15 Worst WrestleMania Performers Ever

A surprise list full of Hall-of-Famers and just a few jobbers.

By Scott Carlson /

When you think about WrestleMania, you often think about the many triumphs we see each and every year: Daniel Bryan’s WM 30 ascension; Randy Savage defying the odds to win the WWF Championship at WM IV; Ultimate Warrior toppling Hulk Hogan at WM VI; and of course, The Undertaker racking up 21 straight victories at Mania.

Advertisement

But not everyone can be a picture of success at the biggest show of the year. In fact, the vast majority of wrestlers who have competed at WrestleMania have walked away in defeat. For every Undertaker, there’s the wrestling equivalent of the Brooklyn Brawler or Iron Mike Sharpe.

What’s really interesting when you dive into the records of former and current WWF/E superstars is that you see some household names sporting some very poor won-loss records. There are several WWE Hall-of-Famers who have racked up horrendous WrestleMania records, and others who will surprise you.

A quick note: This list is accurate as possible, taking into account all main show Mania matches, and many of the kickoff show matches that have taken place in the WWE Network era, since they basically air just an hour before the main show on the same platform. Also, multi-man matches, such as the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, will count as a loss for the multiple men who have gotten tossed.

Let’s get to it…

16. Honorable Mentions

Let’s give a quick shout-out to some notable superstars who just missed this list still have notably bad records at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

Big Show deserves mention alone for his record-tying number of losses – 12 – against only five wins. (Triple H also has lost 12 Mania matches, but he’s won nine.) Among those losses are defeats against Akebono and Floyd Mayweather Jr., as well as John Cena, Undertaker and Mankind.

Two wrestlers, new HOFer Mark Henry and Matt Hardy sport 2-6 records, with Henry’s record tanking after four straight unsuccessful appearances in the Andre the Giant battle royal. Hardy was carrying a dismal 1-6 record before winning the Raw Tag Team Championships with his brother Jeff at WrestleMania 33 last year, boosting him out of the main list.

Matt has entered this year’s Andre battle royal, so most likely, we’ll see his record worsen, but that’s for a future list.

15. Booker T (1-5)

Let’s start the list proper with a Hall-of-Famer and six-time former world champion.

Advertisement

Despite his lofty credentials, Booker T has had very little success at WrestleMania. His only win came at WM 20, when he teamed with Rob Van Dam to retain the World Tag Team Championships. His losses, however, are pretty notable.

The most infamous has to be his loss the prior year at WM 19 against Triple H after The Game spent weeks deriding Booker using some pretty racist remarks. It all seemed to be pointing to Hunter getting his comeuppance, but as we all know, quite the opposite happened.

Booker also lost to Edge at WM X-8 in a feud over shampoo (no, seriously), the Boogeyman, a Money in the Bank ladder match, and a Raw versus SmackDown 12-man tag match.

14. Ron Simmons (1-5)

Another WWE Hall-of-Famer, Ron Simmons has not fared well at WrestleMania at all.

Advertisement

As Faarooq, Simmons only competed in tag and multi-man matches at Mania, typically with Bradshaw as the APA. That tandem went 1-3 at WrestleMania, losing a hardcore battle royal and two tag title matches. They did team with Tazz and defeat the Right to Censor at WM X-Seven.

Faarooq also competed in two Manias with the Nation of Domination, but fell short at 13 and 14. Despite that shoddy record, Simmons earned a berth in the HOF in 2012.

13. Shelton Benjamin (1-5)

Poor Shelton Benjamin. He was a victim of his own talents at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

Benjamin and World’s Greatest Tag Team teammate Charlie Haas defeated Los Guerreros and Chris Benoit & Rhyno at Mania 19 to retain the WWE Tag Team Championship. After that, it was all downhill.

Shelton would go on to compete in five Money in the Bank ladder matches at WrestleMania, losing all of them. Benjamin was a human highlight reel, providing some of the most vivid moments in the early days of the MITB match when it was still a part of Mania. But he never was able to capture the briefcase.

As a result Benjamin might show up in a lot of highlights from WrestleMania, but his hand being raised is not among them.

12. Jeff Hardy (1-5)

Former world, tag and Intercontinental champion Jeff Hardy has had a pretty distinguished career in WWE, but he just can’t seem to find the key to success at the biggest show of the year.

Advertisement

Hardy was winless at WrestleMania until he and brother Matt returned to WWE last year as a surprise entrant in the Raw Tag Team Championship ladder match, which they won. Before that, the Hardy Boyz lost at WM 2000, X-Seven and X-8. Jeff would lose a Money in the Bank ladder match at WM 23, and then fall to Matt at WM 25.

It is a little surprising to note that Jeff Hardy doesn’t have more WrestleMania matches under his belt, but it’s worth reminding everyone that he was released from WWE in 2003, returning in 2006, and leaving again in 2009 until last year.

11. MVP (0-4)

Montel Vontavious Porter came to WWE as a (storyline) top free agent and built himself into a solid midcard wrestler, including two runs with the United States Championship.

Advertisement

But MVP never managed to get into the winner’s circle at WrestleMania. He lost his lone singles match, a US title match against Chris Benoit at WM 23. He would go on to participate in three Money in the Bank ladder matches, falling short in all of them.

MVP has made a lone appearance in WWE since he left in late 2010, at Raw 25. At 44, his opportunities to return and get off the schneid at Mania are probably pretty limited.

10. Finlay (0-4)

One of the best brawlers and underrated wrestlers, Finlay has found a successful second life as a producer (or road agent) in WWE.

Advertisement

After WCW was bought out, Finlay became a trainer for WWF/E, his in-ring career seemingly over. But Finlay would return to the ring at 47, and he would land four WrestleMania matches. Unfortunately, he lost all of them.

Finlay competed unsuccessfully in three Money in the Bank ladder matches (at WrestleManias 22, 23 and 25), and he lost the opening match of WM 24 – a Belfast Brawl – to William Regal.

9. Crush (0-4)

Although Crush lost all four matches he competed in at WrestleMania, he might have the most interesting 0-4 record of the bunch, as he was not the same character in any of the four Manias, but still went by the same name in each.

Advertisement

He lost his first Mania match as a member of Demolition, then lost to Doink at WM IX as Kona Crush, then lost to Randy Savage at WM X as a disgruntled version of his previous character. Three years later, Crush (as a member of the Nation of Domination) would lose to Ahmed Johnson and the Legion of Doom in a Chicago Street Fight.

Crush would get another shot in WWF in 2001 under his real name as part of KroniK, but that fell apart quickly, and ended any chance at another Mania appearance.

8. Dudley Boyz (0-4)

You’re kidding right? New Hall-of-Famers the Dudley Boyz have never won at WrestleMania?

Advertisement

Despite participating in two very memorable triple threat tag team matches (ladder match at WM 2000 and TLC at WM X-Seven), the Dudleys are winless. They also lost tag matches at WM X-8 and 20. All four bouts were for tag titles, with the Dudleys going in 2000 and X-Seven as the champs.

It just seems surprising that one of the most successful tag teams in professional wrestling history has never won at the biggest PPV of the year.

7. Kofi Kingston (1-6)

A record-setting WWE Tag Team Championship title reign could not save Kofi Kingston from making this list.

Advertisement

Much like fellow human highlight reel Shelton Benjamin, Kofi battled in two Money in the Bank ladder matches, losing both. He also competed in the first two Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royals, getting tossed from both. He was a member of Team Teddy in a Raw versus SmackDown 12-man tag match. And he lost a fight alongside his New Day compatriots against the League of Nations.

His lone win came in an eight-man tag match with Big Show, Kane and Santino Marella defeating the Corre. That’s a pretty undistinguished record for such a long-tenured WWE wrestler.

6. Dolph Ziggler (1-7)

Dolph Ziggler talks a good game about being the Show-Off and stealing the show, but he has done anything but that at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

Ziggler lost a Money in the Bank ladder match at WM 26, teamed with LayCool in a losing effort against John Morrison, Trish Stratus and Snooki at WM 27, and was on the winning side of the Team Johnny versus Team Teddy match at WM 28.

After that it’s been all downhill.

Ziggler and Big E Langston lost a tag title match as WM 29, and he went on to unsuccessfully vie for the Intercontinental Championship in ladder matches at WM 31 and 32. He also competed in two Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royals.

Sadly, Ziggler’s gripe about never having a singles match at WrestleMania will continue this year, as he’s been relegated to the battle royal once again.

5. Heath Slater (0-5)

It’s pretty safe to say that Heath Slater will add another defeat to his “unblemished” record this year, as he’s competing in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal for the fifth straight year.

Advertisement

In addition to his four losses in the battle royals, Slater also was part of a losing effort by the Corre at WrestleMania 27.

Barring a miracle or getting released, Slater is likely destined to continue racking up losses at Mania, especially as long as bodies are needed in multi-man matches like the Andre battle royal.

4. Tito Santana (0-7)

Tito Santana is in the record books for wrestling in the first WrestleMania match in history, and for winning said match. That alone should merit kudos to the Hall-of-Famer.

Advertisement

But sadly for Tito, that was his only brush with victory at Mania.

Santana went on to lose seven straight matches at WrestleMania, including tag matches at the next four Manias, and singles losses to Barbarian, Mountie and Shawn Michaels at WM VI, VII and VIII.

The tag loss at WM IV was Strike Force losing the tag titles to Demolition, while Strike Force’s loss at WM V to the Brainbusters was the infamous Rick Martel heel turn that led to a rivalry that never really ended.

3. Vince McMahon (0-4)

OK, so the chairman doesn’t have as bad of a record as some of the guys on this list, but Vince McMahon has to make it pretty high on this list given that he makes the matches.

Advertisement

You also have to take into account the four men who beat him at WrestleMania: son Shane McMahon at WM X-Seven was the lesser of the opponents. His other losses? Hulk Hogan, Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart, all Hall-of-Famers, and all high-profile matches.

In each of those losses, Vince took a royal a**-kicking, getting beaten pretty damn bad. So while his record isn’t as bad as someone like Heath Slater or possibly Tito Santana, the significance and degree of his defeats warrant such a high placement.

2. R-Truth (0-6)

That being said, you can’t ignore the futility that is R-Truth at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

Truth has racked up six losses against zero wins at Mania, including three eliminations in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. R-Truth also lost a tag championship match alongside John Morrison at WM 26. He was on the losing end of Team Johnny versus Team Teddy at wm 28. And he was the wrestler scared of heights competing in a ladder match for the Intercontinental Championship at WM 31.

Despite that poor record, there is still one person who has been even worse at WrestleMania…

1. Goldust (0-9)

The son of a son of a plumber has been horrendous at WrestleMania, period.

Advertisement

Even if you remove his four eliminations in the Andre battle royal, he still has lost five actual matches at Mania. He got stripped and chased off in a Back Lot Brawl against Roddy Piper at WM 12. Triple H beat him at WM 13. Marc Mero and Sable teamed up to defeat Goldy and Luna Vachon the following year. And he lost an Intercontinental Championship four-way match at WrestleMania 15.

Goldust returned at WM X-8 to lose a Hardcore Championship match. After that, the Bizarre One didn’t wrestle at Mania until WM 30 for the first Andre battle royal. And Sunday, he’ll compete in his fifth battle royal, so it’s safe to bet that Goldust will reach double-digit losses with no wins, a record no one wants.

Advertisement