Pro wrestling is a simple sport, when you break it down to its very core. There are easy "formulas" that stand the test of time, and are used by wrestling promotions all across the globe, in an attempt to bring fans in to arenas, and in the case of the lucky, get fans to watch on television or order on pay-per-view. One of those formulas is, simply, "David and Goliath". In the bible, Goliath was a gigantic Philistine warrior that would eventually be beaten by the much smaller David, the man who would later become King of Israel. Through time, "David and Goliath" would go on to describe any situation where one side was much smaller than the other, or one side faced incredible odds in trying to obtain the goal they were looking for. With wrestling often being aimed towards the much larger, more muscular workers, it's only natural for the smaller wrestlers, both in stature and promotional hype, to want their share of the spotlight. If you're going to discuss "David and Goliath" situations in wrestling, you must look at these ten instances, where the odds were stacked against someone for one reason or another, and they were forced to overcome those odds when nobody expected them to do so.
10. Santino Defeats Umaga - Raw 2007
It's all about kayfabe, obviously, but the odds against Santino Marella were incredibly high in 2007. He debuted as a "fan in the crowd", chosen at random by Vince McMahon to face Intercontinental Champion Umaga for the title. Raw was coming from Italy that night, and as a man with a heavy Italian accent, the crowd got behind him right off the bat.Umaga was a monster, and he mowed through Santino like he should have. It was some assistance from Bobby Lashley that turned the tide and helped to give Santino the win, shocking the wrestling world. The crowd went nuts, and we had ourselves a new star. It can be argued that, based on his debut night and what his skills were, Santino should have been a bigger star in his career. That's not to say he should have been a ten-time WWE Champion or anything, but he had the tools to be more than what he was for 95% of his time with the company, and that's pretty much a jobber that provides comic relief on occasion.
9. Ron Simmons Defeats Vader - WCW 1992
It really doesn't matter if you think WCW gave Ron Simmons the World Title because of potential lawsuits and other issues over supposed racism in management or not. The fact of the matter is that Simmons was a midcarder one minute, and then the WCW Champion the next minute. With his name thrown into a "random drawing" for a shot at WCW Champion, Vader, after Jake "The Snake" Roberts injured Vader's original opponent, Sting, Simmons won and got his title match. He was over, no doubt, and he was never a bad in-ring performer, but he came out of nowhere. In today's WWE, it would be like R-Truth (totally coincidental, and has nothing to do with race) getting a WWE World Title shot against a beast like Brock Lesnar and then winning the belt, after weeks of beating people like Damien Sandow, Justin Gabriel, and David Otunga on random episodes of Raw. It would blow people away.The fact that it was a WCW Title match was bad enough, but that it was against one of the biggest and baddest men in all of wrestling only made this more shocking. Not that Simmons was a small man (6'2", 275 pounds), but he was certainly no Vader. It might not have been so bad if it was built to, but the "out of left field" nature of it all places it squarely on this list.
8. Shelton Benjamin Defeats Triple H - Raw 2004
Shelton Benjamin will go down as one of the most athletically gifted wrestlers anyone has ever seen. When he got in a ring, there was nothing he couldn't do. Many wrestling fans really wanted to see him become a big star in the business. His detractors would say that he didn't have the charisma or the mic skills needed to make himself a main event player, but realistically, that didn't stop many a wrestler from reaching that level in the past. On an episode of Raw in 2004, Shelton faced off against Triple H, who was only two weeks removed from dropping the World Title to Chris Benoit at WrestleMania 20. As good as Shelton was, he was only going to be a minor obstacle for Triple H to get over as he tried to get his World Title back. Not so fast. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x324y9_triple-h-vs-shelton-benjamin_sport After a distraction by Benoit (who was merely going after Ric Flair, who interfered in the match on behalf of Trips), Shelton got the roll-up victory, shocking the fans in Cincinnati that night. Not only did this happen, but Shelton would then go on to beat Triple H again the following week, albeit by countout this time. In fact, Shelton would go 6-0-1 in matches (singles, six-man tag, and eight-man tag) where he opposed Triple H over the next nine months. To be fair, Shelton never pinned him in any of those matches outside of the first one, but he still won. Fans assumed the wins would lead to something much bigger, but it never happened.
7. The Hurricane Defeats The Rock - Raw 2003
Even though he was largely used as a comedy character, The Hurricane was more than capable in the ring, and was always beloved by WWE fans. When he began having segments with The Rock in 2003, people knew they were going to get some humorous moments, but come on... we're talking about The Rock here. One of wrestling's all-time greats. A surefire WWE Hall Of Famer (at the time). That's when Steve Austin decided to show up and cause a distraction, giving Hurricane a chance to roll Rock up for the win. That is certainly becoming a theme on this list, but it happens. A pinfall victory is a pinfall victory, no matter what led to the pin, though. It's something you can't take away from The Hurricane, and it's something that you have to give The Rock props for going along with and never complaining about. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/xpd4nj_wwe-universal-fr-the-rock-vs-the-hurricane-raw_sport The win never really went anywhere, though. There was no rematch, and it wasn't too much longer until Hurricane was having matches with people like Rodney Mack, Chief Morley, and Christopher Nowinski. You'd think a victory over The Rock would lead to something more than that, but no, not even an Intercontinental Title shot, let alone being moved to the main event.
6. Rey Mysterio Wins The World Title - WrestleMania 22
Having someone the size (5'6" and 175 pounds, both of which are very generous) of Rey Mysterio win the World Title is a big enough upset, but there is a simple reason why it doesn't get a higher spot on this list... really, we all should have seen it coming. With the passing of Eddie Guerrero, it was clear that WWE was going to be pushing Rey Mysterio higher than ever. It made sense, whether or not you think it's despicable to capitalize on someone's death like this. Rey was like family to Eddie and the entire Guerrero clan, and in a wrestling sense, why not position Rey to be the top guy in the always-growing Latino viewing demographic with Eddie gone? http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x12esr4_wwe-wrestlemania-22-triple-threat-match-world-heavyweight-championship-randy-orton-vs-rey-mysterio-v_sport Even with all that said, Rey faced long odds at WrestleMania 22, being involved in a Triple Threat Match with the World Champion, Kurt Angle, and one of the company's top young stars, Randy Orton. The notoriously tough Chicago crowd wasn't in the mood for sentimental victories that night, as they began booing Rey more and more as the match went on, but Rey finally won, and he did what people had been telling him he couldn't do ever since he came to America to continue his career... be a World Champion. He had been dedicating his matches to the memory of Eddie, and the company made sure to mention that at every turn. It was a feel-good moment (unless you're one of the aforementioned people who hated the exploitation of a real-life death) for a very hard-working man, but if you would have asked people, one year prior, if they thought they would see Mysterio as a World Champion, they all would have said "no".
5. 1-2-3 Kid Defeats Razor Ramon - Raw 1993
This is one of those moments that moves down on the list when you look back at it in hindsight, but when it happened, it was one of the more shocking things anyone had ever seen in wrestling. One of the top heels in the WWF, Razor was a rising star that had big things in the future, in the eyes of many. The 1-2-3 Kid was yet another "enhancement talent" that wrestled on television back in that era, random people brought in from across the country to wrestle established names and get destroyed for a few minutes. Nobody looked at Kid and said he would probably go on to win 12 total titles for promotions that had television deals and were on pay-per-view. The match was going on the way everyone thought it would, when absolutely out of nowhere, Kid hit a Moonsault and got the pin, and the crowd went nuts. It was his only offensive move of the entire match, but it was effective. As Kid high-tailed it out of the ring and headed backstage, Razor flipped out in the ring, embarrassed that he lost. It would set up a connection between the two that remains to this day, where they would either be feuding or teaming together for much of the next five in-ring years, both in the WWF and in WCW. We thought The Kid would be another nobody, but the WWF had other plans, and it all started by blowing us all away, 21 years ago.
4. Ivan Koloff Defeats Bruno Sammartino - WWWF 1971
First things first, Ivan Koloff had himself a very successful career, especially working for the NWA, winning singles and tag titles all over the world. This isn't taking anything away from him, or any of his accomplishments. However, the reason he is here is because of a single number... 2,803. That number represents the days Bruno Sammartino had held the World Wide Wrestling Federation Heavyweight Title before dropping it to Koloff. That is over seven-and-a-half years of Bruno beating challenger after challenger after challenger. Bruno truly transcended the wrestling business in his time as champion. He had a private audience with the Pope at the Vatican during his title reign. He very nearly had the WWWF and the NWA come together to merge their titles, just to give him something else to accomplish, which would have changed the wrestling business forever. The crowd at Madison Square Garden was so shocked at Koloff's win that Sammartino famously said he thought he had lost his hearing during Koloff's kneedrop from the top rope because he didn't hear a thing after the bell. Koloff couldn't even have the title belt handed to him, for fear of the crowd starting a riot. When Sammartino began leaving the ring, many in the crowd broke down into tears. In the time long before the internet and overall fan cynicism, this left people stunned. Sammartino's reign had to end at some point, of course, but with successful defense after successful defense, you had to feel fans were beginning to forget that sometimes.
3. Maven Defeats The Undertaker - SmackDown 2002
As the male winner of the first season of Tough Enough, it's fair to say that many wrestling fans assumed Maven Huffman would become a star in the business. He had a good "look", possessed natural charisma, and was improving in the ring. In the 2002 Royal Rumble, Maven appeared to be on the fast track to success when he actually eliminated The Undertaker. As one would expect, Taker didn't appreciate being eliminated by a rookie, so he got back in the ring and beat the hell out of Maven. The Rumble elimination was probably enough to include this on the list, but two weeks later, Maven actually pinned Taker to win the Hardcore Title on an episode of Smackdown. To keep the theme here going strong, it certainly wasn't an earned victory, with Taker dominating the match, only to be attacked by The Rock, who would hit him with a chair and lay him out with a Rock Bottom.That's all it took for Maven to get the win, causing people to really think something special would be in his future. Once he left the Hardcore division two months later, he was back down to being nothing more than a jobber, losing to people like Hardcore Holly, Chavo Guerrero, and D-Von Dudley. Taker, of course, barely recovered from his embarrassing moments, struggling to move on with his career and only won 12 more matches at WrestleMania before losing to Brock Lesnar. What a jobber.
2. Kevin Federline Defeats John Cena - Raw 2007
http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5omzv_john-cena-vs-kevin-federline_sport This is originally where David Arquette winning the WCW Title was included on the list, but that has really been beaten into the ground through the years. It opens doors up for other arguments and discussions altogether, so, in its place, another instance where a celebrity showed up in the world of wrestling and had no business defeating a top tier performer, but did so, anyway. For those unaware of Kevin Federline's "rise to glory", he started off as a backup dancer for Britney Spears on her tours, and then became her husband, giving her two children in the process, and trying to use his new found "fame" to jump start his rap career. He was the ultimate success story for lazy men trying to find some super rich woman to impregnate so he would be able to sit at home and get rich. After their divorce, Federline is still making money, earning over $250,000 a year in child support from Spears. Fresh from news of their divorce (the match happened less than two months after the story broke, before the divorce was finalized), the man known as K-Fed would face John Cena on the New Year's Day 2007 episode of Raw, after being a thorn in Cena's side during previous appearances on the show. It wasn't much of a match at all. It featured several minutes of stall tactics from K-Fed and his "corner man", Johnny Nitro (aka John Morrison), and K-Fed thinking he was strong, while Cena took the entire thing as a joke. Using the No Disqualifications stipulation, Umaga would interfere and lay Cena out, allowing Federline to get the pin, and furthering the theme in this article. It was a very odd booking choice, having the current WWE Champion lose to an "outsider" like that, but it still counts, and Kevin Federline gets to add his name to the not-that-lengthy of a list of people who can claim a pinfall victory over Cena since Cena became a main event guy.
1. Barry Horowitz Defeats Bodydonna Skip - Action Zone 1995
Even though Skip of the Bodydonnas (better known as Chris Candido) was never a main event guy in the WWF, this is the upset in wrestling history. Barry Horowitz is one of the more famous "jobbers" of all-time, working in that role for years. Before the victory over Skip, Horowitz had not won a match on any sort of WWF programming for the entirety of his career there, spanning back to 1987. He won some house show matches in his early years, but television viewers had never once seen him victorious, not even by countout or disqualification. He suffered 176 consecutive losses on WWF programming before the Skip victory, and that number goes even higher if you count his early run in WCW. Think about that the next time your favorite WWE talent loses two or three straight matches on television and you complain about it. Nobody thought we would ever see Horowitz victorious. http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4twaf_action-zone-barry-horowitz-vs-skip_shortfilms The WWF used his win to push him as some sort of weird hybrid of jobber and someone to kind of take seriously, giving him three more televised victories in 1995 (Hakushi, Skip, and then teaming with Hakushi to beat Skip and Rad Radford), but it didn't really work. His career highlight would probably take place the following year, when he defeated Owen Hart on television. Words simply cannot describe how shocking this moment was, for those of you who are newer to the business and only started watching wrestling in the current era. Sure, there are "jobbers" in WWE today, but even the likes of Heath Slater, David Otunga, Zack Ryder, etc, don't go years without winning a match or two on television. Chances are, with the way the business and television have shifted, we'll never see something like this again, so we should cherish this moment and help it to live forever.