2 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 28
Wants In A Lifetime.
WWE weren't remotely phased by the broadly bored response WrestleMania XXVII received, nor did they even have the time. Less than 24 hours after The Rock had cost John Cena the WWE Championship against The Miz, the company were booking the following year's main event in a powerful post-WrestleMania Raw showdown.
It was a bold strategy that fed into an arguably-even-bolder one. 12 long months were to be donated to a bonafide dream match that required no catchy subtitles or chintzy wrestling ones. 'The Champ' wouldn't need a belt, the 'Great One' wouldn't need great matches but the 'Grandest Stage' could remain set all the same.
"Once In A Lifetime" was the only lie WWE needed to tell, though it was so glamorous that they weren't permitted to forget it a year later. The stakes and tension around it when it still appeared for real though? Whew, forget about it.
No, please, forget about it. And don't forget to get your tickets for WrestleMania 29!
(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8, XIX, XX, 21, 22, 23, XXIV, , XXVI, XXVII)
Downs...
7. 18 Seconds
Daniel Bryan had become a fabulous heel since winning the title at December's Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view, infuriating audiences with his self-aggrandising 'YES!' exclamation and poor treatment of sympathetic girlfriend AJ Lee.
Audiences were subsequently not only excited just to see the match between the two, but also a contest befitting of their abilities on a grand stage, especially after an indignity the two suffered one year earlier. The pair had developed somewhat of a kinship behind the scenes at the 'Show of Shows', having seen their planned WrestleMania XXVII United States Title match relegated to the dark portion of the broadcast and then cancelled outright when run-ins turned the contest into a Battle Royal won by The Great Khali.
That dark match got five minutes and eighteen seconds, which was exactly five minutes longer than this opener for the World Heavyweight Title received.
With one swift Brogue Kick after Bryan's stolen good luck kiss from AJ, Sheamus was champion, and an arena of supporters were left deeply unenthused. But more on that later.
6. Randy? Savage.
Legally sound if ethically sketchy as f*ck, WrestleMania XXVIII was bizarrely an event that could be gambled on if you happened to live somewhere where such a thing was permissible.
It was for this reason that Kane went over Randy Orton in a spuriously competitive 10:58 match. It has to be.
The proverbial coupon-buster, this dull midcard dud was infuriatingly predictable to the last - said last being Kane's top rope chokeslam to Orton to snare the victory. Michael Cole knocked out all his cliches, both wrestlers worked the "methodical" pace and chins were firmly locked in position for wrestlers to, ironically, catch a breath.
5. I-C-U
Cody Rhodes' WWE career appeared to be going from strength to strength when viewed through the prism of his WrestleMania record.
After making it onto the 'Grandest Stage' via (and due to the death of) Legacy, he then picked up his first win a year later against established babyface hero Rey Mysterio. This soft-launch required one more victory over an established hand to complete an effective trifecta...but the company reverted to type.
The 'Grandson Of A Plumber' had been in outrageous form ahead of the show bullying The Big Show for his various WrestleMania failings, and deserved much of the comeuppance he received. But he also deserved a win - Show only surrendered the belt back to him after stomping backwards through a table, and a finish like that highlighted why a 'Show Of Shows' victory for the defending Champion could and should have been the obvious outcome.
4. Maria, You Gotta See Her
An underrated celebrity appearance amongst the WrestleMania in-ring efforts from showbiz types, Maria Menounos invested a lifetime of support for the product into a worthy performance alongside steady hands in the opposition and a suspiciously uninvolved Kelly Kelly.
Showing incredible guts and guile, the Entertainment Tonight host worked the bulk of a match she was only really supposed to be a guest in, despite sustaining two cracked ribs and stress fractures during her appearance on 'Dancing With The Stars'.
Far from being the passenger she could have been without the knocks, she took a long beating from Eve Torres and Beth Phoenix and later won the match with a roll-up. Menounos has been a popular fixture on Hall Of Fame red carpets et al ever since, and it's likely the contact with the company she prefers.
3. Team Challenge Series
There was a rather glum irony about the various men and women (literally, in The Bella Twins' cases) waving flags for John Laurinaitis and Teddy Long considering how little the general managers had done for them in kayfabe - if the two suited buffoons had done right by them, they wouldn't have had to slum it in this midcard snoozer.
Ripped right from a Bragging Rights/Survivor Series main event, this Red Vs Blue card-filler afforded The Miz an ego-(if not status)enhancing win, whilst Zack Ryder's WrestleMania Moment was finally, conclusively, binned off by the perpetually devious Eve Torres.
The match gifted 'Big Johnny' total control of both brands too - a further nail in the coffin of the ailing roster split, and a damaging onscreen recreation of the off-screen carnage he'd caused in the role for the better part of a decade.
2. "...Anyone Fancy A Pint?"
CM Punk and Chris Jericho's laboured WWE Championship clash was anything but a fast show, but a feud driven by their claims of being the very "Best" was admirable until the match proved that neither of them were truly deserving of the title.
Silencing the stadium, the pair lost the crowd early and never won them back - a problem not exclusive to this clash in particular but a growing concern for others that ordinarily knew how to blow roofs from venues that actually had them. Jericho had experienced this particular issue once before against Edge, but Punk had fought for a spot of this stature using his battles with Rey Mysterio and Randy Orton as bargaining chips.
This, to say the least, was an enormous backwards step.
1. Once Is Enough
The 'Once In A Lifetime' meeting between John Cena and The Rock was a long, laboured, lie that saw a year-long build result in an irritatingly ordinary affair.
The Miami crowd were on fire for to their returning hero, but an injury during the match sustained by 'The Great One' was just one of the underlying factors that hamstrung what was WWE's biggest box office main event ever. Drawing buys from 1,217,000 homes, WrestleMania XXVIII was an astronomical success and the most-bought in company history, but the disappointing in-ring response to such enormous anticipation saw the following year's rematch lose nearly 200,000 purchases from that number.
An advert for the wrestler 'Big Match John' hadn't quite become at that point, it was slightly lumbering until all the bombastic finisher trades late on.
Ups...
2. The Start Of A Movement
Sheamus' punctuated World Title squash of Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania XXVIII remains one of the most shocking internal character assassination attempts in company history. Not least because it kicked the "movement" WWE didn't realise they'd one day desperately wish to stop.
Fans uttered their incredulous indignation when, after just 18 seconds, Bryan had been defeated. Part of a storyline involving his toxic masculinity and their fractured relationship, the match served merely as a backdrop to their inevitable collapse. In kayfabe, Bryan naturally blamed her for the embarrassment, but the audience were wise to the game.
Tacking on a 'Yes!' chant to virtually every major song or cheer on the night in a show of solidarity with the former champion, the audience made the already-annoying heel mannerism an institutional genre-defining catchphrase. It foreshadowed the next wrestling zeitgeist bubbling under, eventually propelling its proponent to the promised land.
1. End Of An Era
The culmination of a stunning four-year tale, Triple H and The Undertaker's WrestleMania XXVIII Hell In A Cell battle was subtitled the 'End of an Era', as 'The Game' alongside guest referee Shawn Michaels put to bed their attempts to conquer The Undertaker's WrestleMania streak.
It, rather fatalistically, didn't go searching for the beginning of the next one.
Shawn's iconic encounters with 'The Deadman' at WrestleMania 25 and XXVI were never going to be topped by Triple H (or anybody else), but Hunter's gallant losing effort against The Undertaker in 2011 drew praise for finding surprising new ways to convince audiences that he could actually lose.
The Cell was more background than playground, and a Superkick/Pedigree combo almost put 'Taker down. His kick out drew an apoplectic reaction that reduced the crowd to a child-like state. His recovery and eventual win allowed them all to continue to believe in something approaching the fantastical.