The 28-year history of the Royal Rumble match is rife with the greatest Superstars to ever lace a pair of boots. Hulk Hogan, The Rock, "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, Triple H and John Cena have all cashed their tickets to WrestleMania via wins in the 30-man bout. Two-time Hall of Fame inductee, "Nature Boy" Ric Flair, captured his first WWE Championship in the match while Roman Reigns has the opportunity on January 24 to leave Orlando with his title intact. As legendary as some of those competitors are, the Rumble match has also featured its fair share of duds, wrestlers who are either footnotes in history or were eliminated in rapid fashion, their legacies forever tainted by seconds-long stints in the most beloved gimmick match in WWE. For every Kurt Angle or Brock Lesnar, there is a Squat Team member or Saba Simba. With The Undertaker's epic defeat of Shawn Michaels to win the 2007 Rumble match comes the curious inclusion of an over-the-hill Carlos Colon in 1993. Or Doug Gilbert in 1996. Or Dick Murdoch in '95. And what about 2012, when the roster was so incredibly depleted that the commentary team entered the Rumble? As great an institution as the Rumble has become, it has housed its fair share of curiosities and oddballs. In preparation for the 2016 incarnation of the match, which is sure to feature at least one head-scratcher, relive these 15 worst Royal Rumblers ever.
15. Owen Hart
It is not often that the great Owen Hart finds himself on a list devoted to the worst of anything, especially given his immense talents between the ropes. But when it comes to Royal Rumble matches, one cannot ignore how overwhelming his performances in those bouts actually were. In 1994, Hart entered the match just minutes after betraying his brother Bret, kicking his leg out from underneath his...leg. Or something like that. Rather than allowing the gravity of his actions to really sink in with the audience, he was booked for the match. Did he go on a run that firmly established him as the lead villain he would later become? Nope. Instead, he lasted just over four minutes before casually being tossed out of the ring like a piece of garbage by Diesel, joining legendary figures the likes of Bart Gunn and Virgil. One year later, what should have been another opportunity to make a first impression in the Rumble ended in disaster. After interfering in the WWE Championship match between his brother Bret and the aforementioned Diesel, Owens fell prey to an attack at the hands of the Hitman before he even entered the ring. Three seconds later, he was eliminated from the match by his brother-in-law Davey Boy Smith, leaving him with two Rumble appearances totaling less-than five minutes combined. He would appear in future matches but what should have been the two most important, at his height as a main event heel, were immense disappointments that land the all-time great on this list.
14. The Great Kabuki
It had been 13 years since Great Kabuki made his greatest impression on North American fans during his stint with World Class Championship Wrestling, under the tutelage of the fantastic Gary Hart, when he turned up at the 1994 Royal Rumble as one of Mr. Fuiji's henchmen. Having helped Yokozuna successfully retain his WWE Championship against The Undertaker in a Casket Match earlier in the night, it looked as though Kabuki would be key in ensuring that top contenders like Lex Luger and Bret Hart did not make it to WrestleMania and a date with the champion. Though he and Tenryu beat down Luger backstage prior to the Rumble match, the former WCCW star failed miserably once he stepped inside the squared circle. He lasted under three minutes in the match and was eliminated by the man he vowed to prevent from winning, Luger. The result? An appearance in the 1994 match that is more memorable for being an answer to a trivia question than anything else.
13. Carlos Colon
A Hall of Fame inductee in 2014, and a hugely successful promoter in Puerto Rico, there is no denying the impact Carlos Colon has had on professional wrestling. With that said, his inclusion in the 1993 Royal Rumble match remains one of the biggest "huh?" booking decisions in event history. Sure, the roster was depleted of star power, and Colon's influence was undeniable, but he was far past his prime and belonged nowhere near that match at that time. Making matters even worse was commentator Gorilla Monsoon, who referred to the international star as a "young man," despite the fact that he was 44 years old at the time. Actually, come to think of it, that may be the most memorable moment of Colon's run in the Rumble match, which ended after seven minutes of ring time.
12. Jerry "The King" Lawler
Like Owen Hart earlier in this countdown, Jerry Lawler is not a competitor likely to appear on too many "worst" lists. The Royal Rumble is an exception, though. The 2007 Hall of Famer is recognizable for many accomplishments, and has had his greatness professed countless times, but his appearances in the Rumble match are hardly the stuff of legend. The King made his Rumble debut in 1993, just weeks after joining World Wrestling Entertainment. His 14 minutes of ring time in that year's bout would mark his lengthiest run in the match. It would, in fact, be all downhill from there. In 1996, Lawler would officially last 36 minutes in the match, but a substantial portion of that time was spent hiding under the ring. By the time Shawn Michaels entered the match, Lawler's time was up. Ol' HBK pulled The King from his sanctuary and eliminated him, ending any chance the veteran competitor had of headlining that year's Royal Rumble match. One year later, a straight right hand from Bret "Hitman" Hart sent Lawler sailing over the top rope four seconds after he entered. It was an emphatic statement made by Hart about his longtime rival's Rumble track record. Some 15 years later, Lawler would return to the match for one last shot at glory, entering at No. 12. Unfortunately, the Memphis icon was eliminated after just 43 seconds, cementing his status as one of the most underwhelming Rumblers ever.
11. The Squat Team
The 1996 Royal Rumble was interesting in that it featured stars who had no business in or around a match of that magnitude. Doug Gilbert and an over-the-hill Dory Funk, Jr. were brought in to help bolster a roster in desperate need of bodies to fill out the 30-man field. Jake Roberts was brought out of mothballs to assist as well, though he also brought considerable star power to the proceedings. At the very least, those men were established stars, either nationally or regionally, and could be considered quality additions at a time when Vince McMahon's company needed them. The same could not be said for the Squat Team. Having competed in the dying days of the territories as The Headhunters, they garnered a reputation for their girth and brawling style. Trips to Japan helped bolster their reputations but they were far from highly recognizable stars. That should have helped their cause in WWE, where they could have started from the ground up, introduced as the badasses they should have been. Instead, they entered the Rumble match, almost immediately targeting Vader. That was a poor decision. The former WCW world champion dumped one of the super heavyweights while Yokozuna ridded the match of the other. And, after less-than two minutes of ring time combined, their careers in WWE were over.
10. Hornswoggle
The second-half of the 2000s saw the arrival of Hornswoggle, a mini wrestler dressed in leprechaun garb that was closely associated with the great, double-tough Finlay. Why management thought the Irish badass needed such a childish mascot is irrelevant. What is not is the fact that, somewhere along the line, the Hornswoggle character became kid-friendly and featured on television entirely too much. In 2008, he entered the Royal Rumble match for the first time. History books indicate that he lasted 26-plus minutes but in reality, he ducked underneath the ropes and headed underneath the ring to safety, never to return. Not only was it completely unrealistic that he could compete in such a match without being obliterated, but he actually managed to eliminate The Miz, hurting the credibility of one of WWE's brightest young stars at that point. Three years later, he again entered the match, one of 40 Superstars to compete in the biggest Royal Rumble ever. After nine minutes, some of which was spent assisting John Cena in what some consider the most painful period of time in WWE history, he was done away with by fellow Irishman Sheamus. Those two instances represented everything wrong with WWE's creative process. Irreparable damage was done to Superstars courtesy of their interactions with the comedic character, who would never really became anything more than a sideshow act.
9. Santino Marella
Santino Marella has the dubious distinction of being the quickest elimination in Royal Rumble history. With only one second spent in the 2009 Royal Rumble match, he is the punchline of many a Rumble joke and he most certainly deserves inclusion on this list. Just not any higher than No. 9. See, as pathetic and puny as that performance was, Santino made up for it two years later, nearly pulling off the greatest upset of all-time when he came seconds away from eliminating Alberto Del Rio and winning the entire thing. It was nearly the most unexpected moment in professional wrestling. More importantly, it redeemed him for his utter failure earlier, which still ranks as one of the most comical moments in the long history of the Rumble.
8. "Macho Man" Randy Savage
How in the world can someone be as truly great as Randy "Macho Man" Savage, arguably the most dynamic sports-entertainer of all-time, and not grasp the seemingly simple rules of a Royal Rumble match? In 1991, Savage cost The Ultimate Warrior the WWE Championship during a match with Sgt. Slaughter. Later in the night, he was slated to enter the Rumble at No. 18, but never showed up. How he ever expected to win the match without actually showing up is beyond this writer, though running for his life from a crazed, face-painted madman may be a valid explanation for his absence. There is no excuse, though, for what happened two years later. One of the final two competitors in the '93 match, Savage looked poised to win and head to WrestleMania IX in Caesar's Palace to challenge Bret Hart for the WWE Championship. A flying elbow drop may have been a curious choice when it came to wearing the massive Yokozuna down with, but it was his signature move so it at least made a little sense. What did not was the fact that Savage tried for a pinfall. In a Royal Rumble match. A match type he had competed in previously and clearly knew the rules to. He was tossed into the air, over the top rope and to the arena floor, robbing fans of witnessing the future Hall of Famer get one last chance to headline the Showcase of the Immortals. Some will argue that he was caught up in the moment and as such, it makes sense. They would be wrong. One of the greatest wrestlers to ever lace a pair of boots, his Rumble resume is far from sparkling, leading to his status as the worst of the big name stars to ever compete in the match.
7. Gillberg
The 1999 Royal Rumble sucked. Go ahead, try to defend it for its awesome Steve Austin-Vince McMahon storytelling but as a match, it was something truly awful, the likes of which have not been met by any recent Rumble match, regardless of how loud fans may have booed Roman Reigns or Batista. One of the most glaring issues with the match is that, once Austin and McMahon fight out of the ring early in the bout, the match is placed in the hands of such luminaries as The Blue Meanie, Steve Blackman, Tiger Ali Singh and our No. 7 worst Royal Rumbler ever, Gillberg. A parody of WCW's greatest homegrown star Goldberg, the puny ex-jobber had earned television time in the weeks preceding the Rumble, mostly because his off-the-wall persona fit the crash TV style of the Attitude Era. He was different from the mega stars that populated the show and, more importantly, good for a laugh so the Gillberg character was drawn up for him. As humorous as his ridiculous impersonation of the WCW world champion may have been, he did not belong anywhere near the Rumble match. He was a joke and, thankfully, was treated as such when he was tossed after seven seconds of nonsense.
6. Drew Carey
Though this writer may be more tolerant of Drew Carey's 2001 Royal Rumble appearance, that does not effect his placement on this list. Carey was a hugely successful comedian-turned-television star and was hosting his first improv pay-per-view. To help promote it, he appeared at the Rumble, meeting Vince McMahon backstage, as well as a handful of Superstars and Divas, including Trish Stratus. It was his encounter with the blonde bombshell, and McMahon mistress, that doomed Carey to the 30-man match. Goaded into competing by Stratus and McMahon, he entered the match at No. 5 and watched as The Hardy Boyz eliminated each other. No one was there to save him as the pyro exploded and Kane stalked toward the squared circle. Carey yanked out a handful of cash and tried to pay his way to safety, but the Big Red Monster was having none of it. He grabbed hold of Carey's throat, teasing a chokeslam, but Raven made the save. Never a stupid man, he eliminated himself and never again entered the Royal Rumble. Much to the delight of historians.
5. Bushwhacker Luke
There were numerous Superstars in the 1991 Royal Rumble who delivered impressive performances. Hulk Hogan, Mr. Perfect, Bret Hart and Rick "The Model" Martel, just to name a few. Bushwhacker Luke was not one of them. The comedic tag team wrestler walked straight down the aisle, waving his arms up and down, entered the squared circle and was walked right back out the other side, eliminated after only five seconds in the match. The entire ordeal was played for laughs, and it was certainly effective. But comedy does not save one from recognition as one of the worst Rumblers in the history of the event.
4. Mantaur
The 1995 Royal Rumble featured the appearance of Mantaur, a half-bull, half-human. Let that digest for a moment. All done? Not only did he manage to make it through the creative process and onto WWE television, he actually lasted nearly 10 minutes in the Rumble bout before being tossed by Lex Luger. How anyone ever came to the conclusion that a ridiculous character such as that was a good idea is a mystery, but thankfully enough, the embarrassment of a gimmick disappeared from the company. Not before becoming a footnote in Rumble history, one of the most shameful entrants into an otherwise prestigious bout. Good riddance.
3. Michael Cole
By the time the 2012 Royal Rumble rolled around, the roster lacked depth. So much so that WWE's creative brain trust had to resort to gimmicks to fill out the 30-competitor field for its annual battle royal main event. A match that featured the inclusion of Kharma, who had not been seen since announcing her pregnancy almost a year earlier, was bogged down significantly when it was revealed that the announce team had been entered into it. Booker T and Jerry "The King" Lawler were Hall of Fame wrestlers, their accomplishments between the ropes well-documented. Michael Cole, on the other hand, was the furthest thing from a celebrated wrestler. He had undergone a heel turn a year earlier and was incredibly overexposed in that role as 2011 limped on. His entry into the match was but a painful reminder of how much effort was put into booking him, oftentimes at the expense of the other Superstars on the roster. His run was a short one, thankfully, that came to an end when the aforementioned Kharma scared him into eliminating himself, thus ending the run of the most useless Rumbler ever.
2. Mo
Remember how everyone crapped a brick when Mabel won the King of the Ring, believing the super heavyweight to be a terrible choice for a push? He was the star of Men on a Mission. The "Marty Jannetty" to his "Shawn Michaels" was Mo, a former tag team champion who never quite enjoyed anything even remotely close to singles success. In fact, his most notorious feat outside of his brief title reign may have been his stint in the 1995 Royal Rumble match. Entering at No. 16, he lasted just three seconds, dumped over the top rope by the great King Kong Bundy the moment he entered the squared circle. Outside of the previously documented Santino Marella and the No. 1 worst Rumbler on our list, Mo is infamous for his futility in match lore.
1. The Warlord
Whereas Santino Marella had the excuse of being a comedic act when he was eliminated from the 2009 Royal Rumble, The Warlord had no such thing. One-half of The Powers of Pain, a bruising team of badass heavyweights, he was supposed to be an intimidating force in World Wrestling Entertainment. When he made his way to the squared circle at the 1989 Rumble, it should have been as one of the dark horses to win the entire thing. After all, he was chiseled out of stone, the type of physical specimen Vince McMahon loved. Instead, he no sooner stepped over the top rope before Hulk Hogan charged at him with a clothesline, sending him tumbling over the top rope and to the arena floor. It was a moment few could have foreseen, adding to the unpredictability of the match. For The Warlord, though, it remains the most embarrassing moment of his career, one that saw him achieve moderate success as a midcard villain.