16 Ups & 9 Downs For NJPW In 2018

NJPW shone brightly this year, but grey clouds are on the horizon.

By Andy H Murray /

NJPW

Appropriately, 2018 has been an up and down year for New Japan Pro Wrestling.

Advertisement

Everything looks fine on first glance. The promotion continue to set new standards between the ropes, once again delivering the most cutting-edge bell-to-bell action on the planet, particularly during G1 season. The 43,000 fans drawn to the Tokyo Dome for Wrestle Kingdom 12 comprised the biggest Japanese wrestling crowd since 2005. Revenue shot to a record $44.1 million in November, NJPW's inroads on the American market continued throughout 2018, and their global exposure has never been higher.

But scratch beneath the surface and you'll find a myriad of concerns, with reports of unrest towards president Howard Meij's leadership, The Elite's expiring contracts, the in-ring product's perceived Americanisation, and a number of key creative decisions sparking controversy.

Advertisement

NJPW are still on an upswing, and their general perception remains strong, but there are too many spinning plates heading into 2019. The upcoming year could well be one of the most transformational in the company's 46-year history, inside the ring and out, and their future will become a lot clearer when Wrestle Kingdom 13 hits the Tokyo Dome on 4 January.

For now, let's take some time to reflect on the year that was...

Advertisement

Downs...

9. The US Announce Team

AXS TV/NJPW

A cherished wrestling institution Jim Ross may be, but his time in the NJPW on AXS announce booth yielded some of the worst work of his career.

Advertisement

Age has slowed the greatest play-by-play announcer of all-time. It's harder for him to get amped-up like he used to, and he's no longer able to keep up with faster sequences. Such things can be forgiven, but his lack of knowledge on the New Japan product despite working with the promotion since 2015, propensity to get wrestlers' names wrong, and constant whining on things like stylistic differences and angle/match length cannot.

Broadcast partner Josh Barnett wasn't perfect, but at least brought a sense of real-sport credibility to proceedings. That fell apart at the G1 Special in San Francisco in July. A Jay White suplex sent Juice Robinson into the barricade which, in turn, knocked JR off his chair. Barnett, a former UFC Champion, threw down his headset, told White he'd 'done f*cked up now,' then went into business for himself, marching into the ring to confront the 'Switchblade.' Unscripted and unprofessional, Barnett looked a fool.

Advertisement

The good news is that neither will be on commentary going forward, with a Kevin Kelly-led NJPW World team taking the reins instead. This was essential. Good commentary is a must if New Japan are to keep progressing in English-speaking countries, and Kelly, Don Callis, Rocky Romero & co. comprise the best team in the business.

Barnett and Ross, sadly, do not.

Advertisement

8. World Tag League Tedium

NJPW

Storylines like Chuckie T. snapping on his opponents and his Best Friends partner Beretta gave this year's World Tag League an extra dollop of intrigue, but that an entire tour's worth of New Japan shows (finals aside) can even be considered skippable is damning.

Advertisement

These shows are fine. You'll get a couple of hours of passable action every single day, with the participants playing their hits without overexerting themselves. Cards usually contain an easter egg or two to keep completionists happy, but there's no need to watch these dry, unrewarding broadcasts. The odd **** match amidst dozens of middling plodders isn't a tasty enough carrot to dangle.

That wrestlers like Kazuchika Okada, Hiroshi Tanahashi, Kenny Omega, and The Young Bucks took WTL 2018 off speaks volumes. It remains NJPW's least essential tour. On a positive note, this gives weary diehards the chance to recharge their batteries at the end of the year, as only an insane person would commit to watching everything that makes tape on this long, gruelling slog of a tournament.

Advertisement

7. The Junior Tag Division

njpw1972.com

There's plenty of talent in New Japan's Junior Heavyweight tag division.

Advertisement

Champions Yoshinobu Kanemaru and El Desperado are delightful scumbags, with the latter among the most underrated wrestlers in the company. Roppongi 3K are one of the most compelling duos on the planet, with incredible chemistry from their days feuding against each other as Young Lions, and now teaming as former champions. Newcomer Shingo Takagi's arrival has breathed new life into partner BUSHI's tired act. Tiger Mask and Jushin Liger are a solid nostalgia act when thrown together. The list goes on.

Unfortunately, Gedo doesn't do the best job promoting this group, to the point where the IWGP Junior Heavyweight Tag Team Titles often feel like an afterthought. The booker's lofty reputation is earned, but the way he handles tag wrestling has long been a bone of contention, and 2018 has done nothing to dispell the complaint.

Advertisement

The heavyweight scene has similar problems. Still, the abundance of great wrestlers among the juniors makes their situation more galling. The Young Bucks leaving the division has left it devoid of star power. Now, it's a bunch of under-pushed, under-utilised grapplers competing in stopgap lower-card matches, with little hope for advancement.

6. A Slowing US Expansion

Twitter, @socaluncensored

New Japan pushed their US expansion forward with three major shows in California this year. They produced some stellar action (Strong Style Evolved's Young Bucks vs. Golden Lovers bout was one of 2018's finest tag matches), but diminishing business returns, particularly towards the end of the year, suggest the promotion may have rushed into this with too much gusto.

Advertisement

Strong Style Evolved drew 4,372 to Long Beach's Walter Pyramid on 25 March. Six months later, NJPW attracted just 3,007 to the same building for Fighting Spirit Unleashed. Images of empty seeds flooded social media that night, and as confirmed by Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer Newsletter the following week, NJPW resorted to the old WWE trick of selling out the seats in front of the camera to make the building look fuller than it was on tape. Understandable, but sneaky.

While far from disastrous, the situation suggests that New Japan perhaps need to pump the breaks in Calfornia. The good news is that they're coming off a year of record revenue, and their G1 Supercard (co-promoted with Ring Of Honor) sold Madison Square Garden out in minutes. The expansion is still on; it just encountered a few west coast hurdles in 2018.

Advertisement

5. Tetsuya Naito's Mixed Fortunes

Bushiroad

The great hope heading into Wrestle Kingdom 12 was that Tetsuya Naito, the coolest wrestler in the world and most popular star in Japan, would finally defeat the godlike IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada inside the Tokyo Dome, cementing him as NJPW's undisputed top guy.

Advertisement

That didn't come to fruition.

Naito was felled in an awesome, story-driven match, and proceeded to stumble through a very mixed year. The Minoru Suzuki matches were flat disappointments. He became IWGP Intercontinental Champion, but Chris Jericho murdered him at Dominion 6.9. His tournament form wasn't great either: defeated by Zack Sabre Jr. in March's New Japan Cup, a 6-3 G1 Climax run saw him finish fourth in Block B.

Advertisement

Shunted out of the spotlight after Wrestle Kingdom, Naito has been feeding off scraps all year. He'll likely retake the Intercontinental strap on 4 January, and there's no doubt that booker Gedo has a long-term plan, but it's hard to see Naito's 2018 as anything other than a moderate disappointment.

4. The Elite's Song & Dance

NJPW

Regardless of where The Elite end up wrestling next year, the carnival surrounding their NJPW/ROH contractual situation has been tedious. Utterly, utterly tedious.

Advertisement

We'll be glad to see the end of the will they/won't they bullsh*t, even if that means Kenny Omega, Cody, and The Young Bucks walking off to pastures new. It'd be a shame to see them go, of course, but this writer (along with countless others) just wants to see these guys wrestle, not 'work the marks' with vague statements, Being The Elite angles, and co-opted media stories designed to increase their bargaining power.

NJPW can endure their losses. They'll take a hit, particularly in the United States, but there's always someone ready to take your place in this company. Their domestic business will be fine, so while it'd be great to see The Elite stick around, it's not the end of the world if this saga ends in them leaving to form their own promotion (as has been rumoured) or jumping ship to WWE. At least the media shenanigans will be over by that point.

Advertisement

3. Jay White's Reintroduction

njpwworld.com

We'll have more on Jay White's rollercoaster 2018 later, but he endured a difficult start to the year, starting with a disappointing Tokyo Dome clash against the legendary Hiroshi Tanahashi.

Advertisement

Not even New Japan's Ace could help the former Young Lion to a career-making bout. Though fundamentally sound, their clash couldn't captivate the Wrestle Kingdom crowd, with 'Switchblade' still growing into his role as an edgy agitator. It convinced nobody of his prospects as a potential main eventer, and with his defeat of IWGP United States Champion Kenny Omega playing out to cricket chirps a few weeks later, White was on the verge of bombing.

Overcoming these growing pains wasn't easy for the New Zealander, and neither was watching him struggle from one laboured performance to another. It took months before White looked comfortable in his new skin. Even now, as he stands within touching distance of the main event scene, Jay is still a work-in-progress, though he's lightyears beyond the weird basement-dwelling incel he looked at the start of the calendar.

Advertisement

2. Kenny Omega's IWGP Heavyweight Title Reign

njpw

This isn't going to go down well among the commentariat, but Kenny Omega's IWGP Heavyweight Title reign has, in this columnist's eyes, been a rank disappointment.

Advertisement

Omega seized the belt in one of the most breathtaking, cathartic babyface moments in wrestling history, having just partaken in what we go down as a legendary, era-defining bout with Kazuchika Okada. Since then, the Canadian has betrayed everything that made his character so riveting throughout the years-long build to that moment.

NJPW's gaijin hero strutted out for his first G1 Climax match as a sh*t-talking heel. This continued throughout the tournament, as 'The Cleaner' became increasingly cocky, even playing bongo drums on the diminutive Tomohiro Ishii's head. His Twitter feed started resembling that of an insecure teenager. The title defences (66% of which have involved Cody Rhodes) haven't delivered on the same level as Okada's. It was as if Omega had suddenly lost touch with why people connected with his story in the first place, and while this has been spun into a compelling past versus present and future programme with Hiroshi Tanahashi heading into Wrestle Kingdom, Kenny's infatuation with presenting himself as a 'cool' tweener is tarnishing his act.

Advertisement

Compare the Raw, emotional beauty of the Golden Lovers' reunion to those Cody matches. Night and day.

1. Tama Tonga Brings The Cringe

NJPW

NJPW tried with Tama Tonga during this year's G1 Climax.

Advertisement

The Firing Squad vs. The Elite angle put the Bullet Club OG on a bigger pedestal than ever before, with Tama and buddies Bad Luck Fale and Tanga Loa going out of their way to disrupt many a G1 match. This drew legitimate heat in the buildings. To that end, it kind of worked, but western fans rightly tore into their presentation on social media. It prompted them to zone out, not engage with the Firing Squad as heels, and that's not what booker Gedo had in mind.

Tonga's performances throughout this period were unspeakably awful. He was out of his depth anchoring this major angle, delivering nothing but cringe in his countless attempts at looking cool and aloof. From his stunted mid-match trash talking sessions, to his increasingly embarrassing Twitter activity, to the desperate cry for attention that was his Roman Reigns potshot, Tama exposed himself. He was a goober: a guy playing pro-wrestler, and not at all subversive.

Advertisement

NJPW have reneged on Tonga's push since Jay White seized Bullet Club, and rightly so. This was a disaster. They're best-suited keeping Tama as a tag division stalwart and supporting character in the promotion's top heel stable, as 2018 proved he's ill-suited to anything greater.