15 Best Matches To Ever Take Place At Royal Rumble

The Royal Rumble undercard has often been the highlight of the night.

By Chad Matthews /

When we flip the calendar to January each New Year, it usually means one thing above all others for wrestling fans: the Royal Rumble is this month. It may be the fourth oldest of the Big 4 PPVs in WWE, but the Rumble has become the second most popular event of the year over the last decade. Its namesake gimmick is the primary reason for the nostalgic reverie, but it is not the only reason. The Rumble, perhaps more than any WWE special event sans for WrestleMania and mini-WrestleMania (Summerslam), has an indelible legacy for match quality €“ and that extends beyond the 30-man over-the-top-rope Battle Royal. From undercard classics to main-event Match of the Year candidates, the Royal Rumble has developed, over the years, a great reputation for the bouts beyond the Rumble match, itself. The 2015 Rumble PPV is just around the corner. Before we celebrate the finest Rumble matches in history, let us appreciate the best and brightest from the rest of the cards throughout the event's near 30 year history. Let it be understood that the first five picks are considered by your literary narrator to be a collection of underrated stories painted on the pro wrestling canvas, while the top 10 are thought to be indisputable (at least in regards to their presence and not necessarily their order).

15. Goldust Vs. Razor Ramon (Royal Rumble '96)

If you have grown up in this modern generation of growing acceptance and understanding, then you may not fully appreciate the effectiveness of the Goldust character back in the New Generation. When he debuted, he redefined the word €œcontroversy€ in pro wrestling. He played up to every stereotype associated with the homosexual male, while never actually saying outright his orientation. Back then, it was as easy to dislike that character as breathing air. Today, it is as easy to appreciate the talent that Dustin Runnels displayed in that role as writing the word €œiconic.€ It was truly one of the most underrated reasons for the mindset behind the envelope-pushing Attitude Era. The perfect foil to that character was the, in real life, uncomfortable Scott Hall, who portrayed Razor Ramon. He was clearly not OK with what was going on. It was written all over his face and in his body language. He's not that good of an actor. Other than Roddy Piper, Razor was the most high profile Goldust opponent. Their feud over the IC title peaked at the '96 Royal Rumble. We praise in modern times €œreality.€ You can comb through sports entertainment lore and struggle to find a match that felt more real than Goldust vs. Ramon. Every punch thrown, every risque gesture, and every psychological moment. This match is a great example of why WWE Network is a priceless purchase for wrestling enthusiasts.

14. Rey Mysterio Vs. Undertaker (Royal Rumble '10)

The word €œinauspicious€ comes to mind when thinking back a half decade to Mysterio vs. Taker. Everyone knew who was going to win long before the night. So, like a lot of the Deadman's matches at Mania, his World title defense against Mysterio suffered from the foregone conclusion of the result. It was not overly long either, so it is not exactly an epic performance by any means. The reason why €œinauspicious€ comes to mind is because it is unfortunate that nobody talks about this match. Forget what it is not and focus on what it is and what you will see when you rewatch it is the greatest example, perhaps ever, of how to execute a match between a cruiserweight of Rey's size and a heavyweight of Taker's. One of the biggest little criticisms of Mysterio's matches when he became a headliner was that they were not believable. Sure, he was fun to watch, but the psychology often lacked depth, making some of his bouts hokey. Taker became an incredibly underrated psychologist in the latter stages of his career, so maybe it should come as no surprise that he and Mysterio combined to put together a match void of the pitfalls from previous cruiser vs. heavy performances. Mysterio's spots were used as logically as ever before. They each moved around the ring with a fluidity that allowed the match to come across as a unique take on David vs. Goliath €“ call it miniature David vs. Goliath, if you will. It was a beautiful piece of work. You should check it out again.

13. Edge Vs. Dolph Ziggler (Royal Rumble '11)

If Dolph Ziggler ever (finally) makes it to the top of the WWE mountain, then he has a career retrospective ready to be written about or told on a WWE DVD. He started with the Spirit Squad, a wrestle crap gimmick if there ever was one. He re-debuted with the name Dolph Ziggler, for crying out loud. Only a guy who wanted to make it more than his peers could have overcome some of the stuff thrown at him when he was coming up through the ranks. And there he was in early 2011, wrestling Edge for the World Heavyweight Championship and, just as he had done in every previous opportunity, making the absolute most of his chance to shine. That is where the €œStealing the Show€ moniker began to stick for him. Set him up and he never failed to spike it. Edge vs. Ziggler is one of the Rumble's greatest matches that nobody talks about. It was the curtain jerker €“ and one of the finest curtain jerker's in the last decade at that €“ but, perhaps, that hurts its historical stature. It also came during a less-than-memorable character run for the Rated R Superstar, who was more like the Rated PG Superstar by then. Yet, if you watch it back, there is nothing that can be taken away from their performance. They worked like it was the main-event and it reviews in hindsight like a main-event. It was for the World title, after all. Should the Ziggler DVD every get made, surely this is a match that will be featured on it.

12. The Rock Vs. CM Punk (Royal Rumble '13)

Noticing a theme, here? This decade has produced some really good matches at the Royal Rumble. It is safe to say that there has never been a more critical time in WWE fan history and, in fairness, we have not exactly had the chance to allow many of these matches to breathe enough so that we can fully establish where they should rank amongst their peers from past decades. One match that well characterizes the above mindset is Rock vs. Punk from two years ago. The finish was lambasted. The Rock was lampooned for being out of wrestling shape. Punk lost the title and people were up-in-arms. You know what, though? That match was great. It will never be mistaken as an all-time classic, but it was the caliber of match that often earns the €œ4-star€ label. Are you rolling your eyes? Hang on a second. Pause for a moment your thoughts on what it did wrong, in your opinion. What about the things that it did right? Here is what it did right: CM Punk may have lost the title, but he was displayed as a cunning student of the game that had nearly every Rock-ism scouted, thus making him look like the superior talent even in defeat. It was part of what made him a believable threat to the masses that he might be able to dethrone Taker's Streak at Mania. Punk worked very well with Rock, who might have been out of ring shape (which was totally understandable), but who still managed to connect on each move that he tried without issue (with the exception of the announce table breaking €“ out of their control). Some of the spots executed were awesome and there was a palpable buzz throughout the match that reflected the fact that we were all lucky to have seen what we were watching. The finish protected CM Punk after a match that managed to get the people squarely rooting for Rock (not an easy thing to do against Punk). Rock vs. Punk is a €œrainy day€ match if there ever was one.

11. Edge Vs. Jeff Hardy (Royal Rumble '09)

It is a rarity to see matches that excelled in the mid-card advance to the main-event with opportunities to recreate the magic. Edge vs. Jeff Hardy was one of them. They took their rivalry from the TLC Era in the tag team division and eventually turned it into a feud over the WWE title. Good for them. Good for us. They had a good run in 2009, never quite producing a match that gets talked about in conversations regarding €œawesome€ matches, but offering up several noteworthy efforts, including the match from the '09 Rumble that saw Matt Hardy turn on Jeff to set-up a WrestleMania match. One thing that often worked to the advantage of Jeff Hardy's matches was that he always seemed like he was one risk away from losing. WWE often tries to manufacture that feeling in other wrestlers, but Jeff had it naturally. He could take a home run shot that took him to the Promised Land or he could swing and miss so badly that it cost him everything. Edge, the Ultimate Opportunist, was an ideal opponent to take advantage of that. He seemed like he would be the wrestler that could psychologically target those moments of daredevil heroics, like a snake in the grass waiting for the right time to strike. It made Hardy vs. Edge an organically engaging viewing experience. It would have been awfully easy to slot this match into the top 10 if there was more wiggle room available, but after last year's unexpected classic curtain-jerker, there no longer remains any space for a match such as this. Nevertheless, it was a borderline classic worthy of praise and a re-watch.

10. Bret Hart Vs. Diesel (Royal Rumble '95)

History has had a tendency to think of Bret Hart vs. Diesel and cite Survivor Series '95 as the finest match in their series. That may be true. It does have an innovative climax. A few, perhaps more daring, members of the critical world might give the nod to the first of the three PPV bouts between the pair at the '94 King of the Ring. That was certainly a chance to see Kevin Nash at his hungriest €“ before he became the star that we remember him to be. Frankly, all three watched in succession is a fun venture and it may leave you thinking that, despite its finish, the middle bout at Rumble '95 was actually the best of the lot. It is a good debate. Bret and Diesel had natural chemistry, as much if not more so than Nash had with HBK or anyone else. The dynamic is what makes both 1995 matches so intriguing. At the Rumble, the intent was clear: get Diesel over as the company's top babyface. Bret held that title at the time, even though he did not hold the literal championship belt that often accompanied that honor. He was tasked with helping make the transition. Credit to his professionalism that he willingly did so in such spectacular fashion, working the '95 Rumble bout largely as the heel and allowing the crowd to naturally gravitate toward Diesel. It was a long match with plenty of room to tell a complete tale. Only its ending, which worked for the moment but is not particularly enjoyable on replay, holds it back from definitively staking the claim as the best of their three. Later in the year, the roles were reversed, with Nash inching toward turning heel and Bret being repositioned as the top €œgood guy.€

9. The Rockers Vs. The Orient Express (Royal Rumble '91)

€œInnovation€ is not a word reserved for Ladders, Cages, and other gimmicks, grappling fans. For all intents and purposes, the four men involved in the opener at Royal Rumble '91 would be insulted if you made that insinuation. Just look at the sheer number of times that they threw a new wrinkle into the well-established tag team wrestling formula that night. Some of the moves performed, to traditionalists, might have come across as €œtoo choreographed,€ but the undercard cannot and should not be wrestled as €œmini-main-event style€ matches. If that were the case, it would be awfully rare to see an undercard match €œsteal the show.€ So, who cares if a tag team match such as this exemplifies professional wrestling as a performance art akin to dancing? It is, in fact, a dance. It is show business. Shawn Michaels embraced that as much as any talent in the WrestleMania Era. The Rockers vs. Orient Express is as innovative a match as you could ever hope to watch for its day. As much as €œhigh risk€ has become associated with stunts, it is just as much about the degree of difficulty in a high spot. Watch some of the sequences that these four men pull off so seamlessly and try to argue that they were not €œhigh risk.€ Clearly, if they had not worked, then we would not be discussing this match at all. If 50% of the chances taken had failed? The Rockers vs. Orient Express would have disappeared from memory a long time ago. To some, it already has for the aforementioned reasons of misinformation and incorrect definitions. Let us not make that mistake, here. Go back and count the number of innovative €œLadder spots€ in the Edge/Christian vs. Hardys match from 1999. Then, go back and count the number of just plain old innovative spots from this match. Are they not nearly quantitatively equal? This is a forgotten classic.

8. The Hardys Vs. The Dudleys (Royal Rumble '00)

This is not quite a forgotten classic, but it is getting there. The TLC Era featured so many matches with death-defying stunts that it is becoming easy to forget about the first WWE Tables match that was sandwiched in-between the first tag team Ladder match and the first Triangle Ladder match. Do not make that mistake. This match was too incredible an example of the hardcore visual arts for you to do that. The original Tables match has never been topped. Think about that for a moment. WWE gimmick matches are all about redefining the standard. It does not happen frequently, but in every instance of a stipulation, the standard does eventually get redefined. Or at least there is an argument to be made that it does. The Ladder, Hell in a Cell, Cage, Last Man Standing, Royal Rumble. It never fails....almost. The first Tables match was by far the best and there is not really even a candidate in the running to be mentioned as the redefinition. It is not even close. Why is that? Simple: the competitors involved were the perfect mix of talents to be placed in the gimmick's environment. The Dudleys already had it down to a science from their time in ECW. The Hardys were glorified babyface stuntmen €“ and that is meant as a compliment given the memories that they provided in that era and the extent that they damaged their bodies in doing so, in part for our entertainment. A common criticism of modern Tables matches is that creating drama through €œnear table breaks€ is quite difficult. Funny, the original made it look incredibly easy. And it was easy for the era's premiere stunt brawlers. All due respect to Edge and Christian, but they could not have done with either team what the Dudleys and Hardys did, here, together.

7. Daniel Bryan Vs. Bray Wyatt (Royal Rumble '14)

A year ago, immediately following the Bryan vs. Wyatt match that surprised everyone by both its length and overall quality, some members of the WWE Universe proclaimed it €œthe greatest match in Rumble history.€ That will be up for time to decide. There is stiff competition for that honor, some that has aged incredibly well. It has, no doubt, jumped right into the conversation, though. The crowd, you may recall, was so rabidly in support of the Yes! Movement that everything that happened in that match was met with thunderous ovations. The two wrestlers worked their tails off, cutting a frenetic pace that people expected of Bryan but were not yet aware of for Wyatt. It was an emotionally investing match that sucked you into its story and did not let you go until you were dejected by its conclusion. Historically, it could end up becoming quite significant, which will help the bout's standing. It was Wyatt's coming out party. We knew he could talk, but his in-ring action had been limited to throwaway matches, tag team bouts, and needlessly gimmicked environments (such as the Inferno match at Summerslam 2013). What he showed himself capable of accomplishing at the Royal Rumble was nothing short of astounding. You would have had to have seen him in a place other than the WWE main roster to know that he could do that. He was brilliant in all aspects of the game. It was like seeing Aaron Rodgers come off the bench in his first meaningful game in 2007 and play like a Pro Bowler and future MVP. €œWhere did that come from,€ you might have asked. For Bryan, it was the night that his movement grew strong enough to cause WWE to scrap WrestleMania plans and put him where so many thought that he belonged: in the main-event. His loss was with met with the exact reaction you'd expect from an all-time level top babyface getting pinned. The pacing, the psychology, the execution, the spots, the selling, and the climax all came together wonderfully in a 21-minute package wrapped with an unexpected bow and a tag that read €œclassic.€

6. The Rock Vs. Chris Jericho (Royal Rumble '02)

If Bryan vs. Wyatt is to overtake any of the top 6 matches in the near future, then surely it will be this one. Yet, do not count out this match for the Undisputed Championship. Jericho and Rock had amazing chemistry and put together arguably their finest match against each other at the '02 Rumble. If you have read Jericho's books, then you know how proud he was of this effort...and for good reason. It was fantastic. There were a lot of matches back then that were off-the-charts in the athleticism department, but it was difficult to top the level of pacing and stamina that Rock and Jericho executed when facing off. How do you tell a thirty minute story in less than twenty minutes? Ask those guys... The Rock was at his athletic peak in 2002. Jericho has always been able to shift quickly into fifth gear. There was just a short time where you could expect that from Rock. As we will look at an entry or two later, early career Rock as a headliner relied heavily on his unmatched charisma to tell his stories. When he put it all together from 2000-2002, he became one of the most unique workers of all-time because there just was nothing that he could not do. Jericho challenged him to pick up the pace in a way that only Kurt Angle was ever able to do in quite the same way. The early moments of this match might remind some of the Rock-Austin classic at WM17, during which the blistering pace of the first few minutes made it so that you could not ease your way into engaging the performance; if you did, you missed something important. Rock made that a hallmark of his matches and his matches benefited greatly from it. From there, it was an exercise in reminding the audience that Jericho was a little turd of a heel, but he was a very, very good little turd of a heel, capable of conniving his way to victory by any means available. This was by no means a cookie-cutter match. If anything, they made a new cutter for future batches of cookies.

5. Chris Jericho Vs. Chris Benoit (Royal Rumble '01)

The Top 5 separates itself from the pack. Though the last few entries were all great matches, they have not left the sort of impression that did this match and the next four. Frankly, they could be considered interchangeable at the top. Jericho vs. Benoit is, for instance, one of the greatest iterations of the original intention for the Ladder match that there has ever been. Only the original (HBK vs. Razor) and another Jericho edition (HBK vs. Y2J in 2008) are in its league, as story-driven Ladder matches go. Basically there are two different types in the gimmick, from a fundamental standpoint. The first uses the Ladder as a prop to tell a story. The second makes the Ladder the actual story. One is heavily predicated on creatively weaving the Ladder into a greater context, while the other involves the most creative use of creating memories by virtue of spots off of the Ladder. In rare instances, the two formats blend together (such as the most recent Money in the Bank Ladder match in 2014). Benoit and Jericho had been feuding for nearly a year, with pauses in between, leading to their Royal Rumble '01 Ladder match for the IC title. Their Ladder match fell into category A. It was personal and it was about winning at the expense of your opponent. Any innovation we saw that night came within the context of their rivalry. It is not a perfect match, as some might argue that the two other €œbest in category A€ Ladder matches were. The finish, featuring Benoit a little too slowly trying to get back into the ring to stop Jericho from winning the title, pales in comparison to the others in its class. That was the primary reason why it was listed at #5. It was, nonetheless, phenomenal.

4. John Cena Vs. Umaga (Royal Rumble '07)

Right this second, someone on the internet is writing on social media or in a blog or in a column that John Cena is a completely inadequate sympathetic babyface €“ that he is just not capable of playing that role. No argument will be made to the contrary in this column, as it relates specifically to 2015. We have long been conditioned that he is Superman and that he will always win. Yet, if you rewind to 2007, then it is a different story; and it is the difference in that story that allowed him to play very well the role of sympathetic babyface against Umaga. Umaga was never going to be WWE Champion. Anyone reading this column, now, can look back to then and see that pretty clearly. All the same, the Samoan Bulldozer was presented for almost an entire year as an unstoppable monster, stronger in his booking than even Rusev in modern times. The talented worker was able to make you question your previously held belief €“ make you wonder about what was essentially a borderline €œundeniable truth.€ At New Year's Revolution in early January '07, Cena squeaked out a win by the skin of his teeth, setting up a rematch with Last Man Standing rules at the Royal Rumble. Sometimes in wrestling, it is not about the €œwhat€; it is about the €œhow.€ There is no doubt that unpredictability can help make a story more interesting, but it is not an essential element to storytelling €“ it really isn't. The €œwhat€ in Cena-Umaga was the result. We all knew Cena was winning. The €œhow€ was the important part. The success of that match was going to come down to how well they executed the story of Cena €“ the modern Hulk Hogan €“ overcoming considerable odds. €œHow€ were they going to book it? They booked it extraordinarily well. It was a brutal battle, innovative and arguably superlative for its genre. Cena got his butt kicked, but he was crafty enough to beat the odds (and a good enough performer to make himself look vulnerable when the result never was).

3. Mankind Vs. The Rock (Royal Rumble '99)

If you are a wine drinker, you will appreciate this analogy. Some wines are just better after they have been allowed to sit in the bottle for several years. Some wrestling matches are the same. If given the chance to age so that they can be properly and historically contextualized, their place in wrestling lore only rises. Such is the case for Rock vs. Mankind. Scour the internet and you may note that the critical marks earned by this match have, largely, made its place in the top 5 of a list like this seem out of touch. No, it is the other way around. If Terry Funk vs. Ric Flair in 1989 had a €œ5-star€ €œI Quit€ match, then surely the same rating should be given to Rock vs. Mankind, which was more entertaining, more brutal, and better produced. Rock vs. Mankind at the '99 Rumble is one of the most underrated critical achievements in modern wrestling lore. Think of what it accomplished. The Rock, thought of before this match as more of a muscle car than an off-road utility, proved to be well within his element brawling the toughest wrestler in the history of the business, never backing down an inch despite taking a beating like he had never taken before. Mick Foley, thought of before this feud as a fantastic second-tier player in WWE, proved to be a top drawing stud in a ragamuffin€™s attire, more than capable of €œputting asses in seats.€ Was it a little too much in the end? Sure, ten unprotected chair shots is not something that we ever need to see again in this business. It was and is too dangerous. We cannot go back in time and stop them from doing it, though, so we may as well celebrate it for what it afforded both men's legacies. Frankly, Rock vs. Mankind should be remembered as no less than the defining version of its gimmick in the history of pro wrestling. Even its finish €“ piping in Mankind's voice screaming €œI Quit€ from a promo €“ made as much sense as any other climax in the stipulation's storied past. These are larger-than-life characters. Would one elite persona really be able to make another say those words? To both guys, €œThank You.€

2. Chris Benoit Vs. Kurt Angle (Royal Rumble '03)

In #4, we discussed the element of the foregone, conclusive result. We had a similar case in 2003 with Angle vs. Benoit. Though it may not have worked for everyone, the match that they put together at the Royal Rumble for the WWE title had some second-guessing themselves. It was a masterpiece, perhaps more of a #1A than a #2 on this list, getting bumped to second place merely because it has basically been erased from existence. Their biggest accomplishment may have been tearing down the veil of certainty and replacing it with a shroud of unexpected unpredictability. The sheer volume of counters and false finishes - not just the number of false finishes, but the incredible execution and selling of those near falls €“ created a sense of doubt. What started as €œwell, this is going to be fun€ based on the reputation set by previous Angle vs. Benoit outings, morphed into a series of €œwell, I know we're getting Lesnar vs. Angle at Mania, but what if they put the title on Benoit for a week or two and switched it back at the next PPV?€ Even if you did not feel that way about the result, then surely the work speaks for itself. Is there a better sub-20-minute match in wrestling history? Does this match not contend with Savage vs. Steamboat for the pantheon of stories that were epic even though they were not epically long? It was spectacular. If not the greatest half-technical, half-athletically superior WWE style main-event ever, then certainly one of the greatest. It is certainly difficult for this particular writer to dream up a scenario that could have made this match any better. There is an interesting moment that puts the match into perspective. The crowd, for the duration of the match, was pretty quiet. Yet, when they gave the match a standing ovation after it was over, that told you everything you needed to know. It changed the perception from €œmildly engaged live attendees€ to €œstunned beyond words attendees.€ They became more of a Japanese audience of old, politely watching the incredible action unfold and then showing their appreciation once the performance was complete.

1. Cactus Jack Vs. Triple H (Royal Rumble '00)

Since Chris Benoit is basically persona-non-grata in wrestling history, Mick Foley pretty much wins the award for Mr. Royal Rumble by default based on his back-to-back singles matches for the WWE Championship alone. They were each so good that he distanced himself from all of his peers who had far more time to accomplish many more accolades in their Rumble careers. It is a testament to Foley's talent that we could make such a claim. Whatever your opinion on that matter, what is not up for debate is the quality of the stories that he told in 1999 and 2000. A year after shortening his career with a performance for the ages, Foley returned to the Royal Rumble as Cactus Jack to battle the company's next top heel, Triple H. The Game was catching fire at that very moment, furthering his own case to be the top guy in the business in WWE's most heralded era. The Street Fight at Madison Square Garden was important, historically, for many of the same reasons that Rock vs. Foley was in 1999. It built Triple H into an all-time great in the making. It solidified Foley's legacy in WWE, giving him the chance to get back to his roots right before he retired after spending most of '98-'99 as the loveable persona that catered to the kids that still watched WWE's product in a period not geared toward little ones. The violent Cactus Jack persona was not a sock-wielding character. At his roots, Cactus was a maniac. He proved it against Trips, but Trips €“ much like Rock the year before €“ showed a toughness largely absent prior to. To add to the match's legacy, WWE essentially learned how to make a dominant heel champion out of this performance. They may not have known it at the time, but Foley's adaptation of Cactus Jack really screamed €œtitle change is imminent.€ WWE chose otherwise, instead opting to have Trips defeat Cactus at his own game despite interference from The Rock. It was a rather babyface-style win for a dastardly heel. It was an important addition to the WWE playbook, frankly. The formula had gotten tired and needed to be tweaked. €œBad guys sometimes win in the end€ it taught us and future main-events were made better for it.