection, ex-border patrolman Bam Neely. Did Edge need protection? Not really, as Neely's role was more superfluous and a cheap heat device than anything else. Quickly lost in the shuffle, he found his way to ECW, where after middling success, he was released after only eight inconsequential months on WWE's main roster. A guy that nobody cared about put in positions where absolutely nobody had any reason to care about him, Bam Neely could be number one. But there are four better (and more high profile examples) to go.

4. Tori

Why did Raven require a ninja's assistance in winning the Hardcore Championship? Why was that ninja revealed to be Tori? Why were there so many angles in WWE in the early 2000s on the mid and lower card that developed as if out of nowhere and gave fans no reason to actively care about the characters involved? Yes, Tori - as Terri Power - was Raven's valet when he was in the Pacific Northwest territory at the start of his career. Also, it's been revealed numerous times by Raven that he oftentimes would pitch his own stories to WWE creative during the Attitude era. However, of the ones that likely hit television, this is the one that is more nonsensical than most. Raven, while wrestling in matches where ALL objects are legal, required a woman wielding an object to win a match. Possibly the ultimate example of excess in the Attitude era, "Ninja Tori" is clearly a heel that absolutely nobody had any reason to care about whatsoever.

3. Farooq

Building ex-WCW World Heavyweight Champion Ron Simmons into a credible contender for the Intercontinental Championship in 1996 didn't need to involve changing his name to Farooq, having him wear a bizarre looking helmet, and also inexplicably be managed by Sunny. In literally stripping everything away from Ron Simmons that made him Ron Simmons, the people literally had to wait until November 1996 to buy into Simmons as a credible contender for the Intercontinental Championship as the head of the Nation of Domination. WWE has always had a need to re-create already successful wrestlers in the company's own image. Just as Dustin Rhodes became Goldust, Ron Simmons had to lose his ability to speak freely as a character and act in a manner that was in not in accordance with the wrestler that many wrestling fans were familiar. Maybe in the most obvious example of WWE's re-branding causing fan acknowledgement of a wrestler's past to drop to zero, the initial incarnation of Farooq is a heel that absolutely nobody cared about because there was absolutely no desire for the company to compel the fans to remember who he was.

2. JBL's Cabinet

Having already mentioned Edge's La Familia member Bam Neely on this list, the mid-2000s were an era of WWE television that oftentimes had fantastic in-ring action, but not-so-fantastic characters for very talented wrestlers and charismatic personalities. Thus was the case with "The Cabinet," JBL's "presidential" 2004-2005 stable involving then-WWE Champion Layfield, Orlando Jordan, The Basham Brothers, and either Amy Weber or Jillian Hall. Similar to Edge's La Familia, The Cabinet allowed a developing tag team (Doug and Danny Basham) the ability to have a prominent spot on television. As well, similar to then-unseasoned in-ring performer Vickie Guerrero, Amy Weber (and later Jillian Hall) were given a space to shine. As well, similar to Chavo Guerrero, Orlando Jordan was pushed as the number two in-ring performer to the "Wres-stle-ing God," putting a wrestler in a position that the fans maybe were not entirely to accept. Though well supported creatively, The Cabinet was not cared about because they again, featured too many under-prepared talents for top-of-the-card spotlight. If the crowd doesn't eventually accept the presentation of a performer of being deserving of the level of spotlight they're being given, then they're highly unlikely to care.

1. Mordecai

In a case of going to the well one too many times, Kevin Fertig being given a character with religious motivations and a Biblical name proved that after accepting Kane, that attempting to re-do The Undertaker was a premise fraught with high potential for failure. Debuting in April 2004, the Mordecai character wore all white and preached to the crowd about religious purity. Furthermore, he carried a staff that had the ability to cause objects to burst into flames. In being similar to the aforementioned Nailz, his motivations as a character made it appear abundantly clear that he could only logically fight The Undertaker, Thus, even when wrestling a top babyface of that era like Rey Mysterio, the clear heat is on seeing Mordecai wrestle only The Undertaker, with the potential for that match lessening with each interaction that isn't well, with the Undertaker. Had say, Mordecai been debuted like Mankind, and attacked The Undertaker in his debut, all other interactions with all other characters following could be driven by motivations expanding out of his first motivation which had been handled immediately. However, Fertig was not the ten-year veteran that Foley was in 1996 as Mordecai in 2004, and the opportunity was missed. What could have easily been a wrestler fans would have cared about instead became just another failed gimmick, Mordecai being demoted to Ohio Valley Wrestling (again) by July of the same year.