2015 was the worst year, creatively speaking, in WWE history. While there is stark competition from previous years of poor quality programming (e.g. 1993, 1995), nothing has ever been as bad as what WWE fans were forced to witness in the past twelve months. From miscast superstars to forced pushes, the writing team followed up a relatively promising 2014 with an absolutely abysmal effort that has even left some wrestling pundits legitimately questioning the effort of the man in charge. To think that Vince McMahon is intentionally sabotaging his company over pride is a scary thought that, especially after the last year's worth of programming, cannot be immediately dispelled. Fans have often wondered what it would take to get the ship turned around in the right direction. USA Network's involvement? Plummetting stock prices? Significant loss of WWE Network subscribers? These would definitely put more pressure on the company, but the only real way to get the WWE corrected is if Vince McMahon is willing to make the necessary changes. Changes that could mean removing himself from having final creative approval, or recognizing that the year 2015 doesn't necessitate a need for a dozen writers. The company ran pretty well back when the three men of Vince, Bruce Prichard and Pat Patterson booked the territory. Regardless of what the future holds, there is no denying that 2015 was the worst year creatively in WWE history...
14. Continued Shift Towards WWE Network
Perhaps one of the reasons the WWE television product has suffered so much in 2015 is because of the WWE Network. The service launched early in 2014 and, like any new major venture, it will take several years for the company to truly understand the role that the Network will play. One of the drawbacks to the new service is that other areas may suffer from a decreased level of focus. The WWE Network is already more successful than Vince's previous gambles as the streaming service has lasted longer than both the XFL and the World Bodybuilding Federation. Like those two defunct brands, time and money has been invested into the new venture and it's only natural that it could lessen the focus on its cable programming. We've already seen SmackDown fall to the wayside in terms of its perceived importance to WWE storytelling, and hopefully it will be rejuvenated with the move to USA Network. As for RAW, it is possible that the WWE Network is monopolizing the best ideas and creative energy, whether the WWE realizes it or not. The network has significantly improved since getting its feet wet in 2014, and although there are still several ways to improve the service, the quality of content has been vastly superior to RAW. Coincidence?
13. A Lack Of Long-Term Planning
No matter how many times this next point has been criticized, the writing team continues to ignore the importance of long-term planning. There are valid reasons to change plans, scripts and formats at the last minute, but dropping storylines and booking on the fly should not become the norm. Unfortunately, that is exactly what's happening in WWE. The latest example is the whole Lana/Rusev/Ziggler/Summer Rae storyline that, as bad as it was, was completely abandoned after Lana, on Twitter, revealed her real-life engagement to her fake-life rival and ex-boyfriend Rusev that was picked up TMZ. If that was a one-off, I'd be able to forgive the WWE for it, but it's not. Most likely the fault lies with Vince McMahon as he may decide at the last minute to change things around, but regardless of who's to blame in this case, the only way to get back on track is to write and book for the future. Start at the end and work backwards. WCW was ridiculed for constantly dropping storylines and not booking long-term. Now, it's become common on WWE programming as well.
12. Where's The Heat?
The sports-entertainment genre has always been a business that has told the story of good vs. evil being settled in a ring. Regardless of whom or what is perceived as "good" and "bad" in the changing times, the morality play of babyface vs. heel remained. WWE has blurred the lines in such a poor way that audiences often do not know whom to cheer, and one of the causes is a lack of HEAT. Where has the heat gone? Why are the audiences supposed to want to pay to see the heel get their comeuppance if they're never building their heat? It has and always will be a crucial element to the professional wrestling business and, make no mistake, Vince McMahon is still in the pro-wrestling business. His company might be different than the rasslin his daddy booked, but to ignore the basic fundamentals of this genre is so stupid, it's beyond words. It makes no sense and it goes against everything the business is about. No matter how bad Vince wants to reinvent the wheel with what type of business he is perceived to be in, the fact is he runs a pro-wrestling company. Call it 'rasslin', call it sports-entertainment, call it baseball for all I care, but it doesn't change the type of product fans expect and Vince McMahon is not providing it to them.
11. Hardly Anyone Is Over
In thinking about 2015 creatively, you might be tempted to say that 1995 or 1993 was worse. Allow me to share with you one major difference between then and now. In those years, the WWE had several talents that were OVER! When Luger flopped in '93, Vince went back to Bret Hart. When Diesel flopped in '95, Vince went back to Bret again and then tried Shawn Michaels. Nobody on the current main roster, outside of John Cena and Brock Lesnar, is over. That is a major problem! In 1995, the company was running on Diesel power and while Kevin Nash's year-long run as WWF Champion was considered a failure, there were plenty of other superstars that captivated crowds throughout the year. Bret Hart was over. Shawn Michaels was over. The Undertaker was over. Razor Ramon was over. Hell, even Diesel got over once he dropped the title late in the year and turned heel/tweener the night after Survivor Series '95. And 1993? Bret Hart, Hulk Hogan, The Undertaker, Yokozuna all headlined various PPVs that year and, like 'em or not, those men were over. These superstars of '93 and '95 made the best of any poor storylines the WWE put them in, and the fans believed in these men. There is no such correlation to 2015.
10. No Creative Freedom
To say that no one is over isn't entirely the fault of the talent. Talents are wise to not want to risk their future with the biggest sports-entertainment company in the world. It's well documented how the lack of competition has negatively impacted the business in various ways, but the absence of creative freedom that wrestlers face today might just be the biggest. Without creative freedom, Austin 3:16 nor The Rock would have existed, Shawn Michaels would be a completely different character, and Triple H might've been a career-long mid-carder. As risky as the talents may have appeared in years past, talents today are almost equally submissive and, again, it's hard to blame them. Recently, Brad Maddox took the smallest creative liberty in a non-televised dark match by cutting a promo calling the crowd "cocky pricks" instead of the scripted term "cocky losers". This seemingly innocuous change would hardly be considered a risk by yesteryear's standards, but in 2015, WWE determined that Brad Maddox's actions were a terminable offence and he lost his job. No wonder there's no Stone Cold or D-Generation X telling Vince to suck it. It's one thing to manage talent and to de-escalate any overblown egos, but WWE has petrified the talents to the point of stagnancy. The product is a reflection of the environment the company breeds: creatively stifled.
9. Roman Reigns
You knew this one was coming. As everyone knows by now, Roman is the man chosen by the WWE to be the next face of the company. The push started long ago, but it really started to "heat up" (yeah, right) at the 2015 Royal Rumble. Without exaggerating, I can honestly say that if the WWE wanted to make the crowd dislike Roman Reigns more than anyone in the company, they couldn't have done a better job. The problem is they were trying to make Roman Reigns beloved by the fans and turn him into the biggest babyface in the WWE. That's embarrassing. Do I really need to say that much more? The issues with Roman Reigns' booking have been well documented. WWE continues to highlight this man's weaknesses, putting him in positions that he shouldn't be in, and booking him in the most incredible ways (a Daniel Bryan-esque underdog, that'll make fans cheer him!). With the entire year's worth of planning leading to a crowning moment for a superstar who isn't even remotely close to being over at the level the top spot demands, it's no wonder 2015 has been brutal.
8. Injuries
Most of the reasons that made 2015 a disaster revolved around decisions made by the WWE. This one wasn't something they could control. The year started on a positive note with Daniel Bryan announcing his return to the WWE and his participation in the 2015 Royal Rumble. Unfortunately, things didn't turn out great as he was forced to vacate his newly won Intercontinental Championship shortly after WrestleMania 31 and may never return to a WWE ring. The biggest star of 2015 has arguably been Seth Rollins. After his historic Money In The Bank cash-in during the main event of WrestleMania, Rollins went on to hold the title for 7 months before injury forced him to vacate the title. That's two former WWE Champions currently out of action, and one's career is in serious doubt. Beyond those two huge names Randy Orton recently suffered another shoulder injury that has also put his career in question. Sami Zayn is only just now returning to the ring after suffering a shoulder injury of his own, and Sting suffered multiple injuries in his main event match against Seth Rollins at Night Of Champions. There's been other superstars that have been hit with injury too, but the amount of top level talents that were seriously hurt this year made 2015 made not just the worst year from a creative standpoint, but the worst ever for injuries as well.
7. CenaSTILLwinslol
The past year has featured some of the best matches in John Cena's entire career, but, aside from the fantastic US Open Challenge, the booking of John Cena was a huge contribution to the disaster that has been 2015. As the year began, Rusev was an undefeated monster heel who had soundly defeated Sheamus to become the United States Champion. Like Bray Wyatt the year before, Rusev lost to John Cena at WrestleMania and then went on to lose again at Extreme Rules, and again in an "I Quit" Match at Payback. While far from being unsalvageable, Rusev has yet to recover from those three decisive defeats. Next up for the 15-time World Champ was NXT Champion Kevin Owens. Like Rusev before him, Owens secured the victory in their first PPV match but would lose the next two encounters, including another submission. Cena's next feud involved the WWE Champion Seth Rollins. Like the two heels before him, Rollins won the first encounter, a Title vs. Title match at SummerSlam. Continuing the trend of needing multiple victories before ultimately winning the feud, Cena defeated the WWE Champion cleanly in the next two PPV/Special Event matches, Night Of Champions and Live From Madison Square Garden. To summarize, John Cena successfully vanquished the undefeated United States Champion Rusev, the undefeated NXT Champion Kevin Owens, and the WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins all within 6 months. If that doesn't provide a good illustration of why there no new stars, why no one is over (except Cena and Lesnar), and why 2015 was so poor creatively, I don't know what will.
6. Ineffectiveness Of NXT As Developmental
Arguably the best promotion of the year, NXT had a phenomenal 2015, make no mistake. But as a developmental territory that is supposed to churn out future superstars for WWE? 2015 was meh. As the reigning Intercontinental Champion, Kevin Owens is the best argument for an NXT success story in 2015, but who else from NXT has had a successful transition since being called up? The Ascension? Neville? Charlotte? The jury's still out on this one, but bringing up three NXT women at the same time and shuffling them into a misguided, 9-woman tag-team feud under the failed branding of a "Divas Revolution" is not exactly the best way to start. Becky Lynch? Sash Banks? See above and entry #5. Meanwhile on the main roster, Sheamus is WWE Champion and the embarrassingly stagnant Roman Reigns is #1 contender, both just headlined December's PPV. Am I the only one that thinks Samoa Joe vs. Finn Balor would have been better off main-eventing TLC instead of NXT Takeover? This is the problem with NXT; talented performers that are clear impact players remain sidelined and underutilized by staying in NXT for far too long. If the yellow brand is first and foremost the developmental system for the future, and WWE is in dire need of help right now, why not call up these two men and put them on the card instead of Tommy Dreamer and Rhyno? Timing is everything and if NXT is to remain the breeding ground for future WWE superstars, then WWE must do a better job at the planning and execution of NXT call-ups going forward.
5. Divas Revolution
What a failure. This was such a huge swing-and-a-miss for WWE Creative and Vince McMahon whom is rumored to be heavily involved in planning the divas' storylines. It's such a shame too because the women that were called up to WWE, Sasha Banks, Charlotte, and Becky Lynch, are talented wrestlers. To start, excluding Natalya right off the bat was a gross disservice to the company, as well as Natty. It's awful that Tyson Kidd suffered a terrifying, life-threatening neck injury right around the the start of this angle, but Natalya could certainly have been incorporated in some fashion. At least put her name out there as a "Who's side is she on?" type of tease to keep fans engaged. Instead of slowly injecting these three NXT call-ups into the main roster to compete for Nikki Bella's historic championship, the company blew it by hotshotting these women into the angle all at once. All of this is without even mentioning the involvement of superheel Stephanie McMahon and her sudden, inexplicable on-screen spearheading of the entire ordeal as if she was some sort of beloved babyface. Ugh, 2015.
4. Authority Still Top Heels
Speaking of Stephanie, the Authority remained in the top heel position throughout all of 2015. Triple H and Stephanie began the year by being brought back on TV only 5 weeks after a stipulation forced them to be taken off following the 2014 Survivor Series. While Stephanie can garner heat like no other, the Authority angle had been going on for over a year and a half at that point and even further when you consider its roots. The whole "heel authority role" has been a staple of WWE programming ever since Steve Austin stunned Vince McMahon in Madison Square Garden on September 22nd, 1997. That's over 18 years ago. Half of the reason why that angle was so damn successful in the first place is because of the legendary Stone Cold Steve Austin, and the other half was Vince McMahon. For the time period, the storyline was interesting and well received, but it was the performers that brought the magic to it. The WWE doesn't have anyone like Austin on the roster today and Vince McMahon hasn't been a full time on-screen performer for years, yet they still push forward with this beaten up storyline and, unfortunately, there's still no end in sight.
3. NXT Has Been Better Than WWE
Maybe if there was no NXT, the WWE brand might have been better in 2015? It's a notion worth thinking about considering the levels of talent that exist in Orlando. Where would those talents be working if NXT didn't exist? It's hard to believe that all of the athletes from the Performance Center would be under contract to the WWE, but there's clearly enough confidence in Finn Balor, Bayley, Sami Zayn, and Apollo Crews to warrant spots on the main roster.
There have been reports stating that some NXT talents were brought in with the sole intention of strictly working NXT and won't be considered for the main roster. These are veteran performers that WWE believes to have more to offer as an on-the-job trainer than they would as a money-drawing superstar. Rumors have abound that Samoa Joe and Asuka are in for these roles. Would those talents have helped WWE in 2015?
Advertisement
The WWE shows have been bad and the roster is thin, but if NXT didn't exist, would WWE have more depth in their talent pool to be able to put out a better product or inspire new stories for the writing team? As the developmental territory for WWE, it does make it interesting to think about what 2015 could have been if all of these talents were on RAW.
2. No One Left To Turn To
The WWE is currently suffering through a ratings crisis that hasn't been felt in nearly 20 years. The WWE has faced the reality of declining viewership before and Vince doesn't seem to sweat it. What makes 2015 different than in years past is that now Vince truly has no where to turn. Previously, he might have made a call to Shawn Michaels or Ric Flair to make an appearance, but that well's run dry and, with all due respect to those two legends, they no longer have the impact they once did as performers. Steve Austin and The Rock were two of the biggest superstars in history and can still pop a number, but there's no confidence in WWE Creative to effectively use these stars judging by Austin's latest RAW appearance in which he was a glorified ring announcer. Finally, The Undertaker was the one man Vince would turn to whenever he needed help, but despite the character he portrays, the man behind The Undertaker actually is human. Time has caught up with the Deadman and while he can still put on a decent-to-good match given the proper protection, he's well past his prime. Even his appearances don't have the impact they used to since the creative team's ideas for The Undertaker don't ever seem to extend beyond a pairing with Kane. So Vince has no one left he can turn to and seems to have run out of tricks.
1. Vince McMahon
There's no where to else to put the blame. Vince micro-manages many aspects of the company and the creative department is no different. He approves everything that makes it on television, so if audiences are not happy with what they are seeing, and judging by the ratings they clearly aren't, who else should be held responsible? Triple H is able to run a compelling program every Wednesday night on the WWE Network with similar, yet fewer resources down in Orlando than McMahon has. There's no evil billionaire poaching Vince's talent that he can blame for a lack of star power these days. No government agency is breathing down his neck causing him to shift his focus off WWE. Surely, his company isn't in financial peril or suffering from a lack of assets or resources needed to help develop his talent and programming, yet still his television shows and stories remain poor. There is no valid reason why Vince McMahon should not be held accountable for the abysmal storytelling and creative campaign that the WWE has embarked upon in 2015. The results of which are still being felt and will likely continue to until radical changes take place internally, but don't hold your breath. Yes, there were years in the past when the WWE was less than good, but nothing can compare to the brutal year that was 2015.