13 WWE Extreme Rules 2019 Impulse Reactions

The best WWE Pay-Per-View of the year.

By Michael Hamflett /

It’s becoming increasingly difficult to assess and adjust expectations for WWE pay-per-views.

Advertisement

In the criminally crap planning, promotion and execution of its Seth Rollins/Baron Corbin main event, June’s Stomping Grounds could be graded one of the lousiest shows in company history. A three-sided arena bore the critique out. Yet, half of the card was objectively of a decent standard, and some would subjectively argue more fervently in its favour.

The history books won’t look fondly on the event because of the empty seats and wretched conclusion, but the company haven’t ever cared less about any of that. They were probably more p*ssed off that the show lacked buzz, and only received the worst kind as it went off the air. Perception is reality, but in actual reality, the had enough early on that it was nearly - whisper it - a great pay-per-view.

Whispering it was all anybody was willing to do before this show, too. On a weekend in which wrestling’s fertile marketplace offered a multitude of options - NJPW's two G1 Climax cards, AEW's Fight For The Fallen and Evolve's anniversary show broadcast on the Network - a July B-show was paradoxically elevated to becoming the last big show from a very big weekend.

A card was assembled that, on paper at least, appeared prepared enough to live up to the billing. As an exhilirating Extreme Rules concluded, it remained increasingly difficult to assess and adjust expectations for WWE pay-per-views...

13. Finn Bálor (c) Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura

Corey Graves farted out platitudes about Shinsuke Nakamura getting his groove back against Finn Bálor during his non-title victory over the Intercontinental Champion on the go-home SmackDown Live, perhaps acutely aware that 'The Artist' wasn't going to be quite as potent here as he was on Tuesday night.

Advertisement

Bálor and Nakamura assembled a mini-banger for the blue brand, but on Sunday were stuck having their high spots interrupted by promos for the main show like every other poor f*cker in this spot. Was this match, this feud or the secondary strap itself not deemed worthy of something more?

In truth, all three would have benefited from addition by subtraction - the quality conclusion to this contest was betrayed by an inconsequential seven-minute snoozer beforehand. Nakamura winning his first Intercontinental Championship would have felt bigger within the confines of SummerSlam rather than skirting around the perimeter of Extreme Rules, regardless how forceful the usual suspects were about getting the "Nakamura is back" messaging across.

That should have been a job for a Michael Cole or Tom Phillips, not Jonathan Coachman.

12. Drew Gulak (c) Vs. Tony Nese

Ahead of the Kickoff clash between Drew Gulak and Tony Nese, Jonathan Coachman noted how the Cruiserweights would be working to top Finn Bálor and Shinsuke Nakamura's Intercontinental Title battle sharing space on the pre-game hour.

Advertisement

Can you blame them?

The division hadn't felt as hot all year as when Drew claimed the gold in a ripper of a battle before Stomping Grounds. The wrestlers had worked their way on to the pay-per-view a month earlier, but have taken multiple steps back after that one forward. Positioning, yet again, wasn't a reflection of their work.

"We're gonna steal the show before the show", yelled Nese as he entered Philadelphia's Wells Fargo Center to mild boos. Uphill struggles were the theme of his night - he faced a partisan crowd favouring hometown hero Gulak, then a silent one as he came a little too close for comfort to injuring his opponent with a moonsault that nearly missed and a 450 splash that caved in the Champions chest with an errant knees-first landing.

'The Human Torture Machine' survived the worst of the offence to retain his title, but how much will any of it matter? These matches keep getting gasps, and keep getting overlooked. 205 Live will turn three this year, but still won't be able to stand up by itself until the parent company permits it.

11. The Undertaker & Roman Reigns Vs. Shane McMahon & Drew McIntyre

Weeks ahead of the pay-per-view, your writer was amongst the (foolish) many that booked this match as a rather simplistic spectacle - tease out Undertaker's entrance with the heels sh*thousing Roman Reigns at every point until 'The Deadman' fires up and fires in to give the heels their just desserts.

Advertisement

Minutes ahead of the pay-per-view, the reality of the structure was altogether clearer.

By announcing that the contest was to open Extreme Rules, WWE effectively promised an endless stream of boypopping moments, including 'Taker getting the bulk of the opening salvo (and chasing Shane McMahon with a f*cking steel chair!) before the set the aforementioned hot tag up at the second attempt.

Undertaker sprinted through all the good stuff as if his reputation depended on it...because it absolutely f*cking did. A vital performance at a vital time, this was his most enjoyable match in five years, and went some way to erasing not just the chronic Saudi Arabia catastrophe against Goldberg but all his other knackered displays since losing to Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania XXX.

This was relentlessly fun. Catharsis, rather fittingly, in the extreme.

10. The Revival (c) Vs. The Usos

The Revival and The Usos can't have expected an uphill battle when they saw their names on the board underneath those of the oldest two performers on the show, but the entire wrestling world was still in shock following The Undertaker/Roman Reigns victory - particularly the exhausted observers in Philadelphia.

Advertisement

A hard match to parse as it was happening let alone after the contest, the two best working tag teams in WWE had a great working WWE tag team match but simply couldn't get the crowd up as quickly following their early Sports Entertainment overdose.

Michael Cole, presumably under instruction from Vince McMahon, noted that the contest was "a clinic" immediately after the Champions registered the winning fall with a Shatter Machine. They'd grafted to wrongfoot the talented challengers a number of times in a tacit show of respect, but like much of the other nuanced double team work throughout, it was slightly lost in the haze left behind by the opener's absurd drama.

9. Aleister Black Vs. Cesaro

What the f*ck did Aleister Black sit in that room for following WrestleMania? And why?

Advertisement

Not to downvote a superb technical scrap between Black and his apparent letterbox-botherer Cesaro, but if the payoff to that weeks-long build wasn't already odd enough, the match completed the backwards repackaging of one of the few developmental call-ups that had actually gone pretty well before this.

The two put on another one of those dreaded clinics for all of ten minutes before the 'Swiss Superman' fell to a wicked Black Mass, but the structure bizarrely favoured the loser rather than the winner. "Favoured", here, is pretty generous too - it was neither showcase for a reintroduced Black, not overwhelming losing effort for plucky runner-up Cesaro. Black went over but nobody got over.

It was, much like everything related to the repackaging of the former NXT Champion - completely counterproductive in achieving its stated aims. Where next for Cesaro following this defeat? For that matter, where next for Aleister Black? Back into his cupboard? This entire repackage should get locked away in there for good.

8. Bayley (c) Vs. Alexa Bliss & Nikki Cross

Few more than your writer wanted Bayley and Alexa Bliss to show off their old NXT chemistry on a main roster pay-per-view in 2019, but it may be high time now for 'Little Miss Bliss' to spin off into her planned programme with Nikki Cross rather than yet again hassling the SmackDown Women's Champion for another title shot.

Advertisement

The two didn't really click - sigh, again - at Extreme Rules, though the handicap match didn't descend into farce at least. The pleasing opposite in fact; Bayley made her own saves, discovered double submissions and blind dives, and even shook off taking a face full of steel steps before pinning Cross without Bliss to make the save.

WWE have at least undone much of the damage inflicted on Bayley's gimmick by damaging losses to Bliss in 2017, by - imagine this - having her win most of her matches. She should, in storyline and reality, be rewarded for this by being moved into something of greater significance in time for SummerSlam.

7. Braun Strowman Vs. Bobby Lashley

Braun Strowman is back on track. Typically, all it took was for the company to craft something utterly f*cking bananas for him to do, too.

Advertisement

Having smashed the (holy) sh*t out of each other on a recent Raw, Bobby Lashley and 'The Monster Among Men' were back at it in Philadelphia, battering one another all over the arena en route to a spectacular set piece finale in which Strowman hit his running powerslam in the crowd through a wooden construction designed to absorb their ginormous frames with the most amount of noise and nebulous bluster.

It served as a reminder of Strowman's potential at the top of the card, if that's indeed his destination following what must surely now be the end of his programme with 'The All Mighty'. On Lashley - his contributions to the company since returning last year remain uneven, but this beef-slapper (an Andy Murray original) worked wonders for him too. His stock hasn't been higher, even if this loss saw him plummet to hilarious new lows.

6. Daniel Bryan & Rowan (c) Vs. The New Day Vs. Heavy Machinery

Daniel Bryan bidding farewell to his SmackDown Live Tag Team Championship should free him up to salvage the status of the WWE Title instead...but more on that later. Instead - and to vindicate everything Bryan's attempted to do with this division and these titles - it's more important to talk about what a rousing, roaring success this contest was.

Advertisement

Heavy Machinery were both excellent again. Rowan looked like a killer, again. The New Day, spare parts for too long in a league that's struggled without them, Champions again. Daniel Bryan was a gift to everything he's a part of again.

It's hard to classify this as match of the night considering the strength of the card overall but something felt special about this, not least because of the ultra-happy ending. This was the one contest that achieved greatness without bells and whistles - it relied on high quality wrestling to produce a high quality outing, which has been the modus operandi of the brilliant Bryan since the day he started wrestling. Impossible not to pin its success on him after all...

5. Ricochet (c) Vs. AJ Styles

Fans showed reverence and respect for a technical bottle rocket that exploded late in the day as the two traded their tastiest ariel assaults. The silence wasn't the sort of deafening, difficult non-noise of Stomping Grounds, but of the interested and intrigued masses looking on, eagerly awaiting one of the two bonafide phenoms to perform yet another jaw-dropping gasp-inducing stunt.

Advertisement

The contest started hot - Lule Gallows and Karl Anderson decked Ricochet before the bell to give their Club mate the advantage, but 'The One And Only' remained plucky trying to fight back against his experienced rival.

AJ Styles' heel turn couldn't have come at a better time - his every single step in this contest with a younger version of himself came with spike and spunk missing from the lengthy WWE Championship reign he embarked upon last year.

He pulled the pace back a bit as per the brief, but it fed into his eventual victory. This was a cruel, cruel lesson for Ricochet to learn. He'll either have to find some mates to help him get revenge, or find resolve to be his best if and when he gets another shot.

4. Kevin Owens Vs. Dolph Ziggler

Kevin Owens dropped Dolph Ziggler with a stunner to claim victory in just 17 seconds as 'The Show Off' continued his selfless mid-year return.

Advertisement

With no match to speak of, the 'Prizefighter' instead spoke again of his disgust with Shane McMahon, mocking him for the beating he took from The Undertaker as well as highlighting just how much damage he's done with his post-Crown Jewel ego trip.

This - and Owens' SmackDown Live promo earlier this week - has made chicken salad from what was rapidly becoming a sweaty puddle of chicken s**t. It's hard to imagine that the overabundance of 'The Money' across both shows was designed to get a new babyface over (not least after immediately just finishing a series with Roman Reigns) but that's exactly what's happened thanks to the brilliant instincts of the former Universal Champion.

It's unclear where all of this will go, but that's part of the nervous excitement around this tantalising babyface switch. For the first time in ages, Owens feels relevant, dangerous and - like his ardent fans - hopeful that he may finally have turned a corner.

3. Kofi Kingston (c) Vs. Samoa Joe

Even better for lingering in the shadow of AJ Styles' deconstruction of Ricochet, Samoa Joe's physical decimation of Kofi Kingston ending in failure provided a unique twist when all looked lost for The New Day member.

Advertisement

The match was objectively good, and cutely booked - Joe dominated before Kingston hit a Trouble In Paradise for a flash victory to subvert the ending of the United States Championship clash earlier in the evening - but it was yet another nothing match in a series of them for the Champion.

Kofi's run of victories has tragically masked a dull babyface reign akin to Styles' last year rather than the transcendent Daniel Bryan run that sat in between the two. Kofi's tear-jerking, history-making WrestleMania win remains the peak of the entire experience, classifying the rest of the tenure as a downward slide.

Joe was one of several men that seemed suited to dethrone the titleholder, but WWE may presumably be lining up Roman Reigns for a big babyface battle at the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer'. Finding tension may be a bigger test for 'The Big Dog' than reclaiming his old treasure.

2. Seth Rollins (c) & Becky Lynch (c) Vs. Baron Corbin & Lacey Evans

During a brilliantly bizarre Kickoff promo featuring "homewreckers" Baron Corbin and Lacey Evans, the 'Lone Wolf' and the 'Sassy Southern Belle' made big promises about the violence they intended to unleash upon Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch.

Advertisement

Failing profoundly to deliver on their threats, it was a good job neither of them made assurances about quality too. Becky and Seth provided most of the violence (despite proffering zero sex as a precursor), wailing on the pair with chairs and kendo sticks before putting them through tables for the big set piece near the end.

If that feels a little too close to the description given for a common-or-garden hardcore match, it's because that's exactly what this was. When the heels had their moments, they were campy and comedic with it, but the never-in-doubt result left the hardened and previously-heated Philadelphia fans cold to the supposed aggression. Corbin triggering Rollins with an assault on Lynch at least made for a good finish. It felt like a bit of a slog getting there.

Here's the thing with WWE in 2019 - there's simply no excuse not to be top of the wrestling class. Some of Extreme Rules made Seth Rollins' ill-advised tweets from earlier this year sound true. It's a shame his match couldn't advocate them with such confidence. Onwards and downwards for the titleholders to SummerSlam then, hopefully not together after this failed experiment...

1. Seth Rollins (c) Vs Brock Lesnar

And so the inevitable came to pass.

Advertisement

Brock Lesnar's Money In The Bank cash-in victory over Seth Rollins didn't bring with it the dread of his original victory, which perhaps damns Rollins' run with the red strap more than it credits 'The Beast'. The cathartic conclusions to his last two reigns presented both Roman Reigns and 'The Architect' respectively as saviours. As of 2019, Lesnar is again the safest pair of hands.

With SummerSlam in need of a main event, Brock will now be the first Champion booked by Paul Heyman going into the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer'. Will this tee up Rollins for round two as Universal Champion having beaten him in cleaner fashion in August, or could WWE have somebody entirely different in mind to go up against Brock? Braun Strowman appears to lead the chasing pack on tonight's evidence, but even speculation of that at this point seems vacant with both and Raw and SmackDown Live great unknowns.

Net positives, all around. Extreme Rules 2019, in a nutshell.

Advertisement