12 WWE Stars Who Left And Returned More Bad Ass

Attitude Era Big Boss Man was definitely more menacing than before...

By Jamie Kennedy /

Recently inducted into the WWE Hall Of Fame, Ray 'Big Boss Man' Traylor was one performer who played a variety of characters throughout his lengthy pro wrestling career. Gimmick names such as the Guardian Angel, Big Bubba Rogers and The Boss were used, but his most famous incarnation was when performing as The Big Boss Man.

Advertisement

Even though it was the same character, the version of Boss Man WWE fans witnessed from 1998 onwards was vastly different to the guy people had become accustomed to during his first stint with the company from the late-1980's into the early-90's.

Harder-edged, the character had a much more menacing tone.

Traylor isn't alone in that respect, there have been numerous examples of wrestlers leaving WWE and then returning later with a renewed emphasis on being more bad !*$%.

Some of these performers simply had cartoon-like gimmicks the first time around, only to make a comeback and appear more serious. Others just came across as more threatening, leading to a more fruitful portion of their career overall.

Here are 12 of the most notable examples of performers who returned to WWE (months or even years) after their first runs to become somewhat cooler...

12. Justin Credible

It wasn't really difficult for Peter Polaco to look cooler upon rejoining the then-WWF in 2001. 

Advertisement

During his first stint with the company in the early-to-mid-1990's, the guy had largely been used as enhancement talent. Originally known as P.J Walker, it was his follow-up gimmick that became infamous.

Dubbed the 'Portuguese Man O' War', the wrestler was handed the name Aldo Montoya. Wearing a mask which appeared more like he had donned a jock strap, Montoya was not a raging success. 

In fact, the character was borderline laughable, and nobody could treat Aldo with credibility wearing that colourful outfit. It'd take his release in 1997 and a jump to ECW for Polaco to find his feet.

Transforming into the more foreboding Justin Credible, he used that name upon rejoining the WWF years later following ECW's collapse. Forming a faction alongside X-Pac and Albert called 'X-Factor', Credible was finally taken a little more seriously, even if their Uncle Kracker entrance music was a bit regressive...

11. Sgt. Slaughter

In 1984, Sgt. Slaughter became a top babyface in the WWF by challenging the evil foreign menace of The Iron Sheik. Such patriotic angles were nothing new for wrestling, but had a proven track record of success.

Advertisement

They weren't quite antiquated by the mid-80's, so there was still a place for the 'American Hero' persona.

Upon leaving the company, Slaughter would spend time in the faltering AWA before making a WWF comeback towards the end of 1990. Sending a letter to Vince McMahon explaining his admiration for what the boss was presenting, Slaughter was brought back into the fold, only this time he'd be playing the heel.

Unthinkably aligning with The Iron Sheik, the former patriot was booked to turn his back on the United States. Suddenly, Slaughter was a much more threatening character, even finding enough success as a villain to bag the WWF Heavyweight Title from The Ultimate Warrior at the 1991 Royal Rumble.

Realistically, Slaughter's heel gimmick only existed so that all-American good guy Hulk Hogan had someone to beat at WrestleMania VII, but it still had a decidedly harder edge than his previous babyface guise.

10. Al Snow

Mired in the midcard pack during the cartoon-like 'New Generation' Era of the WWF, Allen Sarven was cast as the dorky Leif Cassidy and his team with Marty Jannetty, dubbed 'The New Rockers', was doomed from the start. 

Advertisement

People were not going to embrace the rejigged duo the way they had Shawn Michaels and Jannetty years before.

Other hammy characters such as Shinobi and Avatar did nothing for the man - he was another failed experiment during an era responsible for many. Much like Justin Credible, it'd take some time in ECW for Sarven to find his feet. 

There, he was embraced as the psychotic Al Snow, a deranged figure who brought a mannequin head to the ring with him.

The character became so popular that officials in the WWF started paying attention. In 1998, Snow moved back to the company, this time armed with a killer gimmick. He had been loaned to ECW in a talent exchange, only to completely turn his career around and be welcomed back. 

The Al Snow persona was just as loved in the WWF as it had been in ECW. There was something wacky about it that appealed to people and it was definitely cooler than the geeky Cassidy.

9. Luke Gallows

The most current entry featured on this list, Luke Gallows spent significant time away from the WWE spotlight. Following many failed attempts to ignite his career with characters like the 'Fake' Kane and Festus, the man found some success as part of CM Punk's short-lived 'Straight Edge Society'. 

Advertisement

That stable was disbanded, though, and the big man's contract was terminated shortly thereafter. A move to TNA yielded the Aces & Eights stable for Gallows, renamed Doc by the company. 

It wasn't until he moved to New Japan Pro Wrestling that Gallows managed to once again grab WWE's attention however.

Forming an excellent tag-team alongside Karl Anderson, Gallows was part of the Bullet Club. His performances caught WWE's eye, and they signed him to a deal this year. 

It was only on the most recent episode of Monday Night Raw that Gallows made his debut, beating down The Usos alongside Anderson.

Instantly, he has more of a badass aura surrounding him. Let's hope he isn't placed in another hokey gimmick and that he can keep this cool edge. 

8. Raven

Before he made his debut under the guise in September 2000, WWF fans had never witnessed Raven in the promotion.

Advertisement

Scott Levy had worked extensively for the company, but his role was Johnny Polo, a colourful announcer and occasional wrestler. Raven was something entirely different, Levy's attempt to reinvent himself.

That reinvention occurred during the man's stint in ECW. Much like some others on this list, Levy used the creative freedom rife in Paul Heyman's group to his advantage. Raven was a darker character than Polo could ever hope to be in the more garish world of early-1990's WWF. 

By the time he re-debuted with the company at the turn of the millennium, Raven had high hopes he could finally achieve big things. A WCW run had been promising, but had faded following a great start.

Surely in the WWF he would hit the heights many claimed he could?

Self-loathing and extolling self-confidence with a truly cool vibe, Raven was a lone wolf kind of character that was easy to identify with. 

7. Viscera

Nelson Frazier Jr can be used to effectively display the differences between the WWF in 1995 and the same company in 1999. 

Advertisement

During his first run in the organisation, Frazier played the part of Mabel, a large tag-team performer who donned purple and gold attire. He was part of the passé 'Men On A Mission' duo with Mo.

Later, management tried to push Mabel to the moon, even booking him to win the 1995 King Of The Ring tournament. That shunt up the ladder didn't work, audiences simply didn't accept Mabel as a headliner. He was released in 1996, and the next time WWF fans would see him would be remarkably different.

Kidnapped during the 1999 Royal Rumble by members of The Ministry Of Darkness, Frazier soon morphed into Viscera. Now with a more gothic look, including lipstick and some evil-looking contact lenses, the mountain of a man looked genuinely frightening. 

This switch reinvigorated his entire career, and Viscera was infinitely better suited to the 'Attitude Era' than Mabel would have ever been.

6. The 1-2-3 Kid (X-Pac)

By his own admission, Sean Waltman was dismayed when he learned in 1993 that his WWF name would be The 1-2-3 Kid. 

Advertisement

For the fresh-faced youngster, that was a potential death knell on his career, but the Kid overcame the odds to become a legitimately popular midcard act. 

In 1996, he departed the WWF and made his way to WCW. Joining his buddies Scott Hall and Kevin Nash, Waltman became Syxx. The character was much more dynamic than The 1-2-3 Kid had ever been, especially from the standpoint of handing the wrestler a more street-savvy guise. 

Returning to the WWF in 1998, Waltman brought his new attitude with him. Reborn as X-Pac, he instantly hooked up with Triple H and The New Age Outlaws to form a new version of D-Generation X. Waltman was able to be himself with his new role, and it served him well.

X-Pac quickly became one of the most popular names on the entire roster. Dripping with coolness, he was now a million miles away from the dorky kid Bobby Heenan used to crack jokes about on commentary.

5. Hulk Hogan

Even as early as 1993, the red and yellow hero known as Hulk Hogan came across as stale in the WWF. Fans demanded something new, but Hogan was still performing the same old shtick he had for years.

Advertisement

A match against Yokozuna at the first King Of The Ring pay-per-view in June would mark Hogan's last WWF appearance for almost 9 years.

During the intermittent period, he added freshness to his act by turning heel and forming the New World Order in WCW. By the time 2002 rolled around, that company was out of business and WWF enthusiasts were more than ready to embrace Hogan once again.

Returning alongside original nWo members Kevin Nash and Scott Hall at the No Way Out pay-per-view in February, Hulk looked like a million bucks. 

Dressed in nifty black and looking awesome, Hollywood Hogan was way cooler than the more traditional variation of Hulk that longtime WWF supporters had last seen in Titan rings. 

Ironically, he'd soon turn babyface and revert to the red and yellow, but that first nWo-styled impression hit the mark.

4. Scott Steiner

Regardless of his assertions that his mullet was "hot" during a recent Q&A tour of the UK, Scott Steiner's old look was definitely dated. Had he rolled into WWE towards the tail end of 2002 sporting the hairdo, it's unlikely that anybody would have deemed him badass. 

Advertisement

Thankfully, Steiner had updated his look successfully during the late 90s in WCW. Looking to establish himself as a top singles performer, Scott cut his long hair, dyed it blonde and began referring to himself by wacky nicknames like the 'Big Bad Booty Daddy'.

Suddenly, the accomplished tag wrestler was now a standalone star oozing coolness and machismo.

WWE fans hadn't seen Steiner in the company since 1994 when he made his return in 2002. Complete with the fresh look and his bulging muscles, he interrupted a throwaway segment between Christopher Nowinski and Matt Hardy at the Survivor Series. 

Swearing, posing and looking like the man, Steiner had completely changed his character and the fans responded positively. No longer was he a stoic wrestling machine, he was now an ultra-charismatic superstar.

3. The Big Boss Man

Racing down the aisle to the tune of his cheesy WWF entrance music, The Big Boss Man wore bright blue shirts and fit in nicely to the product of the early-1990's. 

Advertisement

For his return in 1998, things had to be different. The man was entering a different kind of World Wrestling Federation.

The 'Attitude Era' was already underway, and characters had be more rough around the edges than before. No longer could wrestlers be slick, child-friendly packages, they had to have an air of violence about them. 

This is criteria Ray Traylor was able to meet, entirely changing the perception of the Boss Man gimmick.

Trading the baby blue for black, he now wore more military-esque attire and black sunglasses. Carrying a nightstick with him, The Big Boss Man looked like he meant business. He was tailor-made to be part of Vince McMahon's Corporation faction. 

Even his entrance tune had changed, turned into a chilling, chugging series of riffs that suited the new aesthetic down to the ground.

2. Brock Lesnar

The first time around, Brock Lesnar hadn't exactly been a friendly kind of character. 

Advertisement

From 2002-2004, he stormed out of the gates as one of WWE's biggest success stories, but time away from the promotion actually served him well. From 2004-2012, Lesnar became one of the world's most potent fighting machines.

Winning the UFC Heavyweight Championship, Brock became one of the most intimidating men on the planet. A WWE return had been intermittently discussed for a few years before it happened, but there was still shock when he appeared on Monday Night Raw the night after WrestleMania XXVIII. 

Attacking WWE poster boy John Cena, Lesnar now carried more credibility with him than ever before. Perception now was that Brock had been able to prove himself in the legitimate fighting world of UFC, and that only made him more marketable to WWE. 

Dubbed 'The Beast', Lesnar more than lived up to that billing. His matches during his latest WWE run have been more realistic than before, hard-hitting and uncompromising are both words that could be used to describe the guy. 

He's the very definition of badass. 

1. The Undertaker

As well as many of the names on this list were repackaged, none of them actually had the term 'badass' in their nickname. 

Advertisement

Electing to take some time away from the spotlight, The Undertaker stepped away from the WWF in September, 1999. The main purpose of this was to heal up some injuries that had been plaguing him for years.

Somewhere along the way from the start of his sabbatical to his reappearance, 'Taker decided to mix up his act. Returning in May 2000 at the Judgment Day pay-per-view, he interfered in the 'Iron Man' Match between Triple H and The Rock, debuting a markedly different look. 

Gone were the supernatural elements of before, Undertaker was now known as the 'American Badass'. Riding down to ringside on a killer motorcycle, he looked amazing and people were delighted to see him back. 

Suddenly, The Undertaker of before was replaced with a kickass biker who wasn't afraid to speak his mind. It was refreshing, and is still fondly remembered as one of the best periods of the man's epic career.

What other WWE stars can you think of who returned to the fold decidedly more badasss? Let us know your thoughts down in the comments section below!

Advertisement