14 Wrestlers Who Should Probably Regret Leaving WWE

The grass wasn't always greener on the other side.

By Jay Alletto /

Twenty years ago, the pro wrestling landscape was in a completely different place. Take a look at July 1994 and where mainstream pro wrestling was. WWE was in a transitional period; moving away from Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage to pushing new stars like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. World Championship Wrestling (WCW) was acquiring mainstream talent, like Hogan and Savage, that shifted momentum in the world of pro wrestling into their direction. Meanwhile, a little promotion in Philadelphia, Eastern Championship Wrestling, was on the verge of taking things to "THE EXTREME." Here we are in 2014; taking a look back into the annals of pro wrestling history with just one major company in play. While TNA & Ring of Honor are doing what they can to make a splash, WWE is still the mark of excellence in professional wrestling; overcoming the onslaught of competitors along the way. WWE is the place to be. Sadly for the following 14 stars, they chose to leave WWE at entirely the wrong time and have probably been regretting it ever since.

14. Curt Hennig

The former Mr. Perfect was never quite the same after leaving the WWE for WCW. While he returned to the ring and became a key member of the nWo, he also was cast as a character in the West Texas Rednecks. He battled with a young superstar who thought he was perfect, "PerfectShawn" Shawn Stasiak and then started sliding into obscurity. Had Curt Hennig continued to be Mr. Perfect and was able to make his in-ring wrestling return to a WWE ring, he would have benefitted from the birth of "The Attitude Era" in a huge way. With emerging talents like The Rock, Mick Foley and Stone Cold Steve Austin, Mr. Perfect would have been a great addition to some interesting battles. Sadly, Curt Hennig passed away in February of 2003 of a cocaine overdose. He did have a short-lived, solid return to WWE starting in January of 2002 at the Royal Rumble. However, if he would have ran the course with WWE and didn't take the money to go to WCW, he may have had many strong years as Mr. Perfect.

13. Sycho Sid

WWE.comSid bounced back and forth between WWE and WCW in the early 1990s, eventually landing back on the WWE roster in 1995. When Sid originally joined WWE in 1991, he had a lot of hype around him as a massive, heir to the throne of Hulk Hogan. He arrived on the scene as a fan favorite and was the referee for a huge match at SummerSlam 1991 when Sgt Slaughter teamed with Col. Mustafa (The Iron Sheik) against Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior. Soon thereafter, Sid started a feud with Hogan, turning heel and gaining a main event spot at WrestleMania 8. After failing a drug test in WWE and a failed run to be a professional softball player, Sid returned to WCW. In his 2nd of three stints with WCW, Sid got into an infamous altercation with Arn Anderson at a hotel in the United Kingdom. During this scuffle, Sid stabbed Arn Anderson with scissors twenty times in the chest and stomach. Both men were rushed to the hospital and Sid was released from WCW shortly thereafter. After returning to Memphis for a couple of years to feud with Jerry Lawler in the USWA, Sid returned to WWE in 1995. During his run as Shawn Michaels' bodyguard, Sid was able to gain momentum and get back into the public eye of WWE fans. He became WWE Champion twice and even main evented WrestleMania 13 against The Undertaker, his 2nd WrestleMania main event while a member of the WWE roster. Sid parted ways with WWE in 1997, had a short stint in ECW in early 1999 and eventually landing back in WCW later that year, being hyped as "The Millennium Man." During his final WCW run, Sid suffered a major injury on January 14, 2001 at the "Sin" pay-per-view. While attempting a flying big boot from the middle turnbuckle, Sid landed on one leg and fractured it. When thinking back, if Sid never decided to leave WWE after his main event level run in 1997, he may have never fractured his leg and nearly ended his career. The injury not only took him off WWE's radar, but shortened his professional career overall. Also, if Sid hadn't left the WWE in 1992, he likely wouldn't have ended up in a life-threatening situation with Arn Anderson in a United Kingdom hotel room.

12. Lex Luger

In 1995, Lex Luger committed career treason when he left WWE for WCW without giving Vince McMahon any notice whatsoever. He had a handshake agreement to stay with WWE. While he gained financial success returning to WCW and achieved a huge career moment by defeated Hollywood Hulk Hogan for the WCW Championship on Nitro, he left WWE just a few short years before they blew up as a mainstream powerhouse. As WCW started to go on a downward spiral, Lex was one of the guys at the top of the ladder. He suffered a few out of place, illogical heel turns and floundered as a talent through the creative changes to the company. When WWE acquired WCW in 2001, he was blackballed and basically called out by Vince McMahon live on the air that we would never see him again on WWE television. After suffering a spinal stroke in 2007, Lex Luger was bound to a wheelchair without the use of his arms or legs. As time went on, the movement came back and he now works for WWE as a consultant on their wellness policy. You can see how the downward trend on the career of Lex Luger took place after he left WWE.

11. Chyna

The 9th Wonder of the World had a fantastic run in WWE while it lasted. She was unlike any female that WWE has seen in the past and she's unlike any female that WWE has since since. Chyna was brought in as the bodyguard of Triple H and Shawn Michaels in Degeneration X. She was romantically linked to Triple H for a few years before a nasty break-up took place when Triple H turned storyline into reality & started dating Stephanie McMahon in 2000. She left WWE in November of 2001 after months of not appearing on television. When Chyna left WWE, she struggled to find her calling in life; turning up in a celebrity sex-tape with fellow ex-Degeneration X member, X-Pac. She used the success of her sex tape to move on to a career in porn and had a stint on the VH-1 reality series, "Celebrity Rehab" along the way. One has to wonder if the circumstances leading to her departure started the path of destruction in her personal life.

10. Mick Foley

If Mick Foley knew then what he knows now... In 2008, The Hardcore Legend, Mick Foley ventured into the world of color commentary in WWE debuting at Backlash along side Michael Cole. Throughout his run as a commentator, Foley was paired with Jim Ross when Ross was surprisingly moved to Smackdown in an effort to create a new voice of WWE with Michael Cole at the helm of Raw. At the time, Mick didn't know that WWE was going to start him out on a commentating contract; which was a substantial amount of money less than his normal WWE appearance deal. As time went on, Foley became disenchanted by the constant badgering from Vince McMahon in his headphones throughout the broadcast. He started to understand the nuances and intricacies of what it takes to be a full-time WWE color commentator. Mick Foley soon left WWE and headed to TNA where he was the victim of strange creative circumstances and another fledgling run with an ECW reunion. If Mick Foley would have stayed with WWE, he may have continued a potentially great career as a broadcaster. Foley did return to WWE shortly after his TNA run came to an end and appeared numerous times on special occasions.

9. Bobby Heenan

When Bobby Heenan took the money and left WWE for WCW, his career was never quite the same. While in WWE, he had an undeniable dynamic with his fellow announcers that wasn't even close to what he accomplished in WCW. While his work with Eric Bischoff, Tony Schivanoe, Mike Tenay and others wasn't bad, he definitely didn't seem as genuinely motivated as he was previously. He was one of the most hated heel managers and announcers of all in time WWE. But in WCW, he became an afterthought. WCW missed many opportunities to get Bobby Heenan involved in some top storylines. Imagine if he became Hulk Hogan's manager in the nWo after years of trying to destroy Hulkamania? This isn't a knock on Bobby Heenan, but when listening to his commentary in WCW, you could tell how uninterested he was in certain aspects of the show. If he would have stayed in WWE throughout the rest of the New Generation Era and into The Attitude Era, his talents would have no doubt been utilized to their full potential.

8. Jeff Jarrett

After years of mid card success in the New Generation Era during the mid-90s, Jeff Jarrett ventured to WCW after a contract dispute where he signed a one year contract. After a year of wallowing in WCW mediocrity, Jarrett went back to the WWE for another two year run. There may not have been another athlete that jumped back and forth between two companies as much as Jeff Jarrett did in the late 1990's. In 1999, Jeff Jarrett jumped back to WCW where he became one of their more featured athletes and WCW World Champion. Sadly, with Jeff Jarrett at the top of the mountain, WCW started to go on a huge downward spiral on the business end. When WCW was officially purchased by WWE, Mr. McMahon made his feelings on Jeff Jarrett public on Monday Night Raw by saying that Jeff was officially gone. While Jarrett was able to use his experience in the wrestling business to start TNA Wrestling, there is no telling what heights his career would have went to if he didn't leave WWE in 1996 over contract issues.

7. Ravishing Rick Rude

In 1987, Rick Rude made his debut in WWE after years of wrestling throughout different territories of the National Wrestling Alliance. Upon his debut, Rude was pushed as a member of The Heenan Family with immediate success. Rude had epic battles with Jake "The Snake" Roberts, "Rowdy" Roddy Piper & The Ultimate Warrior during his time with WWE. Rude had a series of matches with newly crowned WWE Champion, The Ultimate Warrior, but we never able to defeat Warrior for the gold. Unfortunately, the late Rick Rude left WWE in 1990. Circumstances around his departure have been speculated upon for years, but most signs point to Rude's failure to stay in top contention for the WWE Championship as a reason for leaving the company. He never received a long-term run against Hulk Hogan and was consistently put back in the ring with The Ultimate Warrior. While Rick Rude went on to have great success in WCW (even becoming their World Champion), he suffered a career ending back injury in a match against Sting. With the way things ended up in the WCW, one has to wonder if Rick Rude regretted his decision to leave WWE. How would his career have turned out if he stuck around through the transition into The New Generation and The Attitude Era as an active competitor?

6. Randy Savage

The "Macho Man" Randy Savage is one of the biggest names in the history of the pro wrestling business. While he had two incredible runs as WWE Champion in 1988-1989 and then in 1992, he was banished to the announce table after WWE started their talent transition to The New Generation. In 1994, Randy Savage decided that he was going to leave WWE for WCW because he wanted to be an active in-ring competitor. Savage had a lot left in his tank in the wrestling ring and WCW was offering large amounts of money in guaranteed contracts to former WWE wrestlers. While Savage was able to reap the benefits of the New World Order and headline a variety of huge WCW shows, he also never seemed to have the love and admiration from the fans that he did while in the WWE. Hulk Hogan always seemed to stop any added momentum that Randy Savage started to gain in WCW, much like he did in WWE a decade earlier. His legacy also became tarnished for years as the WWE rarely acknowledged his existence in the history of the company.There are many rumors surrounding the relationship of the late Randy Savage and Vince McMahon. Savage never was able to fully return to the WWE before his untimely death in 2011, although he started to rekindle a relationship with the company through appearances in video games & use of his likeness in action figures. Longtime wrestling fans have to wonder how Randy Savage would have fared on the WWE roster if he would have been a member of The Attitude Era. The amount of epic storylines and angles that could have taken place involving The Macho Man could have altered the foundation of the pro wrestling business.

5. Kurt Angle

The Olympic Gold Medalist unexpectedly left WWE in 2006 after a short stint in the newly relaunched "ECW" brand. Angle had been going through a variety injuries and personal issues during his final year with WWE. He asked for and was granted his release. Although Angle will probably tell you that he didn't regret leaving WWE when he did, there is no doubt that moving from the top of the pro wrestling industry down to TNA has an effect on the prestige of a career. There is no doubt in my mind that Kurt Angle has had a successful career in TNA over the past 8 years. The run has lasted longer than his first WWE run did! He won championship after championship, but could you imagine where his standing in wrestling history would be if he stuck around WWE? He missed out on a fair share of huge opportunities in WWE. Shortly after he left, WWE started running WrestleMania in huge, 75,000 seat stadiums. There's no question that Kurt missed out on "WrestleMania Moment" after "WrestleMania Moment." Lately, there has been speculation that there will be a return of Kurt Angle to WWE. He has stated on occasion that he would love to finish his pro wrestling career where it started. But will he? Only time will tell.

4. Booker T

In 2007, Booker T was riding high as the snotty, arrogant "King Booker." However, Booker was the victim of a suspension due to being on a list by Signature Pharmacy, who was allegedly distributing steroids to many top athletes including an array of WWE Superstars. Although Booker claimed he was suspended erroneously, WWE still issued the suspension for violating their Wellness Policy. Shortly thereafter, Booker headed to TNA Wrestling where he wallowed in mediocrity for nearly 3 years of his career. Much like Kurt Angle, I'm sure Booker T enjoyed his time in TNA; especially the much lighter work & travel schedule. He undoubtedly missed some huge moments that would have taken place in WWE had he not decided to leave the company when he did. When he returned to WWE, he was past his prime and couldn't contribute much as an in-ring competitor to the product. He mainly focused on out of the ring roles as an announcer and a short-lived run as General Manager of Smackdown.

3. Ricky "The Dragon" Steamboat

Over the past 20 years, Ricky Steamboat has had a tumultuous on and off relationship with WWE. In 1988, only a year after his epic encounter with Randy Savage at WrestleMania 3, Ricky Steamboat retired from in-ring competition and left WWE. The story is that Steamboat requested some time off from WWE competition shortly after WrestleMania 3 to spend time with his wife and newborn son. This didn't sit well with Vince McMahon and other higher ups in WWE and he was forced to drop the Intercontinental Championship to The Honky Tonk Man. After a successful run in the NWA, Steamboat once again returned to WWE for another short-lived run. This time, Steamboat allegedly quit because he was set to lose a squash match to The Undertaker on an episode of "Superstars" a few weeks before Undertaker was set to win the WWE Championship from Hulk Hogan. At this point, Steamboat headed back to WCW for another successful run, albeit not achieving the World Championship caliber success in his previous stint. Unfortunately, Steamboat suffered a career-ending back injury in a match against Stunning Steve Austin and was fired shortly thereafter via FedEx package by Eric Bischoff. While it is unlikely that Ricky Steamboat has any real regret about leaving WWE on two separate occasions, one has to wonder what path his career had taken if he didn't leave in both instances.

2. Steve Austin

Stone Cold Steve Austin is one of the biggest draws in the history of the sports entertainment industry. However, he was also a part of one of the more controversial exits in the history of WWE. In 2002, Steve Austin admittedly became exhausted by his legendary run at the top of the mountain. Things started to spiral out of control for "The Rattlesnake" as years of injuries & travelling all over the world were effective his psyche. Also, the lack of direction for the "Stone Cold" character & illogical creative ideas were something that rightfully got in the way of Austin's desire to wrestle. Steve Austin has admitted countless times that one of the biggest regrets of his career was not showing up to Raw on June 17, 2002. The plan was for Stone Cold to face Brock Lesnar in a "King of the Ring" qualifying match where Lesnar was booked to defeat Austin. The illogical booking is something that Austin didn't agree with. He chose to not show up to Raw that night and leave WWE for all intents and purposes. It took nearly a year for WWE to get back on the same page with Austin to "bury the hatchet" and plan for a Stone Cold return to the ring. The events of that night changed the course of WWE history & tainted WWE's view of Austin over the course of 2002. Since then, Austin has been embraced by the WWE Universe once again and has become a member of the WWE Hall of Fame. If Stone Cold would have stuck around in 2002, rumors were circulating that there could have been a showdown between Austin & Hulk Hogan at SummerSlam. And who knows how long his feud with Eddie Guerrero would have gone on for and what kind of amazing matches could have come out of that.

1. Bret Hart

Bret "The Hitman" Hart had signed an unprecedented 20 year contract with WWE in 1996 that ensured he would spend the rest of his career as a WWE employee. Over the next year or so, Vince McMahon decided that he wanted out of that contract. A deal was brokered for Bret to head to WCW under a 3 year contract for an unbelievable amount of money. Unfortunately, "The Montreal Screwjob" took place at WWE Survivor Series 1997 & Bret's career went into a monumental downward spiral. To this day, Bret regrets having to leave WWE for WCW. Nearly a decade went by before Bret Hart was brought back to WWE for an induction into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2006. One has to wonder how things would have ended up for both WWE and Bret had he stayed throughout The Attitude Era. Would the Mr. McMahon character have flourished as one of the greatest heels in pro wrestling history? Would Bret have suffered a career ending concussion? And to go even further: would Owen have been in the rafters of Kemper Arena at Over The Edge 1999? Hypothetical questions can be posed in almost every situation that I've written about so far. But none go deeper than the ripple effect that was caused when Bret left WWE for WCW.